Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 105, Issue 3, pp 357–373 | Cite as

Ethical Objections to Fairtrade

Article

Abstract

The Fairtrade movement is a group of businesses claiming to trade ethically. The claims are evaluated, under a range of criteria derived from the Utilitarian ethic. Firstly, if aid or charity money is diverted from the very poorest people to the quite poor, or the rich, there is an increase in death and destitution. It is shown that little of the extra paid by consumers for Fairtrade reaches farmers, sometimes none. It cannot be shown that it has a positive impact on Fairtrade farmers in general, but evidence suggesting it harms others is presented. Many of the weaknesses are due to an attempt to impose political views on farmers and others. Secondly, the unfair trading criteria require that sellers do not lie about their product, nor withhold information that might alter the decisions of a substantial proportion of buyers. It is argued that the system only can exist because of the failure of the Fairtrade industry to give the facts on what happens to the money and what it can be proved it achieves. This unfair trading compromises the reputation of charities in general. Much of the trading may constitute the criminal offence of Unfair Trading in the EU.

Keywords

Fairtrade Fair trade Ethical trading Third world marketing Agricultural and food marketing 

References

  1. ADB. (2010). Asian Development Bank and Vietnam: Fact Sheet. Retrieved June 14, 2010, from http://www.adb.org/Documents/Fact_Sheets/VIE.pdf.
  2. Aranda, J., & Morales, C. (2002) Poverty alleviation through participation in Fair Trade Coffee: The case of CEPCO, Oaxaca, Mexico. Retrieved from http://www.colostate.edu/Depts/Sociology/FairTradeResearchGroup.
  3. Audebrand, L., & Pauchant, T. (2009). Can the fair trade movement enrich traditional business ethics? an historical study of its founders in Mexico. Journal of Business Ethics, 87, 343–353.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bahra, P. (2009a, January 2). Fairtrade is struggling to change practices on tea estates and tackle abuses. The Times.Google Scholar
  5. Bahra, P. (2009b, January 7). Tea workers still waiting to reap Fairtrade benefits. The Times.Google Scholar
  6. Bassett, T. (2009). Slim pickings: Fairtrade cotton in West Africa. Geoforum, 41(1), 44–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Berndt, C. E. (2007) Is fair trade in coffee production fair and useful? Evidence from Costa Rica and Guatemala and implications for policy (Mercatus 65 Policy Series, Policy Comment 11). Washington DC: Mercatus Centre, George Mason University.Google Scholar
  8. Boersma, F. V. (2002). Poverty alleviation through participation in Fair Trade Coffee Networks: The case of UCIRI, Oaxaca, Mexico. Retrieved from http://www.colostate.edu/Depts/Sociology/FairTradeResearchGroup.
  9. Boersma, F. (2009). The urgency and necessity of a different type of market: The perspective of producers organized within the Fair Trade market. Journal of Business Ethics, 86, 51–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bowbrick, P. (1988). Are price reporting systems of any use? British Food Journal, 90(2), 65–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Bowbrick, P. (1992). The economics of quality, grades and brands. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  12. Cabañas, A. A. (2002). Evaluation of the current and potential poverty alleviation benefits of participation in the fair trade market: The case of Unión La Selva, Chiapas, Mexico. San Cristóbal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico: Union of Societies of La Selva, Federation of Social Solidarity Societies.Google Scholar
  13. Doussin, J.-P. (2007, October). Max Havelaar reply. Le Monde Diplomatique, p. 2.Google Scholar
  14. Escalante, M. Y. (2001). Transcription of the workshop on alternative markets, Tacuba, July 18. San Salvador, El Salvador: Shade, Livelihoods and Conservation Project—UCSC/PROCAFE/CFHF.Google Scholar
  15. European Commission. (2005). Directive 2005/29/EC “Unfair Commercial Practices Directive”. Retrieved May 27, 2011, from http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:32005L0029:EN:NOT.
  16. Fairtrade UK. (2009). Annual Report. Retrieved May 5, 2010, from http://www.fairtrade.org.uk/includes/documents/cm_docs/2009/2/2008_ar_fs.pdf.
