Agriculture and Human Values

, Volume 32, Issue 1, pp 63–75 | Cite as

The sustainability promise of alternative food networks: an examination through “alternative” characteristics

Article

Abstract

Concerns about the unsustainability of the conventional food system have brought attention to so called alternative food networks (AFNs), which are widely thought to be more sustainable. However, claims made about AFNs’ sustainability have been subject to a range of criticisms. Some of them present counterevidence, while others have pointed to problematic underlying features in the academic literature and popular discourse that may hamper our understanding of AFNs’ sustainability. Considering these criticisms, together with the fact that the literature often addresses a specific type of AFN or a specific sustainability-related issue, it is hard to form a clear overall picture of the sustainability promise of AFNs. In this article, we seek to contribute to a clearer understanding of this promise through a structured review, focusing on links between AFN characteristics and sustainability. Through an analysis of AFN conceptualizations reflected in the literature, we identify and consolidate their key characteristics. We then synthesize claims of how these characteristics may translate into sustainability, finding a wide range of potential direct and indirect impacts. Examining these from different angles, we find that the sustainability promise of AFNs found in these claims is qualified by the presence of potentially unaddressed issues, by criticisms regarding for example the evidence base of the assumed impacts and their power in addressing sustainability, and by considerations of how these impacts might play out in actual, real-life food networks. Indirect impacts of learning and participation may be highly significant for sustainability. We conclude with recommendations for research and practice.

Keywords

Alternative food networks Localized food systems Short food supply chains Sustainability 

