Abstact
In a recent paper in Business Ethics Quarterly Professor Jeffrey Moriarty (2005) asserted the relevance of political philosophy to business ethics. Moriarty asked whether “businesses ought to be run (more) like states” and argued why that might be beneficial. This paper on the contrary asserts that there are distinct disadvantages to businesses attempting to be run more like states. Specifically, it asserts that any such an attempt increases the likelihood of the re-emergence of a totalitarian society as businesses currently often act as an intermediary between the individual and the state. The paper contemplates Moeller’s ambitions in the Weimar period for the business to be run like a state and the historical outcome of those ambitions. The paper also distinguishes between two different kinds of rights and argues that different kinds of rights pertain to different sectors which preclude business being run like a state.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Archard D.: 1996, Should Nationalists be Communitarians. Journal of Applied Philosophy 13, 215–220
Baker M. J.: 2000, Marketing Theory (Thomson Learning, London)
Beatty J.: 1998, The World According to Drucker (Orion, London)
Berle A. A., G. C. Means: 1967, The Modern Corporation and Private Property (Harcourt, Brace & World, Inc., New York)
Bonaparte T. H., J. E. Flaherty (eds.): 1970, Peter Drucker – Contribution to Business Enterprise (New York University Press, New York)
Buber M.: 1969, Between Man and Man (Fontana Books, London)
Buber M.: 1974, Pointing the Way (Schoken Books, New York)
Berger P. L.: 1986, The Capitalist Revolution: Fifty Propositions about Prosperity, Equality, and Liberty (Basic Books, New York)
Berger, P. L.: 1992, A Far Glory (Free press, New York)
Campbell J.: 1989, Joy in Work, German Work – The National Debate, 1800–1945 (Princeton University Press, Princeton)
Canovan M.: 1994, Hannah Arendt: A Reinterpretation of Her Political Thought (Cambridge University Press, Melbourne)
Cassis Y.: 1997, Big Business: The European Experience in the Twentieth Century (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
Cohen S.: 2004, The Nature of Moral Reasoning: The Framework and Activities of Ethical Deliberation, Argument, and Decision-Making (Oxford University Press, South Melbourne)
Collingwood R. G.: 1994, The Idea of History (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
Conan Doyle A.: 1985, The Original Illustrated Sherlock Holmes (Castle, Secaucus, New Jersey)
D’Entreves M. P.: 1994, The Political Philosophy of Hannah Arendt (Routledge, London)
Drucker P. F.: 1939, The End of Economic Man: A Study of the New Totalitarianism (Heinemann, London)
Drucker, P. F.: 1942, The Future of Industrial Man (reprinted in 1995 by Transaction Publishers, London; originally published in 1942 by The John Day Company)
Drucker, P. F.: 1953, ‚The Employee Society’, American Journal of Sociology (January), 358–363
Drucker P. F.: 1960, Concept of the Corporation, (Beacon Press, Beacon Hill)
Drucker P. F.: 1969, Age of Discontinuity (Heinemann, London)
Drucker P. F.: 1971, Men, Ideas & Politics (Harper and Row, New York)
Drucker P. F.: 1973, Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices (Harper and Row, New York)
Drucker P. F.: 1980 Adventures of a Bystander (Harper & Row, New York)
Drucker P. F.: 1981, Towards the Next Economics and Other Essays (Heinemann, London)
Drucker P. F.: 1985, The Changing World of the Executive (Times Books, New York)
Drucker P. F.: 1987, The Frontiers of Management (Heinemann, London)
Ehrenberg J.: 1999, Civil Society: The Critical History of an Idea (New York University Press, New York)
Flaherty J. E.: 1999, Peter Drucker: Shaping the Managerial Mind (Jossey-Bass Publishers, San Francisco)
