Advertisement

Community Mental Health Journal

, Volume 47, Issue 3, pp 252–266 | Cite as

Can Consumer-Led Mental Health Services be Equally Effective? An Integrative Review of CLMH Services in High-Income Countries

  • Carolyn Doughty
  • Samson TseEmail author
Original Paper

Abstract

This study examined the evidence from controlled studies for the effectiveness of consumer-led mental health services. Following an extensive search of material published in English from 1980, predefined inclusion criteria were systematically applied to research articles that compared a consumer-led mental health service to a traditional mental health service. A total of 29 eligible studies were appraised; all of them were conducted in high-income countries. Overall consumer-led services reported equally positive outcomes for their clients as traditional services, particularly for practical outcomes such as employment or living arrangements, and in reducing hospitalizations and thus the cost of services. Involving consumers in service delivery appears to provide employment opportunities and be beneficial overall for the consumer-staff members and the service. Despite growing evidence of effectiveness, barriers such as underfunding continue to limit the use and evaluation of consumer-led services. Future studies need to adopt more uniform definitions and prioritize the inclusion of recovery oriented outcome measures.

Keywords

Service users Recovery Empowerment Consumer-led Mental health services 

Notes

Acknowledgments

We gratefully acknowledge the contributions of anonymous reviewers and Mr Leo McIntyre whose assistance significantly improved the quality of this manuscript.

