The “woke movement” is now under fire globally. Seeking to right social injustice and battle racism, the woke movement has laudable intentions, but its implementation can exacerbate social inequalities. In the case of Canada, a social movement seeks to ferret out “Pretendians” or those White individuals deemed to be falsely assuming, and thus appropriating, Indigenous identity. Though this movement may seem righteous, the problem arises that individuals targeted are those who are Non-Status Indians and have yet to be recognised by the state, as well as Métis (or mixed-heritage people) whose historical communities have yet to be sanctioned by governments or courts, and who are also portrayed as being “Fétis” or fake Métis. Our challenge as researchers is to do the deep ethnographic, historical, and legal research to provide a nuanced understanding of indigeneity that does not constrain it solely to colonial models as the case studies provided will demonstrate.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
“Other Métis” is a designation found in the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples report, volume 4. It includes all Canadian Métis peoples who are not members of the neo-nationalist Métis National Council which represents the interest of only the Western-based Metis of Canada, Red River, in particular (Canada 1997, pp. 193–196).
Leroux, an independent scholar, has positioned himself at the forefront of those seeking to call out the Métis that he considers as race-shifters. In addition to being very active on Twitter, he has set up a website—raceshifting.com—that expressly defines Métis based on a very narrow spectrum “actual Métis are a western-based Indigenous people whose culture grew out of kinship relations with the Plains Cree, Saulteaux, Assiniboine, and Dene” that conforms to the Métis National Council’s narrative.
Malette and Pulla (2022) report on collective research on the ethnohistory of the larger Maniwaki Region, including the Baskatong community. The historical evidence gathered shows a significant Métis presence before the area was flooded by construction of a dam.
Coburn had misread Bain’s (2020) Flare magazine article, misleadingly titled “My Story”, which quotes Latimer relating Arnaquq-Baril’s story describing her grandparents as residential school survivors.
The AAFN is not affiliated with the Algonquins of Ontario (AoO) with which the Province of Ontario is negotiating a land claims agreement on behalf of ten Algonquin communites. Only one Algonquin nation, the Algonquins of Pikwakanagan First Nation, has legal status under the federal Indian Act.
Allen, Michelle. 2022. Queen’s review of policies on Indigenous identity claims rife with issues, say critics. CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/queen-s-university-indigenous-identity-policy-review-1.6415618. Accessed September 21, 2022.
Andersen, Chris. 2014. Métis: Race, recognition, and the struggle for Indigenous peoplehood. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Andersen, Chris. 2016. Who is Indigenous? Indigenous ancestry, white possessiveness and the tyranny of self-identification. YouTube. Western University, London (Canada). Accessed September 22, 2022.
Ardoch Algonquin First Nation v. Ont. (2000) 134 O.A.C. 201 (SCC).
Ardoch Algonquin First Nation (2022) Responding to the attacks against AAFN. http://www.aafna.ca/responding-to-the-attacks-against-aafn. Accessed 21 Sep 2022.
Barrera, Jorge. 2021. Michelle Latimer breaks silence, presents ancestry report following questions about Indigenous identity. CBC News Indigenous. https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/michelle-latimer-ancestry-report-expert-1.6024508. Accessed September 20, 2022.
Basken, Paul. 2022. Canadian universities tackle false claims of Indigenous identities. Inside Higher Ed. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2022/07/28/canadian-universities-tackle-false-claims-indigenous-identities#:~:text=Canadian%20universities%20are%20making%20stronger,mistrust%20of%20government%2Dled%20efforts. Accessed September 20, 2022.
Beckerman, G. 2022. The quiet before: On the unexpected origins of radical ideas. New York: Crown.
Bouchard, Michel, Sébastien. Malette, and Guillaume Marcotte. 2020a. A river cuts through it: The Métis on the two banks of the Ottawa River. Journal De La Société Des Américanistes 106–2: 345–374.
Bouchard, Michel, Sébastien. Malette, and Guillaume Marcotte. 2020b. Bois-Brûlés: The untold story of the Métis of western Québec. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Bouchard, Michel, Sébastien. Malette, and Siomonn Pulla. 2021. Eastern Métis: Chronicling and reclaiming a denied past. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Bresge, Adina. 2018. East Coast awards pull Indigenous artist nominee amid questions about Metis ties. CTV News Atlantic. https://atlantic.ctvnews.ca/east-coast-awards-pull-indigenous-artist-nominee-amid-questions-about-metis-ties-1.3841146?cache=yes%3FclipId%3D263414. Accessed August 27, 2022.
