Abstract
Computerized respiratory sound analysis has recently captured the attention of researchers, and its implementation can assist physicians in the diagnosis of pulmonary pathologies. The relationship between respiratory sounds and breathing flow reveals the pathophysiology of the respiratory system and can be used as a basis for acoustical airflow estimation. Respiratory sound signals are also acoustically analysed for the detection of breath phases. Although this research area is being actively studied, the available literature has not been reviewed. This manuscript highlights the previous studies that focused on the use of computer-based acoustical techniques for the analysis of respiratory sounds and airflow. Articles related to computerized respiratory flow-sound analysis were identified through a search of the Scopus academic database, and 66 articles were ultimately selected for this systematic review. A brief overview of the subject details, auscultation sites, respiratory manoeuvres, sound parameters of interest and techniques used is provided. The findings revealed the following: (1) deterministic relationships can be established between airflow and respiratory sounds, (2) an established strong flow-sound correlation can be used for airflow estimation, (3) breath phase detection and identification without flow measuring devices remains in the infancy research stage and (4) further research needed to examine the potential of computerized respiratory sound analysis in revealing the pathophysiology of airways for future clinical implementation. This review concludes by discussing the possibilities and recommendations for further advancements in computerized acoustical flow-sound analysis.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anusha AR, Soodi AL, Kumar SP (2012) Design of low-cost hardware for lung sound acquisition and determination of inspiratory-expiratory phase using respiratory waveform. In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on computing communication and networking technologies, pp 1–5
Beck R, Rosenhouse G, Mahagnah M, Chow RM, Cugell DW, Gavriely N (2005) Measurements and theory of normal tracheal breath sounds. Ann Biomed Eng 33(10):1344–1351
Bohadana AB, Peslin R, Uffholtz H (1978) Breath sounds in the clinical assessment of airflow obstruction. Thorax 33(3):345–351
Bohadana AB, Peslin R, Ufffioltz H, Pauli G (1995) Potential for lung sound monitoring during bronchial provocation testing. Thorax 50(9):955–961
Christensen MA, Leitner E, Levy B, Sathiyamoorthy BB, Burke DT, Sisson TH (2014) Breath sounds analysis for asthma monitoring: a method for automated detection of flow events from tracheal recordings. In: Proceedings of IEEE conference on healthcare innovations and point of care technologies, pp 331–334
Chuah JS, Moussavi ZK (2000) Automated respiratory phase detection by acoustical means. In: Proceedings of conference on systems, cybernatics & informatics, pp 228–231
Ciftci K, Kahya YP (2008) Respiratory airflow estimation by time varying autoregressive modeling. In: Proceedings of IEEE conference on engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 347–350
Fischer HS, Puder LC, Wilitzki S, Usemann J, Buhrer C, Godfrey S, Schmalisch G (2016) Relationship between computerized wheeze detection and lung function parameters in young infants. Pediatr Pulmonol 51:402–410
Fiz JA, Jané R, Lozano M, Gómez R, Ruiz J (2014) Detecting unilateral phrenic paralysis by acoustic respiratory analysis. PLoS ONE 9(4):e93595
Golabbakhsh M, Moussavi Z (2004) Relationship between airflow and frequency-based features of tracheal respiratory sound. In: Proceedings of IEEE Canadian conference on electrical and computer engineering, pp 751–754
Golabbakhsh M, Moussavi Z, Aboofazeli M (2005) Respiratory flow estimation from tracheal sound by adaptive filters. In: Proceedings of IEEE conference on engineering in medicine and biology, pp 4216–4219
Gomes LL, Oliveira NV, Tauil LM, Mattos RA, Melo PL (2018) Instrumentation for respiratory flow estimation using tracheal sounds analysis: design and evaluation in measurements of respiratory cycle periods and airflow amplitude. In: Proceedings of IOP Journal of Physics: Conference series, pp 1–7
