Abstract
Invasive species threaten biodiversity, ecosystem functions, and human health around the world. Accurate and reliable species delineation and identification are prerequisites for any effort to control the introduction of new species and the spread of those already introduced. The advent of DNA assisted taxonomic tools has fueled the development of diverse and innovative approaches often touted as simple, inexpensive, and universally applicable for addressing impediments to rapid identification of non-native species. Ampullariidae (apple snails) are a family of freshwater snails with at least five species that have been introduced outside their native range and a prime example of how taxonomic uncertainty may hamper our understanding of invasion biology. Matsukura et al. (Appl Entomol Zool 43(4):535–540, 2008) and Cooke et al. (Conserv Genet Resour 4(3):591–593, 2012) developed species-specific PCR primers as rapid, simple, and inexpensive approaches to distinguishing among and identifying the most notorious and widespread invasive apple snails, Pomacea canaliculata and Pomacea maculata, and a third species in the aquarium trade, Pomacea diffusa. Neither approach was evaluated within the context of the overall genetic diversity of the target species, or with consideration for the species diversity within the family. To evaluate both shortcut approaches, the primers were tested for their utility in delineating and identifying the target species and other closely related taxa, including 24 apple snails representing 21 species. The results indicate that the primers are of limited taxonomic utility, and fail to consistently identify the target taxa, or congenerics. More importantly, use of these primers without additional data leads to misidentifications, potentially endangering native biodiversity and allowing novel introduced species to go undetected.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Pippin’s warning to Frodo in Book 1, Chapter 4 of the Fellowship of the ring.
References
Andree KB, López MA (2013) Species identification from archived snail shells via genetic analysis: a method for DNA extraction from empty shells. Molluscan Res 33(1):1–5
Bortolus A (2008) Error cascades in the biological sciences: the unwanted consequences of using bad taxonomy in ecology. Ambio 37(2):114–118
Buckley YM, Catford J (2016) Does the biogeographic origin of species matter? Ecological effects of native and non-native species and the use of origin to guide management. J Ecol 104(1):4–17
Cameron S, Rubinoff D, Will K (2006) Who will actually use DNA barcoding and what will it cost? Syst Biol 55:844–847
Carlsson NO, Brönmark C, Hansson LA (2004) Invading herbivory: the golden apple snail alters ecosystem functioning in Asian wetlands. Ecology 85(6):1575–1580
Cooke GM, King AG, Miller L, Johnson RN (2012) A rapid molecular method to detect the invasive golden apple snail Pomacea canaliculata (Lamarck, 1822). Conserv Genet Resour 4(3):591–593
Cowie RH (2002) Apple snails (Ampullariidae) as agricultural pests: Their biology, impacts and management. In: Baker GM (ed) Molluscs as crop pests. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, pp 145–192
Dayrat B (2005) Towards integrative taxonomy. Bio J Linn Soc 85(3):407–417
Deans AR, Yoder MJ, Balhoff JP (2012) Time to change how we describe biodiversity. Trends Ecol Evol 27(2):78–84
Dubois A (2003) The relationships between taxonomy and conservation biology in the century of extinctions. CR Biol 326:9–21
Dunn CP (2003) Keeping taxonomy based in morphology. Trends Ecol Evol 18:270–271
Ebach MC, Holdrege C (2005a) More taxonomy, not DNA barcoding. Bioscience 55:822–823
Ebach MC, Holdrege C (2005b) DNA barcoding is no substitute for taxonomy. Nature 434:697
Ehrenfeld JG (2010) Ecosystem consequences of biological invasions. Annu Rev Ecol Evol Syst 41:59–80
Ely CV, de Loreto Bordignon SA, Trevisan R, Boldrini II (2017) Implications of poor taxonomy in conservation. J Nat Conserv 36:10–13
