Skip to main content

Advertisement

SpringerLink
Log in

Tough-on-Crime Tolerance: The Cultural Criminalization of Bigotry in the Post-Civil Rights Era

  • Published:
Critical Criminology Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

This article extends critical scholarship on the problem of hate crimes in the U.S. into the field of cultural criminology. Highlighting the role cultural production plays in reinforcing identity-based social harms, this study analyzes the cultural construction of the figure of the white hate crimes perpetrator, or “the hater.” The article integrates findings from a comprehensive discourse analysis of major U.S. news sources from 1986 to 2010 with insights from the fields of whiteness studies and critical criminology. The study first finds that the figure of the hater embodies modern day bigotry through terse stereotypes about white poverty, masculinity, hate group membership, and criminality. It then argues that these widely distributed discursive performances create rhetorical opportunities to define bigotry as an individualized problem with law enforcement remedies and to further normalize extreme hate crimes cases. Ultimately, a new theoretical construct, “post-difference ideology,” is mobilized to challenge the hater’s prescribed role as folk devil.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

Notes

  1. As part of the Jasper’s racial reconciliation process following Byrd’s murder, the town removed the fence segregating the cemetery.

References

  • ABC. (1995, December 8). Soldiers involved in hate crime. ABC World News. LexisNexis Academic (December 11, 2008).

  • Altheide, D. (1997). The news media, the problem frame, and the production of fear. The Sociological Quarterly, 38(4), 663–664.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • American Psychological Association. (2010). Hate crime position paper. http://www.apa.org/ppo/issues/pfranklin.html.

  • Andrews, E. (1995, December 10). Slaying lead army to look at extremism. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (December 26, 2008).

  • AP. (1999, August 19). National news briefs; neo-nazis cancel March over Los Angeles attack. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (January 6, 2009).

  • Axelrod, J. (1999, February 25). Counseling children on racism. CBS Evening News. LexisNexis Academic (January 6, 2009).

  • Bragg, R. (1998, June 17). Unfathomable crime, unlikely figure. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Brokaw, T. (1999, February 23). John William King became a racist in prison. NBC Nightly News. LexisNexis Academic (January 6, 2009).

  • Brooke, J. (1998, October 16). Men held in beating lived on the fringes. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Brown, M. (2003). White washing race: The myth of a color-blind society. Berkeley: University of California.

    Google Scholar 

  • CBS. (1993, May 6). Bias crimes on increase; pre-trial hearing in Florida is example. Morning News. CBS News Transcripts. LexisNexis (December 14, 2008).

  • CBS. (1997, June 26). The enemy within: racists in the ranks. CBS 48 Hours. CBS Transcripts. LexisNexis Academic (December 14, 2008).

  • Chadwick, A. (1992, February 27). Japanese-Americans target of violence. Morning Edition. National Public Radio. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Chen, J. (1999, July 13). Civil rights leaders expanding push for tougher federal hate crime laws. CBS This Morning. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Choy, C., & Tajima-Pena, R. (1989). Who Killed Vincent Chin?

  • CNN. (2000, September 13). Wen Ho Lee case raises unsettling questions for Asian-Americans. LexisNexis Academic (December 14, 2008).

  • Curry, A. (1999, February 17). Day two of testimony in murder trial of John William King. Today, NBC News Transcript. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Doane, A., & Bonilla-Silva, E. (Eds.). (2003). White out: The continuing significance of Racism. New York: Routledge.

    Google Scholar 

  • Dunbar, E. (1997). Hate crime patterns in Los Angeles county: Demographic and behavioral factors of victim impact and reporting of crime. Paper Presented at the Congressional briefing co-sponsored by the American Psychological Association and the Society for Psychological Study of Social Issues. Washington, DC.

  • Editorial Desk. (1999, April 6). Stiff and proper. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (December 26, 2008).

  • Forman, T., & Lewis, A. (2006). Racial apathy and hurricane Katrina: The social anatomy of prejudice in the post-civil rights era. Du Bois Review, 3(1), 196.

    Google Scholar 

  • Fratangelo, D. (1999, January 24). People of Jasper, Texas, prepare for trial over the murder of James Byrd Jr. NBC Nightly News. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Geyelin, M. (1993, August 24). Color of hate: A tense trail begins. Tama, FL., Confronts costs of racial strife–torching black tourist; City Fears Effect on Its Economy–‘Mean Suspects, Shaky Case. The Wall Street Journal. ProQuest (December 1, 2008).

  • Gibson, C. (1999, February 26). Byrd murder trial death sentence. ABC Good Morning America. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Gibson, C. (2007, May 2). A closer look; hate crimes. World News with Charles Gibson. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Hammer, J. (1999, November 8). The ‘Gay Panic’ Defense. Newsweek. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Hartigan, J. Jr. (2003). Who are these white people? ‘Rednecks’, ‘Hillbillies’, and ‘White Trash’ as Marked Racial Subject. In A. Doane & E. Bonilla-Silva (Eds.), White out: The continuing significance of Racism. London: Routledge. 111.