  17. Fairtrade Foundation. (2008, Feb 23). Response to Adam Smith Institute Report. Fairtrade Foundation Press Release.Google Scholar
  18. Fairtrade Foundation. (2011). Are consumers getting a fair deal from Fairtrade products? Retrieved May 22, 2011, from Fairtrade.org.uk: http://www.fairtrade.org.uk/includes/documents/cm_docs/2008/R/1_Retail_pricing.pdf.
  19. Fairtrade Labelling Organizations International. (2010). Annual Report 20092010. Retrieved May 27, 2011, from http://www.fairtrade.net/fileadmin/user_upload/content/2009/resources/FLO_Annual-Report-2009_komplett_double_web.pdf.
  20. Garza, V. P., & Cervantes, E. (2002). Poverty alleviation through participation in Fair Trade Coffee Networks: The case of Unión Majomut, Chiapas, Mexico. Retrieved from http://www.colostate.edu/Depts/Sociology/FairTradeResearchGroup.
  21. Gendron, C. V. B., & Rance, A. (2009). The institutionalization of fair trade: More than just a degraded form of social action. Journal of Business Ethics, 86, 63–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Griffiths, P. (2003). The economist’s tale: A consultant encounters hunger and the World Bank. London and New York: Zed Books.Google Scholar
  23. Griffiths, P. (2008, August). Why Fairtrade isn’t fair. Prospect.Google Scholar
  24. Griffiths, P. (2010). Refutation: Does fair trade deliver on its core value proposition? Retrieved June 26, 2011, from http://www.griffithsspeaker.com/Fairtrade/Arnould%20et%20al%20web.pdf.
  25. Hamel, I. (2006). Fairtrade firm accused of foul play. Swiss Info. http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/Fair_trade_firm_accused_of_foul_play.html?cid=5351232, 23/12/2009.
  26. Hill, M. (2009). European coffee symposium, October 9. Retrieved from http://www.griffithsspeaker.com/Fairtrade/Who%20is%20telling%20the%20truth%204.wmv.
  27. Jacquiau, C. (2006). Les Coulisees du Commerce Équitable. Paris: Mille et Une Nuits.Google Scholar
  28. Jacquiau, C. (2007). Max Havelaar ou les ambiguïtés du commerce équitable: Pourquoi le Sud rue dans les brancards. Monde Diplomatique, September.Google Scholar
  29. Johannesen, S. (2008). Producing and consuming narratives for Fairtrade. Masters thesis, Norwegian University.Google Scholar
  30. Jones, S., & Bayley, B. (2000). Fair Trade: Overview, impact, challenges study to inform DFID’s support to fair trade. Oxford: Oxford Policy Management.Google Scholar
  31. Kilian, B., Jones, C., Pratt, L., & Villalobos, A. (2006). Is sustainable agriculture a viable strategy to improve farm income in Central America? A case study on coffee. Journal of Business Research, 59(3), 322–330.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Lamb, H. (2008, September). Fairtrade is fair (Reply to Peter Griffiths, Fairtrade isn’t Fair, Prospect Aug 2008). Prospect.Google Scholar
  33. Lamb, H. (2008b). Fighting the Banana Wars and other Fairtrade battles. London: Rider Books.Google Scholar
  34. Lamb, H. S. (2006). Trade audits do detect sales of non-certified coffee [REPLY]. Financial Times, September 13.Google Scholar
  35. Luetchford, P. (2006). Relations between coffee cooperatives and alternative trade organizations—A view from Costa Rica. In D. Lewis & D. Mosse (Eds.), Development brokers and translators: The ethnography of aid and agencies (pp. 127–148). Bloomfield, CT: Kumarian Press.Google Scholar
  36. Lyon, S. (2002). Evaluation of the actual and potential benefits for the alleviation of poverty through the participation in Fair Trade Coffee Networks: Guatemalan case study. Retrieved from http://www.colostate.edu/Depts/Sociology/FairTradeResearchGroup.
  37. Lyon, S. (2009). What good will two more trees do? The political economy of sustainable coffee certification, local livelihoods and identities. Landscape Research, 34(2), 223–240.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. McMurtry, J. (2009). Ethical value-added: Fair Trade and the case of Cafe Fenenino. Journal of Business Ethics, 86, 27–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Mendez V. E. (2002). Fair Trade networks in two coffee cooperatives of Western El Salvador: An analysis of insertion through a second level organization. Retrieved from http://www.colostate.edu/Depts/ Sociology/FairTradeResearchGroup.
  40. Mendoza, R. (2002). La paradoja del café, el gran negocio mundial y la peor crisis campesina, Managua, Nitlapán-Universidad Centroamericana, Oxfam UK, CAFOD and Christian Aid. (Cited in Mendoza, R., & Bastiaensen, J. 2003). Google Scholar
