Abstract
The seismicity of Grahamstown, in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa, for the years between 1820 and 1936 is investigated with recourse to contemporaneous documentary sources, leading to the development of a seismic history incorporating consideration of the broader geo-political context. Individual studies of five regional events that were felt in Grahamstown during that period, and of one that was not, are presented. Each study includes the development of a full set of intensity data points, which are used to determine reappraised epicentral locations and magnitudes, some of which differ significantly from previously listed parameters. The results thus obtained highlight the value of seeking out additional contemporary sources from different language groups when revisiting the source parameters of earthquakes for which no or only very limited instrumental information is available.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Note that the Gutenberg and Richter (1956) relation uses 2/3 as the slope coefficient, and the epicentral intensity, \(\hbox {I}_{0}\). The approximation to 0.66 and the assumption of equivalence between the maximum observed intensity \(\hbox {I}_{\max }\) and \(\hbox {I}_{0}\) are due to Fernández and Guzmán (1979).
References
Sources
Anglo-African, The (1867a) Grahamstown. Saturday, October 19, 1867, XXVI, no.853
Anglo-African, The (1867b) Grahamstown. Saturday, October 26, 1867, XXVI, no.845 [sic]
Anonymous (1861) Kafir essays and other pieces with an English Translation. Printed at the office of “The Anglo-African”, Grahamstown, 80 pp
Appleyard JW (1850) The Kafir language: comprising a sketch of its history: which includes a general classification of South African dialects, ethnographical & geographical remarks upon its nature and a grammar. Wesleyan Missionary Society, King William’s Town, 390 pp
Ayliff J (1821–1830) The Journal of John Ayliff, I: 1821–1830. Edited by Peter Hinchliff, 1971, Rhodes University, The Graham’s Town Series, 1. Balkema, Cape Town, 130 pp
Binnington Boyce W (1875) Memoir of the Rev. William Shaw. Edited by his oldest surviving friend W.B.B., Wesleyan Conference Office, London, 463 pp
Burger, De (1932) Cape Town. Wednesday, August 10, 1932
Butler J (1876–1879) “Jim’s Journal”: the diary of James Butler. Edited by Jane Garner, 1996, Rhodes University, Grahamstown, 14, Witwatersrand University Press, 330 pp
Campbell J (1815) Travels in South Africa undertaken at the request of the Missionary Society, Third edition, reprint by C. Struik, Cape Town, 1974, 400 pp
Cape and Natal News, The (1864) London. 25 April 1864, p 131
Cape and Natal News, The (1867a) London. 23 November 1867, IX, 181, p 340
Cape and Natal News, The (1867b) London. 23 December 1867, IX, 182, 372–373
Cape Argus, The (1864a) Cape Town. Saturday, February 27, 1864
Cape Argus, The (1864b) Cape Town. Tuesday, March 8, 1864
Cape Argus, The (1867) Cape Town. Tuesday, October 22, 1867, XI, no.1659
Cape Frontier Times, The (1850a) Grahamstown. Tuesday, May 28, 1850, no.522
Cape Frontier Times, The (1850b) Grahamstown. Tuesday, June 4, 1850, no.523
Cape Frontier Times, The (1850c) Grahamstown. Tuesday, June 18, 1850, no.525
Cape Frontier Times, The (1850d) Grahamstown. Tuesday, June 25, 1850, no.526
Cape Frontier Times, The (1864) Grahamstown. 19 February to 18 March 1864 (no information on the 24 February 1864 earthquake)
Cape Mercantile Advertiser, The (1864) Cape Town. 24 February to 14 March 1864 (no information on the 24 February 1864 earthquake)
Cape Mercury, The (1895) King William’s Town. Saturday, April 27, 1895, XXXIII, no.2697
