Abstract
The effect of moorland management on the release of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) from blanket peat is currently a topic of great interest in the UK. A recent paper by Chapman et al. (Biogeochemistry, doi:10.1007/s10533-010-9474-x, 2010) reports on changes in humic colour/DOC concentrations in surface waters draining 15 upland peat catchments in the North Pennines (UK) over two decades, and examines the possible underlying drivers of those changes. Chapman et al. identify significant variation in water colour between adjacent catchments and over time. One potential driver of changes in DOC is managed moorland burning, and Chapman et al. state that their study provides evidence that burning has no effect on colour in upland catchment drainage waters. This observation counters a recent series of papers showing strong links between new moorland burn management on blanket peat soils and colour/DOC in catchment drainage waters. We have reviewed the methodological approach and results presented by Chapman et al. that relate to the assessment of managed burning, and show significant errors in the data used in their analysis. This has resulted in conclusions being drawn about the role of managed burning in DOC release that are not supported by evidence.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
References
Chapman PJ, McDonald AT, Tyson R, Palmer SM, Mitchell G, Irvine B (2010) Changes in water colour between 1986 and 2006 in the headwaters of the River Nidd, Yorkshire, UK. Biogeochemistry. doi:10.1007/s10533-010-9474-x
Charman DJ (1992) Blanket mire formation at the Cross Lochs, Sutherland, northern Scotland. Boreas 21:53–72
Clay GD, Worrall F, Fraser EDG (2009) Effects of managed burning upon dissolved organic carbon (DOC) in soil water and runoff water following a managed burn of a UK blanket bog. J Hydrol 367:41–51
Clutterbuck B, Yallop A (2010) Land management as a factor controlling dissolved organic carbon release from upland peat soils 2: changes in DOC productivity over four decades. Sci Total Environ 408(24):6179–6191
Evans CD, Monteith DT, Cooper DM (2005) Long-term increases in surface water dissolved organic carbon: observations, possible causes and environmental impacts. Environ Pollut 137:55–71
Freeman C, Fenner N, Ostle NJ, Kang H, Dowrick DJ, Reynolds B, Lock MA, Sleep D, Hughes S, Hudson J (2004) Export of dissolved organic carbon from peatlands under elevated carbon dioxide levels. Nature 430:195–198
Lindsay RA (1995) Bogs: the ecology, classification and conservation of ombrotrophic mires. Scottish Natural Heritage, Edinburgh
Mitchell G, McDonald AT (1995) Catchment characterisation as a tool for upland water quality management. J Environ Manag 44:83–95
Monteith DT, Stoddard JL, Evans CD, de Wit HA, Forsius M, Høgåsen T, Wilander A, Skjelkvåle BL, Jeffries DS, Vuorenmaa J, Keller B, Kopácek J, Vesely J (2007) Dissolved organic carbon trends resulting from changes in atmospheric deposition chemistry. Nature 450:537–540
Moore PD (1993) The origin of blanket mire, revisited. In: Chambers FM (ed) Climate change and human impact on landscape. Chapman & Hall, Boston, pp 217–224
Shaw SC, Wheeler BD, Kirby P, Phillipson P, Edmunds R (1996) Literature review of the historical effects of burning and grazing of blanket bog and upland wet heath. English Nature Research Report, No. 172, English Nature, Peterborough
Simmons IG (2003) The moorlands of England and Wales: an environmental history 8000 BC–AD 2000. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh
Stewart GB, Coles CF, Pullin AS (2004) Does burning degrade blanket bog? Systematic Review No. 1, Centre for Evidence-Based Conservation
Tallis JH (1991) Forest and moorland in the South Pennine uplands in the mid-Flandrian period. III. The spread of moorland—local, regional and national. J Ecol 79:401–415
Tucker G (2003) Review of the impacts of heather and grassland burning in the uplands on soils, hydrology and biodiversity. English Nature Research Report No. 550, English Nature, Peterborough
Ward SE, Bardgett RD, McNamara NP, Adamson JK, Ostle NJ (2007) Long-term consequences of grazing and burning on northern peatland carbon dynamics. Ecosystems 10:1069–1083
Worrall F, Burt TP (2004) Time series analysis of long term river DOC records. Hydrol Process 18:893–911
Worrall F, Armstrong A, Adamson JK (2007) The effects of burning and sheep-grazing on water table depth and soil water quality in a upland peat. J Hydrol 339:1–14
Yallop AR, Clutterbuck B (2009) Land management as a factor controlling dissolved organic carbon release from upland peat soils 1: spatial variation in DOC productivity. Sci Total Environ 407(12):3803–3813
Yallop AR, Thacker J, Thomas G, Stephens M, Clutterbuck B, Sannier C (2006) The extent and intensity of management burning in the English uplands. J Appl Ecol 43(6):1138–2664
Yallop AR, Clutterbuck B, White S (2008) Evidence for a mechanism driving recent observed trends in dissolved organic carbon release from upland peat soils. Asp Appl Biol 85:127–132. In: Shaping a vision for the uplands
Yallop AR, Clutterbuck B, Thacker J (2010) Increases in humic dissolved organic carbon (hDOC) export from upland peat catchments: the role of temperature, declining sulphur deposition and changes in land management. Clim Res 22. doi:10.3354/cr00884
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Yallop, A.R., Clutterbuck, B. & Thacker, J.I. Changes in water colour between 1986 and 2006 in the headwaters of the River Nidd, Yorkshire, UK: a critique of methodological approaches and measurement of burning management. Biogeochemistry 111, 97–103 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10533-011-9628-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10533-011-9628-5