Abstract
Professional identity formation, the process of transformation from lay person to doctor, is at the heart of medical education. Medical student cohorts can include students who enter medicine from a previous career, i.e. with developed professional identities and who are usually older and more mature. Students with previously developed professional identities may have specific challenges in negotiating their new ‘doctor’ identity. This study examined the development of professional identity in mature medical students who had a variety of previous careers prior to entering medical school. A narrative inquiry was undertaken using interviews of mature medical students with backgrounds that included physiotherapy, clinical physiology, public health and nutrition, and the armed forces. A narrative analysis was conducted combining both thematic and structural perspectives using linguistics and positioning theory as interpretive tools. Three main themes emerged that portray the development processes that arise in this cohort as they develop their medical professional identity: holding back aspects of the previous self; foregrounding aspects of the previous self; and developing new aspects towards forming a ‘new’ self. These themes and their implications are discussed in the context of current literature, highlighting some of the specific challenges that this cohort faces in developing their medical identity. We argue that dedicated faculty and student development be offered, exploring how professional identity formation in mature medical students can be facilitated and supported, so staff and students are better equipped to engage and shape mature students’ professional identity in a meaningful way.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andrews, M., Squire, C., & Tamboukou, M. (Eds.). (2013). Doing narrative research. London: Sage.
Atkinson, P. (1995). Medical talk and medical work. London: Sage.
Bamberg, M. (1997). Positioning between structure and performance. Journal of Narrative and Life History,7(1), 335–342.
Bamberg, M. (2003). Positioning with Davie Hogan—Stories, tellings and identities. In C. Daiute & C. Lightfood (Eds.), Narrative analysis: Studying the development of individuals in society (pp. 135–158). London: Sage.
Bamberg, M., & Georgakopoulou, A. (2008). Small stories as a new perspective in narrative and identity analysis. Text & Talk,28, 377–396.
Bleakley, A., Bligh, J., & Browne, J. (2011). Medical education for the future: Identity, power and location. London: Springer.
Bold, C. (2012). Using narrative in research. London: Sage.
Caldas-Coulthard, C., & Iedema, R. (Eds.). (2008). Identity trouble. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.
Chur-Hansen, A. (2003). Mature-aged medical students: A qualitative study. Learning in Health and Social Care,2(3), 159–168.
Clandinin, D., & Cave, M. T. (2008). Creating pedagogical spaces for developing doctor professional identity. Medical Education,42(8), 765–770. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2008.03098.x.
Cooke, M., Irby, D. M., & O’Brien, B. C. (2010). Educating physicians: A call for reform of medical school and residency. Stanford, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Costello, C. (2005). Professional identity crisis: Race, class, gender, and success at professioanl schools. Nashville, TN: Vanderbuilt Univeristy Press.
Cruess, R. L., Cruess, S. R., Boudreau, J. D., Snell, L., & Steinert, Y. (2014). Reframing medical education to support professional identity formation. Academic Medicine,89, 1446–1451.
Cruess, R. L., Cruess, S. R., Boudreau, J. D., Snell, L., & Steinert, Y. (2015). A schematic representation of the professional identity formation and socialization of medical students and residents: A guide for medical educators. Academic Medicine,90(6), 718–725.
Davies, B., & Harré, R. (1990). Positioning: The discursive production of selves. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour,20(1), 43–63.
De Fina, A. (2013). Positioning level 3. Connecting local identity displays to macro-social processes. Narrative Inquiry,23(1), 40–61.
De Fina, A., Shiffrin, D., & Bamberg, M. (2006). Discourse and identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Finlay, G., & Gough, B. (2003). Reflexivity: A practical guide for researchers in health and social sciences. Oxford: Blackwell.
Gallagher, P., & Hoare, K. (2015). Transition: Health professionals as medical students. The Clinical Teacher, 16, 223–226.
Goldie, J. (2012). The formation of professional identity in medical students: Considerations for educators. Medical Teacher,34(9), e641–e648.
Goodwin, E. (2016). ED, board slated after death of young girl. Otago Daily Times. Retrieved February 2, 2017 from https://www.odt.co.nz/news/dunedin/health/ed-board-slated-after-death-young-girl.
Gubrium, J. F., & Holstein, J. A. (1997). The new language of qualitative method. Oxford: Oxford Univeristy Press.
Jarvis-Selinger, S., Pratt, D. D., & Regehr, G. (2012). Competency is not enough: Integrating identity formation into the medical education discourse. Academic Medicine,87(9), 1185–1190.
Jenkins, R. (2008). Social identity (4th ed.). London: Routledge.
Jurjus, R. A., Butera, G., Abdelnabi, M., & Krapf, J. M. (2017). Comparing the experience of mature-aged and traditional medical students in the clinical setting: A qualitative approach. Journal of Academic Development and Education,7, 8–28.
Kay, J., & Blythe, M. (1984). Professionalization of the older medical student. Academic Medicine,59(7), 559–566.
Kick, S., Adams, L., & O’Brien-Gonzales, A. (2000). Unique issues of older medical students. Teaching and Learning in Medicine,12(3), 150–155.
