The Effect of Environmental Activism on the Long-run Market Value of a Company: A Case Study
- 406 Downloads
This paper investigates the impact of activism on a large, powerful corporation in Tasmania. Gunns Ltd was a large woodchip processor in Tasmania that fought a long-running battle with environmental activists regarding Gunns’ logging and processing activities. The study focuses on events in 2004–2005, when Gunns applied to build a pulp mill in rural northern Tasmania and began a legal case against activists. The research question is whether there is clear statistical evidence that these events were important, as is widely believed, in the ultimate failure of Gunns in (Annual Report 2011, Gunns Ltd, Tasmania, available from: http://www.asx.com.au [11/04/14]), just 6 years after being the largest and one of the most financially successful Tasmanian companies. We use a mixed methods approach that combines a detailed narrative informed by theory, to examine issues of corporate social responsibility (CSR) and ethical behaviour, with an econometric time series analysis of the impact of activism on the market value of Gunns. Our analysis supports the contention that the events in 2004–2005 played a significant part in the decline of the long-run market value of Gunns over the subsequent period, through to its failure in 2011. We discuss the underlying causes for Gunns’ failure in terms of agency, stakeholder, legitimacy and leadership theories. Research frequently assesses effects such as those in the Gunns’ case through solely qualitative means. This paper integrates a quantitative analysis into a detailed qualitative narrative and theoretical interpretation of events, to provide additional precision to its findings. It contributes to research in CSR and the impact of activism.
KeywordsActivism Corporate social responsibility Gunns Mixed methods Ethical management Error correction modelling
Australian Bureau of Statistics
Autoregressive distributed Lag model
Australian stock exchange
Corporate social responsibility
Error correction model
Error correction term
Global financial crisis
Resource planning and development commission
Tap into a better Tasmania
Tasmanian wilderness society
Victorian supreme court
- ABC News. (2005). Gunns denies green campaign caused profit drop, ABC News 27 August, Available from http://www.abc.net.au/news/2005-08-27/gunns-denies-green-campaign-caused-profit-drop/2090018 [24/04/15].
- ABC News. (2006). Gunns drops major legal claim, ABC News 17 August, Available from http://www.abc.net.au/news/2006-10-17/gunns-drops-major-legal-claim-wilderness-society/1288134 [24/04/15].
- ABC News. (2008). Financial Crisis may sink Gunns pulp mill, ABC News 28 October, Available from http://www.abc.net.au/news/2008-10-28/financial-crisis-may-sink-gunns-pulp-mill/185284 [23/04/15].
- ABC News. (2012). Gunns extends trading halt, ABC News 26 March, Available from http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-03-26/gunns-extends-trading-halt/3912708 [23/04/15].
- ABC News. (2013). Former Gunns Pulp Mill on the Market, ABC News 5 November, Available from http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-11-01/former-gunns-pulp-mill-project-on-the-market/5064506 [23/04/15].
- Aitken, W. (2011). The pulp mill and the air. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp friction (pp. 176–198). Launceston: Pencil pine Press.Google Scholar
- Ajani, J. (2008). Australia’s transition from native forests to plantations: The implications for woodchips, pulp mills, tax breaks and climate change, Agenda. A Journal of Policy Analysis and Reform, 15(3), 21–38.Google Scholar
- Andrews, A. (2012). $904 m loss: Gunns relies on banks to survive, The Examiner 1 September, Available from http://www.examiner.com.au/story/292241/904m-loss-gunns-relies-on-banks-to-survive/?cs=95 [23/04/15].
- Angle, M. (2001). Tas sawmill giant buys North Forest products, The World Today 20 March, Available from http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/stories/s263031.htm [27/04/15].
- Barr, L., & Barr, N. (1994). Leadership development. Austin: Eakin Press.Google Scholar
- Bass, B. (2008). Bass & Stogdill’s handbook of leadership: theory, research & managerial applications (4th ed.), New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
- Baxter, T., & Browne, R. (2009). Probity issues connected with the Tasmanian pulp mill, Paper presented to the Australian Public Sector Anti-Corruption (APSAC) Conference July28–31. Available from http://www.apsac.com.au/previous/2013conference/pdf/papers09/Day2_30July09/StreamA2/ProbityIssuesTasmanianPulpMill_Baxter_Browne.pdf [27/04/15].
