Advertisement

Advances in Health Sciences Education

, Volume 23, Issue 2, pp 413–447 | Cite as

Group interventions to promote mental health in health professional education: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials

  • Kristin Lo
  • Jamie Waterland
  • Paula Todd
  • Tanvi Gupta
  • Margaret Bearman
  • Craig Hassed
  • Jennifer L. Keating
Review

Abstract

Effects of interventions for improving mental health of health professional students has not been established. This review analysed interventions to support mental health of health professional students and their effects. The full holdings of Medline, PsycINFO, EBM Reviews, Cinahl Plus, ERIC and EMBASE were searched until 15th April 2016. Inclusion criteria were randomised controlled trials of undergraduate and post graduate health professional students, group interventions to support mental health compared to alternative education, usual curriculum or no intervention; and post-intervention measurements for intervention and control participants of mindfulness, anxiety, depression, stress/distress or burnout. Studies were limited to English and short term effects. Studies were appraised using the PEDro scale. Data were synthesised using meta-analysis. Four comparisons were identified: psychoeducation or cognitive-behavioural interventions compared to alternative education, and mindfulness or relaxation compared to control conditions. Cognitive-behavioural interventions reduced anxiety (−0.26; −0.5 to −0.02), depression (−0.29; −0.52 to −0.05) and stress (0.37; −0.61 to −0.13). Mindfulness strategies reduced stress (−0.60; −0.97 to −0.22) but not anxiety (95% CI −0.21 to 0.18), depression (95% CI −0.36 to 0.03) or burnout (95% CI −0.36 to 0.10). Relaxation strategies reduced anxiety (SMD −0.80; 95% CI −1.03 to −0.58), depression (−0.49; −0.88 to −0.11) and stress (−0.34; −0.67 to −0.01). Method quality was generally poor. Evidence suggests that cognitive-behavioural, relaxation and mindfulness interventions may support health professional student mental health. Further high quality research is warranted.

Keywords

Mental health Health professional student Mindfulness Cognitive-behavioural Relaxation Psychoeducation Systematic review Meta-analysis 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We acknowledge the Traditional Custodians of our land and pay our respects to their Elders, past and present. Thank you to Tonya Jones for her assistance in data extraction.

