Advertisement

Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 84, Supplement 2, pp 195–208 | Cite as

Ethical Issues Relating to the Health Effects of Long Working Hours

  • Allard E. Dembe
Article

Abstract

Considerable research evidence has accumulated indicating that there is an increased likelihood for illness and injury among employees working in long-hour schedules and schedules involving unconventional shift work (e.g., night and evening shifts). In addition, studies show that fatigue-related errors made by employees working in these kind of demanding schedules can have serious and adverse repercussions for public safety. As the result of these concerns, new protective legislation is being advocated in the United States, for instance, to restrict the hours of work among nurses and other health-care professionals. This article reviews the history of concerns about long working hours and the current scientific evidence regarding their effects on workers’ health. The ethical implications of unconventional shift work and long work-hour schedules are considered. Relevant ethical considerations involve mandatory or unpaid overtime and the possibility of employer coercion, the political basis for government regulation of working hours, potential limits on voluntary assumption of risk, societal benefits accruing from the equitable distribution of available working hours, gender-based inequities related to working hours, and employer responsibilities for protecting individuals who are not employees from the spillover effects of demanding work schedules.

Keywords

long work hours overtime shift work ethical issues legislation regulation equity workers’ compensation occupational health 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. American Association of Insurance Services (AAIS): 2004, ‹Extended Hours, Extended Risks? Should Commercial Lines Underwriting and Rating Reflect a “24/7” World?’, AAIS Viewpoint 28(3). Retrieved December 27, 2006 at: http://www.aaisonline.com/Viewpoint/04win3.html
  2. American Nursing Association (ANA): 2007, ‹Mandatory Overtime’, ANA Nursing World. Retrieved on December 26, 2007 at: http://www.nursingworld.org
  3. American Organization of Nurse Executives (AONE): 2003, AONE Policy Statement on Mandatory Overtime. Retrieved on December 26, 2007 at: http://www.aone.org/aone/advocacy/ps_mandatory_ot.html
  4. Åkerstedt T. E.: 2003, Shift Work and Disturbed Sleep/Wakefulness. Occupational Medicine 53, 89–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Åkerstedt T. E., P. Fredlund, M. Gillberg, B. Jansson: 2002, A Prospective Study of Fatal Occupational Accidents: Relationship to Sleeping Difficulties and Occupational Factors. Journal of Sleep Research 11, 69–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Åkerstedt T., A. Knutsson, P. Westerholm, T. Theorell, I. Alfredsson, G. Kecklund: 2002, Sleep Disturbances, Work Stress and Work Hours: A Cross-Sectional Study. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 53, 741–748CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Andrews, A. R.: 2000, ‹What Every Student Should Know About Journalism’, The American Reporter 6 (1266W). Retrieved December 27, 2007 at: http://www.toad.net/~andrews/studentknow.htm
  8. Atack, J. and F. Bateman: 1991, ‹Whom did Protectionist Legislation Protect? Evidence from 1880’, National Bureau of Economic Research Historical Working Paper No. 33, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  9. Axelsson G., R. Rylander: 1989, Outcome of Pregnancy in Relation to Irregular and Inconvenient Work Schedules. British Journal of Industrial Medicine 46, 306–312Google Scholar
  10. Barger L. K., B. E. Cade, N. T. Ayas, J. W. Cronin, B. Rosner, F. E. Speizer C., A. Czeisler: 2005, Extended Work Shifts and the Risk of Motor Vehicle Crashes. New England Journal of Medicine 352(2), 125–134CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Barton J., J. Aldridge, P. Smith: 1998, The Emotional Impact of Shift Work on the Children of Shift Workers. Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment and Health 24(Suppl 3), 146–150Google Scholar
