Human microbiome research makes causal connections between entire microbial communities and a wide array of traits that range from physiological diseases to psychological states. To evaluate these causal claims, we first examine a well-known single-microbe causal explanation: of Helicobacter pylori causing ulcers. This apparently straightforward causal explanation is not so simple, however. It does not achieve a key explanatory standard in microbiology, of Koch’s postulates, which rely on manipulations of single-microorganism cultures to infer causal relationships to disease. When Koch’s postulates are framed by an interventionist causal framework, it is clearer what the H. pylori explanation achieves and where its explanatory strengths lie. After assessing this ‘simple’, single-microbe case, we apply the interventionist framework to two key areas of microbiome research, in which obesity and mental health states are purportedly explained by microbiomes. Despite the experimental data available, interventionist criteria for explanation show that many of the causal claims generated by microbiome research are weak or misleading. We focus on the stability, specificity and proportionality of proposed microbiome causal explanations, and evaluate how effectively these dimensions of causal explanation are achieved in some promising avenues of research. We suggest some conceptual and explanatory strategies to improve how causal claims about microbiomes are made.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Buy single article
Instant unlimited access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT for USA
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
This is the net price. Taxes to be calculated in checkout.
We are grateful to John Matthewson for suggesting this comparison.
Although some animals—especially gerbils—now model gastric symptoms concomitant with H. pylori infections, they are argued to be ‘inadequate’ models because H. pylori alone cannot produce human-like symptoms (e.g., Chen et al. 2007).
Typically, more distal causes will have less specificity than more proximate ones, simply because the longer a causal chain, the more associated causes would need to be mapped to unique values of the effect.
Stability is also related to proximity. The more proximal a pair of cause and effect variables, the fewer causal links or steps between them. The fewer causal links there are, the fewer background conditions (per causal link) can perturb the total causal relationship. Generally, therefore, distal causal relationships are considered less stable than proximal ones (Woodward 2010: 294).
Note that this sense of proportionality can apply to both the selection of causes and effects. Whether or not proportionality is used to select causes or effects depends upon the explanatory project: whether it is focused on explaining what causes an outcome, or on explaining what kinds of outcomes are produced by a particular factor. When selecting the most appropriate effect, proximity is also a good indicator of proportionality. This is because proximate effects often encompass the entire causal output, whereas more distal effects are parsed into different variables, some of which have other contributing causes influencing them.
This sense of proportionality can also be applied to both causes and effects, again depending on the explanatory project. When trying to understand the effects of a particular factor, effects may be invoked that are inappropriately broad or narrow, such as claiming that H. pylori causes illness, rather than more exactly ulcers.
Philosopher Paul Thagard (1998) has long argued that the interacting causal factors in the H. pylori-ulcer explanation make a ‘causal network’ explanation more effective than a single-cause explanation.
This is generally due to pragmatic factors such as ease of intervention. While diet may be a distal cause, it is often easier to manipulate compared to more proximate physiological factors.
