Moving away from technocratic framing: agroecology and food sovereignty as possible alternatives to alleviate rural malnutrition in Bangladesh
- 195 Downloads
Abstract
Bangladesh continues to experience stubbornly high levels of rural malnutrition amid steady economic growth and poverty reduction. The policy response to tackling malnutrition shows an overwhelmingly technocratic bias, which depoliticizes the broader question of how the agro-food regime is structured. Taking an agrarian and human rights-based approach, this paper argues that rural malnutrition must be analyzed as symptomatic of a deepening agrarian crisis in which the obsession with productivity increases and commercialization overrides people’s democratic right to culturally appropriate, good, nutritious food. Using qualitative insights from a case study of three villages, this research illustrates how agricultural modernization and commercialization reproduce rural malnutrition by degrading local biodiversity and the rural poor’s access to nutrient-rich diets. In so doing, it undermines the official discourse’s simplistic and literal reading of malnutrition as a pathological health condition resulting from the mere absence of certain micronutrients in the human body, and thus questions the adequacy of the proposed solutions. Instead, this research suggests that solving malnutrition in large part involves facilitating the rural poor’s access to nutritious diets through democratizing and reorganizing the agriculture sector in a manner that is eco-friendly and unconstrained by market imperatives. It cautiously advances agroecology and food sovereignty as possible alternatives, while recognizing that overcoming the challenges agrarian class conflict, gender disparity and urban–rural divide pose would not be easy.
Keywords
Agroecology Biodiversity Capitalist agriculture Food security Food sovereignty Malnutrition BangladeshAbbreviations
- FAO
Food and agriculture organization
- FPMU
Food planning and monitoring unit
- GDP
Gross domestic product
- GoB
Government of Bangladesh
- GR
Green revolution
- MDG
Millennium development goal
- NGO
Non-governmental organization
- P2015DA
Post 2015 development agenda
Notes
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by Hankuk University of Foreign Studies Research Fund. My deepest gratitude goes to Juel, Kamrul, Mehedi, and Milon for helping me gain access to the research sites. I sincerely thank Daniel, Julia, Saee, Theresa, and the participants of 2015 ADI Food, Feeding, and Eating in and out of Asia conference at the University of Copenhagen for their insightful comments on an earlier draft of this paper. I also gratefully acknowledge the two anonymous reviewers and the editor for their valuable suggestions and feedback.
References
- Agarwal, B. 2014. Food sovereignty, food security and democratic choice: Critical contradictions, difficult conciliations. Journal of Peasant Studies 41 (6): 1247–1268.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ahmed, M. 1995. Biodiversity conservation of Bangladesh. In Compilation of theme papers on environmental studies. Dhaka: Bangladesh Technical Education Board.Google Scholar
- Akram-Lodhi, A. H. 2013. Hungry for change: Farmers, food justice and the agrarian question. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing.Google Scholar
- Akram-Lodhi, A. H. 2015. Accelerating towards food sovereignty. Third World Quarterly 36 (3): 563–583.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Allen, P. 2008. Mining for justice in the food system: Perceptions, practices, and possibilities. Agriculture and Human Values 25 (2): 157–161.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Alonso-Fradejas, A., S. M. Borras Jr, T. Holmes, E. Holt-Giménez, and M. J. Robbins. 2015. Food sovereignty: Convergence and contradictions, conditions and challenges. Third World Quarterly 36 (3): 431–448.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Asian, Development Bank. 2014. Bangladesh: Agribusiness Development Project. Completion Report. Project No: 33224. https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/project-document/82385/33224-013-pcr.pdf Accessed 29 Nov 2017.