References

  1. Allott, P., Clark, M., & Slade, M. (2006). Taking DREEM Forward. Background and summary of experience with REE/REEM so far. Report prepared for Director of Mental Health Research, London, United Kingdom: Department of Health.Google Scholar
  2. Anderson, R., Caputi, P., & Oades, L. (2006). Stages of recovery instrument: Development of a measure of recovery from serious mental illness. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 40, 972–980.Google Scholar
  3. Burti, L., Amaddeo, F., Ambrosi, M., Bonetto, C., Cristofalo, D., Ruggeri, M., et al. (2005). Does additional care provided by a consumer self-help group improve psychiatric outcome? A study in an Italian community-based psychiatric service. Community Mental Health Journal, 41(6), 705–720.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Campbell, J. (2005). The historical and philosophical development of peer-run support programs. In S. Clay (Ed.), Doing it our way: Peer programs that work for people with mental illness. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Campbell, J. (2004). Consumer-operated services program (COSP) multisite research initiative: Overview and preliminary findings. Saint Louis, MO: Missouri Institute of Mental Health.Google Scholar
  6. Castelein, S., Bruggeman, R., van Busschbach, J. T., van der Gaag, M., Stant, A. D., Knegtering, H., et al. (2008). The effectiveness of peer support groups in psychosis: A randomized controlled trial. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 118, 64–72.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Chen, H. (1990). Theory-driven evaluations. Newbury Park, California: Sage.Google Scholar
  8. Chinman, M. J., Rosenheck, R., Lam, J. A., & Davidson, L. (2000). Comparing consumer and non-consumer provided case management services for homeless persons with serious mental illness. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 188(7), 446–453.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Chinman, M. J., Weingarten, R., Stayner, D., & Davidson, L. (2001). Chronicity reconsidered: Improving person-environment fit through a consumer-run service. Community Mental Health Journal, 37(3), 215–229.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Clark, C., Scott, E., Boydell, K., & Goering, P. (1999). Effects of clients interviewers on client-reported satisfaction with mental health services. Psychiatric Services, 50, 961–963.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  11. Clarke, G. N., Herinckx, H. A., Kinney, R. F., Paulson, R. I., Cutler, D. L., Lewis, K., et al. (2000). Psychiatric hospitalizations, arrests, emergency room visits, and homelessness of clients with serious and persistent mental illness: Findings from a randomized trial of two ACT Programs vs. usual care. Mental Health Services Research, 2(3), 155–164.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Cook, J. A., Jonikas, J. A., & Razzano, L. (1995). A randomized evaluation of consumer versus non-consumer training of state mental health service providers. Community Mental Health Journal, 31(3), 229–238.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Craig, T., Doherty, I., Jamieson-Craig, R., Boocock, A., & Attafua, G. (2004). The consumer-employee as a member of a Mental Health Assertive Outreach Team. I. Clinical and social outcomes. Journal of Mental Health, 13(1), 59–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Crawford, M. J., & Rutter, D. (2004). Are the views of members of mental health user groups representative of those of ‘ordinary’ patients? A cross-sectional survey of service users and providers. Journal of Mental Health, 13(6), 561–568.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Davidson, L., Chinman, M., Kloos, B., Weingarten, R., Stayner, D., & Tebes, J. K. (1999). Peer support among individuals with severe mental illness: A review of the evidence. Clinical Psychology-Science and Practice, 6(2), 165–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Davidson, L., Chinman, M. J., Kloos, B., Weingarten, R., Stayner, D. A., & Tebes, J. K. (2005). Peer support among individuals with severe mental illness: A review of the evidence. In L. Davidson, C. Harding, & L. Spaniol (Eds.), Recovery from severe mental illnesses: Research evidence and implications for practice, Volume 1 (pp. 412–450). Boston: Boston University Center for Psychiatric Rehabilitation.Google Scholar
  17. Davidson, L., Shahar, G., Stayner, D. A., Chinman, M. J., Rakfeldt, J., & Tebes, J. K. (2004). Supported socialization for people with psychiatric disabilities: Lessons from a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Community Psychology, 32(4), 453–477.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Dumont, J., & Jones, K. (2002). Findings from a consumer/survivor defined alternative to psychiatric hospitalization. Outlook, Evaluation Center@HSRI and NASMHPD Research Institute, Spring issue, pp. 4–6.Google Scholar
  19. Felton, C. J., Stastny, P., Shern, D. L., Blanch, A., Donahue, S. A., Knight, E., et al. (1995). Consumers as peer specialists on intensive case management teams: Impact on client outcomes. Psychiatric Services, 46(10), 1037–1044.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Forchuk, C., Martin, M., Chan, Y. L., & Jensen, E. (2005). Therapeutic relationships: From psychiatric hospital to community. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 12(5), 556–564.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Goldstrom, I., Campbell, J., Rogers, J., Lambert, D., Blacklow, B., Henderson, M., et al. (2006). National estimates for mental health mutual support groups, self-help organizations, and consumer-operated services. Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 33(1), 92–103.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Gordon, S. (2009). Taku Reo, Taku Mauri Ora: My voice, my life. Developing a consumer-assessed outcome measure for Aotearoa/New Zealand. Auckland, New Zealand: The National Centre of Mental Health Research, Information and Workforce Development.Google Scholar
  23. Gordon, S., Ellis, P., & Haggerty, C. (2004). Preliminary work towards the development of a self-assessed measure of consumer outcome. A mental health research and development strategy report. Auckland, New Zealand: Health Research Council of New Zealand.Google Scholar