Cape Mercury, The (1932a) King William’s Town. Tuesday, August 9, 1932, LXIX, no.11834
Cape Mercury, The (1932b) King William’s Town. Wednesday, August 10, 1932, LXIX, no.11835
Cape Mercury, The (1932c) King William’s Town. Thursday, August 11, 1932, LXIX, no.11836
Cape Standard, The (1867a) Cape Town. Thursday, October 17, 1867, II, no.283
Cape Standard, The (1867b) Cape Town. Saturday, October 19, 1867, II, no.284
Cape Standard, The (1867c) Cape Town. Thursday, October 24, 1867, II, no.286
Cape Times, The (1932) Cape Town. Wednesday, August 10, 1932
Cape Town Mail, The (1850) Cape Town. Saturday, June 1, 1850, no.484
Centilivres Chase J (1843) The Cape of Good Hope and the Eastern Province of Algoa Bay etc. etc. with statistics of the colony. London, 338 pp
Eastern Province Herald and Port Elizabeth Commercial News, The (1932) Port Elizabeth. Wednesday, August 10, 1932, no.191
Eastern Province Herald and Port Elizabeth Commercial News, The (1933) Port Elizabeth. Tuesday, February 28, 1933
Eastern Province Herald, The (1850a) Port Elizabeth. Saturday, May 25, 1850, no.263
Eastern Province Herald, The (1850b) Port Elizabeth. Saturday, June 1, 1850, no.264
Eastern Province Herald, The (1850c) Port Elizabeth. Saturday, June 8, 1850, no.265
Eastern Province Herald, The (1864) Port Elizabeth. Friday, February 26, 1864, XIII, no.997
Eastern Province Herald, The (1867) Port Elizabeth. Friday, October 18, 1867, no.1335
Friend of the Sovereignity and Bloemfontein Gazette (1850) Bloemfontein. Monday, June 10, 1850
George Advertiser, The (1867) George. Thursday, 31 October, 1867
Godlonton R (1842) Sketches of the Eastern Districts of the Cape of Good Hope as they are in 1842. Compiled by the Editor of the “Graham’s Town Journal”, with a view to assist the emigrant and to serve as a Hand Book for Travellers. Graham’s Town, printed and published at the office of the “Graham’s Town Journal” 128 pp
Graaff-Reinet Herald, The (1864) Graaff-Reinet. Wednesday, February 24, 1864, XII, no.818
Graaff-Reinet Herald, The (1867) Graaff-Reinet. Wednesday, October 23, 1867, no.1200
Grahamstown Journal, The (1850a) Grahamstown. Saturday, May 25, 1850, no.963
Grahamstown Journal, The (1850b) Grahamstown. Saturday, June 1, 1850, no.964
Grahamstown Journal, The (1850c) Grahamstown. Saturday, June 15, 1850, no.966
Grahamstown Journal, The (1850d) Grahamstown. Saturday, June 22, 1850, no.967
Grahamstown Journal, The (1850e) Grahamstown. Saturday, July 6, 1850, no.969
Great Eastern, The (1864) Grahamstown. Saturday, February 27, 1864, I, no.12
Great Eastern, The (1867a) Grahamstown. Thursday, October 17, 1867, VIII, no.579
Great Eastern, The (1867b) Grahamstown. Saturday, October 19, 1867, VIII, no.580
Great Eastern, The (1867c) Grahamstown. Thursday, November 5, 1867, VIII, no.587
Grocott’s Daily Mail (1932a) Grahamstown. Tuesday, August 9, 1932, no.11,656
Grocott’s Daily Mail (1932b) Grahamstown. Wednesday, August 10, 1932, no.11,657
Grocott’s Daily Mail (1932c) Grahamstown. Thursday, August 11, 1932, no.11,658
Grocott’s Penny Mail (1895) Grahamstown. Friday, April 19, 1895
Hattersley AF (1938) Pietermaritzburg panorama: a survey of one hundred years of an African city. Pietermaritzburg, 126 pp
Journal, The (1864) Grahamstown. 23 February to 11 March 1864 (no information on the 24 February 1864 earthquake)
Journal, The (1867a) Grahamstown. Wednesday, October 16, 1867, no.2304
Journal, The (1867b) Grahamstown. Friday, October 18, 1867, no.2305
Journal, The (1895a) Grahamstown. Monday, April 15, 1895
Journal, The (1895b) Grahamstown. Monday, April 22, 1895
