Skip to main content
Log in

Chinese “archival” stories of lifecycle management: tracing three major reformative events from 1933 to 2010

  • Original Paper
  • Published:
Archival Science Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

In the American style records lifecycle model, its main entity is represented by the concept of records. However, the Chinese way of describing the same entity and its movement utilizes two concepts, (both) WenJian and DangAn, which cannot be directly matched to “records” and “archives.” This historical study tells the stories of three major reformative events in WenJian and DangAn management that occurred in China from 1933 to 2010: the “WenShu–DangAn Reform” in the 1930s, a reformative trend based on an idea called “Integrating WenJian and DangAn Management” that emerged during the 1980s, and a major reformative event pushing for “Whole-process Management” that was initiated in the 2000s. The article traces the background, processes, and outcomes and implications of each reformative event, using the WenJian–DangAn lifecycle as a background “framing device” to help readers to understand the interconnectedness of the three stories. As a conclusion, all three reformative events aimed to promote the coordination between WenJian and DangAn work over the WenJian–DangAn lifecycle (though not necessarily across the full lifecycle), but each event—in interaction with the historical conditions of their period—focused on coordinating the parts/aspects/segments that they considered as the most important, urgent, or practical at the time. Collectively, these stories of WenJian–DangAn lifecycle management can illuminate some of the achievements and struggles of the Chinese DangAn community across 80 years of “archival” history.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Chen Z 陈兆祦 (1987) 再论档案的定义——兼论文件的定义和运动周期问题. [A second discussion on the definition of DangAn: also examining the definition of WenJian and its movement cycle issues]. Arch Sci Bull 02:23–27. http://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.1987.02.006

  • DangAn Unit of the 183 Company 一八三厂档案科 (1991) 谈我厂文书处理和文书档案工作一体化管理. [On the integration of WenJian and DangAn work in my company]. Aviat Arch 05:47–49

    Google Scholar 

  • Dong D 董丹青 (1992) 从“连锁法”看“一体化”. [Examining the “Integration of WenJian and DangAn” from the “Method of Linking WenShu and DangAn”]. Zhejiang Arch 06:22–23. http://doi.org/10.16033/j.cnki.33-1055/g2.1992.06.014

  • Feng H 冯惠玲 (2001a) 档案学概论. [On DangAn science]. 中国人民大学出版社 Remin University of China Press, Beijing

  • Feng H 冯惠玲 (2001b) 电子文件管理教程. [Textbook of electronic records management]. 中国人民大学出版社 Remin University of China Press, Beijing

  • Feng H 冯汉国, Chen X 陈肖静 (1991) 关于文书、档案管理一体化的思考. [Thoughts on integrating the management of WenShu and DangAn]. J Yangzhou Norm Coll (Soc Sci Vers) 04:120–124. http://doi.org/10.19411/j.cnki.1007-7030.1991.04.024

  • Feng H 冯惠玲, Liu Y 刘越男 (2011) 电子文件管理国家战略. [National Strategy for Electronic Records Management]. 中国人民大学出版社 Renmin University of China Press, Beijing

  • Feng H 冯惠玲, Zhao G 赵国俊 (2009) 中国电子文件管理:问题与对策. [Electronic records management in China: problems and solutions]. 中国人民大学出版社 Renmin University of China Press, Beijing

  • Feng H 冯惠玲, Zhao G 赵国俊, Liu Y 刘越男, An X 安小米, Hou W 侯卫真, Qian Y 钱毅, Zhang N 张宁 (2006) 电子文件管理国家战略刍议. [On the National Strategy for Electronic Records Management]. Arch Sci Bull 03:4–8. https://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.2006.03.002

  • Fu R 傅荣校 (2005) 南京国民政府前期(1928—1937年)行政机制与行政能力研究. [Study on the administrative system and ability of the Nanjing national government at its early stages (from 1928 to 1937)]. Ph.D. thesis, ZJU

  • Gan N 甘乃光 (1934) 文书档案连锁办法之试验. [Experiments on the Method of Linking Wenshu and Dangan]. Adm Effic 01(10):428

  • Gan N 甘乃光 (1937) 文书档案改革运动的回顾与展望. [A review and outlook of the WenShu-DangAn Reform Movement]. In:《档案学通讯》杂志社 Archives Science Bulletin Journal Press (ed) 档案学经典著作, 第二卷 [Classics of DangAn science, volume II]. 上海世界图书出版公司 Shanghai World Publishing, Shanghai, pp 93–110

  • General Office of the State Council (GOSC) of China, General Office of the CPC (GOCPC) (2009) 电子文件管理暂行办法. [Interim measures for electronic records management]. http://en.pkulaw.cn/display.aspx?cgid=a1f37535661b2e35bdfb&lib=law. Accessed 1 Dec 2019