Canada. 1994. Report on the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples. Volume 4: Perspectives and Realities.
CBC News (2022) Queen’s University criticized over including Ardoch group in review. CBC News Video. https://www.cbc.ca/player/play/2021962819927. Accessed September 20, 2022.
CBC Radio. How this woman reconnected with her Métis ancestry, and the land they live on. CBC Tapestry. April 9, 2021. https://www.cbc.ca/radio/tapestry/women-who-find-meaning-and-purpose-on-the-land-1.5981131/how-this-woman-reconnected-with-her-m%C3%A9tis-ancestry-and-the-land-they-live-on-1.5981260. Accessed September 22, 2022. Accessed September 20, 2022.
Chartrand, David. 2021. The Metis people: an inconvenient nation. Canadian Issues: 32–37.
Coburn, Veldon [@VeldonCoburn] Twitter, “Essentially, white settlers posing as Algonquin—many on the basis of forged documents” October 7, 2021a, 1:32 p.m.
Coburn, Veldon [@VeldonCoburn] Twitter, There’s a couple of the fake ‘chiefs’ from the AOO still there: two are descended from the fraudulent toot[sic] ancestor Thomas Laguarde. October 7, 2021b.
Cohen, Stanley. 2011. Folk devils and moral panics. Oxfordshire: Routledge.
Deer, Ka’nhehsí:io, and Jorge Barrera. 2020. Award-winning filmmaker Michelle Latimer’s Indigenous identity under scrutiny. CBC News Indigenous. https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/michelle-latimer-kitigan-zibi-indigenous-identity-1.5845310#:~:text=%22Most%20of%20her%20ancestors%20were,documents%20don't%20lie.%22 . Accessed September 18, 2022.
Deer, Ka’nhehsí:io, and Jorge Barrera. 2021. Trickster producers resign amid Michelle Latimer Indigenous identity questions. CBC News Indigenous. https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/trickster-producers-resign-michelle-latimer-1.5848094 Accessed September 19, 2022.
Dowling, Amber. 2021. CBC cancels ‘trickster’ following director Michelle Latimer’s Indigenous identity scandal. Variety. https://variety.com/2021/tv/global/trickster-canceled-cbc-michelle-latimer-1234895893/ Accessed September 18, 2022.
Dubois, Janique, and Kelly Saunders. 2017. Rebuilding Indigenous nations through constitutional development: a case study of the Métis in Canada. Nations and Nationalism: Journal of the Association for the Study of Ethnicity and Nationalism: 1–24.
Evans, M. 1999. What it is to be a Métis: The stories and recollections of the elders of the Prince George Métis Elders Society. Prince George: UNBC Press.
Gagnon, D. 2021. Symbolic violence against the ‘Other Métis’: The making of a new forgotten people in Canada. In Eastern Métis: Chronicling and Reclaiming a Denied Past, ed. Michel Bouchard, Sébastien. Malette, and Siomonn Pulla, 3–22. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Gaudry, A., and D. Leroux. 2017. White settler revisionism and making Métis everywhere: The evocation of Métissage in Quebec and Nova Scotia. Critical Ethnic Studies 3 (1): 116–142.
Hathaway, Bill. 2021. ‘Likes’ and ‘shares’ teach people to express more outrage online. Yale News. https://news.yale.edu/2021/08/13/likes-and-shares-teach-people-express-more-outrage-online. Accessed September 20, 2022.
Hertz, Barry. 2021. ‘All I can do is speak my truth’: filmmaker Michelle Latimer breaks her silence after Indigenous ancestry controversy. The Globe and Mail. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/arts/film/article-all-i-can-do-is-speak-my-truth-filmmaker-michelle-latimer-breaks-her/ Accessed September 18, 2022.
Jacobs, Devery. [@kdeveryjacobs], Twitter, My response to the CBC exposé written by @Kanhehsiio & @JorgeBarrera. December 18, 2020, 10:49 a.m.
Jones, Thai. 2022. The tricky role of social media in social-justice movements: a review of the quiet before: on the unexpected origins of radical ideas, by Gal Beckerman. Columbia Magazine. https://magazine.columbia.edu/article/tricky-role-social-media-social-justice-movements. Accessed September 20, 2022.
