Abstract
The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of wearing older, lower-ranked football helmets (LRank) to wearing newer, higher-ranked football helmets (HRank) on pre- to post-season changes in cortical thickness in response to repetitive head impacts and assess whether changes in cortical thickness are associated with head impact exposure for either helmet type. 105 male high-school athletes (NHRank = 52, NLRank = 53) wore accelerometers affixed behind the left mastoid during all practices and games for one regular season of American football to monitor head impact exposure. Pre- and post-season magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) were completed to assess longitudinal changes in cortical thickness. Significant reductions in cortical thickness (i.e., cortical thinning) were observed pre- to post-season for each group, but these longitudinal alterations were not significantly different between the LRank and HRank groups. Further, significant group-by-head impact exposure interactions were observed when predicting changes in cortical thickness. Specifically, a greater frequency of high magnitude head impacts during the football season resulted in greater cortical thinning for the LRank group, but not for the HRank group. These data provide preliminary in vivo evidence that HRank helmets may provide a buffer between the specific effect of high magnitude head impacts on regional thinning by dissipating forces more evenly throughout the cortex. However, future research with larger sample sizes, increased longitudinal measures and additional helmet technologies is warranted to both expand upon and further validate the present study findings.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- LRank:
-
Lower-ranked football helmets
- HRank:
-
Higher-ranked football helmets
- SRC:
-
Sports-related concussion
- DTI:
-
Diffusion tensor imaging
- fMRI:
-
Functional magnetic resonance imaging
- NOCSAE:
-
National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment
References
Adler, C. M., M. P. DelBello, W. Weber, M. Williams, L. R. P. Duran, D. Fleck, E. Boespflug, J. Eliassen, S. M. Strakowski, and J. Divine. MRI evidence of neuropathic changes in former college football players. Clin. J. Sport Med. 28:100–105, 2018
Bahrami, N., D. Sharma, S. Rosenthal, E. M. Davenport, J. E. Urban, B. Wagner, Y. Jung, C. G. Vaughan, G. A. Gioia, J. D. Stitzel, C. T. Whitlow, and J. A. Maldjian. Subconcussive head impact exposure and white matter tract changes over a single season of youth football. Radiology. 281:919–926, 2016
Bailey, A. M., T. L. McMurry, J. M. Cormier, J. R. Funk, J. R. Crandall, C. D. Mack, B. S. Myers, and K. B. Arbogast. Comparison of laboratory and on-field performance of american football helmets. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 48:2531–2541, 2020
Bailey, A. M., E. J. Sanchez, G. Park, L. F. Gabler, J. R. Funk, J. R. Crandall, M. Wonnacott, C. Withnall, B. S. Myers, and K. B. Arbogast. Development and evaluation of a test method for assessing the performance of American football helmets. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 48:2566–2579, 2020
Barber-Foss, K. D., W. Yuan, J. A. Diekfuss, J. Leach, W. P. Meehan III., C. A. DiCesare, G. Solomon, D. K. Schneider, J. MacDonaled, J. A. Dudley, N. Cortes, R. Galloway, M. Halstead, G. Walker, and G. D. Myer. Relative head impact exposure and brain white matter alterations after a single season of competitive football: a comparison of youth versus high school football. Clinical Journal of Sports Medicine. 29:442–450, 2019
