Abstract
Recent work has stressed the importance of pluralism in archival education, practice, and research. By examining the promises and perils of pluralism as it has been constructed in another field—religion—this article analyzes, expands, and delineates the notion of archival pluralism in a way that helps form the conceptual foundation for further work on pluralistic approaches to archival education, theory and practice. More specifically, it argues that archival pluralism can learn from four basic principles of religious pluralism—energetic engagement, understanding, strengthened commitment, and dialog—while at the same time avoiding four major perils: claims of universality, inattention to power, silencing dissent, and collapsing of difference. First, this article presents a brief discourse analysis tracing the emergence and development of archival pluralism in the literature to date. Next, turning to how pluralism has been constructed in another field, this article gives a brief overview of conceptions of religious pluralism using the work of two of its most prominent American scholars as guideposts and then addresses the strengths and weaknesses of this conceptualization of pluralism in the religious sphere. Next, this article proposes how religious pluralism’s main principles and pitfalls can be adapted and applied in the realm of memory keeping in order to strengthen the conceptual framework for archival pluralism. It concludes by suggesting aspects of a research agenda for future work in archival pluralism.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
AERI (undated) Archival concepts: an AERI curriculum development initiative. http://www.archivalconcepts.net/tikiwiki/tiki-login_scr.php. Accessed 25 Sep 2012
AERI (2012) Building the future of archival education and research. http://aeri.gseis.ucla.edu/index.htm. Accessed 24 Sep 2012
Bastian J (2003) Owning memory: how a Caribbean community lost its archives and found its history. Libraries Unlimited, Westport, CT
Brown R (1991–1992) Records acquisition strategy and its theoretical foundation: the case for a concept of archival hermeneutics. Archivaria 33:34–56
Carter R (2006) Of things said and unsaid: power, archival silences, and power in silence. Archivaria 61:215–233
Caswell M (2010) Khmer Rouge archives: accountability, truth and memory in Cambodia. Arch Sci 10:25–44
Caswell M, Broman G, Kirmer J, Martin L, Sowry N (2012) Implementing a social justice framework in the introductory curriculum: lessons from both sides of the classroom. InterActions. Accepted for publication, forthcoming
Christen K (2011) Opening archives: respectful repatriation. Am Arch 74:185–210
Cook T (1992) Mind over matter: towards a new theory of archival appraisal. In: Craig BL (ed) The archival imagination: essays in honour of Hugh A Taylor. Association of Canadian Archivists, Ottawa, pp 38–70
Cook T (2001) Fashionable nonsense or professional rebirth: postmodernism and the practice of archives. Archivaria 51:14–35
Cordova V (2007) How it is: the native American philosophy of V.F. Cordova. In: Moore K, Peters K, Jojola T, Lacy A, Hogan L (eds) University of Arizona Press, Tucson
Cox R (2000) Closing an era. Greenwood Press, Westport, CT
Eastwood T (2002) Reflections on the goal of archival appraisal in democratic societies. Archivaria 54:59–71
Eck D (1993) 2003) Encountering God: a spiritual journey from Bozeman to Banaras. Beacon Press, Boston
Eck D (1997) Our mission. Pluralism project. http://pluralism.org/about/mission. Accessed 1 May 2012
Eck D (1997–2012) What is pluralism? Pluralism project. http://pluralism.org/pages/pluralism/what_is_pluralism. Accessed 1 May 2012
Eck D (2006a) From diversity to pluralism. http://pluralism.org/pages/pluralism/essays/from_diversity_to_pluralism. Accessed 1 May 2012
Eck D (2006b) On common ground. Columbia University Press, New York
Flinn A, Stevens M (2009) ‘It is noh mistri, wi mekin histri’. Telling our own story: independent and community archives in the UK, challenging and subverting the mainstream. In: Bastian J, Alexander B (eds) Community archives: the shaping of memory. Facet, London, pp 3–27
Flinn A, Stevens M, Shepherd E (2009) Whose memories, whose archives? Independent community archives, autonomy, and the mainstream. Arch Sci 9:71–86
Furner J (2004) Conceptual analysis: a method for understanding information as evidence, evidence as information. Arch Sci 4:233–265
Gilliland A (2000) Archival research: a “new” issue for graduate education. Am Arch 63:258–270
Gilliland A, McKemmish S (2004) Building an infrastructure for archival research. Arch Sci 4:149–197
