Abstract
We examine the relation between earnings information content and the use of trust words, such as “character,” “ethics,” and “honest,” in the MD&A section of 10-K. We find that earnings announcements of firms using trust words have lower information content than earnings announcements of firms that do not use trust words. We also find that the value relevance of earnings is lower for firms using trust words than those not using trust words. Further, firms using trust words are more likely to receive a comment letter from the SEC, pay higher audit fees, and have lower corporate social responsibility scores. Overall, our results suggest that firms that use trust words in the 10-K are associated with negative outcomes, and trust words are an inverse measure of trust.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Larcker & Zakolyukina (2012) and Hope & Wang (2018) apply linguistic analysis to assess the likelihood of management deception. A textual analysis could be useful in identifying misleading corporate disclosures that can result in wealth transfers to managers from investors (Merkl-Davies et al., 2011). Deloitte Consulting’s textual analysis tool, Bullfighter, found that when Enron's performance began to sink, its communications became increasingly laden with ambiguous words and sentences (Finextra, 2003). Similarly, Craig et al. (2013) find that Ramalinga Raju, former Chairman of Satyam Computers, changed his word choices noticeably in the five annual reports prior to the collapse of Satyam.
The complete list of trust words used in the study appears in Section “Measure of trust”.
Audi et al. (2016) report that firms use an average of 0.6315 words of the 21 trust words and the 90th percentile is 2. We find an average of 0.94 words and the 90th percentile of 2 in our pooled sample (untabulated).
See Merkl-Davies & Brennan (2007) for earlier studies on impression management.
Guiso et al. (2015) do not find evidence of the relation between advertised values and Tobin’s q.
Haggard et al. (2008) report that firms with higher disclosure quality tend to have lower price comovement and lower price crash risk.
These findings are consistent with Yuthas et al. (2002) that managers engage in ethical communication to establish legitimacy with stakeholders.
Corporate narratives are not audited or regulated.
Our results remain qualitatively unchanged with the number of first occurrences of the 21 trust words (TRUSTF) in 10-Ks.
Untabulated results show that 27.72 percent of firms using trust words use them once, and 14.46 percent of the firms use trust words for 2 years in a row. 57.82 percent of the firms use trust words for 3 years or longer in a row.
Untabulated results show that the mean (median) value of the number of first use of trust words (TRUSTF) in the pooled sample is 0.940 (0.0), comparable to the mean (median) of 0.632 (0.0) in Audi et al. (2016) based on data from 1997 to 2012. The mean length of 10-Ks is 55,236, compared to the mean of 42,275 words in Audi et al. (2016), suggesting an increase in the number of words in 10-Ks in recent years.
We interpret our results as evidence of the association between lower earnings information content and the use of trust words, not as trust words causing lower earnings information content.
Functional form misspecification may arise if the dependent and independent variables are misspecified (Shipman et al., 2017).
The sample was matched with replacement. The mean (median) propensity score of firms using trust words is 0.4768 (0.4819) while the mean (median) score of firms without trust words is 0.4768 (0.4816). The mean (median) firm size (SIZE) of firms using trust words is 5.5877 (5.5786) while the mean (median) value of firms without trust words is 5.5984 (5.5894). The mean (median) ROA of firms using trust words is − 0.1426 (0.0156) while the mean (median) value of firms without trust words is − 0.1522 (00177). The SIZE and ROA differences are statistically insignificant. We find that managerial ability is negatively associated with the likelihood of using trust words, consistent with the view that managers may use discretion in the writing to manage impression (Guillamon-Saorin et al., 2017). The likelihood of using trust words is positively associated with size, loss, and complexity.
References
Altman, E. (1968). Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy. Journal of Finance, 23(4), 589–609.
Audi, R., Loughran, T., & McDonald, B. (2016). Trust, but verify: MD&A language and the role of trust in corporate culture. Journal of Business Ethics, 139, 551–561.
