Abstract
Theoretical, field-based, and experimental research all suggest that animal populations remain relatively stable under increasing habitat alteration until a critical threshold is reached, after which small changes to habitats result in large negative responses. However, there are few empirical examples demonstrating this in marine fishes, making identification of such thresholds difficult. Here, we synthesized long-term (25 + year) fisheries and habitat datasets across four estuaries in Florida (USA) to examine the combined effects of a once in ninety-year cold spell and habitat alterations on populations of an estuarine dependent fish, common snook (Centropomus undecimalis). In Florida, common snook support an important recreational fishery where harvest is well-managed. Common snook populations in three estuaries with less severe habitat alterations recovered to pre-disturbance levels within 4 years of the cold spell. However, in the estuary with the most extensive habitat alteration—including 34% loss of mangrove habitats, near complete loss or fragmentation of saltmarsh habitats, a 65,000 acre seagrass die-off, and eutrophication—the common snook population had yet to recover 8 years after the cold spell. Using a life-stage explicit approach, habitat alterations affecting early life history processes (i.e., juvenile survival and larval settlement) may be responsible for decreased resilience. This study highlights the need for fisheries management to consider habitat loss and disturbance, along with harvest in stock assessment and management processes. Adopting policies to protect and restore habitats will improve fish population resiliency to disturbance, thereby mitigating non-linear and costly declines to fisheries.
Similar content being viewed by others
Data availability
The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
References
Adams A (2017) Guidelines for evaluating the suitability of catch and release fisheries: lessons learned from Caribbean flats fisheries. Fish Res 186:672–680
Adams A, Hill E, Kurth B, Barbour A (2012) Effects of a severe cold event on the subtropical, estuarine-dependent common snook Centropomus Undecimalis. Gulf Caribb 24(1):13–21
Adams A, Wolfe RK, Barkowski N, Overcash D (2009) Fidelity to spawning grounds by a catadromous fish, Centropomus undecimalis. Mar Ecol Prog 389:213–222
Adams AJ, Dahlgren C, Kellison GT, Kendall MS, Layman CA, Ley JA, Nagelkerken I, Serafy JE (2006) Nursery function of tropical backreef systems. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 318:287–301
Ault E, Webb S, Cox D (2021) Offshore behavioral contingent of an estuarine fish population, common snook Centropomus undecimalis. Mar Ecol Prog 669:175–189
Barbour AB, Adams AJ, Lorenzen K (2014) Size-based, seasonal, and multidirectional movements of an estuarine fish species in a habitat mosaic. Mar Ecol Prog 507:263–276
Beck MW, Heck KL, Able KW, Childers DL, Eggleston DB, Gillanders BM, ... Orth, R. J. (2001) The identification, conservation, and management of estuarine and marine nurseries for fish and invertebrates: a better understanding of the habitats that serve as nurseries for marine species and the factors that create site-specific variability in nursery quality will improve conservation and management of these areas. Biosci 51(8): 633–641
Blewett D, Stevens PW, Carter J (2017) Ecological effects of river flooding on abundance and body condition of a large, euryhaline fish. Mar Ecol Prog 563:211–218
Boswell GP, Britton NF, Franks NR (1998) Habitat fragmentation, percolation theory and the conservation of a keystone species. Proc R Soc Lond B Proc Biol Sci 265(1409): 1921–1925
Boucek RE, Heithaus MR, Santos R, Stevens P, Rehage JS (2017a) Can animal habitat use patterns influence their vulnerability to extreme climate events? An estuarine sportfish case study. Glob Chang Biol 23(10):4045–4057
Boucek RE, Leone E, Bickford J, Walters-Burnsed S, Lowerre-Barbieri S (2017b) More than just a spawning location: examining fine scale space use of two estuarine fish species at a spawning aggregation site. Front Mar Sci 4:355