    Google Scholar 

  • Hartigan, J. Jr. (2005). Odd tribes: Towards a cultural analysis of white people (pp. 118–119). Durham, North Caroline: Duke University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • Herbert, B. (1999, February 28). In America: Staring at Hatred. Editorial Desk. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Ifill, S. (2007). On the court house lawn: Confronting the legacy of lynching in the 21st century. Boston: Beacon Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • Innes, M. (2003). Signal crimes: Detective work, mass media and constructing collective memory. In P. Mason (Ed.), Criminal visions: Media representations of crime and justice. Portland, OR: William Publishing. pp 159.

    Google Scholar 

  • Janofsky, M. (1999, November 5). Parents of gay obtain mercy for his killer. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic. (January 5, 2009).

  • Jennings, P. (1999, February 17). Jury in Jasper, TX Sees Grisly Evidence. World News Tonight with Peter Jennings, LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Koppel, T. (2002, May 21). A matter of choice? Gays, straights and the search for common grounds; Roanoke Newspaper Profiles Local Gays and Lesbians Causing Controversy. ABC Nightline. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Lyman, R. (1999, February 17). Dragging death is called signal for racist plan. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Lyman, R. (1999, February 26). Texas Jury Picks death sentence in fatal dragging of a black man. The New York Times. (October 27, 2009).

  • Lyman, R. (1999, February 28). A guilty verdict in Texas dragging death. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (December 11, 2008).

  • Mencken, H. L. (1931, December 17). Eastern Shore Kultur. Evening Sun.

  • Murr, A., & Fineman, H. (1998, October 26). Echoes of a Murder in Wyoming. Newsweek. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • NBC. (1998, October 12). Death of victim in Wyoming hate crime increases charges against suspect. NBC Nightly News. LexisNexis (December 12, 2008).

  • NBC. (1999a, February 5). Memories of matthew; parents of murdered college student, matthew shepard speak about their son. NBC Dateline. LexisNexis Academic (December 12, 2008).

  • NBC. (1999b, August 12). Brian Levin, professor at Cal State University Discusses Hate Crimes and Hate Groups. NBC Nightly News. LexisNexis Academic (December 11, 2008).

  • O’Brien, S. (1998, October 10). Citizens of Laramie, Wyoming, show Disdain for hate in their community. NBC Nightly News, LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Rather, D. (1999a, August 11). Changing face of hate crimes from groups committing them to individuals. CBS Evening News. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Rather, D. (1999b, February 16). John William King Goes on trial for brutal killing of Black Man in Texas Last June. CBS Evening News. LexisNexis Academic (December 11, 2008).

  • Rather, D. (1999c, February 17). Prosecutors paint an ugly picture of Racism at John William King’s Trial. CBS Evening News, LexisNexis Academic (December 11, 2008).

  • Rather, D. (1999d, February 19). Ongoing Trial in Jasper, Texas, of a man accused of dragging a black man to his death. CBS Evening News, LexisNexis Academic (December 11, 2008).

  • Rather, D. (1999e, February 25). John William King sentenced to death by lethal injection for the dragging death of James Byrd. Jr. CBS Evening News.

  • Reiner, R., Livingstone, S., & Allen, J. (2003). From law and order to lynch mobs: Crime news since the second world war. In P. Mason (Ed.), Criminal visions: Media representations of crime and justice (pp. 13–32). UK: William Cullompton.

    Google Scholar 

  • Reiner, R., Livingstone, S., & Allen, J. (2007). Law and order: An honest citizen’s guide to crime and control. UK: Polity.

    Google Scholar 

  • Robelot, J. (1999, February 16). Opening Statements To Begin In Racially Charged Trial in Jasper, Texas. CBS This Moring. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Sack, K. (1998, March 3) Hate groups in U.S. are growing, report says. The New York Times. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Salters, L. (1998, October 13). Mourners gather for Matthew Shepard. ABC Good Morning America, LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Sawyer, F. (1995, December 8). Damage assessment of Ames Scandal. ABC World News Tonight, LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Schmitt, E. (1995, December 13). Inquiry by army focuses on hate. The New York Times, LexisNexis Academic (December 26, 2008).

  • Smothers, R. (1992, February 19). Hate groups seen growing as Neo-Nazis draw young. The New York Times, LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Tuch, S., & Martin, J. (Eds.). (1997). Racial attitudes in the 1990s: Continuity and change. London: Praeger.

    Google Scholar 

  • Urbina, I. (2007, September 20). Victim tells police of possible motive for abduction. The New York Times, LexisNexis Academic (December 23, 2009).

  • Vester, L. (1999, August 16). Los Angeles police department trying to prevent spread of racial violence with help of new computer database. NBC News at Sunrise, LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

  • Williams, B. (2009, June 10). In depth; hate crimes on rise in US. NBC Nightly News. NBC News Transcripts. LexisNexis Academic (February 11, 2010).

  • Wohl, C., & Moran, T. (1999, April 7) Trying to stop hate crimes. ABC World News This Morning. LexisNexis Academic (October 27, 2009).

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. New York University, New York, NY, USA

    Clara S. Lewis

Authors
  1. Clara S. Lewis
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Clara S. Lewis.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Lewis, C.S. Tough-on-Crime Tolerance: The Cultural Criminalization of Bigotry in the Post-Civil Rights Era. Crit Crim 20, 275–292 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-011-9140-1

Download citation

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-011-9140-1

Keywords

Search

Navigation