Balachandran, B., Karuna, C., Mishra, S., & Puwanenthiran, P. (2021). Client-firm culture-related disclosure in Form 10-K reports and audit fees. Retrieved from https://ssrn.com/abstract=3908295.
Beaver, W. H. (1968). The information content of annual earnings announcements. Journal of Accounting Research, 6, 67–92.
Brennan, N. M., Guillamon-Saorin, E., & Pierce, A. (2009). Developing and illustrating a scheme of analysis for narrative disclosures—a methodological note. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 22(5), 789–832.
Breuer, W., Knetsch, A., & Salzmann, A. J. (2020). What does it mean when managers talk about trust? Journal of Business Ethics, in press.
Brown, P., & Levinson, S. C. (1987). Politeness. Some universals in language usage. Cambridge University Press.
Campbell, J. (2007). Why would corporations behave in socially responsible ways? An institutional theory of corporate social responsibility. Academy of Management Review, 32, 946–967.
Cassell, C. A., Dreher, L. M., & Myers, L. A. (2013). Reviewing the SEC’s review process: 10-K comment letters and the cost of remediation. The Accounting Review, 88(6), 1875–1908.
Chen, H., Francis, B. B., Hasan, T., & Wu, Q. (2021). Does corporate culture impact audit pricing? Evidence from textual analysis. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, forthcoming.
Cho, M., & Kwon, S. Y. (2014). Trading volume and investor disagreement around management forecast disclosure. Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, 29(1), 3–30.
Choi, J., Kim, J., & Zang, Y. (2010). Do abnormally high audit fees impair audit quality? Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 29(2), 115–140.
Clatworthy, M., & Jones, M. J. (2001). The effect of thematic structure on the variability of annual report readability. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 14(3), 311–326.
Collins, D. W., Maydew, E. L., & Weiss, I. S. (1997). Changes in the value-relevance of earnings and book values over the past forty years. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 24(1), 39–67.
Craig, R., Mortensen, T., & Iyer, S. (2013). Exploring top management language for signals of possible deception: The words of Satyam’s chair Ramalinga Raju. Journal of Business Ethics, 113, 333–347.
Davis, A. K., Ge, W., Matsumoto, D., & Zhang, J. L. (2015). The effect of manager-specific optimism on the tone of earnings conference calls. Review of Accounting Studies, 20(2), 639–667.
Demerjian, P. R., Lev, B., Lewis, M. F., & McVay, S. E. (2012). Managerial ability and earnings quality. The Accounting Review, 88(2), 463–498.
DePaulo, B. M., Kashy, D. A., Kirkendol, S. E., Wyer, M. M., & Epstein, J. A. (1996). Lying in everyday life. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 70(5), 979–995.
Dobija, D., & Klimczak, K. M. (2010). Development of accounting in Poland: Market efficiency and the value relevance of reported earnings. International Journal of Accounting, 45(3), 356–374.
Easton, P. D., & Harris, T. S. (1991). Earnings as an explanatory variable for returns. Journal of Accounting Research, 29(1), 19–36.
Falschlunger, L. M., Eisl, C., Losbichler, H., & Greil, A. M. (2015). Impression management in annual reports of the largest European companies. A longitudinal study on graphical representations. Journal of Applied Accounting Research, 16(3), 383–399.
Fan, J. P. H., Guan, F., Li, Z., & Yang, G. (2014). Relationship networks and earnings informativeness: Evidence from corruption cases. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 41(7), 831–866.
Finextra. (2003). Deloitte declares war on corporate jargon. Retrieved from https://www.finextra.com/newsarticle/9221/deloitte-declares-war-on-corporate-jargon.
Francis, J., Philbrick, D., & Schipper, K. (1994). Shareholder litigation and corporate disclosures. Journal of Accounting Research, 32(2), 137–164.
Francis, J., & Schipper, K. (1999). Have financial statements lost their relevance? Journal of Accounting Research, 37(2), 319–352.
Francis, J., LaFond, R., Olsson, P. M., & Schipper, K. (2004). Costs of equity and earnings attributes. The Accounting Review, 79(4), 967–1010.