  12. Bayley, D. H. and R. E. Worden: 1998, ‹Police Overtime: An Examination of Key Issues’, National Institute of Justice Research in Brief, May 1998, 1–8Google Scholar
  13. Berney B., J. Needleman: 2005, Trends in Nurse Overtime, 1995–2002. Policy, Politics, and Nursing Practice 6(3), 183–190CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Berney B., J. Needleman, C. Kovner: 2005, Factors Influencing the Use of Registered Nurse Overtime in Hospitals, 1995–2000. Journal of Nursing Scholarship 37(2), 165–172CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Bøggild H., A. Knutsson: 1999, Shift Work, Risk Factors and Cardiovascular Disease. Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment and Health 25, 85–99Google Scholar
  16. Braver E. R., C. W. Preusser, D. F. Preusser, H. M. Baum, R. Beilock, R. Ulmer: 1992, Long Hours and Fatigue: A Survey of Tractor-Trailer Drivers. Journal of Public Health Policy 13(3), 341–366CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Brogmus G., W. Maynard 2006, Safer Shift Work Through More Effective Scheduling. Occupational Health and Safety 75(12), 16Google Scholar
  18. Caruso, C., E. Hitchcock, R. Dick, J. M. Russo and J. M. Schmit: 2004, Overtime and Extended Work Shifts: Recent Findings on Illnesses, Injuries, and Health Behaviors (U.S. Centers for Disease Control, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Cincinnati), Publication No. 2004-143Google Scholar
  19. Circadian Technologies, Inc.: 2000, ‹The Costs of Human Breakdown’, Chapter 5 of 24 × 7 Operations: Optimizing Human Performance (Circadian Technologies, Inc., Cambridge, MA). Retrieved on December 24, 2007 at: http://www.tcrc355.com/legislative/shift_work_maladapation.pdf
  20. Colligan M., R. Rosa: 1990, Shiftwork Effects on Social and Family Life. Occupational Medicine: State of the Art Reviews 5(2), 315–322Google Scholar
  21. Cornell University Institute for Workplace Studies: 1999, Overtime and the American Worker. Ithaca, NY: New York State School of Industrial and Labor RelationsGoogle Scholar
  22. Costa G.: 2003, Shift Work and Occupational Medicine: An Overview. Occupational Medicine 53, 83–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Davis S., D. K. Mirick, R. G. Stevens: 2001, Night Shift Work, Light at Night, and Risk of Breast Cancer. Journal of the National Cancer Institute 93, 1557–1562Google Scholar
  24. Dawson, D., K. McCulloch and A. Baker: 2001, Extended Working Hours in AustraliaCounting the Costs (Centre for Sleep Research, The University of South Australia, The Adelaide). Retrieved December 19, 2007 at: http://www.deir.qld.gov.au/pdf/ir/extendedhours.pdf
  25. Dembe, A. E., J. B. Erickson and R. G. Delbos: 2008, ‹Industry and Occupation Variations in the Injury Risks Related to Shift Work and Extended Work Hours’, Working Paper, The Ohio State University Center for Health Outcomes, Policy and Evaluation StudiesGoogle Scholar
  26. Dembe A. E., J. B. Erickson, R. G. Delbos, S. M. Banks: 2005, The Impact of Overtime and Long Work Hours on Occupational Injuries and Illnesses: New Evidence from the United States. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 62(9), 588–597CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Dembe A. E., J. B. Erickson, R. G. Delbos, S. M. Banks 2006, Nonstandard Shift Work and the Risk of Job-Related Injuries: A National Study from the United States. Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment and Health 32(3), 232–240Google Scholar
  28. DeMoss C., M. McGrail, E. Haus, A. L. Crain, S. E. Asche: 2004, Health and Performance Factors in Health Care Shift Workers. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 46, 1278–1281Google Scholar
  29. Dorman, P.: 2000, ‹The Role of Economic Incentives for Occupational Safety and Health’, International Labor Organization, Geneva, Programme on Safety and Health at Work and the Environment (SafeWork)Google Scholar
  30. Federal Railroad Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation (FRA): 2006, Validation and Calibration of a Fatigue Assessment Tool for Railroad Work Schedules, Summary Report (RFA, Washington, DC). Report DOT/FRA/ORD/06-21Google Scholar
