Public debate about post 9/11 policing presumes for the most part that the world changed fundamentally at that point and that policing powers and tactics have altered in response. For some people, largely defenders of the necessity of a strong security stance, the changes have been possibly not enough. For others, opponents of the security state, the changes represent a latest instalment in an always threatening rise of totalitarian policing. Seen in macro-perspective these views represent the politics of security, helping to shape, modulate, contain, expand, limit the powers available to police, and the possible uses of them. These opposing views, very often highly antagonistic in expression, are part of the politics, and do not stand outside them. They have also been heard before. In seeking to understand what policing means for stable societies under threat of political violence, this article examines some key transitions in the development of security policing over the last 100 years in Australia, highlighting some of the contextual features that have shaped them. In doing so it will suggest that apocalyptic rhetoric is part of the politics of policing, shared by both advocates and opponents of tougher policing, and in tension with the more sober realities of a policing that operates within a framework of enabling as well as limiting conditions.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Nathaniel Peffer to JV Barry, 30 Sep 1954, NLA MS 2505/1/2206, cited in : Peffer referred here to the defection in 1954 of the Australian-based Soviet intelligence agents Vladimir and Evdokia Petrov.
The temper of the time can be gathered from the unique historical incident in November 1920 of the expulsion (on the motion of the Prime Minister) from the Federal Parliament of Irish–Australian parliamentarian, Hugh Mahon, for statements made outside the house regarding the Irish grievance against England: [18, 23].
National Archives of Australia (hereafter NAA) A816 (A816/1), 11/301/270, Conference of the Police Commissioners of the Commonwealth of Australia and New Zealand with military officers, regarding national emergency, Brisbane, 1 Aug 1939.
See e.g. the fumbling government attempts to use the migration language test to exclude the visiting Czech writer Egon Kisch in 1934: 
Maurice Blackburn (1939) cited in 
For the administrative history of the CSS see ‘Agency notes for agency CA 660’, NAA (online at http://naa12.naa.gov.au/scripts/AgencyDetail.asp?M=3&B=CA+660); on Duncan and wartime policing see 
On relations between the newly formed ASIO and State police see ‘History of ASIO by Bob Swan’, vol 10, fols 7–11, NAA A6122/2076. In 1965 the State police commissioners rejected a suggestion for an annual gathering of Special Branch heads (in parallel with the CIB meetings which had been held since the 1940s), on the grounds that the ASIO co-ordinated meetings made this proposal redundant: Minutes of Conference of Police Commissioners, 1965, p. 249 (AFP Library, Canberra).
Minutes of Conference of Police Commissioners, 1964–1966.
In 1968 the national Conference of the Police Commissioners discussed establishment of a National Police Research Unit; their discussions suggest that one concern was to combat the dangers of outsider research. The brief reference to this discussion in the memoirs of the most independent and forward looking of the Commissioners, Ray Whitrod, fails to convey just how resistant were the police to outside scrutiny: 
Charter attached to letter of RG Menzies to Spry, 6 July 1950, ‘History of ASIO by Bob Swan’, volume 12, NAA A6122/2078, fols 35–38.
A comparison of the two charters was made in the 1977 Hope Inquiry: Australia. Royal Commission on Intelligence and Security .
See Swan, Vol 13, Minute to Regional Director, Victoria 29 July 1970 from undisclosed officer, fol 114–115; and see 
Some indication of the scope of the changes can be gathered from the official Commonwealth information statement, ‘Australian laws to combat terrorism’, at http://www.nationalsecurity.gov.au/agd/www/nationalsecurity.nsf/AllDocs/826190776D49EA90CA256FAB001BA5EA?OpenDocument (accessed 5 March 2008).
Aarons, M. (2001). War criminals welcome: Australia, a sanctuary for fugitive war criminals since 1945. Black: Melbourne.
Anderson, F. (2005). Into the Night: Max Crawford, the Labyrinth of the Social Studies Enquiry and ASIO's ‘Spoiling Operations'. Australian Historical Studies, 125, 60–80.
Australia. Protective Security Review. & Hope R. M. (1979). Protective Security Review report: unclassified version. Canberra, Australian Government.
Australia. Royal Commission on Intelligence and Security (Hope, R. M., Commissioner) (1977). Fourth report. Canberra: Australian Government.