Gardner, W. L., & Martinko, M. J. (1988). Impression management in organizations. Journal of Management, 14(2), 321–338.
Goffman, E. (1959). The presentation of self in everyday life. Doubleday.
Greiner, A., Patelli, L., & Pedrini, M. (2020). Characteristics of managerial tone priced by auditors: evidence based on annual letters to shareholders of large US firms. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 39(2), 139–161.
Gu, Z. (2007). Across-sample incomparability of R2s and additional evidence on value relevance changes over time. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 34(7/8), 1073–1098.
Guillamon-Saorin, E., Isidro, H., & Marques, A. (2017). Impression management and non-GAAP disclosure in earnings announcements. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 44(3–4), 448–479.
Guiso, L., Sapienza, P., & Zingales, L. (2015). The value of corporate culture. Journal of Financial Economics, 117(1), 60–76.
Gul, F. A., & Tsui, J. S. L. (1998). A test of the free cash flow and debt monitoring hypotheses: Evidence from audit pricing. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 24, 219–237.
Gul, F. A., Fung, S. Y. K., & Jaggi, B. L. (2009). Earnings quality: Some evidence on the role of auditor tenure and auditors’ industry expertise. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 47(3), 265–287.
Haggard, K. S., Martin, X., & Pereira, R. (2008). Does voluntary disclosure improve stock price informativeness? Financial Management, 37(4), 747–768.
Highhouse, S., Brooks, M. E., & Gregarus, G. (2009). An organizational impression management perspective on the formation of corporate reputations. Journal of Management, 35(6), 1481–1493.
Hong, H., & Kacperczyk, M. (2007). The Price of Sin: The Effects of Social Norms on Markets. Princeton University Press.
Hooghiemstra, R. (2000). Corporate communication and impression management – New perspectives why companies engage in social reporting. Journal of Business Ethics, 27, 55–68.
Hope, O.-K., & Wang, J. (2018). Management deception, big-bath accounting, and information asymmetry: Evidence from linguistic analysis. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 70(October), 33–51.
Huang, H., Raghunandan, K., & Rama, D. (2009). Audit fees for initial audit engagements before and after SOX. Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory, 28(1), 171–190.
Huang, H. W., Raghunandan, K., Huang, T. C., & Chiou, J. R. (2015). Fee discounting and audit quality following audit firm and audit partner changes: Chinese evidence. The Accounting Review, 90(4), 1517–1546.
Huang, X., Teoh, S. H., & Zhang, Y. (2014). Tone management. The Accounting Review, 89(3), 1083–1113.
Hui, K. W., Lennox, C., & Zhang, G. (2014). The market’s valuation of fraudulently reported earnings. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 41(5–6), 627–651.
Johnson, R., & Greening, D. (1999). The effects of corporate governance and institutional ownership types on corporate social performance. Academy of Management Journal, 42, 564–576.
Joos, P., & Lang, M. (1994). The effects of accounting diversity: Evidence from the European Union. Journal of Accounting Research, 32(Supplement), 141–168.
Karpoff, J. M., & Lott, J. R. (1993). The reputational penalty firms bear from committing criminal fraud. Journal of Law and Economics, 36(2), 757–802.
Kim, Y., Park, M. S., & Wier, B. (2012). Is earnings quality associated with corporate social responsibility? The Accounting Review, 87(3), 761–796.
Kim, I., & Skinner, D. J. (2012). Measuring securities litigation risk. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 53(1–2), 290–310.
Larcker, D., & Zakolyukina, A. A. (2012). Detecting deceptive discussions in conference calls. Journal of Accounting Research, 50(2), 495–540.
Lev, B., & Zarowin, P. (1999). The boundaries of financial reporting and how to extend them. Journal of Accounting Research, 37(2), 353–385.
Li, F. (2010). Textual analysis of corporate disclosures: A survey of the literature. Journal of Accounting Literature, 29, 143–165.
Loughran, T., McDonald, B., & Yun, H. (2009). A wolf in sheep’s clothing: The use of ethics-related terms in 10-K reports. Journal of Business Ethics, 89, 39–49.