Ait-Belgnaoui A et al (2012) Prevention of gut leakiness by a probiotic treatment leads to attenuated HPA response to an acute psychological stress in rats. Psychoneuroendocrinology 37:1885–1895
Arnold JW et al (2016) Emerging technologies for gut microbiome research. Trends Microbiol 24:887–901
Bercik P et al (2011) The intestinal microbiota affect central levels of brain-derived neurotropic factor and behaviour in mice. Gastroenterology 141:599–609.e3
Blaser MJ (1996) The bacteria behind ulcers. Sci Am 274:104–107
Blaser MJ (2014) The microbiome revolution. J Clin Investig 124:4162–4165
Bravo JA et al (2011) Ingestion of Lactobacillus strain regulates emotional behavior and central GABA receptor expression in a mouse via the vagus nerve. Proc Natl Acad Sci 108:16050–16055
Buffie CG et al (2015) Precision microbiome reconstitution restores bile acid mediated resistance to Clostridium difficile. Nature 517:205
Calcott B (2017) Causal specificity and the instructive–permissive distinction. Biol Philos 32:481–505
Carter KC (2003) The rise of causal concepts of disease: case histories. Ashgate, Farnham
Chen D et al (2007) Does Helicobacter pylori infection per se cause gastric cancer or duodenal ulcer? Inadequate evidence in Mongolian gerbils and inbred mice. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol 50:184–189
Cho I, Blaser MJ (2012) The human microbiome: at the interface of health and disease. Nat Rev Genet 13:260–270
Collins SM et al (2013) The adoptive transfer of behavioral phenotype via the intestinal microbiota: experimental evidence and clinical implications. Curr Opin Microbiol 16:240–245
Cox LM et al (2014) Altering the intestinal microbiota during a critical developmental window has lasting metabolic consequences. Cell 158:705–721
Duvallet C et al (2017) Meta-analysis of gut microbiome studies identifies disease-specific and shared responses. Nat Commun 8:1784
Fischbach MA (2018) Microbiome: focus on causation and mechanism. Cell 174:785–790
Fleissner CK et al (2010) Absence of intestinal microbiota does not protect mice from diet-induced obesity. Br J Nutr 104:919–929
Ford AC, Talley NJ (2009) Does Helicobacter pylori really cause duodenal ulcers? Yes. BMJ 339:b2784
Gilbert JA et al (2016) Microbiome-wide association studies link dynamic microbial consortia to disease. Nature 535:94–103
Gillies DA (2016) Establishing causality in medicine and Koch’s postulates. Intl J Hist Philos Med 6:10603
Goodrich JK et al (2014a) Human genetics shape the gut microbiome. Cell 159:789–799
Goodrich JK et al (2014b) Conducting a microbiome study. Cell 158:250–262
Goodwin CS et al (1989) Transfer of Campylobacter pylori and Campylobacter mustelae to Helicobacter gen. nov. as Helicobacter pylori comb. nov. and Helicobacter mustelae comb. nov. respectively. Int J Syst Bacteriol 39:397–405
Graham DY et al (2009) African, Asia or Indian enigma, the East Asian Helicobacter pylori: facts or medical myths. J Dig Dis 10:77–84
Griffiths PE et al (2015) Measuring causal specificity. Philos Sci 82:529–555
Grinspan AM, Kelly CR (2015) Fecal microbiota transplantation for ulcerative colitis: not just yet. Gastroenterology 149:15–18
Grundy SM (1998) Multifactorial causation of obesity: implications for prevention. Am J Clin Nutr 67(Suppl):563S–572S
Hall EK et al (2018) Understanding how microbiomes influence the systems they inhabit. Nat Microbiol 3:977–982
Hamady M, Knight R (2009) Microbial community profiling for human microbiome projects: tools, techniques, and challenges. Genome Res 19:1141–1152
Hanage WP (2014) Microbiome science needs a healthy dose of scepticism. Nature 512:247–249
Harley ITW, Karp CL (2012) Obesity and the gut microbiome: striving for causality. Mol Metab 1:21–31
Hildebrandt MA et al (2009) High-fat diet determines the composition of the murine gut microbiome independently of obesity. Gastroenterology 137:1716–1724
Hobsley M et al (2009) Does Helicobacter pylori really cause duodenal ulcers? No. BMJ 339:b2788
Hooi JKY et al (2017) Global prevalence of Helicobacter pylori infection: systematic review and meta-analysis. Gastroenterology 153f:420–429