Habukawa C, Nagasaka Y, Murakami K, Takemura T (2009) High-pitched breath sounds indicate airflow limitation in asymptomatic asthmatic children. Respirology 14(3):399–403
Hossain I, Moussavi Z (2002a) Respiratory airflow estimation by acoustical means. In: Proceedings of IEEE conference on biomedical engineering society/engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 1476–1477
Hossain I, Moussavi Z (2002b) Relationship between airflow and normal lung sounds. In: Proceedings of IEEE Canadian conference on electrical and computer engineering, pp 1120–1122
Hossain I, Moussavi Z (2004) Finding the lung sound-flow relationship in normal and asthmatic subjects. In: Proceedings of IEEE conference on engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 3852–3855
Huq S, Moussavi Z (2012) Acoustic breath-phase detection using tracheal breath sounds. Med Biol Eng Comput 50(3):297–308
Jin F, Sattar F (2016) Unsupervised phase detection for respiratory sounds using improved scale-space features. In: Proceedings of IEEE international symposium on signal processing and information technology, pp 1–6
Jin F, Sattar F, Goh DYT, Loius IM (2009) A robust respiratory phase identification scheme based on a new mixing index. In: Proceedings of European signal processing conference, pp 637–641
Jin F, Sattar F, Goh DYT (2014) New approaches for spectro-temporal feature extraction with applications to respiratory sound classification. Neurocomputing 123:362–371
Korenbaum VI, Kulakov YV, Tagiltsev AA (1997) Acoustic effects in the human respiraotry system under forced expiration. Acoust Phys 43:78–86
Korenbaum VI, Tagiltsev AA, Kulakov JV, Kilin AS, Avdeeva HV, Pochekutova IA (1998) An acoustic model of noise production in the human bronchial tree under forced expiration. J Sound Vib 213:377–382
Kraman SS (1984) The relationship between airflow and lung sound amplitude in normal subjects. Chest 86(2):225–229
Kulkas A, Huupponen E, Virkkala J, Tenhunen M, Saastamoinen A, Rauhala E, Himanen SL (2009) Intelligent methods for identifying respiratory cycle phases from tracheal sound signal during sleep. Comput Biol Med 39(11):1000–1005
Kulkas A, Huupponen E, Virkkala J, Saastamoinen A, Rauhala E, Tenhunen M, Himanen SL (2010) Tracheal sound parameters of respiratory cycle phases show differences between flow-limited and normal breathing during sleep. Physiol Meas 31(3):427–438
Laënnec RTH (1819) De l’Auscultation Médiate ou Traité du Diagnostic des Maladies des Poumons et du Coeur. Brosson & Chaudé, Paris
Le Cam S, Collet C, Salzenstein F (2008) Acoustical respiratory signal analysis and phase detection. In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on acoustics, speech and signal processing, pp 3629–3632
Lessard CS, Wong WC (1986) Correlation of constant flow rate with frequency spectrum of respiratory sounds when measured at the trachea. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 33(4):461–463
Lyubimov GA, Skobeleva IM, Dyachenko AI, Strongin MM (2013) Estimation of tracheal sound intensity during forced expiration. Hum Physiol 39(1):106–113
Macgregor CA, Moussavi Z (2014) A novel expert classifier approach to pre-screening obstructive sleep apnea during wakefulness. In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 4236–4239
Manecke GR Jr, Dilger JP, Kutner LJ, Poppers PJ (1997) Auscultation revisited the waveform and spectral characteristics of breath sounds during general anesthesia. Int J Clin Monit Comput 14(4):231–240
Messner E, Hagmuller M, Swatek P, Smolle-Juttner F, Pernkopf F (2017) Respiratory airflow estimation from lung sounds based on regression. In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on acoustics, speech and signal processing, pp 1123–1127
Mondal A, Bhattacharya P, Saha G (2014) Detection of lungs status using morphological complexities of respiratory sounds. Sci World J 182938:1–9
Mondal A, Banerjee P, Tang H (2018) A novel feature extraction technique for pulmonary sound analysis based on EMD. Comput Methods Programs Biomed 159:199–209