  24. Graham, C., Coombs, T., Buckingham, B., Eagar, K., Trauer, T., & Callaly, T. (2001). The Victorian Mental Health Outcomes Measurement Strategy: Consumer perspectives on future directions for outcome self-assessment. Report of the Consumer Consultation Project. Victoria, Australia: Department of Human Services.Google Scholar
  25. Greenfield, T., Stoneking, B., Humphreys, K., Sundby, E., & Bond, J. (2008). A randomized trial of a mental health consumer-managed alternative to civil commitment for acute psychiatric crisis. American Journal of Psychology, 42, 135–144.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Kane, C. F., & Blank, M. B. (2004). NPACT: Enhancing programs of assertive community treatment for the seriously mentally ill. Community Mental Health Journal, 40(6), 549–559.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Kaufmann, C. (1995). The self help employment center: Some outcomes from the first year. Psychosocial Rehabilitation Journal, 18(4), 145–162.Google Scholar
  28. Klein, A., Cnaan, R., & Whitecraft, J. (1998). Significance of peer social support with dually diagnosed clients: Findings from a pilot study. Research on Social Work Practice, 8(5), 529–551.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Mowbray, C. T., & Tan, C. (1993). Consumer-operated drop-in centers: Evaluation of operations and impact. Journal of Mental Health Administration, 20, 8–19.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Mueser, K., Glynn, S., Corrigan, P., & Baber, W. (1996). A survey of preferred terms for users of mental health services. Psychiatric Services, 47(7), 760–761.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  31. National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors. (1989). NASMHPD Position Paper on Consumer Contributions to Mental Health Service Delivery Systems. Arlington, VA: NASMHPD.Google Scholar
  32. National Health and Medical Research Council. (2000). How to use the evidence: Assessment and application of scientific evidence. Canberra: NHMRC.Google Scholar
  33. Nelson, G., Ochocka, J., Janzen, R., & Trainor, J. (2006a). A longitudinal study of mental health consumer/survivor initiatives: Part 1–Literature review and overview of the study. Journal of Community Psychology, 34(3), 247–260.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Nelson, G., Ochocka, J., Janzen, R., & Trainor, J. (2006b). A longitudinal study of mental health consumer/survivor initiatives: Part 2—a quantitative study of impacts of participation on new members. Journal of Community Psychology, 34(3), 261–272.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. O’Donnell, M., Parker, G., Proberts, M., Matthews, R., Fisher, D., Johnson, B., et al. (1999). A study of client-focused case management and consumer advocacy: The Community and Consumer Service Project. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 33(5), 684–693.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  36. Ochocka, J., Nelson, G., Janzen, R., & Trainor, J. (2006). A longitudinal study of mental health consumer/survivor initiatives: Part 3—a qualitative study of impacts of participation on new members. Journal of Community Psychology, 34(3), 273–283.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Paulson, R., Henrickx, H., Demmler, J., Clarke, G., Cutler, D., & Birecree, E. (1999). Comparing practice patterns of consumer and non-consumer mental health service providers. Community Mental Health Journal, 35(3), 251–269.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Polowczyk, D., Brutus, M., Orvieto, A., Vidal, J., & Cipriani, D. (1993). Comparison of patient and staff surveys of consumer satisfaction. Hospital & Community Psychiatry, 44(6), 589–591.Google Scholar
  39. Powell, T., Hill, E., Warner, L., Yeaton, W., & Silk, K. (2000). Encouraging people with mood disorders to attend a self-help group. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 30(11), 2270–2288.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Rapp, C. A., & Goscha, R. J. (2006). The strengths model: Case management with people with psychiatric disabilities (2nd ed.). NY, US: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  41. Sells, D., Davidson, L., Jewell, C., Falzer, P., & Rowe, M. (2006). The treatment relationship in peer-based and regular case management for clients with severe mental illness. Psychiatric Services, 57(8), 1179–1184.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Simpson, E. L., & House, A. O. (2002). Involving users in the delivery and evaluation of mental health services: Systematic review. British Medical Journal, 325(7375), 1265.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Solomon, P., & Draine, J. (1995a). The efficacy of a consumer case management team: 2-year outcomes of a randomized trial. Journal of Mental Health Administration, 22, 135–146.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Solomon, P., & Draine, J. (1995b). One year outcome of a randomized trial of consumer case managers. Evaluation & Program Planning, 18, 117–127.Google Scholar
  45. Solomon, P., & Draine, J. (1996). Service delivery differences between consumer and non-consumer case managers in mental health. Research on Social Work Practice, 6(2), 193–207.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Summers, A. (2003). Involving users in the development of mental health services: A study of psychiatrists’ views. Journal of Mental Health, 12(2), 161–174.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. The World Bank. (2010). Country classifications. Available online at http://data.worldbank.org/about/country-classifications.
  48. Uttaro, T., Leahy, V., Gonzalez, A., & Henri, W. F. (2004). Effect of type of survey administrator on Consumer Assessment of Care. Psychological Reports, 94(3 Pt 2), 1279–1282.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  49. Wood, A. L., & Wahl, O. F. (2006). Evaluating the effectiveness of a consumer-provided mental health recovery education presentation. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 30(1), 46–53.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Young, A. S., Chinman, M., Forquer, S. L., Knight, E. L., Vogel, H., Miller, A., et al. (2005). Use of a consumer-led intervention to improve provider competencies. Psychiatric Services, 56(8), 967–975.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Public Health and General PracticeUniversity of OtagoChristchurchNew Zealand
  2. 2.Department of Social Work and Social Administration, Faculty of Social SciencesThe University of Hong KongHong KongChina

Personalised recommendations