Racial disparities in health outcomes have recently become a flashpoint in the debate about the value of race as a biological concept. What role, if any, race has in the etiology of disease is a philosophically and scientifically contested topic. In this article, I expand on the insights of the new mechanistic philosophy of science to defend a mechanism discovery approach to investigating epidemiological racial disparities. The mechanism discovery approach has explanatory virtues lacking in the populational approach typically employed in the study of race and biomedicine. The explanatory constraints that form an integral part of the new mechanistic approach enable mechanism discovery to avoid the epistemic and normative shortcomings of the populational approach. The methodology of mechanism discovery can fruitfully be extended to the treatment and reversal of epidemiological racial disparities.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
By epidemiological racial disparities I mean statistically significant differences in the incidence of disease between racialized groups. Except when discussing the views of others, I use “race” and “racialized group” interchangeably. However, see Hochman (2019) for the argument that since racialization theory is not committed to a racial ontology, “racialized groups” are conceptually distinct from “races.” Since I am not committed to a racial ontology in my use of “race” (unless I am referring to another author’s conception), I do not take this distinction to be a problem for my usage. Thanks to an anonymous reviewer for drawing my attention to this issue.
African Americans are fairly admixed with only modest variation in ancestry and are primarily drawn from populations originating in West and West-Central Africa, including the Yoruba in Nigeria (Zakharia et al. 2009).
Thanks to an anonymous reviewer for suggesting this term.
See discussion of evidence for details.
Alexander D, Currie J (2017) Is it who you are or where you live? Residential segregation and racial gaps in childhood asthma. J Health Econ 55:186–200
Alzheimer’s Association (2019) Alzheimer’s disease facts and figures. Alzheimer’s Dement J Alzheimer’s Assoc 15(3):321–387
Andreasen RO (2004) The cladistic race concept: a defense. Biol Philos 19(3):425–442
Bagby SP, Martin D, Chung ST, Rajapakse N (2019) From the outside in: biological mechanisms linking social and environmental exposures to chronic disease and to health disparities. Am J Public Health 109(S1):S56–S63
Barnes LL, Bennett DA (2015) Dementia: cognitive resilience in APOE* ε4 carriers—is race important? Nat Rev Neurol 11(4):190–191
Bogen J (2008) Causally productive activities. Stud Hist Philos Sci Part A 39(1):112–123
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2005) Racial/ethnic disparities in infant mortality–United States, 1995–2002. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 54(22):553
Collins JW, Wu SY, David RJ (2002) Differing intergenerational birth weights among the descendants of US-born and foreign-born whites and African Americans in Illinois. Am J Epidemiol 155(3):210–216
Craver CF, Darden L (2013) In search of mechanisms: discoveries across the life sciences. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Darden L, Pal LR, Kundu K, Moult J (2018a) The product guides the process: discovering disease mechanisms. In: Danks D, Ippoliti E (eds) Building theories: heuristics and hypotheses in the sciences. Springer, Cham, pp 101–117
Darden L, Kundu K, Pal LR, Moult J (2018b) Harnessing formal concepts of biological mechanism to analyze human disease. PLoS Comput Biol 14(12):e1006540
Drake AJ, Walker BR (2004) The intergenerational effects of fetal programming: non-genomic mechanisms for the inheritance of low birth weight and cardiovascular risk. J Endocrinol 180(1):1–16
Efstathiou S (2012) How ordinary race concepts get to be usable in biomedical science: an account of founded race concepts. Philos Sci 79(5):701–713
Epel ES, Blackburn EH, Lin J, Dhabhar FS, Adler NE, Morrow JD, Cawthon RM (2004) Accelerated telomere shortening in response to life stress. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101(49):17312–17315
Forna F, Jamieson DJ, Sanders D, Lindsay MK (2003) Pregnancy outcomes in foreign-born and US-born women. Int J Gynecol Obstet 83(3):257–265
Franklin-Hall LR (2016) New mechanistic explanation and the need for explanatory constraints. In: Aizawa K, Gillett C (eds) Scientific composition and metaphysical ground. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp 41–74