Bazarian, J. J., T. Zhu, J. Zhong, D. Janigro, E. Rozen, A. Roberts, H. Javien, K. Merchant-Borna, B. Abar, and E. G. Blackman. Persistent, long-term cerebral white matter changes after sports-related repetitive head impacts. PLoS ONE. 9:e94734, 2014
Churchill, N. W., M. G. Hutchison, A. P. Di Battista, S. J. Graham, and T. A. Schweizer. Structural, functional, and metabolic brain markers differentiate collision versus contact and non-contact athletes. Front. Neurol. 8:390, 2017
Dahnke, R., R. A. Yotter, and C. Gaser. Cortical thickness and central surface estimation. Neuroimage. 65:336–348, 2013
Davenport, E. M., C. T. Whitlow, J. E. Urban, M. A. Espeland, Y. Jung, D. A. Rosenbaum, G. A. Gioia, A. K. Powers, J. D. Stitzel, and J. A. Maldjian. Abnormal white matter integrity related to head impact exposure in a season of high school varsity football. J. Neurotrauma. 31:1617–1624, 2014
DeKosky, S. T., M. D. Ikonomovic, and S. Gandy. Traumatic brain injury–football, warfare, and long-term effects. N. Engl. J. Med. 363:1293–1296, 2010
Diekfuss, J. A., W. Yuan, K. D. Barber Foss, J. A. Dudley, C. A. DiCesare, D. L. Reddington, W. Zhong, K. S. Nissen, J. L. Shafer, J. L. Leach, S. Bonnette, K. Logan, J. N. Epstein, J. Clark, M. Altaye, and G. D. Myer. The effects of internal jugular vein compression for modulating and preserving white matter following a season of American tackle football: a prospective longitudinal evaluation of differential head impact exposure. J. Neurosci. Res. 99:423–445, 2021
Diekfuss, J. A., W. Yuan, J. A. Dudley, C. A. DiCesare, M. B. Panzer, T. M. Talavage, E. Nauman, S. Bonnette, A. B. Slutsky-Ganesh, J. Clark, M. Anand, M. Altaye, J. L. Leach, J. D. Lamplot, M. Galloway, M. W. Pombo, K. E. Hammond, and G. D. Myer. Evaluation of the effectiveness of newer helmet designs with emergent shell and padding technologies versus older helmet models for preserving white matter following a season of high school football. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 49:2863–2874, 2021
Dudley, J., W. Yuan, J. Diekfuss, K. D. Barber Foss, C. A. DiCesare, M. Altaye, K. Logan, J. L. Leach, and G. D. Myer. Altered functional and structural connectomes in female high school soccer athletes after a season of head impact exposure and the effect of a novel collar. Brain Connect. 10:292–301, 2020
Fortin, J. P., N. Cullen, Y. I. Sheline, W. D. Taylor, I. Aselcioglu, P. A. Cook, P. Adams, C. Cooper, M. Fava, P. J. McGrath, M. McInnis, M. L. Phillips, M. H. Trivedi, M. M. Weissman, and R. T. Shinohara. Harmonization of cortical thickness measurements across scanners and sites. Neuroimage. 167:104–120, 2018
Giudice, J. S., A. Caudillo, S. Mukherjee, K. Kong, G. Park, R. Kent, and M. B. Panzer. Finite Element Model of a Deformable American Football Helmet Under Impact. Ann Biomed Eng. 48:1524–1539, 2020
Grydeland, H., K. B. Walhovd, C. K. Tamnes, L. T. Westlye, and A. M. Fjell. Intracortical myelin links with performance variability across the human lifespan: results from T1- and T2-weighted MRI myelin mapping and diffusion tensor imaging. J. Neurosci. 33:18618–18630, 2013
Hirad, A. A., J. J. Bazarian, K. Merchant-Borna, F. E. Garcea, S. Heilbronner, D. Paul, E. B. Hintz, E. van Wijngaarden, G. Schifitto, and D. W. Wright. A common neural signature of brain injury in concussion and subconcussion. Sci. Adv. 5:eaau3460, 2019
Howell, D. R., M. Beasley, L. Vopat, and W. P. Meehan 3rd. The effect of prior concussion history on dual-task gait following a concussion. J. Neurotrauma. 34:838–844, 2017
