Abstract
New concepts in phytopathometry continue to emerge, such as the evolution of the concept of pathogen intensity versus the well-established concept of disease intensity. The concept of pathogen severity, defined as the quantitative measurement of the amount of pathogen per sampling unit has also emerged in response to the now commonplace development of quantitative molecular detection tools. Although the concept of disease severity, i.e., the amount of disease per sampling unit, is a well-established concept, the accuracy and precision of visual estimates of disease severity is often questioned. This article will review disease assessment concepts, as well as the methods and assessment aides currently available to improve the accuracy and precision of visually-based disease severity data. The accuracy and precision of visual disease severity assessments can be improved by quantitatively measuring and comparing the accuracy and precision of rates and/or assessment methods using linear regression, by using computer-based disease assessment training programmes, and by developing and using diagrammatic keys (standard area diagrams).
Similar content being viewed by others
References
CL Campbell LV Madden (1990) Introduction to Plant Disease Epidemiology John Wiley New York
GA Forbes MJ Jeger (1987) ArticleTitleFactors affecting the estimation of disease intensity in simulated plant structures Zeitschrift fur Pflanzen Krankheiten und Pflanzenschutz 94 113–120
RE Gaunt (1995) ArticleTitleNew philosophies and technologies in disease measurement and appraisal Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology 17 185–189 Occurrence Handle10.1080/07060669509500710
CV Godoy MTPG Carneiro MT Iamauti M Dalla Pria L Amorim RD Berger A Bergamim Filho (1997) ArticleTitleDiagrammatic scales for bean diseases: development and validation Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection 104 336–345
AMA Gomes SJ Michereff RLR Mariano (2004) ArticleTitleDevelopment and validation of a diagrammatic key for Cercospora leaf spot of lettuce Summa Phytopathologica 30 38–42
J Guan FW Nutter SuffixJr. (2001) ArticleTitleFactors affecting the quality and quantity of sunlight reflected from alfalfa canopies Plant Disease 85 865–874
J Guan FW Nutter SuffixJr. (2003) ArticleTitleQuantifying the intra-rater repeatability and inter-rater reliability of visual disease and remote sensing assessment methods in the alfalfa foliar disease pathosystem Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology 25 143–149 Occurrence Handle10.1080/07060660309507062
J Guan FW Nutter SuffixJr. (2004) ArticleTitleComparison of single-point alfalfa yield models based on visual disease intensity and remote sensing assessments Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology 26 314–324 Occurrence Handle10.1080/07060660409507149
RE Gaunt (1987) Measurement of disease and pathogens PS Teng (Eds) Crop Loss Assessment and Pest Management The American Phytopathological Society St. Paul, MN 6–18
JG Horsfall EB Cowling (1978) Pathometry: the measurement of plant disease JG Horsfall EB Cowling (Eds) Plant Disease: An Advanced Treatise NumberInSeriesVol. 2 Academic Press New York 120–136
James C (1971) A Manual of Assessment Keys for Plant Disease. Canadian Department of Agriculture Publishing.
J Kranz (1988) Measuring plant disease J Kranz J Rotem (Eds) Experimental Techniques in Plant Disease Epidemiology Springer-Verlag New York 35–50
RMVBC Leite L Amorim (2002) ArticleTitleDevelopment and validation of a diagrammatic scale for Alternaria leaf spot of sunflower Summa Phytopathologica 28 14–19
CE Main (1977) Crop destruction – The raison d’ être of plant pathology JG Horsfall EB Cowling (Eds) Plant Disease: An Advanced Treatise Academic Press New York 55–78
Nutter FW, Jr. (1990) Remote sensing and image analysis for crop loss assessment. In: Crop Loss Assessment in Rice (pp. 93–105) International Rice Research Institute, Manila, Philippines.