Frohlich KL, Potvin L (2008) Transcending the known in public health practice: the inequality paradox: the population approach and vulnerable populations. Am J Public Health 98(2):216–221
Goosby BJ, Heidbrink C (2013) The transgenerational consequences of discrimination on African-American health outcomes. Sociol Compass 7(8):630–643
Goosby BJ, Cheadle JE, Mitchell C (2018) Stress-related biosocial mechanisms of discrimination and African American health inequities. Annu Rev Sociol 44:319–340
Gravlee CC (2009) How race becomes biology: embodiment of social inequality. Am J Phys Anthropol 139(1):47–57
Green CR, Cupples LA, Go R, Benke KS, Edeki T, Griffith PA, Williams M (2002) Risk of dementia among white and African American relatives of patients with Alzheimer disease. JAMA 287(2):329–336
Hardimon MO (2013) Race concepts in medicine. J Med Philos 38(1):6–31
Hendrie HC, Ogunniyi A, Hall KS, Baiyewu O, Unverzagt FW, Gureje OW, Gao S (2001) Incidence of dementia and Alzheimer disease in 2 communities: Yoruba residing in Ibadan, Nigeria, and African Americans residing in Indianapolis, Indiana. JAMA 285(2):739–747
Hochman A (2013) Against the new racial naturalism. J Philos 110(6):331–351
Hochman A (2019) Racialization: a defense of the concept. Ethnic Racial Stud 42(8):1245–1262
Kaplan JM (2014) When socially determined categories make biological realities: understanding Black/White health disparities in the US. Monist 93(2):281–297
Kaplan JM, Winther RG (2014) Realism, antirealism, and conventionalism about race. Philos Sci 81(5):1039–1052
Kaup AR, Nettiksimmons J, Harris TB, Sink KM, Satterfield S, Metti AL, Ayonayon HN, Yaffe K (2015) Cognitive resilience to apolipoprotein E ε4: contributing factors in black and white older adults. JAMA Neurol 72(3):340–348
Kennedy A, Malanowski S (2019) Mechanistic reasoning and informed consent. Bioethics 33(1):162–168
Kitcher P (2007) Does ‘race’ have a future? Philos Public Affairs, pp 293–317
Kramer MS, Ananth CV, Platt RW, Joseph KS (2006) US black vs. white disparities in fetal growth: physiological or pathological? Int J Epidemiol 35(5):1187–1195
Kuzawa CW, Sweet E (2009) Epigenetics and the embodiment of race: developmental origins of US racial disparities in cardiovascular health. Am J Hum Biol 21(1):2–15
Kuzawa CW, Thayer Z (2011) The timescales of human adaptation: the role of epigenetic processes. Epigenomics 3(2):221–234
Lewontin RC (1972) The apportionment of human diversity. Evol Biol 6:381–398
Logue MW, Schu M, Vardarajan BN, Farrell J, Bennett DA, Buxbaum JD, Byrd G (2014) Two rare AKAP9 variants are associated with Alzheimer’s disease in African Americans. Alzheimer’s Dement J Alzheimer’s Assoc 10(6):609–618
Lorusso L, Bacchini F (2015) A reconsideration of the role of self-identified races in epidemiology and biomedical research. Stud Hist Philos Sci Part C: Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci 52:56–64
Machamer P (2004) Activities and causation: the metaphysics and epistemology of mechanisms. Int Stud Philos Sci 18(1):27–39
Machamer P, Darden L, Craver CF (2000) Thinking about mechanisms. Philos Sci 67(1):1–25
Matthews LJ (2017) On mechanistic reasoning in unexpected places: the case of population genetics. Biol Philos 32(6):999–1018
McDade TW, Ryan CP, Jones MJ, Hoke MK, Borja J, Miller GE, Kuzawa CW, Kobor MS (2019) Genome-wide analysis of DNA methylation in relation to socioeconomic status during development and early adulthood. Am J Phys Anthropol 169(1):3–11
McEwen BS, Gianaros PJ (2010) Central role of the brain in stress and adaptation: links to socioeconomic status, health, and disease. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1186(1):190–222
O’Donnell KJ, Meaney MJ (2017) Fetal origins of mental health: the developmental origins of health and disease hypothesis. Am J Psychiatry 174(4):319–328
Phillips DIW, Barker DJP, Fall CHD, Seckl JR, Whorwood CB, Wood PJ, Walker BR (1998) Elevated plasma cortisol concentrations: a link between low birth weight and the insulin resistance syndrome? J Clin Endocrinol Metab 83(3):757–760
Prince M, Bryce R, Wimo AE, Ribeiro W, Ferri CP (2013) The global prevalence of dementia: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Alzheimer’s Dement J Alzheimer’s Assoc 9(1):63–75
Reitz C, Jun G, Naj A, Rajbhandary R, Vardarajan BN, Wang LS, Valladares O et al (2013) Variants in the ATP-binding cassette transporter (ABCA7), apolipoprotein E ϵ4, and the risk of late-onset Alzheimer disease in African Americans. JAMA 309(14):1483–1492