Estebenet AL, Martín PR (2002) Pomacea canaliculata (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae): life-history traits and their plasticity. Biocell 26(1):83–89
Estebenet AL, Martín PR, Silvana B (2006) Conchological variation in Pomacea canaliculata and other South American Ampullariidae (Caenogastropoda, Architaenioglossa). Biocell 30(2):329–335
Folmer O, Black M, Hoeh W, Lutz R, Vrijenhoek R (1994) DNA primers for amplification of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I from diverse metazoan invertebrates. Mol Mar Biol Biotechnol 3:291–299
Gallardo B, Clavero M, Sánchez MI, Vilà M (2016) Global ecological impacts of invasive species in aquatic ecosystems. Glob Chang Biol 22(1):151–163
Gregory TR (2005) DNA barcoding does not compete with taxonomy. Nature 434(7037):1067–1067
Hayes KA, Cowie RH, Thiengo SC (2009) A global phylogeny of apple snails: Gondwanan origin, generic relationships, and the influence of outgroup choice (Caenogastropoda: Ampullariidae). Biol J Linn Soc 98(1):61–76
Hayes KA, Cowie RH, Thiengo SC, Strong EE (2012) Comparing apples with apples: clarifying the identities of two highly invasive Neotropical Ampullariidae (Caenogastropoda). Zool J Linn Soc 166(4):723–753
Hayes KA, Joshi RC, Thiengo SC, Cowie RH (2008) Out of South America: multiple origins of non-native apple snails in Asia. Divers Distrib 14(4):701–712
Hayes KA, Burks RL, Castro-Vazquez A, Darby PC, Heras H et al (2015) Insights from an integrative view of the biology of apple snails (Caenogastropoda: Ampullariidae). Malacologia 58:245–302
Hebert PDN, Cywinska A, Ball SL, De WJR (2003) Biological identifications through DNA barcodes. P Roy Soc B-Biol Sci 270:313–321
Hubert N, Hanner R (2015) DNA barcoding, species delineation and taxonomy: a historical perspective. DNA Barcodes 3(1):44–58
Horgan FG, Stuart AM, Kudavidanage EP (2014) Impact of invasive apple snails on the functioning and services of natural and managed wetlands. Acta Oecol 54:90–100
Keawjam RS, Upatham ES (1990) Shell morphology, reproductive anatomy and genetic patterns of three species of apple snails of the genus Pomacea in Thailand. J Med Appl Malacol 2:45–57
Kekkonen M, Hebert PD (2014) DNA barcode-based delineation of putative species: efficient start for taxonomic workflows. Mol Ecol Resour 14(4):706–715
Latombe G, Pyšek P, Jeschke JM, Blackburn TM, Bacher S, Capinha C, Costello MJ, Fernández M, Gregory RD, Hobern D, Hui C (2017) A vision for global monitoring of biological invasions. Biol Conserv 213:295–308
Lipscomb D, Platnick N, Wheeler Q (2003) The intellectual content of taxonomy: a comment on DNA taxonomy. Trends Ecol Evol 2(18):65–66
Matsukura K, Okuda M, Kubota K, Wada T (2008) Genetic divergence of the genus Pomacea (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae) distributed in Japan, and a simple molecular method to distinguish P. canaliculata and P. insularum. Appl Entomol Zool 43(4):535–540
McGeoch MA, Genovesi P, Bellingham PJ, Costello MJ, McGrannachan C, Sheppard A (2016) Prioritizing species, pathways, and sites to achieve conservation targets for biological invasion. Bio Invasions 18(2):299–314
Mochida O (1991) Spread of freshwater Pomacea snails (Pilidae, Mollusca) from Argentina to Asia. Micronesica 3(Supplement):51–62
Ng TH, Annate S, Jeratthitikul E, Sutcharit C, Limpanont Y, Panha S (2020) Disappearing apple snails (Caenogastropoda: Ampullariidae) of Thailand: a comprehensive update of their taxonomic status and distribution. J Mollus Stud. https://doi.org/10.1093/mollus/eyaa015
Ng TH, Tan SK, Ahmad A, Joshi RC, Wang WY, Tan HH, Yeo DC (2019) Not in the Least Concern: anthropogenic influences on a South-east Asian apple snail Pila scutata (Ampullariidae). Oryx 53(2):230–238
Patterson DJ, Cooper J, Kirk PM, Pyle RL, Remsen DP (2010) Names are key to the big new biology. Trends Ecol Evol 25(12):686–691
Pauchard A, Meyerson LA, Bacher S, Blackburn TM, Brundu G, Cadotte MW, Courchamp F, Essl F, Genovesi P, Haider S, Holmes ND (2018) Biodiversity assessments: origin matters. PLoS Biol 16(11):e2006686