  31. Folkard S., D. A. Lombardi, P. T. Tucker: 2005, Shiftwork: Safety, Sleepiness and Sleep. Industrial Health 43(1), 20–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Frankfurter, F. and J. Goldmark: 1915, The Case for the Shorter Work Day: Supreme Court of the United States, October Term, 1915, Franklin O. Bunting, Plaintiff in Error, vs. the State of Oregon, Defendant in Error: Brief for Defendant in Error. Reprinted by National Consumers League, New York, 1916Google Scholar
  33. Glass J., T. Fujimoto: 1994, Housework, Paid Work, and Depression Among Husbands and Wives. Journal of Health Society and Behavior 135, 179–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Golden L., B. Wiens-Tuers 2005, Mandatory Overtime Work in the United States: Who, Where, and What? Labor Studies Journal 30(1), 1–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Goode J. H.: 2003, Are Pilots at Risk of Accidents Due to Fatigue? Journal of Safety Research 34(2), 309–313CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Greenhouse, S.: 2002, ‹U.S. Jury Cites Unpaid Work at Wal-Mart’, New York Times, December 20, 2002Google Scholar
  37. Grosch J. W., C. C. Caruso, R. R. Rosa, S. L. Sauter: 2006, Long Hours of Work in the U.S.: Associations with Demographic and Organizational Characteristics, Psychosocial Working Conditions, and Health. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 49, 943–952CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hänecke K., S. Tiedemann, F. Nachreiner, H. Grzech-Šukalo: 1998, Accident Risk as a Function of Hour at Work and Time of Day as Determined from Accident Data and Exposure Models for the German Working Population. Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment and Health 24(Suppl 3), 43–48Google Scholar
  39. Hansen J.: 2001, Increased Breast Cancer Risk Among Women Who Work Predominantly at Night. Epidemiology 12(1), 74–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Hanson M. A.: 2001, Contemporary Ergonomics, 2001 (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL)Google Scholar
  41. Härmä M., M. Sallinen, R. Ranta, P. Mutanen, K. Müller: 2002, The Effect of an Irregular Shift System on Sleepiness at Work in Train Drivers and Railway Traffic Controllers. Journal of Sleep Research 11(2), 141–151CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Harrington J. M.: 2001, Health Effects of Shift Work and Extended Hours of Work. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 58, 68–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Hayashi T., Y. Kobayashi, K. Yamaoka, E. Yano: 1996, Effect of Overtime Work on 24-Hour Ambulatory Blood Pressure. Journal of Occupational Medicine 38, 1007–1011CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Hewlett, S. and C. B. Luce: 2006, ‹Extreme Jobs: The Dangerous Allure of the 70-Hour Workweek,’ Harvard Business Review, December 1, 2006Google Scholar
  45. Horne J., L. Reyner: 1999, Vehicle Accidents Related to Sleep: A Review. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 56, 289–294CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Horwitz I. B., B. McCall: 2004, The Impact of Shift Work on the Risk and Severity of Injuries for Hospital Employees: An Analysis Using Oregon Workers’ Compensation Data. Occupational Medicine 54, 556–563CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Hughes R., P. Stone: 2004, The Perils of Shift Work. American Journal of Nursing 104, 60–63Google Scholar
  48. Iwasaki K., M. Takahashi, A. Nakata: 2006, Health Problems Due to Long Working Hours in Japan, Industrial Health, 44, 537–540CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Jacobs J. A., K. Gerson: 2004, The Time Divide: Work, Family and Gender Inequality (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)Google Scholar
  50. Japan Press Weekly: 2006, ‹Situation at Toyota Revealed by JCP Investigation’, Retrieved December 30, 2006 at: http://www.japan-press.co.jp/2006/2496/economy.html
  51. Kawakami N., S. Araki, N. Takatsuka, H. Shimizu, H. Ishibashi: 1999, Overtime, Psychosocial Working Conditions, and Occurrence of Non-Insulin Dependent Diabetes Mellitus in Japanese Men, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 53, 359–363CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Keese M.: 2006, Live Longer, Work Longer, Paris: OECD PublishingGoogle Scholar