Australian Federal Police. (2008). The Street Review: a review of interoperability between the AFP and its national security partners (url: http://www.afp.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/71833/The_Street_Review.pdf, accessed 15 March 2008).
Australian Law Reform Commission (2006). Fighting words a review of sedition laws in Australia. Sydney, Australian Law Reform Commission.
Baker, D. (2004). Batons and blockades: Policing industrial disputes in Australasia. Melbourne: Circa.
Blackshield, A. R., Coper, M., et al. (2001). The Oxford companion to the High Court of Australia. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
Bolen, J. (1997). Reform in policing: lessons from the Whitrod era. Sydney: Hawkins.
Brennan, F. (1983). Too much order with too little law. St. Lucia: University of Queensland Press.
Bronitt, S. H., & Stellios, J. (2006). Sedition, security and human rights: ‘unbalanced’ law reform in the ‘War on Terror’. Melbourne University Law Review, 30(3), 923–960.
Burgmann, V. (1995). Revolutionary industrial unionism: The Industrial Workers of the World in Australia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cain, F. (1983). The origins of political surveillance in Australia. Sydney: Angus & Robertson.
Cain, F. (1994). The Australian Security Intelligence Organization: An unofficial history. Richmond: Spectrum.
Chappell, D., & Wilson, P. R. (1969). The police and the public in Australia and New Zealand. St. Lucia: University of Queensland Press.
Cresciani, G. (1980). Fascism, anti-fascism, and Italians in Australia, 1922–1945. Canberra: Australian National University Press.
Curthoys, A. & Merritt J. A., Eds. (1984). Australia's first cold war. Sydney: G. Allen.
Cusack, D. (2005). Contrasting Irish–Australian Responses to Empire: Hugh Mahon MHR and Senator Paddy Lynch. Australian Journal of Irish Studies, 5, 19–35.
Evans, R. (1987). Loyalty and disloyalty: Social conflict on the Queensland homefront, 1914–18. Sydney: G. Allen.
Finnane, M. (1994). Police and government: Histories of policing in Australia. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
Finnane, M. (2002). When police unionise: The politics of law and order in Australia. Sydney: Sydney Institute of Criminology.
Finnane, M. (2007). J V Barry: A Life. Sydney: UNSW.
Fitzhardinge, L. F. (1964). William Morris Hughes: A political biography. Sydney: Angus & Robertson.
Fox, R. (1979). The Salisbury affair: Special Branches, security and subversion. Monash University Law Review, 5, 251–270.
Golder, B., & Williams, G. (2006). Balancing national security and human rights: Assessing the legal response of common law nations to the threat of terrorism. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 8(1), 43–62.
Grabosky, P. (1989). Political surveillance and the South Australian police in P. Grabosky, Wayward governance: illegality and its control in the public sector. Canberra Australian Institute of Criminology, 113–128.
Gumpl, G., & Kleinig, R. (2007). The Hitler Club: The rise and fall of Australia's No. 1 Nazi. Melbourne: Brolga.
Haldane, R. K. (1986). The people's force: A history of the Victoria Police. Carlton: Melbourne University Press.
Hasluck, P. (1952). The government and the people, 1939–1941. Canberra: Australian War Memorial.
Hasluck, P. (1970). The government and the people: 1942–1945. Canberra: Australian War Memorial.
High Court of Australia. (2007). Thomas v Mowbray  HCA 33 (2 August 2007).
Hocking, J. (1997). Lionel Murphy: A political biography. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
Hocking, J. (2001). Robert Menzies. ‘Fundamental authoritarianism’: the 1951 referendum. In P. Love, & P. Strangio (Eds.), Arguing the Cold War. Carlton: Red Rag.
Hocking, J. (2004). Terror laws: ASIO, counter-terrorism and the threat to democracy. Sydney: UNSW.
Kelly, P. (2007). At war over the law. The Australian. July 21.
Kildea, J. (2002). Tearing the fabric: Sectarianism in Australia 1910 to 1925. Sydney: Citadel.
Lake, M. (1975). A divided society: Tasmania during World War I. Carlton: Melbourne University Press.
Loader, I., & Walker, N. (2007). Civilizing security. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Love, P., & Strangio, P. (2001). Arguing the Cold War. Carlton: Red Rag.
Lowe, D. (1999). Menzies and the “great world struggle”: Australia's Cold War 1948–1954. Sydney: UNSW.