Boucek RE, Barrientos C, Bush MR, Gandy DA, Wilson KL, Young JM (2017c) Trophic state indicators are a better predictor of Florida bass condition compared to temperature in Florida’s freshwater bodies. Environ Biol Fishes 100(10):1181–1192
Boucek RE, Trotter AA, Blewett DA, Ritch JL, Santos R, Stevens PW, ... Rehage J (2019) Contrasting river migrations of Common Snook between two Florida rivers using acoustic telemetry. Fish Res 213:219–225
Boucek RE, Rehage JS (2014) Climate extremes drive changes in functional community structure. Glob Chang Biol 20(6):1821–1831
Boyer JN, Kelble CR, Ortner PB, Rudnick DT (2009) Phytoplankton bloom status: chlorophyll a biomass as an indicator of water quality condition in the southern estuaries of Florida, USA. Ecol Indic 9(6):S56–S67
Briceño HO, Boyer JN (2010) Climatic controls on phytoplankton biomass in a sub-tropical estuary, Florida Bay, USA. Estuaries Coasts 33(2):541–553
Brown CJ, Broadley A, Adame MF, Branch TA, Turschwell MP, Connolly RM (2019) The assessment of fishery status depends on fish habitats. Fish Fish 20(1):1–14
Caddy JF (2014) Why do assessments of demersal stocks largely ignore habitat? ICES J Mar Sci 71(8):2114–2126
Childers DL, Gaiser E, Ogden LA (eds) (2019) The Coastal Everglades: the dynamics of social-ecological transformation in the south Florida landscape. Oxford University Press, USA
Cianciotto AC, Shenker JM, Adams AJ, Rennert JJ, Heuberger D (2019) Modifying mosquito impoundment management to enhance nursery habitat value for juvenile common Snook (Centropomus undecimalis) and Atlantic tarpon (Megalops atlanticus). Environ Biol Fishes 102(2):403–416
Connell JH (1985) The consequences of variation in initial settlement vs. post-settlement mortality in rocky intertidal communities. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 93(1–2):11–45
Dahlgren C, Kellison GT, Adams AJ, Gillanders BM, Kendall MS, Layman CA, Ley JA, Nagelkerken I, Serafy JE (2006) Marine nurseries and effective juvenile habitats: concepts and applications. Mar Ecol Prog 312:291–295
Duncan BW, Larson VL, Schmalzer PA (2004) Historic landcover and recent landscape change in the north Indian River Lagoon Watershed, Florida, USA. Nat Areas J 24(3):198–215
Eggenberger CW, Santos RO, Frankovich TA, James WR, Madden CJ, Nelson JA, Rehage JS (2019) Coupling telemetry and stable isotope techniques to unravel movement: Snook habitat use across variable nutrient environments. Fish Res 218:35–47
Fischer J, Lindenmayer DB (2007) Landscape modification and habitat fragmentation: a synthesis. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 16(3):265–280
Fontoura L, D’agata S, Gamoyo M, Barneche DR, Luiz OJ, Madin EM, ..., Maina JM (2022) Protecting connectivity promotes successful biodiversity and fisheries conservation. Science 375(6578):336–340
Gilmore RG, Donohoe CJ, Cooke DW (1983) Observations on the distribution and biology of east-central Florida populations of the common snook, Centropomus undecimalis (Bloch). Fla Sci 46:313–336
Greening H, Janicki A (2006) Toward reversal of eutrophic conditions in a subtropical estuary: water quality and seagrass response to nitrogen loading reductions in Tampa Bay, Florida, USA. Environ Manag 38(2):163–178
Geselbracht L, Freeman K, Kelly E, Gordon D, Birch A (2013) Retrospective analysis and sea level rise modeling of coastal habitat change in Charlotte Harbor to identify restoration and adaptation priorities. Fla Sci 78:328–355
Herren LW, Brewton RA, Wilking LE, Tarnowski ME, Vogel MA, Lapointe BE (2021) Septic systems drive nutrient enrichment of groundwaters and eutrophication in the urbanized Indian River Lagoon, Florida. Mar Pollut Bull 172:112928
Hall MO, Furman BT, Merello M, Durako MJ (2016) Recurrence of Thalassia testudinum seagrass die-off in Florida Bay, USA: initial observations. Mar Ecol Prog 560:243–249
Hinkley DV (1971) Inference about the change-point from cumulative sum tests. 7 Biometrika 5:509–523