FW Nutter SuffixJr. (1997a) Disease severity assessment training L Francl D Neher (Eds) Exercises in Plant Disease Epidemiology APS Press St. Paul, MN 1–7
FW Nutter SuffixJr. (1997b) ArticleTitleQuantifying the temporal dynamics of plant virus epidemics: a review Crop Protection 16 603–618 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0261-2194(97)00055-0
FW Nutter SuffixJr. (1999) ArticleTitleUnderstanding the interrelationship between botanical, human, and veterinary epidemiology: The Ys and Rs of it all Ecosystem Health 5 131–140 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1526-0992.1999.09922.x
FW Nutter SuffixJr. (2001) Disease assessment terms and concepts OC Maloy TD Murray (Eds) Encyclopedia of Plant Pathology John Wiley and Sons, Inc NY 312–323
FW Nutter SuffixJr. PD Esker (2006) Disease assessment keys OC Maloy TD Murray (Eds) Encyclopedia of Plant Pathology John Wiley and Sons, Inc NY 323–326
FW Nutter SuffixJr. PD Esker (2005) ArticleTitleThe role of psychophysics in phytopathology: the Weber-Fechner law revisited European Journal of Plant Pathology 114 199–213 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s10658-005-4732-9
FW Nutter SuffixJr. RE Gaunt (1996) Recent developments in methods for assessing disease losses in forage/pasture crop S Chakraborty DT Leath RA Skipp GA Pederson RA Bray GCM Latch FW Nutter SuffixJr. (Eds) Pasture and Forage Crop Pathology American Society of Agronomy, Crop Science Society of America, and Soil Science Society of America Madison, WI 93–118
FW Nutter SuffixJr. ML Gleason JH Jenco NC Christians (1993) ArticleTitleAssessing the accuracy, intra-rater repeatability and inter-rater reliability of disease assessment systems Phytopathology 83 806–812
FW Nutter SuffixJr. J Guan (2001) Disease losses OC Maloy TD Murray (Eds) Encyclopedia of Plant Pathology John Wiley and Sons, Inc NY 340–351
FW Nutter SuffixJr. RH Littrell (1996) ArticleTitleRelationships among percent defoliation, canopy reflectance, and pod yield in the peanut-late leafspot system Crop Protection 15 135–142 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0261-2194(95)00084-4
FW Nutter SuffixJr. D Litwiller (1998) ArticleTitleA computer program to generate standard area diagrams to aid raters in assessing disease severity Phytopathology 88 S117.
Nutter FW, Jr., Litwiller D and Wegulo SN (1998). Do standard area diagrams improve the accuracy and precision of disease assessments? Proceedings of the 7th International Congress of Plant Pathology. p. 2.1.16.
FW Nutter SuffixJr. SK Parker (1997) Fitting disease progress curves using EPIMODEL L Francl D Neher (Eds) Exercises in Plant Disease Epidemiology APS Press St. Paul, MN 24–28
FW Nutter SuffixJr. PM Schultz (1995) ArticleTitleImproving the accuracy and precision of disease assessment: selection of methods and use of computer-aided training programs Canadian Journal of Plant Pathology 17 174–184 Occurrence Handle10.1080/07060669509500709
FW Nutter SuffixJr. PS Teng RM Shokes (1991) ArticleTitleDisease assessment terms and concepts Plant Disease 75 1187–1188
Nutter FW, Jr., Wegulo SN, Litwiller D, Emmitt RW and Magarey PA (2000) A computer program to improve the accuracy and precision of severity assessments in grapevines. In: Magarey, PA, Thiele, SA, Tschirpig, KL, Emmet, RW, Clark, K and Magarey RD (eds) Proceedings of the Third International Workshop on Grapevine Downy and Powdery Mildew (pp. 64–69). South Australian Research and Development Institute Series Report No. 50.
Nutter FW, Jr. and Worawitlikit O (1990) Disease. Pro: A computerized disease assessment training program. Proceedings of the American Peanut Research and Ed. Society 22: 38.
RD O’Brien AHC Bruggen Particlevan (1992) ArticleTitleAccuracy, precision, and correlation to yield loss of disease severity scales for corky root of lettuce Phytopathology 82 91–96
GB Padgett FW Nutter SuffixJr. CW Kuhn (1990) ArticleTitleQuantification of disease resistance that reduces the rate of tobacco etch virus epidemics in bell pepper Phytopathology 80 451–455
RT Sherwood CC Berg MR Hoover KE Zeiders (1983) ArticleTitleIllusions in visual assessment of Stagonospora leaf spot of orchardgrass Phytopathology 73 173–177 Occurrence Handle10.1094/Phyto-73-173
FM Shokes RD Berger DH Smith JM Rasp (1987) ArticleTitleReliability of disease assessment procedures: A case study with late leafspot of peanut Oleagineux 42 245–251
JC Zadoks RD Schein (1979) Epidemiology and Plant Disease Management Oxford University Press New York
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nutter, F.W., Esker, P.D. & Netto, R.A.C. Disease Assessment Concepts and the Advancements Made in Improving the Accuracy and Precision of Plant Disease Data. Eur J Plant Pathol 115, 95–103 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10658-005-1230-z
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10658-005-1230-z