  • He L 何鲁成 (1938) 档案管理与整理. [The arrangement and management of DangAn]. In:《档案学通讯》杂志社 Archives Science Bulletin Journal Press (ed) 档案学经典著作, 第二卷 [Classics of DangAn science, volume II]. 上海世界图书出版公司 Shanghai World Publishing, Shanghai, pp 91–334

  • He J 何嘉荪 (1996a) 档案概念以“非现行性”为基础合理吗?——关于档案概念外延的探讨之一. [Is basing the concept of DangAn on its “non-current” nature appropriate? An initial discussion on the scope of the concept of DangAn]. Arch Sci Bull 02:25–29. https://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.1996.02.005

  • He J 何嘉荪 (1996b) “文档一体化”路在何方? ——关于档案概念外延的讨论之二. [Where is the “Integration of WenJian and DangAn” going? A second discussion on the scope of the concept of DangAn]. Arch Sci Bull 06:17–21. http://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.1996.06.009

  • He J 何嘉荪 (1998) 立卷改革与相关基础理论问题——从四川攀枝花市研制的文档管理系统说起. [Reform on filing and related basic theoretical issues——A discussion about the WenJian-DangAn management system developed by Panzhihua City, Sichuan]. Arch Sci Bull 05:6–10 + 5. https://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.1998.05.002

  • Hou H 侯红骊 (1998) 机关文档一体化管理模式初探. [A preliminary study on the integrated management mode of WenJian and DangAn in organizations]. Secr Companion 04:3–4

  • Huang X 黄霄羽 (2002) 文件、档案一体化管理的科学含义. [The scientific meanings of the integration of WenJian and DangAn management]. Arch Sci Bull 03:29–32. https://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.2002.03.008

  • Jian D 蹇敦品, Xia G 夏国祥 (1991) 文书、档案工作一体化管理之研究. [Study on the integrated management of WenShu and DangAn work]. HuNan Arch 01:16–18

  • Jin H 金慧珠, Wang Z 王志才, Wang J 王俭, Liang W 梁伟 (1989) 文件登记、立卷、著录三位一体. [The trinity of registration, “filing,” and assigning metadata of WenJian]. Arch Work 04:11–13

  • Li C 李财富 (1997) 文书、档案工作一体化的制约因素及对策. [The restrictive factors and countermeasures of the integration of WenJian and DangAn work]. Sichuan Arch 05:8–11

  • Liu X 刘旭刚, Liu P 刘鹏云, Han X 韩晓麟 (1998) 计算机文档一体化管理之我见. [Opinions on the integration of WenJian and DangAn management by computers]. Arch Sci Bull 03:40–41. http://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.1998.03.014

  • Liu Y 刘越男 (2006) 电子文件全程管理——对纸质文档一体化管理的继承和发展. [Whole-process Management of electronic records—Inheritance and development of the integration of paper-based WenJian and DangAn]. Zhejiang Arch 03:19–21. http://doi.org/10.16033/j.cnki.33-1055/g2.2006.03.008

  • Lü J 吕军 (1995) 文书档案连锁法与文书、档案工作一体化管理之比较研究. [A comparative study of the Method of Linking WenShu and DangAn and the integration of WenShu and DangAn management]. Arch Constr 02:31–33

  • Luo Y 罗永平 (1998) 文档一体化问题探析. [An analysis of the integration of WenJian and DangAn work]. Guizhou Arch 06:9–11

  • Ma L 马林青 (2015) 文书档案连锁法的重新发现:一场登记制的革新实验. [The rediscovery of the Method of Linking WenShu and DangAn: an experiment on the reform of the registry system]. Arch Sci Bull 01:31–34. http://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.2015.01.010

  • Qi L 齐鲁人 (1998) 关于文档一体化管理的整体构想. [The overall conception of the integration of WenJian and DangAn work]. Shaanxi Arch 06:10–12

  • Qin F 覃凤琴 (2010) 论甘乃光与文书档案改革运动. [On Gan Naiguang and the WenShu-DangAn Reform]. Arch Manag 01:64–67. http://doi.org/10.15950/j.cnki.1005-9458.2010.01.025

  • Qiu Z 邱祖铭 (1934) 档案编制问题之检讨. [Review of DangAn filing]. Adm Effic 08:327–329

  • Qu Y 屈一平 (2011) 中国规划电子文件管理. [China’s plans for electronic records management]. Outlook 29:36–37

  • Schwandt TA (2007) The SAGE dictionary of qualitative inquiry. SAGE, Thousand Oaks, pp 75–76. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781412986281

    Book  Google Scholar 

  • State Council of China (1956) 国务院关于加强国家档案工作的决定. [Decision on strengthening the nation’s DangAn work by the State Council]. http://www.saac.gov.cn/daj/gwywj/201112/5e7bb6ac3d60489f828732a781cd1daf.shtml. Accessed 5 Dec 2019