Pejchar L, Mooney HA (2009) Invasive species, ecosystem services and human well-being. Trends Ecol Evol 24(9):497–504
Rama Rao S, Liew TS, Yow YY, Ratnayeke S (2018) Cryptic diversity: two morphologically similar species of invasive apple snail in Peninsular Malaysia. PLoS ONE 13(5):e0196582
Rawlings TA, Hayes KA, Cowie RH, Collins TM (2007) The identity, distribution, and impacts of non-native apple snails in the continental United States. BMC Evol Biol 7(1):97
Rubinoff D, Holland BS (2005) Between two extremes: mitochondrial DNA is neither the panacea nor the nemesis of phylogenetic and taxonomic inference. Syst Biol 54(6):952–961
Rubinoff D (2006) Utility of mitochondrial DNA barcodes in species conservation. Conserv Biol 20(4):1026–1033
Savolainen V, Cowan RS, Vogler AP, Roderick GK, Lane R (2005) Towards the encyclopedia of life: an introduction to DNA barcoding. Philos T R Soc B 360:1805–1811
Sheth BP, Thaker VS (2017) DNA barcoding and traditional taxonomy: an integrated approach for biodiversity conservation. Genome 60(7):618–628
Thaewnon-Ngiw B, Klinbunga S, Phanwichien K, Sangduen N, Lauhachinda N, Menasveta P (2004) Genetic diversity and molecular markers in introduced and Thai native apple snails (Pomacea and Pila). J Biochem Mol Biol 37(4):493–502
Turbelin AJ, Malamud BD, Francis RA (2017) Mapping the global state of invasive alien species: patterns of invasion and policy responses. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 26(1):78–92
Valdecasas AG, Williams D, Wheeler QD (2008) ‘Integrative taxonomy’then and now: a response to Dayrat (2005). Biol J Linn Soc 93(1):211–216
Vinarski MV (2020) Roots of the taxonomic impediment: Is the “integrativeness” a remedy? Integr Zool 15(1):2–15
Will KW, Mishler BD, Wheeler QD (2005) The perils of DNA barcoding and the need for integrative taxonomy. Syst Biol 54(5):844–851
Yang QQ, Qian ZX, Ye ZH, Zhou AN, Zhao XX, Zhang PJ, Liu GF, Yu XP (2020) Widespread mislabeling of nonnative apple snails (Ampullariidae: Pomacea) as native field snails (Viviparidae: Cipangopaludina) on the Chinese food markets. Aquaculture. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2020.735756
Yang QQ, Yu XP (2019) A new species of apple snail in the genus Pomacea (Gastropoda: Caenogastropoda: Ampullariidae). Zool Stud 58:e13. https://doi.org/10.6620/ZS.2019.58-13
Yang QQ, Liu SW, He C, Yu XP (2018) Distribution and the origin of invasive apple snails, Pomacea canaliculata and P. maculata (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae) in China. Sci Rep 8(1):1185
Yang Q, Liu S, He C, Cowie RH, Yu X, Hayes KA (2019) Invisible apple snail invasions: importance of continued vigilance and rigorous taxonomic assessments. Pest Manag Sci 75(5):1277–1286
Yusa Y, Hirayae K (1998) Amplification of DNA fragments of the golden apple snail Pomacea canaliculata (Lamarck) using random primers. Kyushu Pl Prot Res 44:53–55
Yusa Y, Wada T (1999) Impact of the introduction of apple snails and their control in Japan, Naga. ICLARM Quart 22(3):9–13
Acknowledgements
I am thankful for the numerous discussions of this manuscript and the ideas for it with Keiichiro Matsukura, Robert Cowie, Norine Yeung, and Jaynee Kim. Norine Yeung and Caroline Owens helped with some of the lab work for this study, and they along with Jaynee Kim, Christopher Hobbs, Tricia Goulding, John Slapcinsky, and Kelli DeLeon contributed substantially to improving early drafts of this manuscript. This study was supported in part by NSF award DEB- 0949061 to Robert Cowie, Kenneth Hayes, Ellen Strong and Silvana Thiengo. This is contribution number 11211 of the University of Hawaii School of Ocean and Earth Sciences.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hayes, K.A. Taxonomic shortcuts lead to long delays in species discovery, delineation, and identification. Biol Invasions 23, 1285–1292 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-020-02438-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-020-02438-8