References

  1. Allen, P., D. Van Dusen, J. Lundy, and S. Gliessman. 1991. Integrating social, environmental, and economic issues in sustainable agriculture. American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 6(1): 34–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Allen, P., and M. Kovach. 2000. The capitalist composition of organic: The potential of markets in fulfilling the promise of organic agriculture. Agriculture and Human Values 17(3): 221–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Allen, P., M. FitzSimmons, M. Goodman, and K. Warner. 2003. Shifting plates in the agrifood landscape: The tectonics of alternative agrifood initiatives in California. Journal of Rural Studies 19(1): 61–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Anderson, M.D. 2008. Rights-based food systems and the goals of food system reform. Agriculture and Human Values 25(4): 593–608.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Berry, W. 1987. A defense of the family farm. In Is there a moral obligation to save the family farm?, ed. G. Comstock, 347–360. Ames: Iowa State University Press.Google Scholar
  6. Born, B., and M. Purcell. 2006. Avoiding the local trap. Scale and food systems in planning research. Journal of Planning Education and Research 26(2): 195–207.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bowen, S., and K. De Master. 2011. New rural livelihoods or museums of production? Quality food initiatives in practice. Journal of Rural Studies 21(1): 73–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Brown, S., and C. Getz. 2008. Towards domestic fair trade? Farm labor, food localism, and the “family scale” farm. GeoJournal 73(1): 11–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Brown, C., and S. Miller. 2008. The impacts of local markets: a review of research on farmers markets and Community Supported Agriculture (CSA). American Journal of Agricultural Economics 90(5): 1296–1302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Callon, M. 1986. Some elements of a sociology of translation: domestication of the scallops and fishermen of St. Brieuc Bay. In Power, action, and belief. A new sociology of knowledge?, ed. J. Law, 196–233. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  11. Coley, D., M. Howard, and M. Winter. 2009. Local food, food miles, and carbon emissions: A comparison of farm shop and mass distribution approaches. Food Policy 34(2): 150–155.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Coley, D., M. Howard, and M. Winter. 2011. Food miles: Time for a re-think? British Food Journal 113(7): 919–934.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Cone, C.A., and A. Myhre. 2000. Community-supported agriculture: A sustainable alternative to industrial agriculture? Human Organization 59(2): 187–197.Google Scholar
  14. Cox, R., L. Holloway, L. Venn, L. Dowler, J.R. Hein, M. Kneafsey, and H. Tuomainen. 2008. Common ground? Motivations for participation in a community-supported agriculture scheme. Local Environment 13(3): 203–218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. DEFRA (Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs). 2002. The strategy for sustainable farming and food. Facing the future. DEFRA Publications. http://archive.defra.gov.uk/foodfarm/policy/sustainfarmfood/documents/sffs.pdf. Accessed 23 March 2014.
  16. De Roest, K., and A. Menghi. 2000. Reconsidering “traditional” food: the case of Parmigiano Reggiano cheese. Sociologia Ruralis 40(4): 439–451.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Edwards-Jones, G., L. Milà i Canals, N. Hounsome, M. Truninger, G. Koerber, B. Hounsome, P. Cross, E.H. York, A. Hospido, K. Plassman, I.M. Harris, R.T. Edwards, G.A.S. Day, A.D. Tomos, S.J. Cowell, and D.L. Jones. 2008. Testing the assertion that “local food is best”: the challenges of an evidence-based approach. Trends in Food Science & Technology 19(5): 265–274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Esquinas-Alcázar, J. 2005. Protecting crop genetic diversity for food security: Political, ethical, and technical challenges. Nature Reviews Genetics 6: 946–953.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. European Commission. 2007. Council Regulation (EC) No 834/2007 of 28 June 2007 on organic production and labelling of organic products and repealing Regulation (EEC) No 2092/91. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2007:189:0001:0023:EN:PDF. Accessed 6 May 2014.
  20. FARMA. 2010. Certification—abridged rules. http://www.farmersmarkets.net/certification2.htm. Accessed 6 May 2014.
  21. Feagan, R., and A. Henderson. 2009. Devon Acres CSA: Local struggles in a global food system. Agriculture and Human Values 26(3): 203–217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Forsman-Hugg, S., J.-M. Katajajuuri, I. Riipi, K. Järvelä, J. Mäkelä, and P. Timonen. 2013. Key CSR dimensions for the food chain. British Food Journal 115(1): 30–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Gold, M.V. 2007. What is organic production? United States Department of Agriculture National Agricultural Library. http://www.nal.usda.gov/afsic/pubs/ofp/ofp.shtml. Accessed 24 January 2013.
