Abstract
In both the public and the business world, in academe as well as in practice, the ideas of Adam Smith are regarded as the bedrock of modern economics. When present economic conditions and management practices are criticised, Adam Smith is referred to by defenders and detractors of the current status quo alike. Smith, it is believed, defined the essential terms of reference of these debates, such as the rational pursuit of self-interest on part of the individual and the resultant optimal allocation of goods in free markets thanks to the workings of an “invisible hand.” In this article, we question whether this standard view of Smith, the economist, is tenable. We provide an extensive review of the extant secondary literature from economists, business ethicists, and philosophers, comparing their assessments to crucial elements of Smith’s theoretical system. As a result, we show that Smith, far from being an advocate of a value-free or even value-averse conception of economic transactions, stood for a virtue-based and values-oriented model of business. Accordingly, we argue current management education and the pedagogy of business ethics ought to be changed, and certain strategic conclusions drawn for business practice.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Chapman (2004), a Reagan advisor, recalls how for the 8 years of the Reagan Administration everybody wore Adam Smith ties (the women wore Adam Smith scarves).
We cross- and doublechecked the authors in order to ensure that individual authors were not counted twice. Of the 200 individual authors, 39 (19.5 %) paint a somewhat differentiated image of Smith and 161 (80.5 %) see only the ‘Chicago Smith’. One author (Bragues 2008; 2009) was intentionally counted twice because his 2009 paper painted a somewhat differentiated picture of Smith, while his 2008 contribution depicted Smith in the Chicago mould.
References
Alvey, J. E. (1999). A short history of economics as a moral science. Journal of Markets & Morality, 2(1), 52–73.
Andrew, E. G. (2001). Conscience and its critics: Protestant conscience, enlightenment reason, and modern subjectivity. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Berle, A. A., & Means, G. G. C. (1932). The modern corporation and private property. New York: Macmillan.
Blaug, M. (1992). The methodology of economics: How economists explain. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Blosser, J. (2011). Christian freedom in political economy: The legacy of John Calvin in the thought of Adam Smith. In P. Oslington (Ed.), Adam Smith as theologian (pp. 46–60). London: Routledge.
Bofinger, P. (2013). Adam Smith: Der Segen des Egoismus. Frankfurter Allgemeine Sonntagszeitung. http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/wirtschaftswissen/die-weltverbesserer/adam-smith-der-segen-des-egoismus-12536505.html.
Bonar, J. (1922). Philosophy and political economy (3rd ed.). London: Allen & Unwin.
Bragues, G. (2008). The ancients against the moderns: Focusing on the character of corporate leaders. Journal of Business Ethics, 78(3), 373–387.
Bragues, G. (2009). Adam Smith’s vision of the ethical manager. Journal of Business Ethics, 90(4), 447–460.
Brat, D. A. (2005). ‘Adam Smith’s god and the end of economics’, in Virginia Economic Journal. Presented at Virginia Association of Economists Meetings in Richmond, VA, March 2005.
Broadie, A. (2006). Sympathy and the impartial spectator. In K. Haakonssen (Ed.), The Cambridge companion to Adam Smith (pp. 158–188). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Brodbeck, K.-H. (1998). Die Fragwürdigen Grundlagen Der Ökonomie: Eine Philosophische Kritik Der Modernen Wirtschaftswissenschaften. Darmstadt: Wiss. Buchges.
Brown, V. (1994). Adam’s Smith discourse: Canonicity, commerce and conscience. London: Routledge.
Calkins, M. J., & Werhane, P. H. (1998). Adam Smith, Aristotle, and the virtues of commerce. The Journal of Value Inquiry, 32, 42–60.
Carrasco, A. M. (2004). Adam Smith’s reconstruction of practical reason. Review of Metaphysics, 58(1), 81–116.
Chapman, B. (2014, June 10). The invisible hand of Ronald Reagan. Memorial service remarks. Accessed November, 2014, from http://www.discovery.org/p/7.
Clarke, P. H. (2000). Adam Smith, Stoicism and religion in the 18th century. History of the Human Sciences, 13(4), 49–72.
Coase, R. H. (1976). Adam Smith’s view of man. Journal of Law and Economics, 19(3), 529–546.
Darwall, S. (1999). Sympathetic liberalism: Recent work on Adam Smith. Philosophy & Public Affairs, 28(2), 139–164.