Kaapsche Grensblad (1850a) Grahamstown. Saturday, May 25, 1850
Kaapsche Grensblad (1850b) Grahamstown. Saturday, June 1, 1850
Kaapsche Grensblad (1850c) Grahamstown. Saturday, June 8, 1850
Kaapsche Grensblad (1850d) Grahamstown. Saturday, July 6, 1850
King William’s Town Gazette and Kaffrarian Banner (1864) King William’s Town. Thursday, March 3, 1864, VII, no.533
King William’s Town Gazette and Kaffrarian Banner (1867) King William’s Town. Wednesday, November 6, 1867, X, no.1125
McLaren J (1984) A new concise Xhosa-English dictionary [revised by Bennie WG and Jolobe JJR]. Maskew-Miller Longman, Cape Town. 194 pp
Midland News and Karroo Farmer, The (1895) Cradock. Tuesday, April 16, 1895, VIII, no.462
Midland News and Karroo Farmer, The (1932) Cradock. Thursday, August 11, 1932, 41st year
Natal Courier and Pietermaritzburg Advertiser, The (1864) Pietermaritzburg. 24 February to 11 March 1864 (no information on the 24 February 1864 earthquake)
Natal Mercury, The (1864) Durban. 26 February to 15 March 1864 (no information on the 24 February 1864 earthquake)
Natal Witness, The (1850) Pietermaritzburg. Friday, June 28, 1850
Natal Witness, The (1864) Pietermaritzburg. 24 February to 15 March 1864 (no information on the 24 February 1864 earthquake)
Pigot S (1819–1821) The Journals of Sophia Pigot. Edited by Margaret Rainier, 1974, Rhodes University, The Graham’s Town Series, 3. Balkema, Cape Town, 172 pp
Port Elizabeth Mercury, The (1850a) Port Elizabeth. Tuesday, May 28, 1850, no.13
Port Elizabeth Mercury, The (1850b) Port Elizabeth. Tuesday, June 4, 1850, no.14
Port Elizabeth Telegraph and Eastern Province Standard (1895) Port Elizabeth. Thursday, April 18, 1895, Supplement
Port Elizabeth Telegraph (1850) Port Elizabeth. Thursday, May 23, 1850, II, no.90
Pringle T (1835) Narrative of a residence in South Africa. Edward Moxon, London, 356 pp
Shaw W (1820–1829) The Journal of William Shaw. Edited by W.D. Hammond-Tooke, 1972, Rhodes University, The Graham’s Town Series, 2. Balkema, Cape Town, 220 pp
Shone T (1850–1851) Journals. Manuscript 10,763(1), Cory Library, Grahamstown. Partially edited in: The Albany journals of Thomas Shone, Rhodes University, The Graham’s Town Series, 12, Balkema, Cape Town, 200 pp
South African Advertiser and Mail, The (1864) Cape Town. Saturday, February 27, 1864
South African Advertiser and Mail, The (1867) Cape Town. Saturday, October 19, 1867, XLV, no.5930
Thompson G (1822) Travels and adventures in Southern Africa, by George Thompson, eight years resident at the Cape, comprising a view of the present state of the Cape Colony. Edited with notes by Vernon S. Forbes, 1967, The Van Riebeeck Society. Cape Town, Part 1, 187 pp
Tyler J (1891) Forty Years among the Zulus. Boston and Chicago, 300 pp
UK National Archives (1658–1974) Record of local bodies and other colonial miscellanea, Cape Colony, CO 53 [1658-1974], including newspapers printed in South Africa. Kew Gardens
Volksblad, Het (1864) Cape Town, 25 February to 10 March 1864 (no information on the 24 February 1864 earthquake)
Volksblad, Het (1867) Cape Town. Thursday, October 24, 1867
Zuid Afrikaan, De (1850a) Cape Town. Monday, May 27, 1850
Zuid Afrikaan, De (1850b) Cape Town. Thursday, May 30, 1850
Zuid Afrikaan, De (1850c) Cape Town. Monday, June 10, 1850
Zuid Afrikaan, De (1850d) Cape Town. Monday, June 24, 1850
Zuid Afrikaan, De (1864a) Cape Town. Monday, February 29, 1864
Zuid Afrikaan, De (1864b) Cape Town. Thursday, March 3, 1864
Zuid Afrikaan, De (1864c) Cape Town. Monday, March 7, 1864
Zuid Afrikaan, De (1867) Cape Town. Thursday, October 24, 1867
Modern studies