Huttenlocher, P. R., and A. S. Dabholkar. Regional differences in synaptogenesis in human cerebral cortex. J. Comput. Neurol. 387:167–178, 1997
Koerte, I. K., M. Mayinger, M. Muehlmann, D. Kaufmann, A. P. Lin, D. Steffinger, B. Fisch, B. S. Rauchmann, S. Immler, S. Karch, F. R. Heinen, B. Ertl-Wagner, M. Reiser, R. A. Stern, R. Zafonte, and M. E. Shenton. Cortical thinning in former professional soccer players. Brain Imaging Behav. 10:792–798, 2016
MacDonald, J., and G. D. Myer. “Don’t let kids play football”: a killer idea. Br. J. Sports Med. 51:1448–1449, 2017
Mayinger, M. C., K. Merchant-Borna, J. Hufschmidt, M. Muehlmann, I. R. Weir, B. S. Rauchmann, M. E. Shenton, I. K. Koerte, and J. J. Bazarian. White matter alterations in college football players: a longitudinal diffusion tensor imaging study. Brain Imaging Behav. 12:44–53, 2018
McAllister, T. W., J. C. Ford, L. A. Flashman, A. Maerlender, R. M. Greenwald, J. G. Beckwith, R. P. Bolander, T. D. Tosteson, J. H. Turco, and R. Raman. Effect of head impacts on diffusivity measures in a cohort of collegiate contact sport athletes. Neurology. 82:63–69, 2014
Meier, T. B., P. S. Bellgowan, M. Bergamino, J. M. Ling, and A. R. Mayer. Thinner cortex in collegiate football players with, but not without, a self-reported history of concussion. J. Neurotrauma. 33:330–338, 2016
Mills, B. D., M. Goubran, S. N. Parivash, E. L. Dennis, P. Rezaii, C. Akers, W. Bian, L. A. Mitchell, B. Boldt, D. Douglas, S. Sami, N. Mouchawar, E. W. Wilson, P. DiGiacomo, M. Parekh, H. Do, J. Lopez, J. Rosenberg, D. Camarillo, G. Grant, M. Wintermark, and M. Zeineh. Longitudinal alteration of cortical thickness and volume in high-impact sports. Neuroimage. 217:116864, 2020
Myer, G. D., W. Yuan, K. D. Barber Foss, D. Smith, M. Altaye, A. Reches, J. Leach, A. W. Kiefer, J. C. Khoury, M. Weiss, S. Thomas, C. Dicesare, J. Adams, P. J. Gubanich, A. Geva, J. F. Clark, W. P. Meehan 3rd., J. P. Mihalik, and D. Krueger. The effects of external jugular compression applied during head impact exposure on longitudinal changes in brain neuroanatomical and neurophysiological biomarkers: a preliminary investigation. Front Neurol. 7:74, 2016
Myer, G. D., W. Yuan, K. D. Barber-Foss, S. Thomas, D. Smith, J. Leach, A. W. Kiefer, C. Dicesare, J. Adams, P. J. Gubanich, K. Kitchen, D. K. Schneider, D. Braswell, D. Krueger, and M. Altaye. Analysis of head impact exposure and brain microstructure response in a season-long application of a jugular vein compression collar: a prospective, neuroimaging investigation in American football. Br. J. Sports Med. 50:1276–1285, 2016
NFL. https://www.nfl.com/playerhealthandsafety/equipment-and-innovation/equipment-testing/helmet-laboratory-testing-performance-results. NFL Enterprises LLC, 2021.
O’Connor, K. L., S. Rowson, S. M. Duma, and S. P. Broglio. Head-impact–measurement devices: a systematic review. J. Athlet. Train. 52:206–227, 2017
Pacheco, J., J. O. Goh, M. A. Kraut, L. Ferrucci, and S. M. Resnick. Greater cortical thinning in normal older adults predicts later cognitive impairment. Neurobiol. Aging. 36:903–908, 2015
Parker, N., Y. Patel, A. P. Jackowski, P. M. Pan, G. A. Salum, Z. Pausova, and T. Paus. Assessment of neurobiological mechanisms of cortical thinning during childhood and adolescence and their implications for psychiatric disorders. JAMA Psychiatry. 77:1127–1136, 2020
Rowson, S. https://helmet.beam.vt.edu/varsity-football-helmet-ratings.html. Virginia Tech Biomedical Engineering and Mechanics, 2021.