Morillo DS, Moreno SA, Granero MAF, Jiménez AL (2013) Computerized analysis of respiratory sounds during COPD exacerbations. Comput Biol Med 43:914–921
Moussavi ZK, Leopando MT, Pasterkamp H, Rempel G (2000) Computerised acoustical respiratory phase detection without airflow measurement. Med Biol Eng Comput 38(2):198–203
Nabi FG, Sundaraj K, Lam CK, Palaniappan R, Sundaraj S (2017) Wheeze sound analysis using computer-based techniques: a systematic review. Biomed Tech 64(1):1–28
Niu J, Shi Y, Cai M, Cao Z, Wang D, Zhang Z, Zhang XD (2018) Detection of sputum by interpreting the time-frequency distribution of respiratory sound signal using image processing techniques. Bioinformatics 34:820–827
Oliveira A, Marques A (2014) Respiratory sounds in healthy people: a systematic review. Respir Med 108(4):550–570
Palaniappan R, Sundaraj K, Ahamed N, Arjunan A, Sundaraj S (2013a) Computer-based respiratory sound analysis: a systematic review. IETE Tech Rev 30(3):248–256
Palaniappan R, Sundaraj K, Ahamed NU (2013b) Machine learning in lung sound analysis: a systematic review. Biocybern Biomed Eng 33(3):129–135
Palaniappan R, Sundaraj K, Sundaraj S (2014) Artificial intelligence techniques used in respiratory sound analysis—a systematic review. Biomed Tech 59(1):7–18
Palaniappan R, Sundaraj K, Nabi FG (2015) An overview of breath phase detection—techniques & applications. J Telecommun Electron Comput Eng 10(2–7):33–36
Palaniappan R, Sundaraj K, Sundaraj S (2017) Adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system for breath phase detection and breath cycle segmentation. Comput Methods Programs Biomed 145:67–72
Parida PK, Shanmugasundaram N, Gopalakrishnan S (2016) Clinico-radiological parameters predicting early diagnosis of foreign body aspiration in children. Turkish Journal of Ear Nose and Throat 26(5):268–275
Pasterkamp H, Carson C, Daien D, Oh Y (1989) Digital respirosonography. New images of lung sounds. Chest 96:1405–1412
Pochekutova IA, Korenbaum VI (2001) Analysis of tracheal forced exiratory noise in diagnostics of bronchial obstruction. In: Proceedings of XI session of Russian acoustical society, pp 704–707
Pochekutova IA, Korenbaum VI (2013) Diagnosis of hidden bronchial obstruction using computer-assessed tracheal forced expiratory noise time. Respirology 18:501–506
Poreva A, Karplyuk Y, Makarenkova A, Makarenkov A (2015) Detection of COPD’s diagnostic signs based on polyspectral lung sounds analysis of respiratory phases. In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on electronics and nanotechnology, pp 351–355
Pramono RXA, Bowyer S, Rodriguez-Villegas E (2017) Automatic adventitious respiratory sound analysis: a systematic review. PLoS ONE 12(5):e0177926
Reyes BA, Charleston-Villalobos S, González-Camarena R, Aljama-Corrales T (2014a) Assessment of time-frequency representation techniques for thoracic sounds analysis. Comput Methods Programs Biomed 114:276–290
Reyes BA, Reljin N, Chon KH (2014b) Tracheal sounds acquisition using smartphones. Sensors 14(8):13830–13850
Saarinen A, Rihkanen H, Malmberg LP, Pekkanen L, Sovijärvi ARA (2001) Tracheal sounds and airflow dynamics in surgically treated unilateral vocal fold paralysis. Clin Physiol 21(2):223–228
Saha S, Bradley TD, Taheri M, Moussavi Z, Yadollahi A (2016) A subject-specific acoustic model of the upper airway for snoring sounds generation. Sci Rep 6:25730
Sanchez I, Avital A, Wong I, Tal A, Pasterkamp H (1993a) Acoustic vs. spirometric assessment of bronchial responsiveness to methacholine in children. Pediatr Pulmonol 15(1):28–35
Sanchez I, Powell RE, Pasterkamp H (1993b) Wheezing and airflow obstruction during methacholine challenge in children with cystic fibrosis and in normal children. Am Rev Respir Dis 147(3):705–709
Sarkar M, Madabhavi I, Niranjan N, Dogra M (2015) Auscultation of the respiratory system. Ann Thorac Med 10(3):158–168
Schreur HJW, Diamant Z, Vanderschoot J, Zwinderman AH, Dijkman JH, Sterk PJ (1996) Lung sounds during allergen-induced asthmatic responses in patients with asthma. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 153:1474–1480