References

  1. Aboalshamat, K., Hou, X.-Y., & Strodl, E. (2015). The impact of a self-development coaching programme on medical and dental students’ psychological health and academic performance: A randomised controlled trial. BMC Medical Education, 15, 134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Ahmed, I., Banu, H., Al-Fageer, R., & Al-Suwaidi, R. (2009). Cognitive emotions: Depression and anxiety in medical students and staff. Journal of Critical Care, 24, e1–e7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Balogun, J. A., Titiloye, V., Balogun, A., Oyeyemi, A., & Katz, J. (2002). Prevalence and determinants of burnout among physical and occupational therapists. Journal of Allied Health, 31, 131–139.Google Scholar
  4. Braithwaite, S. R., & Fincham, F. D. (2009). A randomized clinical trial of a computer based preventive intervention: Replication and extension of ePREP. Journal of Family Psychology, 23, 32–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3, 77–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Chen, Y., Yang, X., Wang, L., & Zhang, X. (2013). A randomized controlled trial of the effects of brief mindfulness meditation on anxiety symptoms and systolic blood pressure in Chinese nursing students. Nurse Education Today, 33(10), 1166–1172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. 2nd edn. New Jersey: Hillsdale.Google Scholar
  8. Cohen, S., Kamarck, T., & Mermelstein, R. (1983). A global measure of perceived stress. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 24, 385–396.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Conley, C. S., Durlak, J. A., & Dickson, D. A. (2013). An evaluative review of outcome research on universal mental health promotion and prevention programs for higher education students. Journal of American College Health, 61, 286–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Conley, C. S., Durlak, J. A., & Kirsch, A. C. (2015). A meta-analysis of universal mental health prevention programs for higher education students. Prevention Science, 16, 487–507.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Dayalan, H., Subramanian, S., & Elango, T. (2010). Psychological well-being in medical students during exam stress-influence of short-term practice of mind sound technology. Indian Journal of Medical Sciences, 64, 501–507.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. de Morton, N. A. (2009). The PEDro scale is a valid measure of the methodological quality of clinical trials: A demographic study. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy, 55, 129–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. de Vibe, M., Solhaug, I., Tyssen, R., Friborg, O., Rosenvinge, J. H., Sorlie, T., et al. (2013). Mindfulness training for stress management: A randomised controlled study of medical and psychology students. BMC Medical Education, 13, 107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. DiGiacomo, M., & Adamson, B. (2001). Coping with stress in the workplace: Implications for new health professionals. Journal of Allied Health, 30, 106–111.Google Scholar
  15. Dimou, P. A., Bacopoulou, F., Darviri, C., & Chrousos, G. P. (2014). Stress management and sexual health of young adults: A pilot randomised controlled trial. Andrologia, 46, 1022–1031.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Dyrbye, L. N., Harper, W., Moutier, C., Durning, S., Power, D., Massie, F. S., et al. (2012). A multi-institutional study exploring the impact of positive mental health on medical students’ professionalism in an era of high burnout. Academic Medicine, 87, 1024–1031.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Dyrbye, L. N., Thomas, M. R., & Shanafelt, T. D. (2005). Medical student distress: Causes, consequences, and proposed solutions. Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 80, 1613–1622.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Dyrbye, L. N., Thomas, M. R., & Shanafelt, T. D. (2006). Systematic review of depression, anxiety, and other indicators of psychological distress among U.S. and Canadian medical students. Academic Medicine, 81, 354–373.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Erogul, M., Singer, G., McIntyre, T., & Stefanov, D. G. (2014). Abridged mindfulness intervention to support wellness in first-year medical students. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 26, 350–356.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Fahrenkopf, A. M., Sectish, T. C., Barger, L. K., Sharek, P. J., Lewin, D., Chiang, V. W., et al. (2008). Rates of medication errors among depressed and burnt out residents: Prospective cohort study. BMJ, 336, 488–491.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Farrer, L., Gulliver, A., Chan, J. K., Batterham, P. J., Reynolds, J., Calear, A., et al. (2013). Technology-based interventions for mental health in tertiary students: Systematic review. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 15, e101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Fjorback, L. O., Arendt, M., Ornbol, E., Fink, P., & Walach, H. (2011). Mindfulness-based stress reduction and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Acta Psychiatrica Scand, 124, 102–119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Frazier, P., Meredith, L., Greer, C., Paulsen, J. A., Howard, K., Dietz, L. R., et al. (2015). Randomized controlled trial evaluating the effectiveness of a web-based stress management program among community college students. Anxiety, Stress & Coping: An International Journal, 28, 576–586.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Greene, Y., & Hiebert, B. (1988). A comparison of mindfulness meditation and cognitive self-observation. Canadian Journal of Counselling, 22, 25–34.Google Scholar
  25. Green, S.& Higgins, J. P. T. (2011). In Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 5.1.0. (Vol. pp.) The Cochrane Collaboration Version.Google Scholar
  26. Heaman, D. (1995). The quieting response (QR): A modality for reduction of psychophysiologic stress in nursing students. Journal of Nursing Education, 34, 5–9.Google Scholar
  27. Hedges, L. V. (1981). Distribution theory for glass’s estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics, 6, 107–128.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Higgins, J. P., Thompson, S. G., Deeks, J. J., & Altman, D. G. (2003). Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. British Medical Journal, 327, 557.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hintz, S., Frazier, P. A., & Meredith, L. (2015). Evaluating an online stress management intervention for college students. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 62, 137.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hope, V., & Henderson, M. (2014). Medical student depression, anxiety and distress outside North America: A systematic review. Medical Education, 48, 963–979.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hughes, L. C., Romick, P., Sandor, M. K., Phillips, C. A., Glaister, J., Levy, K., et al. (2003). Evaluation of an informal peer group experience on baccalaureate nursing students’ emotional well-being and professional socialization. Journal of Professional Nursing, 19, 38–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. IsHak, W., Nikravesh, R., Lederer, S., Perry, R., Ogunyemi, D., & Bernstein, C. (2013). Burnout in medical students: A systematic review. The Clinical Teacher, 10, 242–245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Jain, S., Shapiro, S. L., Swanick, S., Roesch, S. C., Mills, P. J., Bell, I., et al. (2007). A randomized controlled trial of mindfulness meditation versus relaxation training: Effects on distress, positive states of mind, rumination, and distraction. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 33, 11–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Johansson, N. (1991). Effectiveness of a stress management program in reducing anxiety and depression in nursing students. Journal of American College Health, 40, 125–129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Jones, M. C., & Johnston, D. W. (2000). Evaluating the impact of a worksite stress management programme for distressed student nurses: A randomised controlled trial. Psychology & Health, 15, 689–706.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Jorm, A. F., Morgan, A. J., & Hetrick, S. E. (2008). Relaxation for depression. The Cochrane Library.Google Scholar
