How knowledge deficit interventions fail to resolve beginning farmer challenges
Beginning farmer initiatives like the USDA’s Beginning Farmer and Rancher Development Program (BFRDP), farm incubators, and small-scale marketing innovations offer new entrant farmers agricultural training, marketing and business assistance, and farmland loans. These programs align with alternative food movement goals to revitalize the anemic U.S. small farm sector and repopulate landscapes with socially and environmentally diversified farms. Yet even as these initiatives seek to support prospective farmers with tools for success through a knowledge dissemination model, they remain mostly individualistic and entrepreneurial measures that overlook structural barriers to productive and economic success within U.S. agriculture. Analysis of the BFRDP’s funding history and discourse reveals a “knowledge deficit” based program focused on the technical rather than the structural aspects of beginning farming. This is contrasted with qualitative analysis of beginning farmer experiences in California’s Central Coast region. The discrepancies between the farmer experiences and national structure of the BFRDP program ultimately reveal a policy mismatch between the needs of some beginning farmers and the programs intended to support them.
KeywordsLand access Beginning farmers Beginning Farmer and Rancher Development Program Knowledge deficit model Agricultural policy Land tenure
Beginning Farmer and Rancher Development Program
Farm Service Agency
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
United States Department of Agriculture
The author wishes to acknowledge the precious time, insights, and opinions offered by farmers in the Central Coast. Staff from the Agricultural and Land-based training Association and Mika Maekawa from California Farmlink helped guide this research. Madaly Alcala provided support on the analysis of BFRDP programs. Rachel Perera aggregated USDA census and land tenure statistics. Manuscript feedback was generously offered by Hank Herrera and members of Kathryn De Master’s research group. Essential editing came from Patrick Baur, Lisa Kelley, and Alastair Iles. The arguments of this paper were improved by four anonymous reviewers and the editor, Harvey James. This work has been supported by the Berkeley Food Institute and the UCANR Graduate Students in Extension Program.
Compliance with ethical standards
All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.
Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.
- Ahearn, M. C. 2013. Beginning farmers and ranchers at a glance. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, EB-22. https://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/pub-details/?pubid=42876. Accessed 8 Oct 2016.
- Alkon, A. H., and J. Agyeman, eds. 2011. Cultivating food justice: Race, class, and sustainability. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Altieri, M. 1995. Agroecology: The science of sustainable agriculture. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
- Ayazi, H., and E. Elsheikh. 2015. The US Farm Bill: Corporate Power and Structural Racialization in the US Food System. Haas Institute for a Fair and Inclusive Society. http://haasinstitute.berkeley.edu/farm-bill-report-corporate-power-and-structural-racialization-us-food-system. Accessed 3 Jan 2015.
- Beckett, J. 2011. Beyond the moral economy of local food: Land trusts, beginner farmers, and redefining conservation in the public interest. Master’s thesis, Department of Community Development. Davis: University of California, Davis.Google Scholar
- Beckett, J., and R. Galt. 2014. Land trusts and beginning farmers’ access to land: Exploring the relationships in coastal California. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 4 (2): 19–35.Google Scholar
- Bigelow, D., A. Borchers, and T. Hubbs. 2016. U.S. farmland ownership, tenure and, transfer. US Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service EIB-161. https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/74672/60298_eib161.pdf?v=42607. Accessed 15 Jan 2017.
- Blaikie, P., and H. Brookfield. 1987. Land degradation and society. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
- Bradbury, Z., S. Von Tscharner Fleming, and P. Manalo, eds. 2012. Greenhorns: 50 dispatches from the New Farmers’ Movement. North Adams: Storey Pub.Google Scholar
- Bunnell, R., D. O’Neil, R. Soler, R. Payne, W. H. Giles, J. Collins, U. Bauer, and Communities Putting Prevention to Work Program Group. 2012. Fifty communities putting prevention to work: Accelerating chronic disease prevention through policy, systems and environmental change. Journal of Community Health 37 (5): 1081–1090.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Calo, A., and K. De Master. 2016. After the incubator: Factors impeding land access along the path from farmworker to proprietor. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 6 (2): 111–127.Google Scholar
- Durant, J., M. Bauer, G. Gaskell, C. Midden, M. Liakopoulos, and L. Scholten. 2000. Two cultures of public understanding of science and technology in Europe. In Between understanding and trust: The public, science and technology, eds. M. Dierkes, and C. von Grote, 131–156. Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Publishers.Google Scholar
- Dutta, M. J. 2015. Neoliberal health organizing: Communication, meaning, and politics. Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press.Google Scholar
- Einsiedel, E. 2000. Understanding “publics” in the public understanding of science. In Between understanding and trust. The public, science and technology, eds. M. Dierkes, and C. von Grote, 205–216. Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Publishers.Google Scholar
- Farm Credit Administration (FCA). 2014. 2014 annual report. https://www.fca.gov/Download/AnnualReports/2014AnnualReport.pdf. Accessed 21 Sept 2015.
- Freedgood, J., and J. Dempsey. 2014. Cultivating the next generation: Resources and policies to help beginning farmers succeed in agriculture. American Farmland Trust. http://www.farmlandinfo.org/sites/default/files/AFT_BF_08-27-2014lo_1.pdf. Accessed 7 June 2016.