Rowson, S., and S. M. Duma. The Virginia tech response. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 40:2512–2518, 2012
Rowson, S., S. M. Duma, R. M. Greenwald, J. G. Beckwith, J. J. Chu, K. M. Guskiewicz, J. P. Mihalik, J. J. Crisco, B. J. Wilcox, T. W. McAllister, A. C. Maerlender, S. P. Broglio, B. Schnebel, S. Anderson, and P. G. Brolinson. Can helmet design reduce the risk of concussion in football? J. Neurosurg. 120:919–922, 2014
Schneider, D. K., R. Galloway, J. J. Bazarian, J. A. Diekfuss, J. A. Dudley, J. L. Leach, R. Mannix, T. M. Talavage, W. Yuan, and G. D. Myer. Diffusion Tensor Imaging in Athletes Sustaining Repetitive Head Impacts: A Systematic Review of Prospective Studies. IL: Radiological Society of North America. Chicago, 2019
Slobounov, S. M., A. Walter, H. C. Breiter, D. C. Zhu, X. Bai, T. Bream, P. Seidenberg, X. Mao, B. Johnson, and T. M. Talavage. The effect of repetitive subconcussive collisions on brain integrity in collegiate football players over a single football season: a multi-modal neuroimaging study. Neuroimage. 14:708–718, 2017
Smith, S. M., and T. E. Nichols. Threshold-free cluster enhancement: addressing problems of smoothing, threshold dependence and localisation in cluster inference. Neuroimage. 44:83–98, 2009
Sproule, D. W., E. T. Campolettano, and S. Rowson. Football helmet impact standards in relation to on-field impacts. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. P. 231:317–323, 2017
Vidal-Pineiro, D., N. Parker, J. Shin, L. French, H. Grydeland, A. P. Jackowski, A. M. Mowinckel, Y. Patel, Z. Pausova, G. Salum, O. Sorensen, K. B. Walhovd, T. Paus, and A. M. Fjell. Cellular correlates of cortical thinning throughout the lifespan. Sci. Rep. 10:21803, 2020
Yotter, R. A., R. Dahnke, P. M. Thompson, and C. Gaser. Topological correction of brain surface meshes using spherical harmonics. Hum. Brain Mapp. 32:1109–1124, 2011
Yuan, W., K. D. Barber-Foss, S. Thomas, C. A. DiCesare, J. A. Dudley, K. Kitchen, B. Gadd, J. L. Leach, D. Smith, M. Altaye, P. Gubanich, R. T. Galloway, P. McCrory, J. E. Bailes, R. Mannix, W. P. Meehan 3rd., and G. D. Myer. White matter alterations over the course of two consecutive high-school football seasons and the effect of a jugular compression collar: a preliminary longitudinal diffusion tensor imaging study. Hum. Brain Mapp. 39:491–508, 2018
Yuan, W., J. Leach, T. Maloney, M. Altaye, D. Smith, P. J. Gubanich, K. D. Barber-Foss, S. Thomas, C. A. DiCesare, A. W. Kiefer, and G. D. Myer. Neck collar with mild jugular vein compression ameliorates brain activation changes during a working memory task after a season of high school football. J. Neurotrauma. 34:2432–2444, 2017
Zhou, D., C. Lebel, S. Treit, A. Evans, and C. Beaulieu. Accelerated longitudinal cortical thinning in adolescence. Neuroimage. 104:138–145, 2015
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank our outstanding collaborators and support staff that made this large-scale investigation possible. While it would be difficult to acknowledge all that contributed to the success with the project, there are those with specific contributions we would like to mention. At Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center we would like to thank faculty members, Brian Coley, Charles Dumoulin, Kim Cecil, Megan Narad, and Paul Gubanich; MRI technologists Lacey Haas, Brynne Williams, Matthew Lanier, Kaley Bridgewater, Elizabeth Fugate, and Marty Jones; MRI engineering and technical support Hui Wang, Zach Heeger, Dennis Flage; staff members Staci Thomas, Sarah Orban, John Simon, Ryan MacPherson, Katie Kitchen, Katherine Kinsella, James Lynch, and Brooke Gadd. We also express our sincere gratitude to the University of Cincinnati medical student interns, Anna Saltman, Brent Waibel, Madeline Engeler, and Ramsey Sabbagh; undergraduate/graduate student interns from various universities including, Dan Braswell, Nicholas Slaboden, Emma Hansen, Ashley Doud, Lila Wright, Nicholas Zenger, Omar Brijawi, Austin Tiernan, Jennifer