- Beeson, A. (2010). The Gunns 20 case: A brief history. National Environmental Law Review, 18, 51–53.Google Scholar
- Buckman, G. (2008). Tasmania’s wilderness battles: A history. Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
- Chow, G. (1960). Tests of equality between sets of coefficients in two linear regressions. Econometrica, 28(3), 591–605.Google Scholar
- Cica, N. (2005). Middle-ground views are up against battleground tactics, The Sydney Morning Herald 7 April, Available from http://www.smh.com.au/news/Opinion/Middleground-views-are-up-against-battleground-tactics/2005/04/06/1112489558868.html [30 May 2014].
- Cohen, J., Krishnamurthy, G., & Wright, A. M. (2004). Corporate governance mosaic and financial reporting. Journal of Accounting Literature, 23, 87–152.Google Scholar
- Colbeck, R. (2012). Gunns Collapse—who wins in the games Greens play?, Sen. Richard Colbeck Media Release 25 September, Available from http://www.richardcolbeck.com.au/clients/richard/downloads/item350/250912_gunns_collapse_-_who_wins_in_the_games_greens_play.pdf [30 March 2015].
- Contreras, K. S., & Siegal, D. S. (2009). A case study of the strategic use of CSR: the American Gaming association and the national center for responsible Gaming. In C. A. Mallin (Ed.), Corporate social responsibility: A case study approach (pp. 177–193). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.Google Scholar
- Crowley, K. (2003). Saving the Franklin: A people’s rebellion in a distant forest. Island, 93(94), 34–43.Google Scholar
- Curran, G., & Hollander, R. (2011). The Wesley Vale Pulp Mill Proposal and its aftermath. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp friction (pp. 37–56). Launceston: Pencil Pine Press.Google Scholar
- Denholm, M., & Main, A. (2011). Ex-Gunns boss John Gay faces insider trade charges, The Australian Newspaper, 17 August, Available from http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/companies/ex-gunns-boss-john-gay-faces-insider-trade-charges/story-fn91v9q3-1226203064934 [30 May 2014].
- Doornik, J. A., & Hansen, H. (2008). An omnibus test for univariate and multivariate normality. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 70, 927–939.Google Scholar
- Duncan, M. (2011). The Pulp Mill and habitat loss. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp friction (pp. 135–154). Launceston: Pencil Pine Press.Google Scholar
- Edwards, N. (2006). Too much risk for the reward—an analysis of the pulp mill returns to the people of Tasmania, Submission 114 to the RPDC.Google Scholar
- Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989). Agency theory: An assessment and review. The Academy of Management Review, 14(1), 57–74.Google Scholar
- Engle, R. F. (1982). Autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity with estimates of the variance of United Kingdom inflation. Econometrica, 50(4), 987–1007.Google Scholar
- Flanagan, M. (2004). The sorry state of Tasmania. The Age Newspaper 14 March, Available from http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2004/03/14/1079199092585.html [11/12/14].
- Flanagan, R. (2007). Out of control: The tragedy of Tasmania’s forests, The Monthly, May 2007, Available from https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2007/may/1348543148/richard-flanagan/out-control [30/04/15].
- Ford, S. (2013). New call for pulp mill at Hampshire, The Advocate, 6 Nov, Available from http://www.theadvocate.com.au/story/1892133/new-call-for-pulp-mill-at-hampshire [11/12/14].
- Forster, J. (2010). The global financial crisis: Implications for Australasian business. QLD: Wiley.Google Scholar
- Frame, C. (2006). Gunns Ltd pulp mill proposal: Latest development, In: Proceedings of 2006 Australian forest growers conference, Launceston.Google Scholar
- Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic management a stakeholder approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Freeman, R. E. (1999). Divergent stakeholder theory. Academy of Management Review, 24(2), 233–236.Google Scholar
- Friedman, M. (1962). Capitalism and freedom. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- Friedman, M. (1970). The social responsibility of business is to increase profits, New York Times Magazine, 13 September 1970, Available from http://www.colorado.edu/studentgroups/libertarians/issues/friedman-soc-resp-business.html [11/12/14].
- Gale, F. (2011a). A review of the environmental assessment of Gunns’ proposed mill. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp friction (pp. 305–322). Launceston: Pencil Pine Press.Google Scholar
- Gale, F. (2011b). Is the Tasmanian forest agreement collapsing?, The Conversation, Available from http://www.theconversation.edu.au/is-the-tasmanian-forest-agreement-collapsing-1401. [3/11/14].