Kusurkar, R., Kruitwagen, C., ten Cate, O., & Croiset, G. (2010). Effects of age, gender and educational background on strength of motivation for medical school. Advances in Health Sciences Education,15(3), 303–313.
Labov, W. (1997). Some further steps in narrative analysis. Journal of Narrative and Life History,7, 395–415.
Lemke, J. (2008). Identity, developement and desire: Critical questions. In C. Caldas-Coulthard & R. Iedema (Eds.), Identity trouble: Critical discourse and contested identities. Palgrave: Hampshire.
Mathers, J., & Parry, J. (2010). Older mature students’ experiences of applying to study medicine in England: An interview study. Medical Education,44(11), 1084–1094.
McLean, M. (2017). From being a nurse to becoming a ‘different’ doctor. Advances in Health Sciences Education,22(3), 667–689. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-016-9700-y.
Meadows, L., & Dodendorf, D. (1999). Data management and interpretation using computers to assist. In B. F. Crabtree & W. L. Miller (Eds.), Doing qualitative research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Monrouxe, L. V. (2009a). Negotiating professional identities: Dominant and contesting narratives in medical students’ longitudinal audio diaries. Current Narratives,1(1), 41–59.
Monrouxe, L. V. (2009b). Solicited audio diaries in longitudinal narrative research: A view from inside. Qualitative Research,9(1), 81–103.
Monrouxe, L. V. (2010). Identity, identification and medical education: Why should we care? Medical Education,44(1), 40–49.
Monrouxe, L. V., & Sweeny, K. (2013). Between two worlds: Medical students narrating identity tensions. In C. Figley, P. Huggard, & C. E. Rees (Eds.), First do no self-harm: Understanding and promoting physician stress resilience. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
O’Flynn, S., Power, S., Horgan, M., & O’Tuathaigh, C. M. P. (2014). Attitudes towards professionalism in graduate and non-graduate entrants to medical school. Education for Health,27(2), 200.
Otago Medical School. (2018). Medicine: Guidelines for admission. Retrieved February 2, 2017 from https://www.otago.ac.nz/healthsciences/students/professional/medicine/index.html.
Patterson, W. (2013). Narrative of events: Labovian narrative analysis. In M. Andrews, C. Squire, & M. Tamboukou (Eds.), Doing narrative events (pp. 27–46). London: Sage.
Patton, M. (2002). Qualitative research & evaluation methods (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Ricoeur, P. (1992). Oneself as another. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Riessman, C. (1993). Narrative analysis. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Riessman, C. K. (2003). Performing identities in illness narrative: Masculinity and multiple sclerosis. Qualitative Research,3(1), 5–33.
Riessman, C. (2008). Narrative methods for the human sciences. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Salmon, P., & Riessman, C. (2013). Looking back on narrative research: An exchange. In M. Andrews, C. Squire, & M. Tamboukou (Eds.), Doing narrative research (pp. 197–204). London: Sage.
Samuel, R., Shuen, A., Dendle, C., Kotsanas, D., Scott, C., & Stuart, R. (2012). Hierarchy and Hand Hygiene: Would medical students speak up to prevent hospital-acquired infection? Infection Control, Hospital Epidemiology,33(8), 861–863. https://doi.org/10.1086/666634.
Schwartz, S., Luyckx, K., & Vignoles, V. (Eds.). (2011). Handbook of identity theory and research: Volume 1 structures and processes. New York: Springer.
Shacklady, J., Holmes, E., Mason, G., Davies, I., & Dornan, T. (2009). Maturity and medical students’ ease of transition into the clinical environment. Medical Teacher,31(7), 621–626.
Sharpless, J., Baldwin, N., Cook, R., Kofman, A., Morley-Fletcher, A., Slotkin, R., et al. (2015). The becoming: Students’ reflections on the process of professional identity formation in medical education. Academic Medicine,90(6), 713–717.
Steier, F. (1991). Research and reflexivity. London: Sage.
van Ryn, M., Burgess, D., Malat, J., & Griffin, J. (2006). Physicians’ perceptions of patients’ social and behavioral characteristics and race disparities in treatment recommendations for men with coronary artery disease. American Journal of Public Health,96(2), 351–357.
van Ryn, M., & Burke, J. (2000). The effect of patient race and socio-economic status on physicians’ perceptions of patients. Social Science and Medicine,50(6), 813–828. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0277-9536(99)00338-X.
Warmington, S., & McColl, G. (2017). Medical student stories of participation in patient care-related activities: The construction of relational identity. Advances in Health Sciences Education,22(1), 147–163. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-016-9689-2.
Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Wong, A., & Trollope-Kumar, K. (2014). Reflections: An inquiry into medical students’ professional identity formation. Medical Education,48(5), 489–501.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to the medical students for providing their time to participate in this study at a difficult time of the year.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Matthews, R., Smith-Han, K. & Nicholson, H. From physiotherapy to the army: negotiating previously developed professional identities in mature medical students. Adv in Health Sci Educ 25, 607–627 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-019-09942-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-019-09942-0