Hinkley D, Schechtman E (1987) Conditional bootstrap methods in the mean-shift model. Biometrika 74:85–93
Hodgdon CT, Tanaka KR, Runnebaum J, Cao J, Chen Y (2020) A framework to incorporate environmental effects into stock assessments informed by fishery-independent surveys: a case study with American lobster (Homarus americanus). An J Fish Aquat Sci (ja) 77(10):1700–1710
Homan RN, Windmiller BS, Reed JM (2004) Critical thresholds associated with habitat loss for two vernal pool-breeding amphibians. Ecol Appl 14(5):1547–1553
Langton RW, Steneck RS, Gotceitas V, Juanes F, Lawton P (1996) The interface between Fish. Res. and habitat management. N Am J Fish Manag 16(1):1–7
Lapointe BE, Herren LW, Debortoli DD, Vogel MA (2015) Evidence of sewage-driven eutrophication and harmful algal blooms in Florida’s Indian River Lagoon. Harmful Algae 43:82–102
Link JS, Huse G, Gaichas S, Marshak AR (2020) Changing how we approach fisheries: a first attempt at an operational framework for ecosystem approaches to fisheries management. Fish Fish 21(2):393–434
Lipton D (2008) Economic benefits of a restored oyster fishery in Chesapeake Bay. J Shellfish Res 27(3):619–623
Lowerre-Barbieri S, Villegas-Rios D, Walters S, Bickford J, Cooper W, Muller R, Trotter A (2014) Spawning site selection and contingent behavior in common snook, Centropomus undecimalis. Plos One 9(7):e101809
Lowerre-Barbieri S, DeCelles G, Pepin P, Catalán IA, Muhling B, Erisman B, Tringali MD (2017) Reproductive resilience: a paradigm shift in understanding spawner-recruit systems in exploited marine fish. Fish Fish 18(2):285–312
Lowerre-Barbieri S, Kays R, Thorson JT, Wikelski M (2019) The ocean’s movescape: fisheries management in the bio-logging decade (2018–2028). ICES J Mar Sci 76:477–488
MacKenzie BR, Horbowy J, Köster FW (2008) Incorporating environmental variability in stock assessment: predicting recruitment, spawner biomass, and landings of sprat (Sprattus sprattus) in the Baltic Sea. An J Fish Aquat Sci 65(7):1334–1341
Macura B, Byström P, Airoldi L, Eriksson BK, Rudstam L, Støttrup JG (2019) Impact of structural habitat modifications in coastal temperate systems on fish recruitment: a systematic review. Environ Evid 8(1):14
Madden CJ, Rudnick DT, McDonald AA, Cunniff KM, Fourqurean JW (2009) Ecol. Indic. for assessing and communicating seagrass status and trends in Florida Bay. Ecol Indic 9(6):S68–S82
Manly BFJ, MacKenzie D (2000) A cumulative sum type of method for 2 environmental monitoring. Environmetrics 11:151–166
Massie JA, Strickland BA, Santos RO, Hernandez J, Viadero N, Boucek RE, ..., Rehage JS (2020) Going downriver: patterns and cues in hurricane-driven movements of common snook in a subtropical coastal river. Estuaries Coasts 43(5):1158–1173
Maunder MN, Punt AE (2013) A review of integrated analysis in fisheries stock assessment. Fish Res 142:61–74
McClanahan TR, Graham NA, MacNeil MA, Muthiga NA, Cinner JE, Bruggemann JH, Wilson SK (2011) Critical thresholds and tangible targets for ecosystem-based management of coral reef fisheries. PNAS 108(41):17230–17233
Muller RG, Trotter AA, Stevens PW (2015) The 2015 stock assessment update of common Snook (Centropomus undecimalis). Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute
Odum WE, McIvor CC and Smith TJ (1982) The ecology of the mangroves of south Florida: a community profile. FWS/OBS-81/24. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Office of Biological Services, Washington, DC, p 144
Osenberg CW, Shima JS, St Mary CM (2006) Habitat degradation and settlement behavior: effects on fish settlement, survival, and recruitment. In Proceedings of the 10th International Coral Reef Symposium, Okinawa, Japan. Japanese Coral Reef Society, Tokyo, Japan, p 257–263
Pardini R, Bueno AdA, Gardner TA, Prado PI, Metzger JP (2010) Beyond the fragmentation threshold hypothesis: regime shifts in biodiversity across fragmented landscapes. PLoS One 5(10):e13666. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0013666