  24. Gomiero, T., D. Pimentel, and M.G. Paoletti. 2011. Environmental impact of different agricultural management practices: Conventional vs. organic agriculture. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 30(1–2): 95–124.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Goodman, D. 2004. Rural Europe redux? Reflections on alternative agro-food networks and paradigm change. Sociologia Ruralis 44(1): 3–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Guthman, J. 2004. The trouble with “organic lite” in California. A rejoinder to the conventionalization debate. Sociologia Ruralis 44(3): 301–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Guthman, J., A.W. Morris, and P. Allen. 2006. Squaring farm security and food security in two types of alternative food institutions. Rural Sociology 71(4): 662–684.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hassanein, N. 2003. Practicing food democracy: A pragmatic politics of transformation. Journal of Rural Studies 19(1): 77–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hinrichs, C.C. 2000. Embeddedness and local food systems: Notes on two types of direct agricultural market. Journal of Rural Studies 16(3): 295–303.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Holloway, L., M. Kneafsey, L. Venn, R. Cox, E. Dowler, and H. Tuomainen. 2007. Possible food economies: A methodological framework for exploring food production–consumption relationships. Sociologia Ruralis 47(1): 1–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Ilbery, B., and D. Maye. 2005a. Alternative (shorter) food supply chains and specialist livestock products in the Scottish–English borders. Environment and Planning A 37(5): 823–844.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Ilbery, B., and D. Maye. 2005b. Food supply chains and sustainability: evidence from specialist food producers in the Scottish/English borders. Land Use Policy 22(4): 331–344.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Jaffee, D., and P.H. Howard. 2010. Corporate co-optation of organic and fair trade standards. Agriculture and Human Values 27(4): 387–399.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Jarosz, L. 2008. The city in the country: Growing alternative food networks in Metropolitan areas. Journal of Rural Studies 24(3): 231–244.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. James, H., and M.K. Hendrickson. 2010. Are farmers of the middle distinctively “good stewards”? Evidence from the Missouri Farm Poll, 2006. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 23(6): 571–590.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Kemp, R., and P. Martens. 2007. Sustainable development: how to manage something that is subjective and never can be achieved. Sustainability: Science, Practice, and Policy 3(2): 5–14.Google Scholar
  37. Kirwan, J. 2004. Alternative strategies in the UK agro-food system: interrogating the alterity of farmers’ markets. Sociologia Ruralis 44(4): 395–415.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Kloppenburg, J., J. Hendrickson, and G.W. Stevenson. 1996. Coming into the foodshed. Agriculture and Human Values 13(3): 33–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Lamine, C. 2005. Settling shared uncertainties: Local partnerships between producers and consumers. Sociologia Ruralis 45(5): 324–345.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Lee, R. 2000. Shelter from the storm? Geographies of regard in the worlds of horticultural consumption and production. Geoforum 31(2): 137–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Lobley, M., A. Butler, and M. Reed. 2009. The contribution of organic farming to rural development: An exploration of the socio-economic linkages of organic and non-organic farms in England. Land Use Policy 26(3): 723–735.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Lyon, S. 2006. Evaluating fair trade consumption: Politics, defetishization, and producer participation. International Journal of Consumer Studies 30(5): 452–464.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Maloni, M.J., and M.E. Brown. 2006. Corporate social responsibility in the supply chain: An application in the food industry. Journal of Business Ethics 68(1): 35–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Mariola, M. 2008. The local industrial complex? Questioning the link between local foods and energy use. Agriculture and Human Values 25(2): 193–196.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Marsden, T., J. Banks, and G. Bristow. 2000. Food supply chain approaches: Exploring their role in rural development. Sociologia Ruralis 40(4): 424–438.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Maye, D., and B. Ilbery. 2006. Regional economies of local food production: Tracing food chain links between “specialist” producers and intermediaries in the Scottish–English borders. European Urban and Regional Studies 13(4): 337–354.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Maxey, L. 2006. Can we sustain sustainable agriculture? Learning from small-scale producer-suppliers in Canada and the UK. The Geographical Journal 172(3): 230–244.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Maxey, L. 2007. From “alternative” to “sustainable” food. In Alternative food geographies: Concepts and debates, ed. D. Maye, L. Holloway, and M. Kneafsey, 55–75. Oxford: Elsevier.Google Scholar
  49. Milestad, R., L. Westberg, U. Geber, and J. Björklund. 2010. Enhancing adaptive capacity in food systems: Learning at farmers’ markets in Sweden. Ecology and Society 15(3): 29.Google Scholar
  50. Morgan, K., T. Marsden, and J. Murdoch. 2006. Worlds of food: Place, power and provenance in the food chain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  51. Morris, C., and H. Buller. 2003. The local food sector: A preliminary assessment of its form and impact in Gloucestershire. British Food Journal 105(8): 559–566.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Morris, C., and J. Kirwan. 2006. Vegetarians: Uninvited, uncomfortable or special guests at the table of the alternative food economy? Sociologia Ruralis 46(3): 192–213.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Norberg-Hodge, H., T. Merrifield, and S. Gorelick. 2002. Bringing the food economy home: Local alternatives to global agribusiness. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