Ambraseys NN (2004) Three little known early earthquakes in India. Curr Sci 86(4):506–508
Ambraseys NN, Adams RD (1991) Reappraisal of major African Earthquakes, South of \(20^{\circ }\text{ N }\), 1900–1930. Nat Hazards 4:389–419
Bakun WH, Wentworth CM (1997) Estimating earthquake location and magnitude from seismic intensity data. Bull Seismol Soc Am 87(6):1502–1521
Bergh JS, Visagie JC (1985) The Eastern Cape Frontier Zone, 1660–1980: a cartographic guide for historical research. Butterworths, Durban, 84 pp
Bommer JJ, Coppersmith KJ, Coppersmith RT, Hanson KL, Mangongolo A, Neveling J, Rathje EM, Rodriguez-Marek A, Scherbaum F, Stafford PJ, Strasser FO (2013a) A SSHAC Level 3 Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Analysis for a New-Build Nuclear Site in South Africa. Earthq Spectra. doi:10.1193/060913EQS145M
Bommer JJ, Coppermsith KJ, Hattingh E, Nel AP (2013b) An application of the SSHAC Level 3 process to the probabilistic seismic hazard assessment for the Thyspunt nuclear site in South Africa. In: Proceedings of the 22nd international conference on structural mechanics in reactor technology (SMiRT22). San Francisco, August 18–23
Brandt MBC, Bejaichund M, Kgaswane EM, Hattingh E, Roblin DLR (2005) Seismic history of Southern Africa. Seismological Series of the Council for Geosciences no.37, Pretoria, 32 pp
Bud-M’Belle I (1903) Kafir scholar’s companion. Lovedale Missionary Press, South Africa, 181 pp
De Klerk WJ, du Read JS (1988) An account of historical seismic activity in southern Africa with emphasis on the southern and eastern Cape. Report, Albany Museum, Grahamstown, 82 pp
Eve J (2003) A literary guide to the Eastern Cape. Double Storey Books, Cape Town, 402 pp
Fernández LM, Guzmán JA (1979) Seismic history of Southern Africa. Seismological Series, 9, Geological Survey of South Africa, 22 pp
Finsen WS (1950) The geographical distribution of some South African earthquakes. Circular No. 110, Union Observatory, Johannesburg, pp 457–472
Gasperini P, Bernardini F, Valensise G, Boschi E (1999) Defining seismogenic sources from historical earthquake felt reports. Bull Seismol Soc Am 89(1):94–110
Gutenberg B, Richter CF (1956) Seismicity of the earth and associated phenomena. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Japha D, Japha V, Le Grange L, Todeschini F (1993) Mission settlements in South Africa: a report on their historical background and prospects for conservation. South Africa Department of Environment Affairs, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, 97 pp +ill
Krüger B (1966) The pear tree blossoms. A history of the Moravian Mission Stations in South Africa 1737–1869. Genadendal, 335 pp
Letcher V (2002) “Five Years in Kaffirland”: Harriet Ward, Frederick I’Ons and nineteenth century Ways of Looking at South Africa. English in Africa, n. 1, May 2002, pp 5–25
Midzi V, Bommer JJ, Strasser FO, Albini P, Zulu BS, Prasad K, Flint NS (2013) An intensity database for earthquakes in South Africa from 1912 to 2011. J Seismol 17:1183–1205. doi:10.1007/s10950-013-9387-y
Musson RMW, Cecić I (2002) Macroseismology. In: Lee WHK, Kanamori H, Jennings PC, Kisslinger C (eds) International handbook of earthquake and engineering seismology. Int Geophys 81: Part A 49: 807–822
Musson RMW (2009) MEEP 2.0 User Guide. Earth Hazards and Systems Programme Open Report OR/09/045, British Geological Survey, 16 pp
Richter CF (1958) Elementary seismology. W.H Freeman, San Francisco
Saunders I, Brandt M, Steyn J, Roblin D, Kijko A (2008) The South African National Seismograph Network. Seismol Res Lett 79(2):203–210