Den Uyl, D. J., & Griswold, C. L. (1996). Adam Smith on friendship and love. Review of Metaphysics, 49(3), 609–637.
Dierksmeier, C. (2011). The freedom-responsibility Nexus in Management Philosophy and Business Ethics. Journal of Business Ethics, 101(4), 263–283.
Elegido, J. (2009). Business education and erosion of character. African Journal of Business Ethics, 9(1), 16–24.
Evensky, J. (1993). Adam Smith on the human foundation of a successful liberal society. History of Political Economy, 25(3), 395–412.
Evensky, J. (2003). Adam Smith on the human foundation of a successful liberal society. History of Political Economy, 25(3), 395–412.
Evensky, J. (2005). Adam Smith’s moral philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Faccarello, G. (2005). A tale of two traditions: Pierre Force’s self-interest before Adam Smith. European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 12(4), 701–712.
Fitzgibbons, A. (1995). Adam Smith’s system of liberty, wealth and virtue. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fleischacker, S. (2012). Sympathy in Hume and Smith: A contrast, critique, and reconstruction. In C. Fricke & D. Føllesdal (Eds.), Intersubjectivity and Objectivity in Adam Smith and Edmund Husserl (pp. 273–311). Frankfurt: Ontos Verlag.
Foley, V. (1974). The division of labor in Plato and Smith. History of Political Economy, 6(2), 220–242.
Force, P. (2003). Self-interest before Adam Smith: A genealogy of economic science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Forman-Barzilai, F. (2010). Adam Smith and the circles of sympathy: Cosmopolitanism and moral theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Friedman, M. (1953). Essays in Positive Economics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Friedman, M. (1970, September 13). The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. New York Times Magazine.
Galbraith, J. K. (1973). Economics and the public purpose. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Ghoshal, S. (2005). Bad management theories are destroying good management practices. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 4(1), 75–91.
Giacalone, R. A. (2004). A transcendent business education for the 21st century. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 3(4), 415–420.
Gray, D., & Clarke, P. (2005). Meeting Goodpaster’s challenge: A Smithian approach to Goodpaster’s paradox. Business Ethics: A European Review, 14(2), 119–126.
Griswold, C. L. (1999). Adam Smith and the virtues of enlightenment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Griswold, C. L. (2010). Smith and Rousseau in dialogue. In V. Brown & S. Fleischacker (Eds.), Adam Smith Review (Vol. 5, pp. 59–84). London: Routledge.
Haakonssen, K. (2006). Introduction—The coherence of Adam Smith’s thought. In K. Haakonssen (Ed.), The Cambridge companion to Adam Smith. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Haakonssen, K., & Winch, D. (2006). The legacy of Adam Smith. In K. Haakonssen (Ed.), The Cambridge companion to Adam Smith (pp. 366–394). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Haase, M., & Neuhäuser, C. (2013). Ethics, sustainability, and the homo economicus model: On the role of meta- and metametatheories. Unpublished presentation at the 8th Zittauer Gespräche zur Unternehmens- und Wirtschaftsethik, October 2013, Zittau, Germany.
Hanley, R. P. (2009). Adam Smith and the character of virtue. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Heilbroner, R. (1979). Modern economics and a chapter in the history of economic thought. History of Political Economy, 11(2), 192–198.
Heise, P. (1995). Stoicism in the EPS: The foundation of Adam Smith’s moral philosophy (pp. 17–30). XI: Perspectives in History of Economic Thought.
Hill, L. (2011). The hidden theology of Adam Smith. European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 8(1), 1–29.
Hollander, S. (1977). Adam Smith and the self-interest axiom. Journal of Law and Economics, 20(1), 133–152.
Hont, I., & Ignatieff, M. (1983). Needs and justice in the wealth of nations: An introductory essay. In I. Hont & M. Ignatieff (Eds.), Wealth and virtue: The shaping of political economy in the Scottish enlightenment (pp. 1–44). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hope, V. (1984). Smith’s Demigod. In V. Hope (Ed.), Philosophers of the Scottish Enlightenment (pp. 157–167). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Hühn, M. P. (2014). You reap what you sow: How MBA programs undermine ethics. Journal of Business Ethics, 121(4), 527–541.