- Azim, M. E., M. C. J. Verdegem, H. Khatoon, M. A. Wahab, A. A. Van Dam, and M. C. M. Beveridge. 2002. A comparison of fertilization, feeding and three periphyton substrates for increasing fish production in freshwater pond aquaculture in Bangladesh. Aquaculture 212 (1): 227–243.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Badgley, C., J. Moghtader, E. Quintero, E. Zakem, M. J. Chappell, K. Aviles-Vazquez, … and I. Perfecto. 2007. Organic agriculture and the global food supply. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 22 (2): 86–108.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Banerjee, A. V., P. J. Gertler, and M. Ghatak. 2002. Empowerment and efficiency: Tenancy reform in West Bengal. Journal of Political Economy 110 (2): 239–280.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. 2013. District statistics 2011 Panchagarh (vol. 1 ed.). Dhaka: BBS, Ministry of Planning, GoB.Google Scholar
- Belton, B., M. Karim, S. Thilsted, K. Murshed-E-Jahan, W. Collis, and M. Phillips. 2011. Review of aquaculture and fish consumption in Bangladesh. Penang: The WorldFish Center.Google Scholar
- Belton, B., I. J. M. Asseldonk, and S. R. Bush. 2017. Domestic crop booms, livelihood pathways and nested transitions: Charting the implications of Bangladesh’s pangasius boom. Journal of Agrarian Change 17 (4): 694–714.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Bernstein, H. 2009. Agrarian questions from transition to globalization. In Peasants and globalization: Political economy, rural transformation and the agrarian question, eds. H. Akram-Lodhi, and C. Kay, 239–261. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Bernstein, H. 2010. Class dynamics of agrarian change. vol. 1. Sterling, VA: Kumarian Press.Google Scholar
- Bernstein, H. 2014. Food sovereignty via the ‘peasant way’: A sceptical view. Journal of Peasant Studies 41 (6): 1031–1063.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Borras, S. M. Jr, and J. C. Franco. 2010. Food sovereignty and redistributive land policies: Exploring linkages, identifying challenges. In Food Sovereignty: Reconnecting food, nature and community, eds. H. Wittman, A. A. Desmarais, and N. Wiebe, pp. 106–119. Nova Scotia: Fernwood Publishing.Google Scholar
- Carolan, M. 2012. The sociology of food and agriculture. London; UK: Routledge.Google Scholar
- De Schutter, O. 2011. Agroecology and the right to food: Report presented at the 16th session of the United Nations Human Rights Council. Geneva: United Nations Human Rights Council.Google Scholar
- Deshwara, M. 2017. May 6. Flood-hit Haor Areas in Sunamganj: Farmers turning into labourers. The Daily Star. Back page. http://www.thedailystar.net/backpage/farmers-turning-labourers-1401445. Accessed 07 June 2017.
- Desmarais, A. A. 2007. La vía Campesina: Globalization and the power of peasants. Halifax: Fernwood.Google Scholar
- Farmers unhappy for too low prices of maize. 2014. The Daily Star. http://www.thedailystar.net/farmers-unhappy-for-too-low-prices-of-maize-32703. Accessed 5 June 2015.
- Faruque, M. O. 2017. Neoliberal resource governance and counter-hegemonic social movement in Bangladesh. Social Movement Studies 16 (2): 254–259.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Feldman, S. 2003. Paradoxes of institutionalisation: The depoliticisation of Bangladeshi NGOs. Development in Practice 13 (1): 5–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Food and Agriculture Organization [FAO]. 1996. World food summit: Rome declaration on world food security and world food summit plan of action. Rome: FAO.Google Scholar
- Food and Agriculture Organization [FAO]. 2012. Fishery and aquaculture statistics 2012. Rome: FAO.Google Scholar
- Food Planning and Monitoring Unit [FPMU]. 2008. National food policy plan of action (2008–2015). Dhaka: Ministry of Food and Disaster Management.Google Scholar
- Food Planning and Monitoring Unit [FPMU]. 2012. Food security policy brief, strengthen diversification to further improve food and nutrition security. Dhaka: Ministry of Food and Disaster Management.Google Scholar
- Food Planning and Monitoring Unit [FPMU]. 2013. Sustainability of groundwater use for irrigation in Bangladesh. Dhaka: Ministry of Food and Disaster Management.Google Scholar
- Friedmann, H. 2005. From colonialism to green capitalism: Social movements and emergence of food regimes. In New directions in the sociology of global development. Research in rural sociology and development, eds. F. H. Buttel, and P. McMichael, vol. 11, 229–267. Oxford: Elsevier.Google Scholar