Pardo LE, de Oliveira RF, Campbell MJ, Younes N, Edwards W, Laurance WF (2018) Identifying critical limits in oil palm cover for the conservation of terrestrial mammals in Colombia. Biol Conserv 227:65–73
Peters KM, Matheson RE Jr, Taylor RG (1998) Reproduction and early life history of common snook, Centropomus undecimalis (Bloch). Florida Bull Mar Sci 62(2):509–529
Purcell JE (2012) Jellyfish and ctenophore blooms coincide with human proliferations and environmental perturbations. Ann Rev Mar Sci 4:209–235
Purtlebaugh CH, Martin CW, Allen MS (2020) Poleward expansion of common snook Centropomus undecimalis in the northeastern Gulf of Mexico and future research needs. PLoS ONE 15(6):e0234083
Radabaugh KR, Powell CE, and Moyer RP (2017) Coastal habitat integrated mapping and monitoring program report for the state of Florida. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Fish and Wildlife Research Institute Technical Report 21
Ratajczak Z, Carpenter SR, Ives AR, Kucharik CJ, Ramiadantsoa T, Stegner MA, Turner MG (2018) Abrupt change in ecological systems: inference and diagnosis. Trends Ecol Evol 33(7):513–526
Rehage JS, Boucek RE, Santos RO, Massie JA, Viadero NM, Rezek RJ (2022) Untangling flow-ecology relationships: effects of seasonal stage variation on common snook aggregation and movement rates in the everglades. Estuaries Coasts 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12237-022-01065-x
Rey JR, Kain T (1990) Guide to the salt marsh impoundments of Florida. Florida Medical Entomology Laboratory Publications, Vero Beach
Rezek RJ, Massie JA, Nelson JA, Santos RO, Viadero NM, Boucek RE, Rehage JS (2020) Individual consumer movement mediates food web coupling across a coastal ecosystem. Ecosphere 11(12):e03305
Ricard D, Minto C, Jensen OP, Baum JK (2012) Examining the knowledge base and status of commercially exploited marine species with the RAM Legacy Stock Assessment Database. Fish Fish 13(4):380–398
Ross BE, Haukos DA, Hagen CA, Pitman JC (2016) Landscape composition creates a threshold influencing lesser prairie-chicken population resilience to extreme drought. Glob Ecol Conserv 6:179–188
Santos RO, Rehage JS, Boucek R, Osborne J (2016) Shift in recreational fishing catches as a function of an extreme cold event. Ecosphere 7(6):e01335
Shade A, Peter H, Allison SD, Baho D, Berga M, Bürgmann H, ..., Matulich KL (2012) Fundamentals of microbial community resistance and resilience. Front Microbiol 3:417
Schirripa MJ, Goodyear CP, Methot RM (2009) Testing different methods of incorporating climate data into the assessment of US West Coast sablefish. ICES J Mar Sci 66(7):1605–1613
Sherwood GD, Kovecses J, Hontela A, Rasmussen JB (2002) Simplified food webs lead to energetic bottlenecks in polluted lakes. An J Fish Aquat Sci 59(1):1–5
Smith MD (2011) The ecological role of climate extremes: current understanding and future prospects. J Ecol 99(3):651–655
Snyder DB, Burgess GH (2016) Marine fishes of Florida. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Stephens SE, Koons DN, Rotella JJ, Willey DW (2004) Effects of habitat fragmentation on avian nesting success: a review of the evidence at multiple spatial scales. Biol Conserv 115(1):101–110
Stevens PW, Blewett DA, Boucek RE, Rehage JS, Winner BL, Young JM, Paperno R (2016) Resilience of a tropical sport fish population to a severe cold event varies across five estuaries in southern Florida. Ecosphere 7(8):e01400
Stevens PW, Blewett DA, Poulakis GR (2007) Variable habitat use by juvenile common snook, Centropomus undecimalis (Pisces: Centropomidae): applying a life-history model in a southwest Florida estuary. Bull Mar Sci 80(1):93–108
Sundblad G, Bergström U, Sandström A, Eklöv P (2014) Nursery habitat availability limits adult stock sizes of predatory coastal fish. ICES J Mar Sci 71(3):672–680
Swift TL, Hannon SJ (2010) Critical thresholds associated with habitat loss: a review of the concepts, evidence, and applications. Biol 85(1):35–53
Taylor RG, Grier HJ, Whittington JA (1998) Spawning rhythms of common snook in Florida. J Fish Biol 53(3):502–520