Hooks KB, O’Malley MA (2017) Dysbiosis and its discontents. mBio 8(5):e0149217
Hryckowian AJ et al (2018) Microbiota-accessible carbohydrates suppress Clostridium difficile infection in a murine model. Nat Microbiol 3:662–669
Human Microbiome Project Consortium (2012) Structure, function and diversity of the healthy human microbiome. Nature 486:207–214
Huss J (2014) Methodology and ontology in microbiome research. Biol Theor 9:392–400
Kelly JR et al (2016) Transferring the blues: depression-associated gut microbiota induces neurobehavioural changes in the rat. J Psychiatr Res 82:109–118
Kelly JR et al (2017) Lost in translation? The potential psychobiotic Lactobacillus rhamnosus (JB-1) fails to modulate stress or cognitive performance in healthy male subjects. Brain Behav Immun 61:50–59
Kendler KS (2005) “A gene for…”: the nature of gene action in psychiatric disorders. Am J Psychiatr 162:1243–1252
Kidd M, Modlin IM (1998) A century of Helicobacter pylori. Digestion 59:1–15
Kristensen NB et al (2016) Alterations in fecal microbiota composition by probiotic supplementation in healthy adults: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Genome Med 8:52
Kusters JG et al (2006) Pathogenesis of Helicobacter pylori infection. Clin Microbiol Rev 19:449–490
Lawley TD, Walker AW (2013) Intestinal colonization resistance. Immunology 138:1–11
Levenstein S et al (2015) Psychological stress increases risk for peptic ulcer, regardless of Helicobacter pylori infection or use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol 13:498–506
Ley RE et al (2006) Microbial ecology: human gut microbes associated with obesity. Nature 444:1022–1023
Lin D, Koskella B (2014) Friend and foe: factors influencing the movement of the bacterium Helicobacter pylori along the parasitism-mutualism continuum. Evol Appl 8:9–22
Liou AP et al (2013) Conserved shifts in the gut microbiota due to gastric bypass reduce host weight and adiposity. Sci Transl Med. https://doi.org/10.1126/scitranslmed.3005687
Lloyd-Price J et al (2016) The healthy human microbiome. Genome Med 8:51
Malfertheiner P et al (2009) Peptic ulcer disease. Lancet 374:1449–1461
Malfertheiner P et al (2014) Helicobacter pylori: perspectives and time trends. Nat Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol 11:628–638
Manor O, Borenstein E (2017) Systematic characterization and analysis of the taxonomic drivers of functional shifts in the human microbiome. Cell 21:254–267
Marshall BJ (1995) Helicobacter pylori in peptic ulcer: Have Koch’s postulates been fulfilled? Ann Med 27:565–568
Marshall BJ (2005) Helicobacter connections (Nobel lecture, December 8, 2005). Reprinted in ChemMedChem (2006) 1:783–802
Marshall BJ, Warren JR (1984) Unidentified curved bacilli in the stomach of patients with gastritis and peptic ulceration. Lancet 16:1311–1315
Marshall BJ et al (1985) Attempt to fulfil Koch’s postulates for pyloric Campylobacter. Med J Aust 142:436–439
Mayer EA et al (2014) Gut microbes and the brain: paradigm shift in neuroscience. J Neurosci 34:15490–15496
McColl KEL et al (1993) A study of the pathogenesis of Helicobacter pylori negative chronic duodenal ulceration. Gut 34:762–768
Mitchell SD (2000) Dimensions of scientific law. Philos Sci 67:242–265
Mithieux G (2018) Gut microbiota and host metabolism: What relationship? Neuroendocrinology 106:352–356
Moayyedi P et al (2015) Fecal microbiota transplantation induces remission in patients with active ulcerative colitis in a randomized controlled trial. Gastroenterology 149:102–109.e6
Momozawa Y et al (2011) Characterization of bacteria in biopsies of colon and stools by high throughput sequencing of the V2 region of bacterial 16S rRNA gene in human. PLoS ONE 6:e16952
Neville BA et al (2018) Commensal Koch’s postulates: establishing causation in human microbiota research. Curr Opin Microbiol 42:47–52
Nguyen TLA et al (2015) How informative is the mouse for human gut microbiota research? Dis Model Mech 8:1–16
O’Malley MA, Skillings DJ (2018) Methodological strategies in microbiome research and their explanatory implications. Persp Sci 26:239–265
Parke EC et al (2018) A cautionary note for claims about the microbiome’s impact on the “self”. PLoS Biol 16(9):e2006654
Pocheville A et al (2017) Comparing causes—an information-theoretic approach to specificity, proportionality and stability. In: Leitgeb H et al (eds) Proceedings of the 15th congress of logic, methodology and philosophy of science. College Publications, London, pp 250–275
Rees T et al (2018) How the microbiome challenges our concept of self. PLoS Biol 16(2):e2005358
Reich T et al (1975) The multifactorial model of disease transmission: I. Description of the model and its use in psychiatry. Br J Psychiatry 127:1–10
Ridaura VK et al (2013) Gut microbiota from twins discordant for obesity modulate metabolism in mice. Science 341:1241214
Ross LN (2018) Causal selection and the pathway concept. Philos Sci 85:551–572
Ross LN, Woodward JF (2016) Koch’s postulates: an interventionist perspective. Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci 59:35–46
Round JL, Mazmanian SK (2009) The gut microbiota shapes intestinal immune responses during health and disease. Nat Rev Immunol 9:313–323
Sampson TR, Mazmanian SK (2015) Control of brain development, function, and behavior by the microbiome. Cell Host Microbe 17:565–576
Schwabe RF, Jobin C (2013) The microbiome and cancer. Nat Rev Genet 13:800–812
Sender R et al (2016) Are we really vastly outnumbered? Revisiting the ratio of bacterial to host cells in humans. Cell 164:337–340
Stein RR et al (2013) Ecological modeling from time-series inference: insight into dynamics and stability of intestinal microbiota. PLoS Comput Biol 9:e1003388
Surana NK, Kasper DL (2017) Moving beyond microbiome-wide associations to causal microbe identification. Nature 552(7684):244–247
Susser M (1991) What is a cause and how do we know one? A grammar for pragmatic epidemiology. Am J Epidemiol 133(7):635–648
Sze MA, Schloss PD (2016) Looking for a signal in the noise: revisiting obesity and the microbiome. mBio 7:e01018-16
Thagard P (1998) Explaining disease: correlations, causes, and mechanisms. Minds Mach 8:61–78
Truax AD et al (2018) The inhibitory innate immune sensor NLRP12 maintains a threshold against obesity by regulating gut microbiota homeostasis. Cell Host Microbe 24:364–378
Turnbaugh PJ et al (2008) Diet-induced obesity is linked to marked but reversible alterations in the mouse distal gut microbiome. Cell Host Microbe 3:213–223
Turnbaugh PJ et al (2009) A core gut microbiome in obese and lean twins. Nature 457:480–484
van Nood E et al (2013) Duodenal infusion of donor feces for recurrent Clostridium difficile. NEJM 368:407–415
van Zanten SJOV, Sherman PM (1994) Helicobacter pylori infection as a cause of gastritis, duodenal ulcer, gastric cancer and nonulcer dyspepsia: a systematic overview. Can Med Assoc J 150:177–185
Vonaesch P et al (2018) Pathogens, microbiome and the host: emergence of the ecological Koch’s postulates. FEMS Microbiol Rev 42:273–292
Wang H et al (2016) Effect of probiotics on central nervous system functions in animals and humans: a systematic review. J Neurogastroenterol Motil 22:589–605
Woodward J (2003) Making things happen: a theory of causal explanation. OUP, Oxford
Woodward J (2006) Some varieties of robustness. J Econ Methodol 13:219–240
Woodward J (2010) Causation in biology: stability, specificity, and the choice of levels of explanation. Biol Philos 25:287–318
Yablo S (1992) Mental causation. Philos Rev 101:245–280
Zmora N et al (2018) Personalized gut mucosal colonization resistance to empiric probiotics is associated with unique host and microbiome features. Cell 174:1388–1405.e21
We thank Brett Calcott, Austen Ganley, David Kelley, John Matthewson, Sam Woolley, and the audience at PBDB 12 who provided crucial feedback on earlier versions of this manuscript, and acknowledge Pierrick Bourrat for earlier discussion of some of these ideas.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Lynch, K.E., Parke, E.C. & O’Malley, M.A. How causal are microbiomes? A comparison with the Helicobacter pylori explanation of ulcers. Biol Philos 34, 62 (2019) doi:10.1007/s10539-019-9702-2
- Causal explanation
- Helicobacter pylori
- Koch’s postulates