Kolopenuk, J. 2018. ‘Pop-up’ Métis and the rise of Canada’s post-Indigenous formation. American Anthropologist. 120 (2): 333–337.
Latimer, Michelle. 2021. In my own words. Medium. https://michelle-latimer.medium.com/in-my-own-words-by-michelle-latimer-f940ff4fce3f. Accessed September 21, 2022.
Lawrence, B. 2004. “Real” Indians and others: Mixed-blood urban native peoples and Indigenous nationhood. Lincoln: U of Nebraska Press.
Leroux, D. 2019. Distorted descent: White claims to Indigenous identity. Winnipeg: University of Manitoba Press.
Leroux, Darryl. 2021. Examining the Nunatukavut Community Council’s land claim. Nunatsiavut Government.
Loreto, Nora. [@NoLore], Twitter. “Is Navigator seriously just a direct channel into national news pages?” May 11, 2021, 12:17 p.m. https://twitter.com/NoLore/status/1392151851345321985. Accessed 19 Sep 2022.
Malette, S. 2021. Political ontologies in turmoil: Métis ‘Neo-nationalism’ and the ‘Other Métis.’ In Eastern Métis: Chronicling and Reclaiming a Denied Past, ed. Michel Bouchard, Sébastien. Malette, and Siomonn Pulla, 23–66. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Malette, Sébastien, and Siomonn Pulla. 2022. Report on the Indigenous identity of Michelle Latimer. Self-published.
Martens, Kathleen. 2021. Time to charge those pretending to be Indigenous with fraud: Cree lawyer. APTN News. https://www.aptnnews.ca/national-news/time-to-charge-those-pretending-to-be-indigenous-with-fraud-cree-lawyer/. Accessed September 18, 2022.
Martin, Debbie. 2022. We have always been here: rebuttal to the 2021 Nunatsiavut Government report entitled Examining the NunatuKavut Community Council’s land claim.
Michaux, Emmanuel. 2021. Métissage and Métis Identity in the Gaspe Peninsula: From Its Origins to the 1886 Paspébiac Riots. In Eastern Métis: Chronicling and Reclaiming a Denied Past, eds. Michel Bouchard, Sébastien Malette, and Siomonn Pulla. Lanham: Lexington Books: 133-152.
Monkman, Lenard. 2020. NFB pulls Michelle Latimer’s documentary Inconvenient Indian from Sundance festival. CBC News Indigenous. https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/nfb-pulls-inconvenient-indian-sundance-1.5852150 Accessed September 18, 2022.
Nunatukavut. Our Ancient Land. https://nunatukavut.ca/. Accessed 25 Sep 2022.
Queen’s University (2021) University to launch consultation on Indigenous identity. Queen’s Gazette. https://www.queensu.ca/gazette/stories/university-launch-consultation-indigenous-identity Accessed September 18, 2022.
Queen’s University (2022) Queen’s releases report following dialogues on indigeneity. Queen’s Gazette. https://www.queensu.ca/gazette/stories/queen-s-releases-report-following-dialogues-indigeneity#:~:text=Statement%20from%20Chancellor%20Murray%20Sinclair%3A&text=The%20announcement%20of%20the%20creation,relies%20solely%20on%20self%2Didentification. Accessed September 18, 2022.
Voshart, Daniel. 2021. Ten rumors about Michelle Latimer. Medium. https://medium.com/@voshart/ten-rumors-about-michelle-latimer-7fd07c77b529 Accessed September 18, 2022.
Vowel, C., and D. Leroux. 2016. White settler antipathy and the Daniels decision. TOPIA: Canadian Journal of Cultural Studies 36: 30–42.
Walsh, J.P. 2020. Social media and moral panics: Assessing the effects of technological change on societal reaction. International Journal of Cultural Studies 23 (6): 840–859.
Ward, Dennis. 2022. Métis National Council moving forward after years of ‘dysfunction’ says MNO president. APTN National News. https://www.aptnnews.ca/facetoface/metis-national-council-moving-forward-after-years-of-dysfunction-says-mno-president/ Accessed September 20, 2022.
Conflict of interest
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Bouchard, M., Malette, S. & Lawless, JA.M. Academia, Twitter wars, and suffocating social justice in Canada: the case of unrecognised Indigenous peoples. Dialect Anthropol 47, 97–107 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10624-022-09677-2
- Academic mobbing
- Social media