Hühn, M. P., & Kuhlmann, C. (2013). Der mißverstandene Mr. Smith. GWP—Gesellschaft Wirtschaft Politik, 62(4), 503–510.
James, H. S., Jr, & Rassekh, F. (2000). Smith, Friedman, and self-interest in ethical society. Business Ethics Quarterly, 10(3), 659–674.
Jensen, M., & Murphy, K. J. (1990). Performance pay and top-management incentives. Journal of Political Economy, 98, 225–264.
Kapp, K. W. (1950). The social costs of private enterprise. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Kennedy, G. (2008). Adam Smith: A moral philosopher and his political economy. Palgrave Macmillan: Basingstoke.
MacIntyre, A. (1981). After virtue: A study in moral theory. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
MacIntyre, A. (2007). After virtue: A study in moral theory (3rd ed.). Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
McCloskey, D. (2006). The Bourgeois virtues: Ethics for an age of commerce. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
McCloskey, D. (2008). Adam Smith, the Last of the former virtue ethicists. History of Political Economy, 40(1), 43–71.
Mehta, P. B. (2006). Self-interest and other interests. In K. Haakonssen (Ed.), The Cambridge companion to Adam Smith (pp. 246–269). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mirowski, P. (1989). More heat than light—Economics as social physics: Physics as nature’s economics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Montes, L. (2008). Adam Smith as an eclectic Stoic. In V. Brown (Ed.), The Adam Smith review (Vol. IV, pp. 30–56). London: New York.
Montes, L., & Schliesser, E. (Eds.). (2006). New voices on Adam Smith. Abingdon: Routledge.
Muller, J. Z. (1995). Adam Smith in his time and ours: Designing a decent society. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Newbert, S. L. (2003). Realizing the spirit and impact of Adam Smith’s capitalism through entrepreneurship. Journal of Business Ethics, 46(3), 251–258.
Nussbaum, M.C. (2002). Mutilated and Deformed: Adam Smith on the Material Basis of Human Dignity. The cosmopolitian tradition
Oslington, P. (2011). The future hope in Adam Smith’s system. Studies in Christian Ethics, 24(3), 329–349.
Otteson, J. R. (2002). Adam Smith’s marketplace of life. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pack, S. J. (2010). Aristotle, Adam Smith and Karl Marx: On some fundamental issues in 21st century political economy. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Pack, S. J., & Schliesser, E. (2006). Smith’s Humean criticism of Hume’s account of the origin of justice. Journal of the History of Philosophy, 44(1), 47–63.
Paganelli, M. P. (2009). Smithian answers to some puzzling results in the experimental literature. In J. T. Young (Ed.), The Elgar companion to Adam Smith (pp. 181–192). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Raphael, D. D. (1978). Adam Smith: Philosophy, Science, and Social Science. Royal Institute of Philosophy Lectures, 12, 77–93. doi:10.1017/S0080443600002594.
Raphael, D. D. (1992). Adam Smith 1790: The man recalled, the philosopher revived. In P. Jones & A. Skinner (Eds.), Adam Smith reviewed (pp. 93–118). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Raphael, D. D. (2007). The impartial spectator: Adam Smith’s moral philosophy. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Raphael, D. D., & Macfie, A. L. (1976). Introduction. In A. Smith (Ed.), The theory of moral sentiments. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Rasmussen, D. C. (2008). The problems and promise of commercial society: Adam Smith’s response to Rousseau. Philadelphia: Penn State Press.
Redman, D. A. (1993). Adam Smith and Isaac Newton. Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 40(2), 210–230.
Rick, J. (2007). Hume’s and Smith’s partial sympathies and impartial stances. Journal of Scottish Philosophy, 5(2), 135–158.
Ross, I. S. (2004). Great works upon the anvil in 1785. Adam Smith’s projected corpus of philosophy. In V. Brown (Ed.), The Adam Smith review (Vol. I, pp. 40–59). London: New York.
Ross, I. S. (2010). The life of Adam Smith. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Rothschild, E. (1994). Adam Smith and the invisible hand. The American Economic Review, 84(2), 319–322.
