Abstract
Ranked purely on the basis of the available reliable and valid measures, the demographic composition of incoming medical students fails to meet societal concerns regarding under-represented minorities (URM). Admissions offices are squeezed, administratively and legally, between honouring objectively measured individual merit and addressing societal needs. Until more successful recruitment and preparation of URM applicants closes that gap, compromise methods balancing those discordant ideals can be applied. Indeed, as progress over time decreases the relative societal need for affirmative action, compromise methods are mandated by no less a voice than that of the United States Supreme Court. This article proffers one such method, based upon the work of Hofstee, and demonstrates how it can be practically applied to a specific URM challenge. As perspective, past and present philosophical approaches to this discordance are categorized.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.References
2020 Vision: Moving Forward with a Good Mind. Report from the September 28–29, 2004 Symposium, held at Six Nations of Grand River, co-hosted by Six Nations and McMaster University, co-chaired by the Honourable Roy J. Romanow and Chief Roberta Jamieson
Beuk C.H. (1984). A method for reaching a compromise between absolute and relative standards in examinations. Journal of Educational Measurement 21: 147–152
Cespedes v. University of Toronto 2004 CarswellOnt 575, (2004) 182 O.A.C. 390 (Ont. Div. Ct.)
Cusimano M.D. and Rothman A.I. (2003). The effect of incorporating normative data into a criterion-referenced standard setting in medical education. Academic Medicine 78: S88–S90
Dawes R.M. (1971). A case study of graduate admission: Application of three principles of human decision-making. American Psychologist 26: 180–188
(1985). Compromise models for establishing examination standards. Journal of Educational Measurement. 4: 263–269
Dershowitz, A.M., 2002 Treatment of Israel strikes an alien note. Jewish World Review Nov 8
Duffin J. (2002). The quota: “An equally serious problem” for us all. Canadian Bulletin of Medical History 19: 327–349
Edelin K.C. and Ugbolue A. (2001). Evaluation of an early medical school selection program for underrepresented minority students. Academic Medicine 76: 1056–1059
Eva K.W., Reiter H.I., Rosenfeld J. and Norman G.R. (2004a). The ability of the Multiple Mini-Interview to predict pre-clerkship performance in medical school. Academic Medicine 79: S40–S42
Eva K.W., Rosenfeld J., Reiter H.I. and Norman G.R. (2004b). An admissions OSCE: The Multiple Mini-Interview. Medical Education 38: 314–326
Gafni, N. & Allalouf, A. Score analysis of the non-cognitive measures used in student selection for medical schools. Presented April 12, 2005 at the 2005. Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association
Gratz et al. v. Bollinger et al. (2003). 539 U.S. 244
Grutter v. Bollinger et al. (2003). 539 U.S. 306, 123
Hofstee W.K.B. (1983). The case for compromise in educational selection and grading. In: Anderson, S.B. and Helmick, J.S. (eds) On Educational Testing, pp. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco
Johnson L. (1998). Minorities in medical school and national medical fellowships, Inc.: 50 years and counting. Academic Medicine 73: 1044–1051
Julian E. (2005). Validity of the Medical College Admission Test for predicting medical school performance. Academic Medicine 80: 910–917
Koenig J.A., Sireci S.G. and Wiley A. (1998). Evaluating the predictive validity of MCAT scores across diverse applicant groups. Academic Medicine 73: 1095–1106
Kulatunga-Moruzi C. and Norman G.R. (2002). Validity of admissions measures in predicting performance outcomes: The contribution of cognitive and non-cognitive dimensions. Teaching and Learning in Medicine 14: 34–42
Marrin M.L., McIntosh K.A., Keane D. and Schmuck M.L. (2004). Use of the paired-comparison technique to determine the most valued qualities of the McMaster medical programme admissions process. Advances in Health Sciences Education 9: 129–135
McGaghie W.C., Downing S.M. and Kubilius R. (2004). What is the impact of commercial test preparation courses on medical examination performance. Teaching and Learning in Medicine 16: 202–211
McGaghie W.C and Kreiter C.D. (2005). Holistic versus actuarial student selection. Teaching and Learning in Medicine 17: 89–91
Meehl P.E. (1954). Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
Moreau K., Reiter H. and Eva K.W. (2006). Comparison of aboriginal and non-aboriginal applicants for admissions on the multiple mini-interview using aboriginal and non-aboriginal interviewers. Teaching and Learning in Medicine 18: 58–61
Pieters v. University of Toronto (2003). 3 Admin L.R. (4t) 21
Regents of University of California v. Bakke (1978). 438 U.S. 265
Sarbin T.R. (1942). A contribution to the study of actuarial and individual methods of prediction. American Journal of Sociology 48: 593–602
Schofield W. and Garrard J. (1975). Longitudinal study of medical students selected for admission to medical school by actuarial and committee methods. British Journal of Medical Education 9: 86–90
Strayhorn G. and Demby K. (1999). Do pre-admission programs make a difference in the enrollment of underrepresented-minority students at U.S. medical schools?. Academic Medicine 74: 431–434
Tekian A. (1998). Attrition rates of underrepresented minority students at the University of Illinois at Chicago College of Medicine, 1993–1997. Academic Medicine 73: 336–338
Thomson W.A. and Denk J.P. (1999). Promoting diversity in the medical school pipeline: A national overview. Academic Medicine 74: 312–314
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/anti-semitism/harvard.html on 12/30/2004, sourced from American Jewish Historical Society
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Reiter, H., MacCoon, K. A Compromise Method to Facilitate Under-Represented Minority Admissions to Medical School. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract 12, 223–237 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-006-0002-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10459-006-0002-7