Schudt F, Gross V, Weissflog A, Mursina L, Koehler U, Sohrabi K (2014) Estimation of respiratory flow by means of normal lung sound. Stud Health Technol Inform 198:232–237
Shykoff BE, Ploysongsang Y, Chang HK (1988) Airflow and normal lung sounds. Am Rev Respir Dis 137(4):872–876
Sohrabi KA, Basu D, Schudt F, Scholtes M, Seifert O, Koehler U, Gross V (2012) Quantification of nasal respiratory flow by tracheal sound analysis. Biomed Tech 57:733–735
Soufflet G, Charbonneau G, Polit M, Attal P, Denjean A, Escourrou P, Gaultier C (1990) Interaction between tracheal sound and flow rate: a comparison of some different flow evaluations from lung sounds. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 37(4):384–391
Sovijärvi ARA, Malmberg LP, Paajanen E, Pürilä P, Kallio K, Katila T (1996) Averaged and time-gated spectral analysis of respiratory sounds: repeatability of spectral parameters in healthy men and in patients with fibrosing alveolitis. Chest 109(5):1283–1290
Sovijärvi ARA, Vanderschoot J, Earis JE (2000) Standardization of computerized respiratory sound analysis current methods used for computerized respiratory sound analysis. Eur Respir Rev 10(77):585
Yadollahi A, Moussavi ZMK (2006) A robust method for estimating respiratory flow using tracheal sounds entropy. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 53(4):662–668
Yadollahi A, Moussavi Z (2008) Comparison of flow-sound relationship for different features of tracheal sound. In: Proceedings of IEEE conference on engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 805–808
Yadollahi A, Moussavi Z (2009) On arithmetic misconceptions of spectral analysis of biological signals, in particular respiratory sounds. In: Proceedings of IEEE conference on engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 388–391
Yadollahi A, Moussavi ZMK (2011) The effect of anthropometric variations on acoustical flow estimation: proposing a novel approach for flow estimation without the need for individual calibration. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 58(6):1663–1670
Yadollahi A, Giannouli E, Moussavi Z (2010) Sleep apnea monitoring and diagnosis based on pulse oximetery and tracheal sound signals. Med Biol Eng Comput 48(11):1087–1097
Yadollahi A, Montazeri A, Azarbarzin A, Moussavi Z (2013) Respiratory flow-sound relationship during both wakefulness and sleep and its variation in relation to sleep apnea. Ann Biomed Eng 41(3):537–546
Yadollahi A, Rudzicz F, Mahallati S, Coimbra M, Bradley TD (2014) Acoustic estimation of neck fluid volume. Ann Biomed Eng 42:2132–2142
Yap YL, Moussavi Z (2001) Respiratory onset detection using variance fractal dimension. In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 1554–1556
Yap YL, Moussavi Z (2002) Acoustic airflow estimation from tracheal sound power. In: Proceedings of IEEE Canadian conference on electrical and computer engineering, pp 1073–1076
Yildirim I, Ansari R, Moussavi Z (2008) Automated respiratory phase and onset detection using only chest sound signal. In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on engineering in medicine and biology society, pp 2578–2581
Yu L, Ting CK, Hill BE, Orr JA, Brewer LM, Johnson KB, Egan TD, Westenskow DR (2013) Using the entropy of tracheal sounds to detect apnea during sedation in healthy nonobese volunteers. Anesthesiology 118:1341–1349
Yuasa Y, Suzuki K (2019) Wearable device for monitoring respiratory phases based on breathing sound and chest movement. Adv Biomed Eng 8:85–91
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka (UTeM) and Malaysian Ministry of Education for providing financial aid through the Fundamental Research Grant Scheme, FRGS (FRGS/1/2016/TK04/UTEM/01/1).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
There is no conflict of interest to declare.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Muthusamy, P.D., Sundaraj, K. & Abd Manap, N. Computerized acoustical techniques for respiratory flow-sound analysis: a systematic review. Artif Intell Rev 53, 3501–3574 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10462-019-09769-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10462-019-09769-6