  • State Education Commission (SEC), National Archives Administration of China (NAAC) (1985) 关于发展和改革档案学教育的几点意见. [Opinions on the Development and Reformation of DangAn Education]

  • Su Z 苏志成 (1999) 谈文件登记、立卷、著录一体化管理. [On the integrated management of registration, “filing,” and assigning metadata of WenJian]. Arch Sci Bull 05:55–56

  • Sun B 孙斌 (1993) 文书档案计算机管理一体化. [Integration of WenShu and DangAn management using computer systems]. Arch Sci Study S1:35

  • Tan C 谭琤培 (2003) 文件与档案关系研究分歧探源. [Exploring the source of disagreements among studies on the relationship between WenJian and DangAn]. Arch Sci Study 01:2–5. http://doi.org/10.16065/j.cnki.issn1002-1620.2003.01.001

  • Wang K 汪孔德 (1994) 试论机关文件、档案一体化管理. [On the integrated management of government WenJian and DangAn]. J of Chizhou University 03:73–76

  • Wu B 吴宝康 (1982) 档案学理论与历史初探. [On the theory and history of DangAn Science]. Department of DangAn, Renmin University of China [internal publication], Beijing

  • Wu B 吴宝康 (1993) “文件生命周期理论”问题引起的若干思考. [Thoughts on the Theory of the Records Lifecycle]. Arch Sci Bull 01:9–12. http://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.1993.01.002

  • Xie SL 谢丽 (2013) National strategy for digital records: comparing the approaches of Canada and China. Int J Info Manag 33(4):697–701. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2013.02.004

  • Xie SL 谢丽 (2015) Developing a national regulation on electronic records management: the story of China. Archives and Records Association (UK and Ireland) annual conference, Dublin, Ireland, 26–28 August 2015

  • Xie SL 谢丽, Feng H 冯惠玲, Ma L 马林青 (2017) Records and farmer workers – a unique Chinese case. Arch Rec 40(3):259–280. http://doi.org/10.1080/23257962.2017.1392936

  • Xu J 许晶晶 (2011) 论地方电子文件管理职责的有效把握——从与电子文件管理国家战略辩证关系的视角. [On the responsibilities of electronic records management on the local government level: from the perspective of the dialectical relationship with the National Strategy for Electronic Records Management]. Beijing Arch 09:30–32

  • Xu P 徐萍, Hou S 侯生军 (1997) 谈谈文档一体化理论指导下的文件工作与档案工作实践. [Discussion on the practice of WenJian and DangAn work under the guidance of the Idea of Integrating WenJian and DangAn]. Shandong Arch 04:23–24

  • Yang X 杨霞 (2000) 论文件的概念. [A discussion on the concept of WenJian]. Arch Sci Bull 01:24–26. http://doi.org/10.16113/j.cnki.daxtx.2000.01.008

  • Yu Y 于英香, Xiao C 肖春红, Han Z 韩震 (2016) “区域—国家”电子文件管理整合模型构建. [Construction of a "regional-national" electronic records management integration model]. Arch Sci Study 03:94–97. https://doi.org/10.16065/j.cnki.issn1002-1620.2016.03.019

  • Zeng L 曾兰兰 (1999) 机关文件与档案一体化管理. [Integrated management of WenJian and DangAn in organizations]. J of Hengyang Norm Univ 02:140–142. http://doi.org/10.13914/j.cnki.cn43-1453/z.1999.02.047

  • Zhang H 张会超 (2011) 文书档案连锁法的重新审视. [An re-examination of the Method of Linking WenShu and DangAn]. Arch Sci Study 06:85–89. http://doi.org/10.16065/j.cnki.issn1002-1620.2011.06.022

  • Zhang Z 张照余 (2006) 文件与档案关系问题评论——兼与陈兆祦、刘东斌先生探讨. [Comments on the relationship between WenJian and DangAn—A discussion with misters Zhaowu Chen and Dongbin Liu]. Arch Manag 05:31–34. http://doi.org/10.15950/j.cnki.1005-9458.2006.05.011

  • Zhou X 周雪恒 (1994) 中国档案事业史. [The history of the Chinese DangAn undertaking]. 中国人民大学出版社 Renmin University of China Press, Beijing

Download references

Acknowledgements

This work was funded by the Fundamental Research Funds for Central Universities and the Research Funds of Renmin University of China (Grant Reference: 15XNL032). The authors would like to thank Professor Sherry L. Xie for her valuable advice during the writing process and Yanli Zhao for her help in preparing this manuscript. They also thank the anonymous peer reviewers of this paper whose helpful comments greatly improved the article.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Ruohua Han.

Additional information

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Ma, L., Han, R. Chinese “archival” stories of lifecycle management: tracing three major reformative events from 1933 to 2010. Arch Sci 21, 117–137 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-020-09348-7

Download citation

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-020-09348-7

Keywords

Navigation