Lustgarten, L., & Leigh, I. (1994). In from the cold: National security and parliamentary democracy. Oxford: Clarendon.
Lynch, A., & Williams, G. (2006). What price security? Taking stock of Australia's anti-terror laws. Sydney: University of New South Wales Press.
Lynch, A., et al. (2007). Law and liberty in the war on terror. Leichhardt, N.S.W.:: Federation.
Macintyre, S. (1998). The reds. St. Leonards: G. Allen.
Martin, A. W. (1996). Mr. Menzies’ anticommunism. Quadrant (Sydney), 40(5), 47–56.
McCulloch, J. (2001). Blue army: Paramilitary policing in Australia. Carlton: Melbourne University Press.
McKnight, D. (1994). Australia's spies and their secrets. St Leonards: G. Allen.
Moore, A. (1992). ‘"A secret policeman's lot": the working life of Fred Longbottom of the New South Wales Police Special Branch. All our labours: oral histories of working life in twentieth-century Sydney, J. Shields. Kensington, NSW, NSWU
Moore, A. (2000). “When the caretaker's busy taking care”? Cross-currents in Australian Political Surveillance and Internment, 1935–1941. In K. Saunders, & R. Daniels (Eds.), Alien justice: wartime internment in Australia and North America. St Lucia, Qld.: University of Queensland Press.
Munro, C. (1984). Wild man of letters: The story of P.R. Stephensen. Carlton: Melbourne University Press.
Murphy, J. (2000). Imagining the fifties: Private sentiment and political culture in Menzies’ Australia. Sydney: Pluto.
Nettelbeck, A., & Foster, R. (2007). In the name of the law: William Willshire and the policing of the Australian frontier. Kent Town: Wakefield.
Nicholls, G. (2007). Deported: A history of forced departures from Australia. Sydney: UNSW Press.
O'Brien, N. (2008). Share intelligence or repeat Ul-Haque debacle. The Australian, 28 February, url: http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,23288095-31477,00.html.
O'Farrell, P. (2000). The Irish in Australia. Kensington, N.S.W.: New South Wales University Press.
O'Neil, A. (2007). Degrading and managing risk: Assessing Australia’s counter-terrorist strategy. Australian Journal of Political Science, 42(3), 471–487.
Peffer, N. (1955). Australia: America’s uneasy ally. Yale Review, 3, 411–420.
Porter, B. (1991). The origins of the vigilant state: The London Metropolitan Police Special Branch before the First World War. Woodbridge, Suffolk: Boydell.
Priest, S., & Simpson, T. (2001). Irish Envoys Case. In A. R. Blackshield, M. Coper, & G. Williams (Eds.), The Oxford companion to the High Court of Australia (pp. 358–359). Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
Simpson, A. W. B. (2001). Human rights and the end of empire: Britain and the genesis of the European Convention. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Svensen, S. (1989). The shearers’ war: The story of the 1891 shearers’ strike. St. Lucia: University of Queensland Press.
Templeton, J. (1977). Australian Intelligence/Security Services, 1900–1950, National Archives of Australia A8909/1.
Thacher, D. (2005). The local role in homeland security. Law & Society Review, 39(3), 635–676.
Watson, D. (1979). Brian Fitzpatrick: A radical life. Sydney: Hale & Iremonger.
Whitrod, R. W. (2001). Before I sleep: memoirs of a modern police commissioner p. 101. St Lucia: Qld., University of Queensland Press.
Wilson, D. (2006). The beat: Policing a Victorian city. Beaconsfield: Melbourne Publishing Group.
Wilson, P. R., & Chappell, D. (1971). The law and order issue and police-public relations. ANZ Journal of Criminology, 4(2), 112–116.
Winter, B. (2005). The Australia First Movement and the Publicist, 1936–1942. Carindale: Glass House.
Woodward, A. E. (2005). One brief interval: A memoir. Carlton: Miegunyah.
ARC Australian Professorial Fellow, ARC Centre of Excellence in Policing and Security, Griffith University. Research for this article has been carried out with the support of the Australian Research Council (DP0771492). I am grateful to John Myrtle for his research assistance.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Finnane, M. The public rhetorics of policing in times of war and violence: countering apocalyptic visions. Crime Law Soc Change 50, 7–24 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10611-008-9125-5
- State Police
- National Security
- Civil Liberty
- Security Threat
- Political Violence