  53. Kivimäki M., P. Kuisma, M. Virtanen, M. Elovainio: 2001, Does Shift Work Lead to Poorer Health Habits? A Comparison Between Women Who had Always done Shift Work with Those Who had Never done Shift Work. Work and Stress 15(1), 3–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Kodz, J., S. Davis, D. Lain, M. Strebler and J. Rick: 2001, Working Long Hours in the U.K.: A Review of the Research Literature, Analysis of Survey Data, and Cross-National Organizational Case Studies. Employment Relations Research Series No. 16, Department of Trade and IndustryGoogle Scholar
  55. Knutsson A.: 2003, Health Disorders of Shift Workers. Occupational Medicine 53, 103–108CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Kristensen T. S. 1989, Cardiovascular Diseases and the Work Environment: A Critical Review of the Epidemiologic Literature on Nonchemical Factors. Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment and Health 15, 165–179Google Scholar
  57. Kuhn, P. and F. Lozano: 2005, The Expanding Workweek? Understanding Trends in Long Work Hours Among U.S. Men, 1979–2004. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper Number 11895Google Scholar
  58. Lee K. A.: 1992, Self Reported Sleep Disturbances in Employed Women. Sleep 15, 493–498Google Scholar
  59. Lee S., D. McCann, J. C. Messenger: 2007, Working Time Around the World: Trends in Working Hours, Laws, and Policies in a Global Comparative Perspective. Geneva: International Labor OrganizationGoogle Scholar
  60. Lehmkuhl, L.: 1999, Health Effects of Long Work Hours. “32 Hours” Organization Report. Retrieved December 28, 2007 at: http://www.wen.net/32hours/Health%20Effects%20v2.htm
  61. Lipscomb J. A., A. M. Trinkoff, J. Geiger-Brown, B. Brady: 2002, Work-Schedule Characteristics and Reported Musculoskeletal Disorders of Registered Nurses. Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment and Health 28, 394–401Google Scholar
  62. Liu, Y., H. Tanaka and The Fukuoka Heart Study Group: 2002, ‹Overtime Work, Insufficient Sleep, and Risk of Non-Fatal Acute Myocardial Infarction in Japanese Men’, Occupational and Environmental Medicine 59, 447–451Google Scholar
  63. Mishel, L., J. Bernstein and S. Allegretto (eds.): 2006, The State of Working America, 2006/2007 (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)Google Scholar
  64. Mohren D. C., G. M. Swaen, I. J. Kant, P. J. Borm, J. M. Galama: 2001, Associations Between Infections and Fatigue in a Dutch Working Population: Results of the Maastricht Cohort Study on Fatigue at Work. European Journal of Epidemiology 17(12), 1081–1087CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Motoyama, S.: 2000, ‹Time Crunch Hits Home’, The Penn Current. March 2, 2000. Retrieved on December 28, 2007 at: http://www.upenn.edu/pennnews/current/2000/030200/research.html
  66. Nachreiner, F., S. Akkermann and K. Haenecke: 2000, ‹Fatal Accident Risk as a Function of Hours into Work’, in S. Hornberger, P. Knauth, G. Costa, and S. Folkard (eds.), Arbeitswissenschaft in der betrieblichen Praxis [Ergonomics in operational practice] 17: Shiftwork in the 21st Century (Peter Lang Publishers, Frankfurt), pp. 19–24Google Scholar
  67. Nakanishi N., H. Yoshida, K. Nagano, H. Kawashimo, K. Nakamura, K. Tatara: 2001, Long Working Hours and Risk for Hypertension in Japanese Male White Collar Workers. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 55, 316–322CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Ottmann W., M. J. Karvonen, K. H. Schmidt, P. Knauth, J. Rutenfranz: 1989, Subjective Health Status of Day and Shift-Working Policemen. Ergonomics 32, 847–854CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Pfesser J.: 2001, What’s Wrong with Management Practices in Silicon Valley? A Lot. MIT Sloan Management Review 42(3), 101–102Google Scholar
  70. Pocock, B.: 2001, The Effect of Long Hours on Family and Community Life: A Survey of Existing Literature. Report for the Queensland Department of Industrial Relations, Adelaide, Australia: Adelaide University Centre for Labour ResearchGoogle Scholar