Shine, Sydney Hamilton, Saed Mustif, Bradley Jacobs, Enna Selmanovic, Kia Hreno, Emily Hornback, Meghan Swearingen, Kristen Jansen, Savannah Bacon, Nicole Veselitis, Samantha Simms, Cody McMillian, Daniel Riveros Molina, Morgan Froelich, Eric Schmitz, Jordan Maxwell, Philip Wienkamp, Teresa Rust, Courtney Johnson, Walker Engelhard, Kelsey Laizure, John Rizk, Victoria Colacicco, Megan Sloboda, Jessica Culbertson, Elizabeth Reddington, Dylan Kirby, Brady Tincher, Abby Odachowski, Hima Devgan. Importantly we want to acknowledge and thank student advisors Dan Carl and Susan Kotowski who were critical to help manage and facilitate the student opportunities to participate on this project. We also express our thanks to the school athletic trainers Mike McCafferty, Craig Lindsey, Dan Forcum, Alex Popken, Katie Taylor, James Muncy, Nathalie Towchik, Alli King, Cindy Busse, Kayla Taske, Becky White, Rebecca Lemmel, Joe Lucas, Mike Gordon, Ken Rushford and Al Ducker; the school athletic directors Rob Heise, Mike Asbeck, Keith Pantling, Tony Hemmelgarn, Steve Ellison, Jan Wilking, Wendy Smith, Kim Gunning, Diane Redmond, Mark Schenkel, Eric Taylor, and Brian Reinhart; school coaches Mike Orlando, Doug Rosfeld, Patrick McLaughlin, Kevin Spraul, Gerry Beauchamp, Tino Mam, Aaron Hancock, Karen Wood, Marissa Wolf, Dave Ruehl, Keith Schaeper, Kiersten Johnson, Heather Vibberts, Mark Mueller, and Steve Spect; team physicians Dr. Stanfield, Dr. Kremcheck, Dr. Buerger, D. Argo, Dr. Rice, Dr. Altenau, Dr. Kevin Reilly, Dr. Eugene Reilly, Dr. Patrick Reilly, Dr. Noyes, Dr, Galloway, Dr. Cha, and Dr. Linz. We also express our thanks to Ed Lodge who helped with accelerometers and Jamison Float for neck collar fitting. Lastly, we express our appreciation to the football players and families from the following high schools for being supportive of our mission to keep athletes safe during sport by engaging and participating in this research project: McNicholas, Archbishop Moeller, LaSalle, Oak Hills, Walnut Hills, Wyoming, Seton, St. Ursula Academy, Ursuline Academy, Mount Notre Dame, St. Xavier, and Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy.
Conflict of interest
Q30 Sports Innovations, LLC funded Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center for the parent Clinical Trial testing the effects of the jugular vein compression on brain health. Vicis Inc. Funded Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center to undertake the secondary analyses of neuroimaging data for comparison of helmet technologies not included in the intervention arm (collar) of the parent clinical trial. Gregory D. Myer consults with Commercial entities to support application to the US Food and Drug Administration but has no financial interest in the commercialization of the products. Dr. Myer’s institutions receive current and ongoing grant funding from National Institutes of Health/NIAMS Grants U01AR067997, R01 AR070474, R01AR055563, R01AR076153, R01 AR077248, and industry sponsored research funding related to brain injury prevention and assessment with Q30 Innovations, LLC and ElMinda, Ltd. Dr. Myer receives author royalties from Human Kinetics and Wolters Kluwer. Dr. Myer is also an inventor of biofeedback technologies (2017 Non provisional Patent Pending- Augmented and Virtual reality for Sport Performance and Injury Prevention Application filed 11/10/2016 (62/420,119), Software Copyrighted.) designed to enhance rehabilitation and prevent injuries and has potential for future licensing royalties.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Associate Editor Stefan M. Duma oversaw the review of this article.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dudley, J.A., Slutsky-Ganesh, A.B., Diekfuss, J.A. et al. Helmet Technology, Head Impact Exposure, and Cortical Thinning Following a Season of High School Football. Ann Biomed Eng 50, 1608–1619 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-022-03023-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-022-03023-x