- Gale, F. (2011c). Planning Tasmania’s Tamar Valley Pulp Mill. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp friction (pp. 57–78). Launceston: Pencil Pine Press.Google Scholar
- Gay, J. (2005). “Chairman’s Report”, Gunns Annual Report, Gunns Ltd, Tasmania, Available from: http://www.asx.com.au [11/04/14].
- Geography of Kamloops. (2013). Kamloops Tourism, Available at http://www.tourismkamloops.com/the-geography-of-kamloops-british-columbia [11/12/14].
- Gibson, K., & O’Donovan, G. (2011). The Pulp Mill and business. In Pencil Pine (Ed.), Pulp friction, Gale (pp. 79–100). Launceston: Press.Google Scholar
- Gray, R. (2010). It’s mostly the Greens’ fault, says Robin Gray, Tasmanian Times, Available from http://www.tasmaniantimes.com/index.php/article/its-mostly-the-greens-fault-says-robin-gray [11/12/13].
- Gunns. (2004). Annual Report 2004, Gunns Ltd, Tasmania, Available from http://www.asx.com.au [11/04/14].
- Gunns. (2005). Annual Report 2005, Gunns Ltd, Tasmania, Available from http://www.asx.com.au [11/04/14].
- Gunns. (2011), Annual Report 2011, Gunns Ltd, Tasmania, Available from http://www.asx.com.au [11/04/14].
- Gunns. (2012) 2012 Preliminary Final Report, Australian Stock Exchange 30 August, Available from http://asx.com.au/asxpdf/20120831/pdf/428fnb3snnjpqh.pdf [10/03//14].
- Gunns. (2012a). Gunns: Our History, Gunns Ltd, Available from http://www.gunns.com.au/about-us/our-history [10/03//14].
- Gunns Statement of Claim. (2005). Gunns Limited and Ors v Alexander Marr and Or et al.,Victorian Supreme Court, VIC.Google Scholar
- Guthrie, J., & Parker, L. (1990). Corporate social disclosure practice: A comparative international analysis. Advances in Public Interest Accounting, 3, 159–175.Google Scholar
- Hall, G. (2012). Permits can be bought by other agents, The Examiner Newspaper 26 September, Available from http://www.examiner.com.au/story/359113/permits-can-be-bought-by-other-agents/?cs=95 [11/12/13].
- Harding, R., Hendricks, C., & Faruqi, N. (2009). Environmental decision-making: Exploring complexity and context. Annandale: Federation Press.Google Scholar
- Harvey, A. C. (1990). The econometric analysis of time series. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Haslam, S. A., Reicher, S. D., & Platow, M. J. (2013). The new psychology of leadership. New York: Psychology Press.Google Scholar
- Hay, P. (1998). Green Politics in the system: Assessing the obstacles to the labor/green power sharing. In J. Pakuski & S. Crooks (Eds.), Ebbing of the green tide? Environmentalism, public opinion and the media. Tas: University of Tasmania.Google Scholar
- Hendry, D. F., & Doornik, J. A. (2001). Empirical econometric modelling using PCGive. England: Timberlake.Google Scholar
- ITS Global. (2007). Review of the Social and Economic Benefits of the Gunns Limited Pulp Mill Project, Department of Environment, Available from http://www.environment.gov.au/epbc/notices/assessments/2007/3385/pubs/att-b10.pdf [11/12/13].
- Jamieson, A. (2011). The pulp: The rise and fall of an industry. Tasmania: Forty Degrees South Pty Ltd.Google Scholar
- Kellerman, B. (2004). Bad leadership: What it is, how it happens, why it matters. Boston: Harvard Business Review Press.Google Scholar
- Klasson, A. (2013). Labour council calls on city council to take a stand on Ajax mine, Kamloops this week 14 December, Available at http://www.kamloopsthisweek.com/perception-not-science-behind-opposition-to-ajax-mine/[24/05/14].
- Lennon, P. (2004). Development of a Pulp Mill (Premier Ministerial Statement), Parliament of Tasmania, Available from: http://www.parliament.tas.gov.au/ParliamentSearch/isysquery/379e5024-42f6-47ab-afaf-cf037bbc0340/8/doc/c26october2.pdf [11/12/13].