Taylor W (2000) Change-Point Analyzer 2.0 shareware program, Taylor Enterprises, 11 Libertyville, Illinois. Web: http://www.variation.com/cpa. Accessed 5/11/2020
Taylor DS (2012) Removing the sands (sins?) of our past: dredge spoil removal and saltmarsh restoration along the Indian River Lagoon, Florida (USA). Wetl Ecol Manag 20(3):213–218
Trotter AA, Blewett DA, Taylor RG, Stevens PW (2012) Migrations of common snook from a tidal river with implications for skipped spawning. Trans Am Fish Soc 141(4):1016–1025
Whitfield AK, Grant GN, Bennett RH, Cowley PD (2018) Causes and consequences of human induced impacts on a ubiquitous estuary-dependent marine fish species. Rev Fish Biol Fish 28(1):19–31
Wilson JK, Adams AJ, Ahrens RN (2019) Atlantic tarpon (Megalops atlanticus) nursery habitats: evaluation of habitat quality and broad-scale habitat identification. Environ Biol Fishes 102(2):383–402
Wilson JK, Stevens PW, Blewett DA, Boucek RE, Adams AJ (2022) A new approach to define an economically important fish as an umbrella flagship species to enhance collaborative stakeholder-management agency habitat conservation. Environ Biol Fishes 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-022-01214-y
Wintle BA, Kujala H, Whitehead A, Cameron A, Veloz S, Kukkala A, Bekessy SA (2019) Global synthesis of conservation studies reveals the importance of small habitat patches for biodiversity. PNAS 116(3):909–914
Yarbro LA, Carlson PR (2016) Executive Summary. In: Yarbro LA, Carlson PR Jr (eds). Seagrass integrated mapping and monitoring report no. 2. Fish and Wildlife Research Institute Technical Report TR-17, version 2. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, St. Petersburg, p 1–28. https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.12366.05445
Young JM, Yeiser BG, Whittington JA (2014) Spatiotemporal dynamics of spawning aggregations of common snook on the east coast of Florida. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 505:227–240
Zuckerberg B, Porter WF (2010) Thresholds in the long-term responses of breeding birds to forest cover and fragmentation. Biol Conserv 143(4):952–962
Acknowledgements
We thank the dedicated field staff that assisted with these expansive sampling efforts across the state of Florida. This project was supported with funds collected from Bonefish and Tarpon Trust, the State of Florida Saltwater Fishing License sales, Department of the Interior, US Fish and Wildlife Service, Federal Aid for Sport Fish Restoration Grant Number F-43 to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission. Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission does not require IACUC protocols for government funded state research. As such, no formal protocol was used.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
A.J.A. conceived the idea; R.E.B carried out the analyses and led the writing of the manuscript. All authors contributed to writing, and conceptual development.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethical approval
No approval of research ethics committees was required to accomplish the goals of this study. Aaron Adams is a Guest Editor of this special issue, but he had no involvement in the peer review of this article and had no access to information regarding its peer review. Data collection, ethical treatment of animal subjects and quality control checks were done through standards established by Florida Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, who were responsible for all data collection used in this study.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher's note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Boucek, R.E., Allen, M.S., Ellis, R.D. et al. An extreme climate event and extensive habitat alterations cause a non-linear and persistent decline to a well-managed estuarine fishery. Environ Biol Fish 106, 193–207 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-022-01309-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-022-01309-6