- Government of Bangladesh [GoB]. 2008. National food policy plan of action (2008–15). Dhaka: FPMU, MoFDM.Google Scholar
- Government of Bangladesh [GoB]. 2012a. Export policy 2012–15. Dhaka: Ministry of Commerce.Google Scholar
- Government of Bangladesh [GoB]. 2012b. The sixth five year plan (2011–2015): Accelerating growth and reducing poverty (part one). Dhaka: Planning Commission, Ministry of Planning.Google Scholar
- Government of Bangladesh [GoB]. 2013a. National agriculture policy. Dhaka: Ministry of Agriculture.Google Scholar
- Government of Bangladesh [GoB]. 2013b. Post 2015 development agenda: Bangladesh proposal to the UN. Dhaka: Planning Commission.Google Scholar
- Government of Bangladesh [GoB]. 2015. Bangladesh economic review 2015. Dhaka: Ministry of Finance.Google Scholar
- Guthman, J. 2014. Agrarian dreams: The paradox of organic farming in California. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Holt-Gimenez, E., and M. A. Altieri. 2013. Agroecology, food sovereignty, and the new green revolution. Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems 37 (1): 90–102.Google Scholar
- Iannotti, L., K. Cunningham, and M. Ruel. 2009. Improving diet quality and micronutrient nutrition: Homestead food production in Bangladesh. IFPRI Discussion Paper 00928. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.Google Scholar
- IUCN. 2001. Bangladesh: State of the environment 2001. Dhaka: IUCN.Google Scholar
- Jansen, K. 2015. The debate on food sovereignty theory: Agrarian capitalism, dispossession and agroecology. The Journal of Peasant Studies 42 (1): 213–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Karim, L. 2011. Microfinance and its discontents: Women in debt in Bangladesh. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kerr, R. B., P. R. Berti, and L. Shumba. 2011. Effects of a participatory agriculture and nutrition education project on child growth in northern Malawi. Public Health Nutrition 14 (8): 1466–1472.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lang, T. 2009. Reshaping the food system for ecological public health. Journal of Hunger and Environmental Nutrition 4 (3–4): 315–335.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lang, T., and G. Rayner. 2012. Ecological public health: The 21st century’s big idea? An essay by Tim Lang and Geof Rayner. BMJ 345 (7872): 17–20.Google Scholar
- Ludden, D. 2005. Development regimes in South Asia: History and the governance conundrum. Economic and Political Weekly 40 (37): 4042–4051.Google Scholar
- Mann, S. A., and J. M. Dickinson. 1978. Obstacles to the development of a capitalist agriculture. The Journal of Peasant Studies 5 (4): 466–481.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Maxwell, J. A. 1996. Qualitative research design: An interactive approach. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
- Maxwell, S., and M. Smith. 1992. Household food security: A conceptual review. In Household food security: Concepts, indicators, measurements, eds. S. Maxwell, and T. Frankenberger., Rome: IFAD and UNICEF.Google Scholar
- Mazhar, F., D. Buckles, P. Satheesh, and F. Akhter. 2007. Food sovereignty and uncultivated biodiversity in South Asia: Essays on the poverty of food policy and the wealth of the social landscape. New Delhi: Academic Foundation.Google Scholar
- McIntyre, B. D., H. R. Herren, J. Wakhungu, and R. T. Watson, eds. 2009. Agriculture at a crossroads. The global report of the International Assessment of Agricultural Knowledge, Science, and Technology. Washington, DC: Island Press: [IAASTD].Google Scholar
- McMichael, P. 2006. Peasant prospects in the neoliberal age. New Political Economy 11 (3): 407–418.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- McMichael, P. 2009. Food sovereignty, social reproduction and the agrarian question. In Peasants and globalization: Political economy, rural transformation and the agrarian question, eds. H. Akram-Lodhi, and C. Kay, 288–312. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- McMichael, P. 2010. Food sovereignty in movement: Addressing the triple crisis. In Food Sovereignty: Reconnecting food, nature and community, eds. H. Wittman, A. A. Desmarais and N. Wiebe, 169–185. Nova Scotia: Fernwood Publishing.Google Scholar