- Lyons, B. (1998). All Gunns Blazing: J & T Gunn and the development of Launceston. Launceston: Self-Published.Google Scholar
- Macintosh, A., & Stokes, M. (2010). Tasmania and the Gunns Pulp Mill. In T. Bonyhady & A. Macintosh (Eds.), Mills, mines and other controversies (pp. 16–59). NSW: Federation Press.Google Scholar
- Manning, P. (2011). The felling of Gunns, The Age Newspapers 12 March, p. 7.Google Scholar
- Maurice Blackman. (2011). Gunns—class action’, Maurice Blackburn Solicitors, Available from http://www.mauriceblackburnnsw.com.au/areas-of-practice/class-actions/current-class-actions/gunns–class-action.aspx [30/05/2014].
- Mitchell, R., Agle, B., & Wood, D. (1997). Toward a theory of stakeholder identification and salience: Defining the principle of who and what really counts. Academy of Management Review, 22(4), 853–886.Google Scholar
- Nathan, S., & Pierce, C. (2009). CSR in Islamic financial institutions in the Middle East. In C. A. Mallin, (Ed.), Corporate social responsibility: A case study approach (pp. 258–273). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.Google Scholar
- Neales, S. (2011). Groups firm against pulp mill, The Mercury Newspaper 16 March, Available from http://www.themercury.com.au/article/2011/03/16/214851_tasmania-news.html [30/05/14].
- Neilson, D., & Flynn, R. (2006). The international pulpwood resource and trade review. New Zealand: DANA Publishing.Google Scholar
- O’Donovan, G., & Gibson, K. (2010). Pulp, politics, process and pollution: gunns ltd and the tamar valley pulp mill. In C. A. Mallin (Ed.), Corporate social responsibility: A case study approach. Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.Google Scholar
- Ogilvie, F. (2013). Former Gunns head John Gay pleads guilty to insider trading, The World Today 11 December, Available from http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/content/2013/s3818233.htm [30/05/14].
- Ogle, G. (2009). Gagged: The Gunns 20 and other Law Suits. Canterbury: Envirobooks.Google Scholar
- PM. (2004). Gunns to sue Conservationists, ABC PM 12 December, Available from http://www.abc.net.au/pm/content/2004/s1266098.htm [30/05/14].
- Ramsey, J. B. (1969). Tests for specification error in classical linear least squares regression analysis. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B (Methodologies), 31, 350–371.Google Scholar
- Sorokina, A, Gordon, C., & Matveev, A. (2009). The effects of the GFC on the Russian Banking Sector, Working Paper Series of the 22nd Australasian Finance and Banking Conference, Rochester.Google Scholar
- Stokes, M. (2011). Environmental assessment in Tasmania: The resources management and planning system. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp Friction (pp. 101–132). Launceston: Pencil Pine Press.Google Scholar
- Suchman, M. (1995). Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches. The Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 571–610.Google Scholar
- Swales, P. (2010). Gunns 20 reaches a final settlement. Alternative Law Journal, 35(1), 39.Google Scholar
- The Age. (2006). Gunns, greenies and the law, The Age Newspaper 29 August, Available from http://www.theage.com.au/news/in-depth/gunns-greenies-and-the-law/2006/08/29/1156617279358.html [30/05/14].
- Timmons, H. (2005). Britain faulted over McDonald’s libel case, The New York Times 16 February, Available from http://www.nytimes.com/2005/02/16/business/worldbusiness/16libel.html [30/05/14].
- TWS. (2010). The Pulp mill and the forest, The Wilderness Society, Available from www.wilderness.org.au/campaigns/gunns-pulp-mill/pulp-mill-and-forests [30/05/14].
- Victoria Supreme Court. (2005). Gunns Limited v Marr  VSC 251, Victorian Supreme Court 18 July, Available from http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/vic/VSC/2005/251.html [30/05/14].
- Vince, M. (2011). The Pulp Mill and the sea. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp friction (pp. 155–175). Tasmania: Pencil Pine Press.Google Scholar
- Warnes, P. (2012). Gunns enters administration, The Mercury Newspaper 26 August, Available from http://www.themercury.com.au/article/2012/09/25/362567_tasmanian-news.html [30/05/14].
- Wells, G. (2011). The pulp mill: an economic assessment. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp friction (pp. 224–246). Tasmania: Pencil Pine Press.Google Scholar
- White, H. (1980). A heteroskedasticity-consistent covariance matrix estimator and a direct test for heteroskedasticity. Econometricia, 48, 817–838.Google Scholar
- White, R. (2011). The right to dissent: the Gunns 20 legal case. In F. Gale (Ed.), Pulp friction (pp. 79–100). Tasmania: Pencil Pine Press.Google Scholar