Friedman M.: 1991, Encounter on the Narrow Ridge: A Life of Martin Buber (Paragon, New York)
Fukuyama F.: 1992, The End of History and the Last Man (Avon Books, New York)
Gewirth A.: 1982, Human Rights: Essays on Justification and Applications (University of Chicago Press, Chicago)
Gewirth A.: 1996, The Community of Rights (University of Chicago Press, Chicago)
Gilbert M.: 1987, The Holocaust: The Jewish Tragedy (Fontana, London)
Glatzer N. N.: 1961, Franz Rosenzweig: His Life and Thought (Schoken Books, New York)
Hall J.: 1988, Two Kinds of Rights in Hoffman R. J., G. A. Larue (eds.), Biblical v. Secular Ethics: The Conflict (Prometheus Books, Buffalo, New York), pp. 117–130
Hayek F. A.: 1994, The Road to Serfdom (The University of Chicago Press, Chicago)
Jones C., Parker M., R. ten Bos: 2005, For Business Ethics (Routledge, London)
Kaler J.: 2000, Positioning Business Ethics in Relation to Management and Political Philosophy, Journal of Business Ethics 24, 257–272
Keeley M.: 2000, A Matter of Opinion, What Tends to the General Welfare’: Governing the Workplace, Business Ethics Quarterly 10, 243–254
Lauryssens S.: 1999, The Man Who Invented The Third Reich: The Life and Times of Arthur Moeller van den Bruck (Sutton Publishing, Phoenix Mill)
Levitt T.: 1970, The Living Legacy of Peter Drucker, in T. H. Bonaparte J. E., Flaherty (eds.), Peter Drucker: Contribution to Business Enterprise (New York University Press, New York)
Lohr, S.: 2005, ‚Ex-Chief of CIA Opposes Sale of Oil Firm to China’, International Herald Tribune Friday July␣15, p. 1
Moriarty J.: 2005, On the Relevance of Political Philosophy to Business Ethics, Business Ethics Quarterly 15, 455–474
Mosse G. L.: 1987, Germans and Jews (Wayne State University Press, Detroit)
Polanyi K.: 1944, The Great Transformation (Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York)
Pojman L. P.: 2005, How Should We Live? An Introduction to Ethics (Wadsworth/Thomson Learning, Belmont)
Raphael D. D.: 1976, Problems of Political Philosophy (MacMillan Press, London)
Samar V. J.: 1999, Positive Rights and the Problems of Social Justice, Business Ethics Quarterly 9, 361–376
Schoenbaum D.: 1980, Hitler’s Social Revolution (W. W. Norton & Co., New York)
Schwartz M.: 1998, Peter Drucker and the Denial of Business Ethics, Journal of Business Ethics 17, 1685–1692
Schwartz M.: 2004a, Drucker and Buber: The Germanic Search for Community as the Meaning of the Modern American Corporation. Research in Ethical Issues in Organizations, 5, 21–36
Schwartz M.: 2004b, Drucker’s Communitarian Vision and Its Implications for Business Ethics, Business Ethics: A European Review, 13, 288–301
Scott W. G.: 1992, Chester I. Barnard and the Guardians of the Managerial State (University Press of Kansas, Lawrence)
Stern F.: 1974, The Politics of Cultural Despair (University of California Press, Berkeley)
Thomas, E. and S. McGuire: 2005, ‚Terror at Rush Hour’, Newsweek 18th July, 10–19
Velasquez M. G.: 2006, Business Ethics: Concepts and Cases (Pearson, New Jersey)
Vermes, P.: 1994, Buber on God and the Perfect Man (Littman, London)
Watkins J. L.: 1959, The 100 Greatest Advertisements: Who Wrote Them and What They Did (Dover Publications, New York)
Yergin D.: 1993, The Prize (Simon & Schuster, London)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Dr. Michael Schwartz is an associate professor at the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology. He also serves as the vice-president of the Australian Association for Professional and Applied Ethics. His research in the field of business ethics has been published in Research in Ethical Issues in Organizations, the Journal of Business Ethics, Business Ethics Quarterly and Business Ethics: A European Review.