- McMichael, P. 2015. A comment on Henry Bernstein’s way with peasants, and food sovereignty. Journal of Peasant Studies 42 (1): 193–204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Miah, H. (Undated). Agriculture sector development strategy: Background paper for preparation of 7th five year plan. Dhaka: Government of Bangladesh.Google Scholar
- Ministry of Environment and Forests. 2012. Rio + 20: Bangladesh report on sustainable development. Dhaka: MoEF.Google Scholar
- Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. 2010. Health population & nutrition sector development plan (HPNSDP). Dhaka: Planning Wing.Google Scholar
- Misra, M. 2012. Does government intervention matter? Revisiting recent rice price increases in Bangladesh. Perspectives on Global Development and Technology 11 (1): 112–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Misra, M. 2014. “Through the Valley and Shadow of Death”: Microcredit, neoliberal agriculture and peasant dispossession in Bangladesh. Proceedings of the 109th Annual American Sociological Association Meeting. San Francisco, CA.Google Scholar
- Misra, M. 2017a. Smallholder agriculture and climate change adaptation in Bangladesh: Questioning the technological optimism. Climate and Development 9 (4): 337–347.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Misra, M. 2017b. Is peasantry dead? Neoliberal reforms, the state and agrarian change in Bangladesh. Journal of Agrarian Change 17 (3): 594–611.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Mookerjea, S., and M. Misra. 2017. Coal Power and the sundarbans: Subaltern resistance and convergent crises. In Against colonization and rural dispossession: Local resistance in South and East Asia, the Pacific and Africa, ed. D. Kapoor, 164–183. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
- Moore, J. 2015. Capitalism in the web of life: Ecology and the accumulation of capital. London: Verso.Google Scholar
- NIPORT [National Institute of Population Research and Training]. 2015. Bangladesh demographic and health survey 2014: Key indicators. Dhaka: NIPORT.Google Scholar
- Paprocki, K. 2016. ‘Selling Our Own Skin:’ Social dispossession through microcredit in rural Bangladesh. Geoforum 74: 29–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Paprocki, K., and J. Cons. 2014. Life in a shrimp zone: Aqua-and other cultures of Bangladesh’s coastal landscape. Journal of Peasant Studies 41 (6): 1109–1130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Park, C. M. Y., and B. White, and Julia. 2015. We are not all the same: Taking gender seriously in food sovereignty discourse. Third World Quarterly 36 (3): 584–599.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Patel, R. 2009. Food sovereignty. Journal of Peasant Studies 36 (3): 663–706.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Patel, R. 2013. The long green revolution. The Journal of Peasant Studies 40 (1): 1–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Patel, R., R. B. Kerr, L. Shumba, and L. Dakishoni. 2015. Cook, eat, man, woman: Understanding the new alliance for food security and nutrition, nutritionism and its alternatives from Malawi. The Journal of Peasant Studies 42 (1): 21–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Pimbert, M. 2009. Towards food sovereignty. London: International Institute for Environment and Development.Google Scholar
- Pinstrup-Andersen, P. 2000. Foreward. In Out of the shadows of famine: Evolving food markets and food policy in Bangladesh, R. Ahmed, S. Haggblade, and T. Chowdhury, eds. (p 25). Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
- Pokrant, B. 2014. Brackish water shrimp farming and the growth of aquatic monocultures in Coastal Bangladesh. In Historical perspectives of fisheries exploitation in the Indo-Pacific, eds. J. Christensen, and M. Tull, 107–132. Dordrecht: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Rahman, S. 2003. Farm-level pesticide use in Bangladesh: Determinants and awareness. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 95 (1): 241–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Rahman, M., and S. Minkin. 2007. Net benefits: The ecological restoration of inland fisheries in Bangladesh. In Reclaiming nature: Environmental justice and ecological restoration, eds. J. K. Boyce, S. Narain, and E. A. Stanton, 111–126. New York: Anthem Press.Google Scholar