  71. Presser H. 2000, Nonstandard Work Schedules and Marital Instability. Journal of Marriage and Family 62, 93–110CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Robins P. K., T. L. Idson: 1991, Determinants of Voluntary Overtime Decisions, Economic Inquiry 29(1), 79–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Rogers A. E., W. T. Hwang, L. D. Scott, L. H. Aiken, D. F. Dinges: 2004, The Working Hours of Hospital Staff Nurses and Patient Safety. Health Affairs 23(4), 202–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Schernhammer E. S., F. Laden, F. E. Speizer, W. C. Willett, D. L. Hunter, I. Kawachi, C. S. Fuchs, G. A. Colditz 2003, Night-Shift Work and Risk of Colorectal Cancer in the Nurses’ Health Study. Journal of the National Cancer Institute 95, 825–828CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Scott A.: 2000, Shift Work and Health. Primary Care 27, 1057–1079Google Scholar
  76. Scott A. J., LaDou J. 1990, Shiftwork: Effects on Sleep and Health with Recommendations for Medical Surveillance and Screening. Occupational Medicine 5(2), 273–299Google Scholar
  77. Segawa K., S. Nakazawa, Y. Tsukamoto, Y. Kurita, H. Goto, A. Fukui, K. Takano: 1987, Peptic Ulcer is Prevalent Among Shift Workers. Digestive Diseases and Sciences 32, 449–453CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Shields M.: 1999, Long Working Hours and Health. Health Reports 11, 33–48Google Scholar
  79. Simon B. L.: 1990, Impact of Shift Work on Individuals and Families. Families in Society 71, 342–348Google Scholar
  80. Simpson R.: 1998, Presenteeism, Power and Organizational Change: Long Hours as a Career Barrier and the Impact on the Working Lives of Women Managers. British Journal of Management 9(s1), 37–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Spurgeon, A.: 2003, Working Time: Its Impact on Safety and Health. International Labor Organization, Geneva. Retrieved December 18, 2007 at: http://www.ilo.org/public/english/protection/condtrav/publ/wtwo-as-03.htm
  82. Staines G. L., J. H. Pleck: 1984, Nonstandard Work Schedules and Family Life. Journal of Applied Psychology 69(3), 515–523CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Trinkoff A. M., R. Le, J. Geiger-Brown, L. Lipscomb, G. Lang: 2006, Longitudinal Relationship of Work Hours, Mandatory Overtime, and On-Call to Musculoskeletal Problems in Nurses. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 49(11), 964–971CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Trinkoff A. M., C. L. Storr: 1998, Work Schedule Characteristics and Substance Use in Nurses. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 34(3), 266–271CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Van der Hulst, M.: 2003, Long Workhours and Health. Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment and Health 29, 171–188Google Scholar
  86. Viscusi W. K.: 1983, Risk by Choice: Regulating Health and Safety in the Workplace. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University PressGoogle Scholar
  87. Webber, N.: 2002, ‹The Issue for 2002: An End to Mandatory Overtime’, New York State Nurses Association. Retrieved on December 31, 2007 at: http://www.legislativegazette.com/read_more.php?story=1350
  88. Whaples, R.: 2001, ‹Hours of Work in U.S. History’, Retrieved December 31, 2007, from http://www.eh.net/encyclopedia/article/whaples.work.hours.us
  89. White, J. and J. Beswick: 2003: Working Long Hours. Report HSL/2003/02. Health and Safety Laboratory, Sheffield, UK. Retrieved December 17, 2007 at: http://www.hse.gov.uk/research/hsl_pdf/2003/hsl03-02.pdf
  90. Wright L. D.: 2007, Voluntary Overtime, Unsafe Nursing Practice, and the Quest for Institutional Accountability. JONA’s Healthcare Law, Ethics, & Regulation 9(2), 50–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Yang H., P. L. Schnall, M. Jauregui, T.-C. Su, D. Baker: 2006, Work Hours and Self-Reported Hypertension Among Working People in California. Hypertension 48, 744–750CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Division of Health Services Management & Policy, Center for Health Outcomes, Policy and Evaluation StudiesThe Ohio State University College of Public HealthColumbusU.S.A.

Personalised recommendations