Abstract
The US National Residency Matching Program (NRMP) is a computerized, national system for matching residency applicants to programs. Similar systems exist in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, and the need for such a program will probably make itself felt in the European Union soon. NRMP is an important laboratory for the ethical challenges that computerized matching programs create, especially its current prohibition of making commitments by both applicants and residency programs. Nonetheless, it would be denial to suppose that commitments are not being made and that there is no dishonesty when commitments are made. We analyze the current NRMP no-commitment policy by reference to Plato’s retelling of the myth of the Ring of Gyges, which makes its wearer physically invisible and therefore ethically unaccountable. Because applicants and programs complete their preference-lists in secret, the matching process inadvertently slips a Ring of Gyges on the fingers of both parties. As a result, making false commitments promotes the rational self-interest of both parties. To strengthen the professional integrity of the matching process, we argue that NRMP should abandon its no-commitment policy and adopt a new paradigm: sanctioning honest, non-contingent, accountable, one-party, and documented commitments. Computerized residency matching systems in other countries should consider the NRMP a laboratory and develop policies about making commitments that promote professionalism in the residency application process.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Chervenak, F. A., & McCullough, L. B. (2005). The diagnosis and management of progressive dysfunction of health care organizations. Obstetrics and Gynecology, 105, 882–887.
Delamothe, T. (2007). Why the UK’s medical training application service failed. BMJ (Clinical Research Ed.), 334, 543–544. doi:10.1136/bmj.39154.476956.BE.
Delamothe, T. (2008). Modernising medical careers: Final report. BMJ (Clinical Research Ed.), 336, 54–55. doi:10.1136/bmj.39455.401817.80.
Facheris, M., Mancuso, M., Scaravilli, T., & Bonifati, M. (2005). Neurology residency training in Europe: An Italian perspective. Lancet Neurology, 4, 258–262. doi:10.1016/S1474-4422(05)70046-6.
Jeffries, R. (2007). Selection for specialist training: What can we learn from other countries? BMJ (Clinical Research Ed.), 334, 1302–1304. doi:10.1136/bmj.39238.447338.AD.
Konstantakos, E. K., Laughlin, R. T., Markert, R. J., & Crosby, L. A. (2007). Follow-up on misrepresentation of research activity orthopaedic residency applicants: Has anything changed? The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. American volume, 89, 2084–2088. doi:10.2106/JBJS.G.00567.
Loewenstein, G., Brennan, T., & Volpp, K. G. (2007). Asymmetric paternalism to improve health behaviors. Journal of the American Medical Association, 298, 2415–2417. doi:10.1001/jama.298.20.2415.
McCullough, L. B. (2006). The ethical concept of medicine as a profession: its origins in modern medical ethics and implications for physicians. In N. Kenny & W. Shelton (Eds.), Lost virtue: Professional character development in medical education (pp. 17–27). New York: Elsevier.
National Practitioner Data Bank. (2009). Available at http://www.npdb-hipdb.hrsa.gov/. Accessed 13 May 2009.
National Residency Match Program. (2009). http://www.nrmp.org. Accessed 13 May 2009.
National Residency Matching Program. (2009). NRMP statement on professionalism. Available at http://www.nrmp.org/res_match/policies/professionalism.html. Accessed 13 May 2009.
Phillips, R. L. Jr., Phillips, K. A., Chen, F. M., & Mellilo, A. (2003). Exploring residency match violations in family practice. Family Medicine, 35, 717–720.
Plato. (1969). Republic. In E. Hamilton & H. Cairns (Eds.), The collected dialogues of Plato including the letters (Bollingen Series LXXI, pp. 575–844). Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Tolkien, J. R. R. (2001). The lord of the rings. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
R. Cefalo (1934–2008)—Deceased.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chervenak, F.A., McCullough, L.B. & Cefalo, R. An ethical justification and policy for making commitments during computerized residency application processes: The US matching program as a laboratory for needed reform. Adv in Health Sci Educ 16, 427–433 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-009-9167-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-009-9167-1