Loughran, T., & McDonald, B. (2016). Textual analysis in accounting and finance: A survey. Journal of Accounting Literature, 54(4), 1187–1230.
Loughran, T., McDonald, B., & Otteson, J. R. (2022). How have corporate codes of ethics responded to an era of increased scrutiny? Journal of Business Ethics, in press.
Lys, T., Naughton, J. P., & Wang, C. (2015). Signaling through corporate accountability reporting. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 60, 56–72.
McWilliams, A., & Siegel, D. (2000). Corporate social responsibility and financial performance: Correlation or misspecification? Strategic Management Journal, 21, 603–609.
Merkl-Davies, D. M., & Brennan, N. M. (2007). Discretionary disclosure strategies in corporate narratives: Incremental information or impression management? Journal of Accounting Literature, 26, 116–194.
Merkl-Davies, D. M., Brennan, N. M., & McLeay, S. J. (2011). Impression management and retrospective sense-making in corporate narratives. A social psychology perspective. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 24(3), 315–344.
Patelli, L., & Pedrini, M. (2014). Is the optimism in CEO’s letters to shareholders sincere? Impression management versus communicative action during the economic crisis. Journal of Business Ethics, 124, 19–34.
Patelli, L., & Pedrini, M. (2015). Is tone at the top associated with financial reporting aggressiveness? Journal of Business Ethics, 126, 3–19.
Pevzner, M., Xie, F., & Xin, X. (2015). When firms talk, do investors listen? The role of trust in stock market reactions to corporate earnings announcements. Journal of Financial Economics, 117, 190–223.
Preston, L., & O’Bannon, D. (1997). The corporate social-financial performance relation: A typology and analysis. Business Society, 36, 419–429.
Schlenker, B. R., & Weigold, M. F. (1989). Goals and the self-identification process: Constructing desired identities. In L. A. Pervin (Ed.), Goal concepts in personality and social psychology (pp. 243–290). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.
Shipman, J. E., Swanquist, Q. T., & Whited, R. L. (2017). Propensity score matching in accounting research. The Accounting Review, 92(1), 213–244.
Tong, Y. H., & Miao, B. (2011). Are dividends associated with the quality of earnings? Accounting Horizons, 25(1), 183–205.
Veldkamp, L. L. (2006). Information markets and the comovement of asset prices. Review of Economic Studies, 73, 823–845.
Whetten, D. A., Felin, T., & King, B. G. (2009). The practice of theory borrowing in organizational studies: Current issues and future directions. Journal of Management, 35, 537–563.
Wieser, R. (2005). Research and development productivity and spillovers: Empirical evidence at the firm level. Journal of Economic Surveys, 19, 587–621.
Wu, M. (2006). Corporate social performance, corporate financial performance, and firm size: A meta-analysis. Journal of American Academy of Business, 8, 163–171.
Xu, Q., Fernando, G. D., & Tam, K. (2019). Trust and firm performance: A bi-directional study. Advances in Accounting, 47, 100433.
Yuthas, K., Rogers, R., & Dillard, J. F. (2002). Communicative action and corporate annual reports. Journal of Business Ethics, 41(1–2), 141–157.
Acknowledgements
We thank Sheila Killian (editor), two anonymous reviewers, and seminar participants at Bentley University, Kingston University, University of Texas at San Antonio, and the 2022 American Accounting Association Annual Meetings for helpful comments and suggestions on our paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare they have no conflict of interest.