  54. O’Hara, S.U., and S. Stagl. 2001. Global food markets and their local alternatives: A socio-ecological economic perspective. Population and Environment: A Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies 22(6): 533–554.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Pole, A., and M. Gray. 2013. Farming alone? What’s up with the “C” in community supported agriculture. Agriculture and Human Values 30(1): 85–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Redclift, M. 2002. Pathways to sustainability? Geography 87(3): 189–196.Google Scholar
  57. Reisch, L., U. Eberle, and S. Lorek. 2013. Sustainable food consumption: An overview of contemporary issues and policies. Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy 9(2): 7–25.Google Scholar
  58. Renting, H., T.K. Marsden, and J. Banks. 2003. Understanding alternative food networks: exploring the role of short food supply chains in rural development. Environment and Planning A 35(3): 393–411.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Robinson, J. 2004. Squaring the circle? Some thoughts on the idea of sustainable development. Ecological Economics 48(4): 369–384.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Sage, C. 2003. Social embeddedness and relations of regard: alternative “good food” networks in south-west Ireland. Journal of Rural Studies 19(1): 47–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Schonhart, M., M. Penker, and E. Schmid. 2009. Sustainable local food production and consumption. Challenges for implementation and research. Outlook on Agriculture 38(2): 175–182.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Selfa, T., and J. Qazi. 2005. Place, taste, or face-to-face? Understanding producer–consumer networks in “local” food systems in Washington State. Agriculture and Human Values 22(4): 451–464.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Shreck, A. 2005. Resistance, redistribution, and power in the Fair Trade banana initiative. Agriculture and Human Values 22(1): 17–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Sonnino, R., and T. Marsden. 2006. Beyond the divide: Rethinking relationships between alternative and conventional food networks in Europe. Journal of Economic Geography 6(2): 181–199.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Starik, M., and P. Kanashiro. 2013. Toward a theory of sustainability management: Uncovering and integrating the nearly obvious. Organization and Environment 26(1): 7–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Sundkvist, Å., R. Milestad, and A. Jansson. 2005. On the importance of tightening feedback loops for sustainable development of food systems. Food Policy 30(2): 224–239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Sustain. 2002. Sustainable food chains. Briefing paper 1. Local food; benefits, obstacles, and opportunities. Sustain: The Alliance for Better Food and Farming, London. http://www.sustainweb.org/pdf/briefing1.pdf. Accessed 28 March 2014.
  68. Sustain. 2013. The sustain guide to good food. Sustain: The Alliance for Better Food and Farming, London.Google Scholar
  69. Sustainable Development Commission. 2005. Sustainability implications for the Little Red Tractor Scheme. http://www.sd-commission.org.uk/publications.php?id=195. Accessed 28 March 2014.
  70. Tavernier, E.M., and V. Tolomeo. 2004. Farm typology and sustainable agriculture: Does size matter? Journal of sustainable agriculture 24(2): 33–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Taylor, P.L., D.L. Murray, and L.T. Raynolds. 2005. Keeping trade fair: Governance challenges in the fair trade coffee initiative. Sustainable Development 13(3): 199–208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Terstappen, V., L. Hanson, and D. McLaughlin. 2013. Gender, health, labor, and inequities: A review of the fair and alternative trade literature. Agriculture and Human Values 30(1): 21–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Thilmany, D., C.A. Bond, and J.K. Bond. 2008. Going local: Exploring consumer behavior and motivations for direct food purchases. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 90(5): 1303–1309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Tregear, A. 2011. Progressing knowledge in alternative and local food networks: Critical reflections and a research agenda. Journal of Rural Studies 27(4): 419–430.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Virtanen, Y., S. Kurppa, M. Saarinen, J.-M. Katajajuuri, K. Usva, I. Mäenpää, J. Mäkelä, J. Grönroos, and A. Nissinen. 2011. Carbon footprint of food—approaches from national input–output statistics and a LCA of a food portion. Journal of Cleaner Production 19(16): 1849–1856.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Watts, D.C.H., B. Ilbery, and D. Maye. 2005. Making reconnections in agro-food geography: Alternative systems of food provision. Progress in Human Geography 29(1): 22–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Weber, C.L., and H.S. Matthews. 2008. Food-miles and the relative climate impacts of food choices in the United States. Environmental Science and Technology 42(10): 3508–3513.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Whatmore, S., P. Stassart, and H. Renting. 2003. What’s alternative about alternative food networks? Environment and Planning A 35: 389–391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Winter, M. 2003. Embeddedness, the new food economy, and defensive localism. Journal of Rural Studies 19(1): 23–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Yakovleva, N. 2007. Measuring the sustainability of the food supply chain: A case study of the UK. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 9(1): 75–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Zepeda, L. 2009. Which little piggy goes to market? International Journal of Consumer Studies 33(3): 250–257.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Economics and ManagementUniversity of HelsinkiUniversity of HelsinkiFinland

Personalised recommendations