Strasser FO, Albini P, Flint NS, Beauval C (2013a) 20th century seismicity of the Koffiefontein region (Free State, South Africa): Consistent determination of earthquake catalogue parameters from mixed data types. Geophys J Int, submitted
Strasser FO, Beauval C, Albini P (2013b) Comparative study of third-generation macroseismic analysis techniques. Bull Seismol Soc Am, submitted
Switzer L, Switzer D (1979) The Black Press in South Africa and Lesotho. A descriptive bibliographic guide to African, Coloured and Indian newspapers, newsletters and magazines 1836–1976. G. K. Hall & Co., Boston
Theron JN (1974) The seismic history of the south-western Cape Province. In: The earthquake of 29 September 1969 in the south-western Cape Province, South Africa, Seism. Ser. Geol. Survey S. Africa, 14, 53 pp
Wilson M, Thompson L (1969) The Oxford History of South Africa: South Africa to 1870, vol I. Oxford, xxiii pp, Clarendon, 500 pp
Acknowledgments
The work presented in this paper was conducted as a part of the PSHA project for the Thyspunt site conducted by the Council for Geoscience under contract from Eskom, the South African state-owned energy utility. The contributions of individuals from both CGS and Eskom in supporting this work are too numerous for mention herein, but we note particular thanks to Erna Hattingh, Project Manager from the CGS Nuclear Geo-hazard Group, and André P Nel from Eskom Nuclear Sites for their support for the work and their appreciation of the value of extending the earthquake record for this region of South Africa. Sincere thanks are also due to the project PTI, Julian Bommer, and the SSC TI Lead, Kevin Coppersmith, for their continued guidance and support. Moreover, the authors are extremely grateful to Vindina Mitha, who accompanied P.A. in Eastern Cape repositories and shared the labours of historical field-work in a frozen Karoo; the staff of the Cory Library for Historical Research, at Rhodes University, Grahamstown, for their warm welcome and valuable support; Linda Akromah, for her translation of the Xhosa documents, and valuable feedback on terminology issues; Refilwe Shelembe, for additional thoughtful feedback on these issues, and a thorough check of the draft manuscript; Andrea Rovida for the painstaking effort to prepare all the maps in this paper; and Céline Beauval, for guidance in the determination of the source parameters. The work presented herein also greatly benefited from lively discussions with, and thoughtful comments from, various participants of the Thyspunt PSHA project.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Disclaimer As explained in the text, the nature of the work presented herein requires the use of sources that are contemporary to the earthquakes studied. These sources may, in some instances, employ terminology or voice views that would be unacceptable in a modern context. Their inclusion in the present study only reflects their use in sources used for assessing the macroseimic effects of the earthquakes under investigation, and by no means constitutes an endorsement, by the authors or their institutions, of aforementioned terminology and views. Wherever possible, modern equivalents have been used, however for reasons of traceability geographic locations and titles have been left in their original form.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Albini, P., Strasser, F.O. & Flint, N.S. Earthquakes from 1820 to 1936 in Grahamstown and surroundings (Eastern Cape Province, South Africa). Bull Earthquake Eng 12, 45–78 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10518-013-9562-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10518-013-9562-0