Ethical Approval
This article does not contain research involving human participants or animals performed by the authors.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Appendices
Appendix 1
Examples of Firms Using Trust Words in the MD&A Section of 10-K |
Hillenbrand Industries, INC (2007) (TRUSTDM = 1; TRUSTF = 2; and TRUSTTL = 3) |
An increasing emphasis is being placed within U.S. hospitals to assure quality of care through increased accountability and public disclosure. Quality indicators surrounding patient safety and clinical outcome measurements are increasingly being publicized, and improvement of institutional performance is a matter of focus by many hospital executives and their boards. The “pay for performance” initiative by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (“CMS”) aims to better align reimbursement with improved patient outcomes and the reduction of adverse events. Transparency through public reporting of quality data continues to accelerate, as well as the focus to increase accountability through penalties or rewards resulting from whether quality measures are reported. |
Bank of America Corporation (2009) (TRUSTDM = 1; TRUSTF = 1; and TRUSTTL = 1) |
The Corporation’s risk management infrastructure is evolving to meet the challenges posed by the increased complexity of the financial services industry and markets, by our increased size and global footprint, and by the rapid and significant financial crisis of the past two years. We have redefined our risk framework, articulated a risk appetite approved by the Board of Directors (the Board), and begun the roll out and implementation of our risk plan. While many of these processes, and roles and responsibilities continue to evolve and mature, we will ensure that we continue to enhance our risk management process with a focus on clarity of roles and accountabilities, escalation of issues, aggregation of risk and data across the enterprise, and effective governance characterized by clarity and transparency. |
Coca Cola (2010) (TRUSTDM = 1; TRUSTF = 1; and TRUSTTL = 1) |
Our vision for sustainable growth includes the following: |
Planet: Being a responsible global citizen that makes a difference. |
Willbros Group (2010) (TRUSTDM = 1; TRUSTF = 2; and TRUSTTL = 2) |
Adherence to our values of safety, honesty and integrity, our people, our customers, superior financial performance, vision and innovation and effective communication will guide us in the execution of our strategy. |
KeyCorp (2013) (TRUSTDM = 1; TRUSTF = 2; and TRUSTTL = 3) |
MRM is an independent risk management function that partners with the lines of business to identify, measure, and monitor market risks throughout our company. MRM is responsible for ensuring transparency of significant market risks, monitoring compliance with established limits, and escalating limit exceptions to appropriate senior management. The various business units and trading desks are responsible for ensuring that market risk exposures are well-managed and prudent |
PDC Energy, INC. (2014) (TRUSTDM = 1; TRUSTF = 1; and TRUSTTL = 2) |
We define adjusted cash flows from operations as the cash flows earned or incurred from operating activities, without regard to changes in operating assets and liabilities. We believe it is important to consider adjusted cash flows from operations, as well as cash flows from operations, as we believe it often provides more transparency into what drives the changes in our operating trends, such as production, prices, operating costs and related operational factors, without regard to whether the related asset or liability was received or paid during the same period |
(…) |
We define adjusted net income (loss) as net income (loss), plus loss on commodity derivatives, less gain on commodity derivatives and net settlements on commodity derivatives, each adjusted for tax effect. We believe it is important to consider adjusted net income (loss), as well as net income (loss). We believe this measure often provides more transparency into our operating trends, such as production, prices, operating costs, net settlements from derivatives and related factors, without regard to changes in our net income (loss) from our mark-to-market adjustments resulting from net changes in the fair value of unsettled derivatives |
(Ellipsis Added) |
HSBC Finance Corp (2016) (TRUSTDM = 1; TRUSTF = 2; and TRUSTTL = 3) |
Our credit and portfolio management procedures focus on ethical and effective collection and customer account management efforts for each receivable |
(…) |
We are committed to delivering the highest quality financial products and services to our customers. Critical to our relationship with our customers is their trust in us, as fiduciary, advisor and service provider. That trust is earned not only through superior service, but also through the maintenance of the highest standards of integrity and conduct. We must, at all times, comply with high ethical standards, treat customers fairly, and comply with both the letter and spirit of all applicable laws, codes, rules, regulations and standards of good market practice, and HSBC policies and standards. |
(Ellipsis Added) |
Appendix 2
See Table 8
.
Appendix 3
See Table 9.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Cho, M., Krishnan, G.V. & Cho, H. Can We Trust the Trust Words in 10-Ks?. J Bus Ethics 190, 975–992 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-023-05350-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-023-05350-y