Root M (2003) The use of race in medicine as a proxy for genetic differences. Philos Sci 70(5):1173–1183
Russo F, Williamson J (2007) Interpreting causality in the health sciences. Int Stud Philos Sci 21(2):157–170
Safieh M, Korczyn AD, Michaelson DM (2019) ApoE4: an emerging therapeutic target for Alzheimer’s disease. BMC Med 17(1):64
Scholaske L, Buss C, Wadhwa PD, Entringer S (2018) Acculturation and interleukin (IL)-6 concentrations across pregnancy among Mexican-American women. Brain Behav Immun 73:731–735
Sesardic N (2010) Race: a social destruction of a biological concept. Biol Philos 25(2):143–162
Spencer QNJ (2015) Philosophy of race meets population genetics. Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci 52:46–55
Spencer QNJ (2018) A racial classification for medical genetics. Philos Stud 175(5):1013–1037
Stepler KE, Robinson RA (2019) The potential of ‘omics to link lipid metabolism and genetic and comorbidity risk factors of Alzheimer’s Disease in African Americans. In: Reviews on biomarker studies in psychiatric and neurodegenerative disorders. Springer, Cham, pp 1–28
Sternthal MJ, Slope N, Williams DR (2011) Racial disparities in health. Du Bois Rev: Soc Sci Res Race 8(01):95–113
Stewart CP, Oaks BM, Laugero KD, Ashorn U, Harjunmaa U, Kumwenda C, Dewey KG (2015) Maternal cortisol and stress are associated with birth outcomes, but are not affected by lipid-based nutrient supplements during pregnancy: an analysis of data from a randomized controlled trial in rural Malawi. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 15(1):346
St-Pierre J, Hivert MF, Perron P, Poirier P, Guay SP, Brisson D, Bouchard L (2012) IGF2 DNA methylation is a modulator of newborn’s fetal growth and development. Epigenetics 7(10):1125–1132
Strevens M (2008) Depth: an account of scientific explanation. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Sullivan S (2013) Inheriting racist disparities in health: epigenetics and the transgenerational effects of white racism. Critical Philos Race 1(2):190–218
Tabery J (2014) Beyond versus: the struggle to understand the interaction of nature and nurture. MIT Press, Boston
Tarver-Carr ME, Powe NR, Eberhardt MS, LaVeist TA, Kington RS, Coresh J, Brancati FL (2002) Excess risk of chronic kidney disease among African-American versus white subjects in the United States: a population-based study of potential explanatory factors. J Am Soc Nephrol 13(9):2363–2370
Taylor P (2011) Rehabilitating a biological notion of race? A response to sesardic. Biol Philos 26(3):469–473
Temple R, Stockbridge NL (2007) BiDil for heart failure in black patients: the US Food and Drug Administration perspective. Ann Intern Med 146(1):57–62
Valles SA (2012) Heterogeneity of risk within racial groups, a challenge for public health programs. Prev Med 55(5):405–408
Vlietinck R, Derom R, Neale MC, Maes H, Van Loon H, Derom C, Thiery M (1989) Genetic and environmental variation in the birth weight of twins. Behav Genet 19(1):151–161
Waters CK (2007) Causes that make a difference. J Philos 104(11):551–579
Weslake B (2010) Explanatory depth. Philos Sci 77(2):273–294
Whitfield JB, Treloar SA, Zhu G, Martin NG (2001) Genetic and non-genetic factors affecting birth-weight and adult body mass index. Twin Res 4(05):365–370
Wilson V, Rogers III WM (2016) Black white wage gaps expand with rising wage inequality. Economic Policy Institute. Web. http://www.epi.org/publication/black-white-wage-gaps-expand-with-rising-wage-inequality/#epi-toc-7
Woodward J (1997) Explanation, invariance, and intervention. Philos Sci 64:S26–S41
Woodward J (2003) Making things happen: a causal theory of explanation. Oxford University Press, New York
Woodward J (2010) Causation in biology: stability, specificity, and the choice of levels of explanation. Biol Philos 25:287–318
Zakharia F, Basu A, Absher D, Assimes TL, Go AS, Hlatky MA, Sidney S (2009) Characterizing the admixed African ancestry of African Americans. Genome Biol 10(12):R141
Zijlmans MA, Riksen-Walraven JM, de Weerth C (2015) Associations between maternal prenatal cortisol concentrations and child outcomes: a systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 53:1–24
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Kalewold, K.H. Race and medicine in light of the new mechanistic philosophy of science. Biol Philos 35, 41 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-020-09759-x