  41. Mendoza, R., & Bastiaensen, J. (2003). Fair trade and the coffee crisis in the Nicaraguan Segovias. Small Enterprise Development, 14(2), 36–46.Google Scholar
  42. Milford, A. (2004). Coffee, co-operatives and competition: The impact of fair trade. Postterminalen, Norway: Chr. Michelsen Institute Development Studies and Human Rights.Google Scholar
  43. Moberg, M. (2005). Fairtrade and eastern Caribbean banana farmers: Rhetoric and reality in the anti-globalization movement. Human Organization, 64, 4–16. (Cited in Nelson & Pound 2009, p. 10).Google Scholar
  44. Moore, G., Gibbon, J., & Slack, R. (2006). The mainstreaming of Fair Trade: A macromarketing perspective. Journal of Strategic Marketing, 14, 329–352.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Murray, D., Raynolds, L., & Taylor, P. (2003). One cup at a time: Poverty alleviation and Fair Trade Coffee in Latin America. Fort Collins: Colorado State University.Google Scholar
  46. Nelson, V., Pound, B. (2009). The last ten years: A comprehensive review of the literature on the impact of Fairtrade. Retrieved from http://www.fairtrade.org.uk/resources/natural_resources_institute.aspx.
  47. Newman, P. (2006, September 23). How the Fairtrade ethos seeks to protect the growers. Financial Times.Google Scholar
  48. Nicholls, A. (2008). Thriving in a hostile environment: Fairtrade’s role as a positive market mechanism for disadvantaged producers. Retrieved from http://www.fairtrade.org.uk/includes/documents/cm_docs/2008/a/alex_nichols.pdf.
  49. Organic Consumers Association.: n.d., Starbucks campaign. Retrieved May 22, 2007, from http://www.purefood.org/Starbucks/coffeelabor.htm.
  50. Proctor, R. N. (2008). Agnotology: a missing term to describe the cultural production of ignorance and its study. In R. N. Proctor & L. Shiebinger (Eds.), Agnotology: The making and unmaking of ignorance (pp. 1–36). Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
  51. Raynolds, L. T. (2009). Mainstreaming Fair Trade Coffee: From partnership to traceability. World Development, 37(6), 1083–1093.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Reed, D. (2009). What do corporations have to do with Fair Trade? Positive and normative analysis from a value chain perspective. Journal of Business Ethics, 86, 3–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Ronchi, L. (2002). The impact of fairtrade on producers and their organisations. A case study with COOCAFE in Costa Rica.Google Scholar
  54. Ruben, R., Fort, R., & Zuniga-Arias, G. (2009). Measuring the impact of fair trade. Development in Practice, 19(6), 777–788.Google Scholar
  55. Taylor, P. (2002). Poverty alleviation through participation in Fair Trade Coffee Networks: Synthesis of case research question findings. Fort Collins: Colorado State University.Google Scholar
  56. Utting-Chamorro, K. (2005). Does fairtrade make a difference? The case of small coffee producers in Nicaragua. Development in Practice, 15(3, 4).Google Scholar
  57. Utting, K. (2009). Assessing the impact of Fair Trade Coffee: Towards an integrative framework. Journal of Business Ethics, 86, 127–149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Valkila, J. (2009). Fair trade organic coffee production in Nicaragua—Sustainable development or a poverty trap? Ecological Economics, 68, 3018–3025.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Valkila, J., Haaparanta, P., & Niemi, N. (2010). Empowering coffee traders? The coffee value chain from Nicaraguan fair trade farmers to Finnish consumers. Journal of Business Ethics, 97, 257–270.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Valkila, J., & Nygren, A. (2010). Impacts of fair trade certification on coffee farmers, cooperatives, and laborers in Nicaragua. Agriculture and Human Values, 27, 321–333.Google Scholar
  61. Weitzman, H. (2006a, August 9). ‘Fair’ coffee workers paid below minimum wage. Financial Times.Google Scholar
  62. Weitzman, H. (2006b, September 9). ‘Ethical-coffee’ workers paid below legal minimum. Financial Times.Google Scholar
  63. Weitzman, H. (2006c, September 8). The bitter cost of Fair Trade coffee. Financial Times.Google Scholar
  64. Wilson, B. R. (2009). Indebted to Fair Trade? Coffee and crisis in Nicaragua. Geoforum, 41(1), 84–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.EdinburghUK

Personalised recommendations