Gilliland A, McKemmish S (2011) Pluralising the archives in the multiverse: a report on work in progress. Atlanti Rev Modern Arch Theory Pract 21:177–185
Gilroy P (2005) Postcolonial melancholia. Columbia University Press, New York
Gopalan S (1973) Outlines of Jainism. Halsted Press, New York
Harris V (2002) The archival sliver: power, memory and archives in South Africa. Arch Sci 2:63–86
Harris V (2007) Archives and justice. SAA, Chicago
Harris V (2012) Nelson Mandela, memory and the work of justice. InterActions UCLA J Edu Inf Stud 8(2):1–14
Hatang S, Harris V (2007) Archives, identity, and place: a dialogue on what it (might) mean(s) to be an African archivist. In: Archives and justice. SAA, Chicago, pp 215–235
Hurley C (2005) Parallel provenance: if these are your records, where are your stories? http://www.infotech.monash.edu.au/research/groups/rcrg/publications/parallel-provenance-combined.pdf. Accessed 2 Jan 2013
Iacovino L (2004) Multi-method interdisciplinary research in archival science: the case of recordkeeping, ethics and the law. Arch Sci 4:267–286
Interfaith Youth Core (Undated) Communicating the movement. http://www.ifyc.org/communicating-movement. Accessed 1 May 2012
James W (1909, 2011) A pluralistic universe. CreateSpace, Seattle
Ketelaar E (2001) Tacit narratives: the meanings of archives. Arch Sci 1:131–141
Klassen P, Bender C (2010) Introduction: habits of pluralism. In: Bender C, Klassen P (eds) After pluralism: reimaging religious engagement. Columbia University Press, New York, pp 1–28
Leavelle T (2010) The perils of pluralism: colonization and decolonization in American Indian religious history. In: Bender C, Klassen P (eds) After pluralism: reimaging religious engagement. Columbia University Press, New York, pp 156–177
Marty M (1995) Too bad we’re so relevant: the fundamentalism project projected. http://www.illuminos.com/mem/selectPapers/fundamentalismProject.html. Accessed 1 May 2012
Marty M (2005) When faiths collide. Blackwell, Malden, MA
Mayer D (1985) The new social history: implications for archivists. Am Arch 48:388–399
McKemmish S, Faulkhead S, Russell L (2011) Distrust in the archive: reconciling records. Arch Sci 11:211–239
Montalto N (1978) The challenge of preservation in a pluralistic society. Am Arch 41:399–404
Mookerjee S (1978) The Jaina philosophy of non-absolutism: a critical study of anekantavada. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi
Nesmith T (2002) Seeing archives: postmodernism and the changing intellectual place of archives. Am Arch 65:24–41
PACG (2011) Educating for the archival multiverse. Am Arch 74:69–101
Patel E, Meyer C (2011) The civic relevance of interfaith cooperation for colleges and universities. J College Character 12(1):1–9
Peterson B (2002) The archives and the political imaginary. In: Hamilton C, Harris V, Taylor J, Pickover M, Reid G, Saleh R (eds) Refiguring the archive. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 28–35
Pluralism Project (1997) On common ground: world religions in America. CD-ROM, Columbia University Press, New York
Punzalan R (2005) Cultural diversity and post-colonial realities: challenge of archival training in the Philippines. Arch Manuscr 33(1):289–293
Rice B (2005) Seeing the world with Aboriginal eyes: a four directional perspective on human and non-human values, cultures and relationships on Turtle Island. Aboriginal Issues Press, Winnipeg
Strong J (1995) The experience of Buddhism. Wadsworth Publishing, Belmont, CA
Upward F (1996) Structuring the records continuum—part one: postcustodial principles and properties. Arch Manuscr 22(2):268–285
Upward F, McKemmish S, Reed B (2011) Archivists and changing social and information spaces: a continuum approach to recordkeeping and archiving in online cultures. Archivaria 72:197–237
White K (2009) Meztizaje and remembering in Afro-Mexican communities of the Costa Chica: implications for archival education in Mexico. Arch Sci 9:43–55
Acknowledgments
The author wishes to thank Anne Gilliland for her important input on this paper and her tireless work on archival pluralism. Much gratitude is also due to the Institute of Museum and Library Services, funder of AERI, where many of the ideas discussed in this article were developed.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Caswell, M. On archival pluralism: what religious pluralism (and its critics) can teach us about archives. Arch Sci 13, 273–292 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-012-9197-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10502-012-9197-y