Rothschild, E. (2001). Economic sentiments—Adam Smith, condorcet, and the enlightenment. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Rothschild, E., & Sen, A. (2006). Adam Smith’s economics. In K. Haakonssen (Ed.), The Cambridge companion to Adam Smith. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schumpeter, J. A. (1954). History of economic analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Seele, P., & Seele, K. (2012). Standalone, curricular infusion or generic skills in business ethics education? An overview of extracurricular ‘studium generale’ programs in Austria, Germany, and Switzerland. Journal of Business Ethics Education, 9, 145–164.
Skinner, A. S. (1974). Adam Smith and the role of imagination. In W. B. Todd (Ed.), Hume and the enlightenment: Essays presented to Ernest Campbell Mossner. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Skinner, A. S. (1996). A system of social sciences: Papers relating to Adam Smith. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Smith, A. (1776/1976). An enquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations. In D. Raphael (Ed.), Glasgow edition of the works and correspondence of Adam Smith (2 Vols.). Glasgow: Glasgow Publishers.
Smith, A. (1790/1976). The theory of moral sentiments. In D. Raphael (Ed.), The Glasgow edition of the works and correspondence of Adam Smith (Vol. 1). Glasgow: Glasgow Publishers.
Smith, A. (1982). Essays on philosophical subjects. In W. P. D. Wightman & J. C. Bryce (Eds.), Glasgow edition of the works and correspondence of Adam Smith (Vol. 3). Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Solomon, R. C. (1993). Review: beyond selfishness: Adam Smith and the limits of the market. Business Ethics Quarterly, 3(4), 453–460.
Solomon, R. C. (2008). Free enterprise, sympathy, and virtue. In P. J. Zak (Ed.), The critical role of values in the economy (pp. 16–41). Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Stewart, D. (1794/1980). Account of the life and writings of Adam Smith, LL.D. In A. Smith (Ed.), Essays on philosophical subjects. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Stigler, G. (1971). Smith’s travels on the ship of state. History of Political Economy, 3, 237–246.
Valihora, K. (2001). The judgement of judgement: Adam Smith’s theory of moral sentiments. British Journal of Aesthetics, 41(2), 138–161.
Viner, J. (1927). Adam Smith and laissez-faire. Journal of Political Economy, 35(2), 198–232.
Viner, J. (1960). The intellectual history of Laissez Faire. Journal of Law and Economics, 3(October), 45–69.
Viner, J. (1972). The role of providence in the social order. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society.
Vivenza, G. (1984). Adam Smith e la cultura classica. IPEM: Pisa.
Vivenza, G. (2001). Adam Smith and the classic: The classical heritage in Adam Smith’s thought. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
von Hayek, F. A. (1975). The pretence of knowledge. Nobel memorial lecture. The Swedish Journal of Economics, 77(4), 433–442.
Waszek, N. (1984). Two concepts of morality: A distinction of Adam Smith's ethics and its stoic origin. Journal of the History of Ideas, 45(4) 591–606.
Waterman, A. M. C. (2002). Economics as theology: Adam Smith’s wealth of nations. Southern Economic Journal, 6, 907–921.
Wells, T., & Graafland, L. (2012). Adam Smith’s Bourgeois virtues in competition. Business Ethics Quarterly, 22(2), 319–350.
Werhane, P. H. (2000). Business ethics and the origins of contemporary capitalism: Economics and ethics in the work of Adam Smith and Herbert Spencer. Journal of Business Ethics, 24(3), 185–198.
Werhane, P. H. (2004). …laissez-faire when it was new… In V. Brown (Ed.), The Adam Smith review (Vol. I, pp. 135–140). London: New York.
Williams, B. (2006). Ethics and the limits of philosophy. London: Routledge.
Winch, D. (1978). Adam Smith’s politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Young, J. T. (1986). The impartial spectator and natural jurisprudence: An interpretation of Adam Smith’s theory of the natural price. History of Political Economy, 18(3), 365–382.
Young, J. T. (1997). Economics as a moral science. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Zúñiga, G. L. (1997). Scholastic economics: Thomistic value theory. Religion & Liberty, 7(4), 5–7.
Acknowledgments
For instructive criticism and decisive help with the bibliographic apparatus, we wish to thank Katharina Hoegl. We are also indebted to the three anonymous reviewers who made this paper better.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hühn, M.P., Dierksmeier, C. Will the Real A. Smith Please Stand Up!. J Bus Ethics 136, 119–132 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-014-2506-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-014-2506-z