  37. Kanji, N., White, A., & Ernst, E. (2006). Autogenic training to reduce anxiety in nursing students: Randomized controlled trial. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 53, 729–735.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Kiecolt-Glaser, J. K., Glaser, R., Strain, E. C., Stout, J. C., Tarr, K. L., Holliday, J. E., et al. (1986). Modulation of cellular immunity in medical students. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 9, 5–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Lo, K., Curtis, H., Francis-Cracknell, A., Maloney, S., Keating, J., & Bearman, M. (2015). Plan B: Clinicians’ perceptions of an innovative Fitness to Practise program. In Association of medical educators Europe (AMEE) conference. (Ed.), (Vol. pp.) Glasgow September 5–9.Google Scholar
  40. Manzoni, G. M., Pagnini, F., Castelnuovo, G., & Molinari, E. (2008). Relaxation training for anxiety: A 10-years systematic review with meta-analysis. BMC Psychiatry, 8, 1–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Maslach, C., & Jackson, S. E. (1981). The measurement of experienced burnout. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2, 99–113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. McGrady, A., Brennan, J., Lynch, D., & Whearty, K. (2012). A wellness program for first year medical students. Applied Psychophysiology & Biofeedback, 37, 253–260.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., & Altman, D. G. (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Med, 6, e1000097.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Neumann, M., Edelhäuser, F., Tauschel, D., Fischer, M. R., Wirtz, M., Woopen, C., et al. (2011). Empathy decline and its reasons: A systematic review of studies with medical students and residents. Academic Medicine, 86, 996–1009.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Paholpak, S., Piyavhatkul, N., Rangseekajee, P., Krisanaprakornkit, T., Arunpongpaisal, S., Pajanasoontorn, N., et al. (2012). Breathing meditation by medical students at Khon Kaen University: Effect on psychiatric symptoms, memory, intelligence and academic achievement. Journal of the Medical Association of Thailand, 95, 461–469.Google Scholar
  46. Porter, S., & Johnson, A. (2008). Increasing paramedic students’ resiliency to stress: Assessing correlates and the impact of intervention. College Quarterly, 11, 13.Google Scholar
  47. Ratanasiripong, P., Park, J. F., Ratanasiripong, N., & Kathalae, D. (2015). Stress and anxiety management in nursing students: Biofeedback and mindfulness meditation. Journal of Nursing Education, 54, 520–524.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Regehr, C., Glancy, D., & Pitts, A. (2013). Interventions to reduce stress in university students: A review and meta-analysis. Journal of Affective Disorders, 148, 1–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Roberts, L. W., Warner, T. D., Carter, D., Frank, E., Ganzini, L., & Lyketsos, C. (2000). Caring for medical students as patients: Access to services and care-seeking practices of 1027 students at nine medical schools. Academic Medicine, 75, 272–277.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Rudman, A., & Gustavsson, J. P. (2012). Burnout during nursing education predicts lower occupational preparedness and future clinical performance: A longitudinal study. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 49, 988–1001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Seritan, A., Hunt, J., Shy, A., Rea, M., & Worley, L. (2012). The state of medical student wellness: A call for culture change. Academic Psychiatry, 36(1), 7–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Shapiro, S. L., Schwartz, G. E., & Bonner, G. (1998). Effects of mindfulness-based stress reduction on medical and premedical students. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 21, 581–599.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Shapiro, S. L., Shapiro, D. E., & Schwartz, G. E. (2000). Stress management in medical education: A review of the literature. Academic Medicine, 75, 748–759.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Spielberger, C. D., Gorsuch, R. L., Lushene, R. E., & Vagg, P. R. (1970). State-trait anxiety inventory (STAI). BiB, 2010, 180.Google Scholar
  55. Stroebel, C. F. (1983). QR, the quieting reflex. Berkley Trade Pub: Berkley.Google Scholar
  56. Struber, J. C. (2003). Physiotherapy in Australia—Where to now. The internet Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice, 1, 2.Google Scholar
  57. Unno, K., Tanida, N., Ishii, N., Yamamoto, H., Iguchi, K., Hoshino, M., et al. (2013). Anti-stress effect of theanine on students during pharmacy practice: Positive correlation among salivary (alpha)-amylase activity, trait anxiety and subjective stress. Pharmacology, Biochemistry and Behavior, 111, 128–135.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Van Der Heijden, F., Dillingh, G., Bakker, A., & Prins, J. (2008). Suicidal thoughts among medical residents with burnout. Arch Suicide Research, 12, 344–346.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Warnecke, E., Quinn, S., Ogden, K., Towle, N., & Nelson, M. R. (2011). A randomised controlled trial of the effects of mindfulness practice on medical student stress levels. Medical Education, 45, 381–388.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Whitehouse, W. G., Dinges, D. F., Orne, E. C., Keller, S. E., Bates, B. L., Bauer, N. K., et al. (1996). Psychosocial and immune effects of self-hypnosis training for stress management throughout the first semester of medical school. Psychosomatic Medicine, 58, 249–263.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Williams, D., Tricomi, G., Gupta, J., & Janise, A. (2014). Efficacy of burnout interventions in the medical education pipeline. Academic Psychiatry, 39, 47–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. World Health Organisation (2014). Mental health: A state of wellbeing. In (ed.), (Vol. pp.).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  • Kristin Lo
    • 1
  • Jamie Waterland
    • 1
  • Paula Todd
    • 2
  • Tanvi Gupta
    • 3
  • Margaret Bearman
    • 4
  • Craig Hassed
    • 5
  • Jennifer L. Keating
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of PhysiotherapyMonash UniversityMelbourneAustralia
  2. 2.Subject Librarian, Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health SciencesMonash UniversityMelbourneAustralia
  3. 3.South Eastern Private HospitalMelbourneAustralia
  4. 4.HealthPEER Monash UniversityMelbourneAustralia
  5. 5.Department of General PracticeMonash UniversityMelbourneAustralia

Personalised recommendations