- Rayner, G., and T. Lang. 2015. Ecological public health: leaders, movements and ideas to shift the boundaries between the normal and the desirable. In Healthy people, places and planet: Reflections based on Tony McMichael’s four decades of contribution to epidemiological understanding, C. Butler, and J. Dixon, eds. and A. G. Capon, 617–641. Canberra: ANU Press.Google Scholar
- Razavi, S. 2009. Engendering the political economy of agrarian change. The Journal of Peasant Studies 36 (1): 197–226.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Rivera-Ferre, M. G. 2012. Framing of agri-food research affects the analysis of food security: The critical role of the social sciences. International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food 19 (2): 162–175.Google Scholar
- Roos, N., M. M. Islam, and S. H. Thilsted. 2003. Small indigenous fish species in Bangladesh: Contribution to vitamin A, calcium and iron intakes. The Journal of Nutrition 133 (11): 4021S–4026S.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Rosset, P., and M. E. Martínez-Torres. 2012. Rural social movements and agroecology: Context, theory, and process. Ecology and Society 17 (3): 17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Scrinis, G. 2008. On the ideology of nutritionism. Gastronomica 8 (1): 39–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Sen, A. 1981. Poverty and famines: An essay on entitlement and deprivation. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
- Sharif, N. R., and A. A. Dar. 1996. An empirical study of the patterns and sources of technical inefficiency in traditional and HYV rice cultivation in Bangladesh. The Journal of Development Studies 32 (4): 612–629.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Singh, R. B. 2000. Environmental consequences of agricultural development: A case study from the Green Revolution state of Haryana, India. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 82 (1): 97–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Smith, L. C., and L. Haddad. 2015. Reducing child undernutrition: Past drivers and priorities for the post-MDG era. World Development 68: 180–204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Taylor, M. 2011. ‘Freedom from poverty is not for free’: Rural development and the microfinance crisis in Andhra Pradesh, India. Journal of Agrarian Change 11 (4): 484–504.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Thilsted, S., and M. Wahab. 2014. Production and conservation of nutrient-rich small fish (SIS) in ponds and wetlands for nutrition security and livelihoods in South Asia. Bayan Lepas: WorldFish.Google Scholar
- Thorne-Lyman, A. L., N. Valpiani, K. Sun, R. D. Semba, C. L. Klotz, K. Kraemer, … and M. W. Bloem. 2010. Household dietary diversity and food expenditures are closely linked in rural Bangladesh, increasing the risk of malnutrition due to the financial crisis. The Journal of Nutrition 140 (1): 182S–188S.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Van Schendel, W. 2009. A history of Bangladesh. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Van den Bosch, R. 1978. The pesticide conspiracy. Garden City: NY Doubleday.Google Scholar
- Wahlqvist, M. L., and R. L. Specht. 1998. Food variety and biodiversity: Eeconutrition. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 7: 314–319.Google Scholar
- Wittman, H., and J. Blesh. 2017. Food sovereignty and Fome Zero: Connecting public food procurement programmes to sustainable rural development in Brazil. Journal of Agrarian Change 17 (1): 81–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Wittman, H., A. A. Desmarais, and N. Wiebe, eds. 2010. The origins and potential of food sovereignty. In Food sovereignty: Reconnecting food, nature and community, 1–14. Halifax: Fernwood.Google Scholar
- World Bank. 2007. World development report 2008: Agriculture for development. Washington, DC World Bank.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- World Food Programme. 2012a. WFP Bangladesh nutrition strategy 2012–2016. Rome: WFP.Google Scholar
- World Food Programme. 2012b. Undernutrition Maps of Bangladesh: Key Findings. Rome: WFP.Google Scholar
- WorldFish. 2015. Factsheet: 2015–16. Penang, Malaysia. http://pubs.iclarm.net/resource_centre/2015-16.pdf. Accessed 24 April 2017.
- Yin, R. K., ed. 2004. Introduction. In The case study anthology, xi-xx. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
- Yunus, M., B. Moingeon, and L. Lehmann-Ortega. 2010. Building social business models: Lessons from the Grameen experience. Long Range Planning 43 (2): 308–325.CrossRefGoogle Scholar