- Guthman, J. 2000. Agrarian dreams?: The paradox of organic farming in California. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Guthman, J. 2011. If they only knew: The unbearable whiteness of alternative food. In Cultivating food justice: Race, class, and sustainability, eds. A. H. Alkon, and J. Agyeman, 263–281. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Hamilton, N. D. 2011. America’s new agrarians: Policy opportunities and legal innovations to support new farmers. Fordham Environmental Law Review 22 (3): 523–562.Google Scholar
- Holmes, S. M. 2013. Fresh fruit, broken bodies: Migrant farmworkers in the United States. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Holt-Giménez, E. 2006. Campesino a campesino: Voices from Latin America’s farmer to farmer movement for sustainable agriculture. Oakland: Food First Books.Google Scholar
- Honeycutt, S., J. Leeman, W. J. McCarthy, R. Bastani, L. Carter-Edwards, H. Clark, W. Garney, J. Gustat, L. Hites, F. Nothwehr, and M. Kegler. 2015. Evaluating policy, systems, and environmental change interventions: Lessons learned from CDC’s prevention research centers. Preventing Chronic Disease 12: E174.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Irwin, A., and B. Wynne, eds. 1996. Misunderstanding science?: The public reconstruction of science and technology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Johnson, K. 2008. Conserving farmland in California: For what and for whom - How agricultural conservation easements can keep farmland farmed. Sustainable Development Law and Policy 9 (1): 45–49.Google Scholar
- Lyson, T. 2004. Civic agriculture: Reconnecting farm, food, and Community. Civil Society. Medford: Tufts University Press.Google Scholar
- Markham, L. 2014. The new farmers. Orion Magazine, Nov–Dec 2014, 18–25.Google Scholar
- Minkoff-Zern, L.-A. 2017. Race, immigration and the agrarian question: Farmworkers becoming farmers in the United States. The Journal of Peasant Studies. doi: 10.1080/03066150.2017.1293661.
- Minkoff-Zern, L.-A., N. Peluso, J. Sowerwine, and C. Getz. 2011. Race and regulation: Asian immigrants in California agriculture. In Cultivating food justice: Race, class and sustainability, ed. A. H. Alkon and J. Agyeman, 65–85. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Niewolny, K., and P. Lillard. 2010. Expanding the boundaries of beginning farmer training and program development: A review of contemporary initiatives to cultivate a new generation of American farmers. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 1 (1): 65–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- OBPA (Office of Budget and Program Analysis) US Department of Agriculture FY. 2016. Budget summary and annual performance plan (2015). USDA. https://www.obpa.usda.gov/budsum/fy16budsum.pdf. Accessed 20 June 2016.
- Overton, M. A. 2014. Growing new farmers: A survey of farm incubator programs in the United States. Master’s thesis, Department of Urban and Environmental Policy and Planning. Medford: Tufts University.Google Scholar
- Parsons, R., K. Ruhf, G. W. Stevenson, J. Baker, M. Bell, E. Epley, J. Gilbert, C. Hinton, and J. Keller. 2010. Farm land access, succession, tenure and stewardship. The FarmLasts Project. https://www.uvm.edu/farmlasts/FarmLASTSResearchReport.pdf. Accessed 20 Sept 2017.
- Petrovic, J., and A. Kuntz. 2014. Citizenship education around the world: Local contexts and global possibilities. Hoboken: Taylor and Francis.Google Scholar
- Pitzer, H. 2015. Urban teachers engaging in critical talk: Navigating deficit discourse and neoliberal logics. Journal of Educational Controversy 9 (1): 8.Google Scholar
- Reid, T. 2013. First generation farmers: An assessment of their challenges, motivations, learning processes, and values. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Community, Agriculture, Recreation, and Resources Studies. East Lansing: Michigan State University.Google Scholar
- Röling, N. G., and M. A. E. Wagemakers, eds. 1998. Facilitating sustainable agriculture: Participatory learning and adaptive management in times of environmental uncertainty. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Rosset, P. M., B. Machín Sosa, A. M. Roque Jaime, and D. R. Ávila Lozano. 2011. The campesino-to-campesino agroecology movement of ANAP in Cuba: Social process methodology in the construction of sustainable peasant agriculture and food sovereignty. The Journal of Peasant Studies 38 (1): 161–191.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ruhf, K. 2013. Access to farmland: A systems change perspective. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 4 (1): 51–60.Google Scholar
- Shute, Lindsey. 2011. Building a future with farmers: Challenges faced by young, American farmers and a national strategy to help them succeed. National Young Farmers’ Coalition. http://www.youngfarmers.org/reports/Building_A_Future_With_Farmers.pdf. Accessed 5 May 2016.
- Sureshwaran, S., and S. Ritchie. 2011. US farm bill resources and programs for beginning farmers. Choices 26 (2): 3.Google Scholar
- United States Department of Agriculture National Agriculture Statistics Service (USDA NASS). 2016. 2014 tenure, ownership, and transition of agricultural land (TOTAL). http://www.agcensus.usda.gov/Publications/2012/Online_Resources/TOTAL/index.php. Accessed 11 Oct 2016.
- United States Department of Agriculture National Institute of Food and Agriculture [NIFA]. 2016. Beginning Farmer and Rancher Development Program: FY 2016 Request for Applications (RFA). https://nifa.usda.gov/sites/default/files/rfa/FY16%20BFRDP%20RFA.pdf. Accessed 11 Oct 2016.
- Warner, K. D. 2007. Agroecology in action: Extending alternative agriculture through social networks. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar