, Volume 14, Supplement 1, pp 30–41 | Cite as

A Comparison of Disease Risk Analysis Tools for Conservation Translocations

  • Antonia Eleanor Dalziel
  • Anthony W. Sainsbury
  • Kate McInnes
  • Richard Jakob-Hoff
  • John G. Ewen
Original Contribution


Conservation translocations are increasingly used to manage threatened species and restore ecosystems. Translocations increase the risk of disease outbreaks in the translocated and recipient populations. Qualitative disease risk analyses have been used as a means of assessing the magnitude of any effect of disease and the probability of the disease occurring associated with a translocation. Currently multiple alternative qualitative disease risk analysis packages are available to practitioners. Here we compare the ease of use, expertise required, transparency, and results from, three different qualitative disease risk analyses using a translocation of the endangered New Zealand passerine, the hihi (Notiomystis cincta), as a model. We show that the three methods use fundamentally different approaches to define hazards. Different methods are used to produce estimations of the risk from disease, and the estimations are different for the same hazards. Transparency of the process varies between methods from no referencing, or explanations of evidence to justify decisions, through to full documentation of resources, decisions and assumptions made. Evidence to support decisions on estimation of risk from disease is important, to enable knowledge acquired in the future, for example, from translocation outcome, to be used to improve the risk estimation for future translocations. Information documenting each disease risk analysis differs along with variation in emphasis of the questions asked within each package. The expertise required to commence a disease risk analysis varies and an action flow chart tailored for the non-wildlife health specialist are included in one method but completion of the disease risk analysis requires wildlife health specialists with epidemiological and pathological knowledge in all three methods. We show that disease risk analysis package choice may play a greater role in the overall risk estimation of the effect of disease on animal populations involved in a translocation than might previously have been realised.


wildlife disease wildlife health translocation reintroduction hihi Notiomystis cincta 

Supplementary material

10393_2016_1161_MOESM1_ESM.docx (52 kb)
Supplementary material 1 (DOCX 52 kb)


  1. Alley M (2002a) Wildlife disease surveillance. Surveillance (Wellington) 39(3): 24–26.Google Scholar
  2. Alley MR (2002b) Avian wildlife diseases in New Zealand: current issues and achievements. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 50, 118–120.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Alley MR, Castro I, Hunter JE (1999) Aspergillosis in hihi (Notiomystis cincta) on Mokoia Island. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 47, 88–91.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Alley MR, Hale KA, Cash W, Ha HJ, Howe L (2010) Concurrent avian malaria and avipox virus infection in translocated South Island saddlebacks (Philesturnus carunculatus carunculatus). New Zealand Veterinary Journal 58, 218–223.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. Armstrong D, Jakob-Hoff R, Seal U (2003) Animal movements and disease risk: a workbook. Conservation Breeding Specialist Group (Species Survival Commission/IUCN), Apple ValleyGoogle Scholar
  6. Armstrong DP, Castro I, Alley JC, Feenstra B, Perrott JK (1999) Mortality and behaviour of hihi, an endangered New Zealand honeyeater, in the establishment phase following translocation. Biological Conservation 89, 329–339CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Armstrong DP, Castro I, Griffiths R (2007) Using adaptive management to determine requirements of re-introduced populations: the case of the New Zealand hihi. Journal of Applied Ecology 44(5): 953–962. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2664.2007.01320.x CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Atkinson CT (2008) Avian Malaria. Parasitic Diseases of Wild Birds 35–53Google Scholar
  9. Birdlife International (2012) Notiomystis cincta. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species Verion 2012.1Google Scholar
  10. Burgman M (2005) Risks and Decisions for Conservation and Environmental Management, Cambridge: Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
  11. CBSG (2008) Tasmanian Devil PHVA final report. Apple Valley, MNGoogle Scholar
  12. Connolly JH, Alley MR, Dutton GJ, Rogers LE (2006) Infectivity and persistence of an outbreak strain of Salmonella enterica serotype Typhimurium DT160 for house sparrows (Passer domesticus) in New Zealand. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 54, 329–332CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Converse KA (2007) Aspergillosis. Infectious Diseases of Wild Birds 360–374Google Scholar
  14. Cork SC, Alley MR, Johnstone AC, Stockdale PH (1999) Aspergillosis and other causes of mortality in the stitchbird in New Zealand. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 35(3): 481–486CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  15. Covello VT, Merkhofer MW (1993) Introduction to risk assessment. Risk Assessment Methods, Springer:1–34Google Scholar
  16. Daoust P-Y, Prescott JF (2007) Salmonellosis. Infectious Diseases of Wild Birds 270–288Google Scholar
  17. Davidson W, Nettles V (1992) Relocation of wildlife: identifying and evaluating disease risks. Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference.Google Scholar
  18. Dobson A, Foufopoulos J (2001) Emerging infectious pathogens of wildlife. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 356(1411): 1001–1012.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Derraik JGB, Tompkins DM, Alley, MR, Holder P (2008) Epidemiology of an avian malaria outbreak in a native bird species (Mohoua ochrocephala) in New Zealand. Journal of the Royal Society of New Zealand 38, 237–242.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Ewen JG, Thorogood R, Nicol C, Armstrong DP, Alley M (2007). Salmonella typhimurium in hihi, New Zealand. Emerging Infectious Diseases 13:788–790CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
  21. Ewen JG, Parker KA, Richardson K, Armstrong D, Smuts-Kennedy C (2011) Translocation of hihi Notiomystis cincta to Maungatautari, a mainland reserve protected by a predator-exclusion fence, Waikato, New Zealand. Conservation Evidence 8:58–65.Google Scholar
  22. Ewen JG, Armstrong DP, Parker KA (2012a) Reintroduction Biology: Integrating Science and Management. New York: WileyGoogle Scholar
  23. Ewen JG, Armstrong DP, Empson R, Jack S, Makan T, McInnes K, Parker KA, Richardson K, Alley M (2012b) Parasite management in translocations: lessons from a threatened New Zealand bird. Oryx, FirstView 1–11Google Scholar
  24. Ewen JG, Renwick R, Adams L, Armstrong DP, Parker KA (2013) 1980–2012: 32 years of re-introduction efforts of the hihi (stitchbird) in New Zealand. In: Global Re-introduction Perspectives: 2013. Further Case-studies from Around the Globe. P. S. Soorae. Gland, Switzerland, IUCN/SSC Re-introduction Specialist Group and Abu Dhabi: Environment Agency—Abu Dhabi, pp 68–73Google Scholar
  25. Forde-Folle K, Mitchell D, Zepeda C (2011) The role of models in estimating consequences as part of the risk assessment process. Revue scientifique et technique - Office International des Epizooties 30(2):541–545Google Scholar
  26. Forrester DJ, Foster GW (2008) Trichomonosis. Parasitic Diseases of Wild Birds 120–153Google Scholar
  27. Frost P, Ewen JG, Armstrong DP, Richardson K, Oates K (2012) Bushy Park Hihi Translocation Proposal 2012. Wellington, NZGoogle Scholar
  28. Gregory R, Failing L, Harstone M, Long G, McDaniels T, Ohlson D (2012) Structured Decision Making: A Practical Guide to Environmental Management Choices, New York: WileyGoogle Scholar
  29. Harms CA, Harms RV (2012) Venous blood gas and lactate values of mourning doves (Zenaida macroura), boat-tailed grackles (Quiscalus major), and house sparrows (Passer domesticus) after capture by mist net, banding and venipuncture. Journal of Zoo and Wildlife Medicine 43:77–84CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  30. Howe L, Castro IC, Schoener ER, Hunter S, Barraclough RK, Alley MR (2012) Malaria parasites (Plasmodium spp.) infecting introduced, native and endemic New Zealand birds. Parasitology Research 110, 913–923CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  31. IUCN/SSC (2013) Guidelines for reintroductions and other conservation translocations. Version 1.0. Gland, Switzerland, IUCN Species Survival Commission: viii + 57ppGoogle Scholar
  32. Jakob-Hoff R (2001) Disease Risk Assessment for Translocation of Kaki (Black Stilt), Himantopus novaezelandiae, from Captivity to the Wild, Department of Conservation.Google Scholar
  33. Jakob-Hoff RM, MacDiarmid SC, Lees C, Miller PS, Travis D, Kock R (2014) Manual of procedures for wildlife disease risk analysis. In: Manual of procedures for wildlife disease risk analysisGoogle Scholar
  34. Kawahara F, Taira K, Nagai S, Onaga H, Onuma M, Nunoya T (2008) Detection of five avian Eimeria species by species-specific real-time polymerase chain reaction assay. Avian Diseases 52:652–656CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  35. Keet D, Davies-Mostert H, Bengis R, Funston P, Buss P, Hofmeyr M, Ferreira S, Lane E, Miller P, Daly B (2009) Disease risk assessment workshop report: African lion (Panthera leo) Bovine Tuberculosis. Conservation Breeding Specialist Group (CBSG SSC/IUCN)/CBSG Southern Africa. Endangered Wildlife TrustGoogle Scholar
  36. Kelly D, Ladley JJ, Robertson AW, Anderson SH, Wotton DM, Wiser SK (2010) Mutualisms with the wreckage of an avifauna: the status of bird pollination and fruit-dispersal in New Zealand. New Zealand Journal Of Ecology 34(1): 66–85.Google Scholar
  37. Kock R, Woodford M, Rossiter P (2010) Disease risks associated with the translocation of wildlife. Revue scientifique et technique 29(2): 329.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  38. Lawson B, Cunningham A, Chantrey J, Hughes L, Kirkwood J, Pennycott T, Simpson V (2006) Epidemic finch mortality. Veterinary Record 159:367CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  39. Lawson B, Robinson RA, Neimanis A, Handeland K, Isomursu M, Agren EO, Hamnes IS, Tyler KM, Chantrey J, Hughes LA, Pennycott TW, Simpson VR, John SK, Peck KM, Toms MP, Bennett M, Kirkwood JK, Cunningham AA (2011) Evidence of spread of the emerging infectious disease, finch trichomonosis, by migrating birds. EcoHealth 8:143–153CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  40. Leighton F (2002) Health risk assessment of the translocation of wild animals. Revue Scientifique et Technique-Office International des Epizooties 21(1):187–216.Google Scholar
  41. McBride MF, Garnett ST, Szabo JK, Burbidge AH, Butchart SH, Christidis L, Dutson G, Ford HA, Loyn RH, Watson DM (2012) Structured elicitation of expert judgments for threatened species assessment: a case study on a continental scale using email. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 3(5): 906–920.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. McKenna PD (2010) An updated checklist of helminth and protozoan parasites of birds in New Zealand. WebmedCentral PARASITOLOGY 1, WMC00705Google Scholar
  43. Masters N, Sainsbury AW (2011) Disease risk analysis for the wild to wild translocation of the smooth snake within the UK. Zoological Society of London and Natural England 62Google Scholar
  44. Michel AL, Bengis RG, Keet D, Hofmeyr M, De Klerk L, Cross PC, Jolles AE, Cooper D, Whyte I, Buss P (2006) Wildlife tuberculosis in South African conservation areas: implications and challenges. Veterinary Microbiology 112(2): 91–100.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  45. Miller PS (2007) Tools and techniques for disease risk assessment in threatened wildlife conservation programmes. International Zoo Yearbook 41(1): 38–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Miskelly CM, Dowding JE, Elliott GP, Hitchmough RA, Powlesland RG, Robertson HA, Sagar PM, Scofield RP, Taylor GA (2008) Conservation status of New Zealand birds, 2008. Notornis 55(3): 117–135.Google Scholar
  47. Murray N, MacDiarmid S, Wooldridge M, Gummow B, Morley R, Weber S, Giovannini A, Wilson D (2004) Handbook on Import Risk Analysis for Animals and Animal Products–Introduction and Qualitative Risk Analysis, vol. 1, Paris: OIE (World Organisation for Animal Health).Google Scholar
  48. Parker KA, Dickens MJ, Clarke RH, Lovegrove TG (2012) The theory and practice of catching, holding, moving and releasing animals. Reintroduction Biology: Integrating Science and Management 105Google Scholar
  49. Perrott JK, Armstrong DP (2011) Aspergillus fumigatus densities in relation to forest succession and edge effects: implications for wildlife health in modified environments. EcoHealth 8(3): 290–300.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  50. Sainsbury AW, Vaughan-Higgins RJ (2012) Analyzing disease risks associated with translocations. Conservation Biology 26(3): 442–452.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  51. Sainsbury AW, Deaville R, Lawson B, Cooley WA, Farelly SS, Stack MJ, Duff P, McInnes CJ, Gurnell J, Russell PH (2008) Poxviral disease in red squirrels Sciurus vulgaris in the UK: spatial and temporal trends of an emerging threat. EcoHealth 5(3): 305–316.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  52. Sainsbury AW, Armstrong DP, Ewen JG (2012) Methods of disease risk analysis for reintroduction programmes. Reintroduction Biology: Integrating Science and Management 12: 336.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Schoener ER (2010) Gastrointestinal parasites in endemic, native, and introduced New Zealand passerines with a special focus on coccidia. M.Sc Thesis, Massey University Library, Palmerston North, New ZealandGoogle Scholar
  54. Seddon PJ, Armstrong DP, Maloney RF (2007) Developing the science of reintroduction biology. Conservation Biology 21(2): 303–312.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  55. Sutherland WJ, Pullin AS, Dolman PM, Knight TM (2004) The need for evidence-based conservation. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 19(6): 305–308.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Taylor S, Castro IC, Griffiths R, BR Unit (2005). Hihi/stitchbird (Notiomystis Cincta) Recovery Plan, 2004–09, Department of ConservationGoogle Scholar
  57. Thorne JM (2007) An Experimental Approach to Translocation of the North Island Saddleback (Philesturnus Carunculatus Rufusater) to Bushy Park Reserve, Wanganui: A Thesis Presented in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Masters of Science in Conservation Biology at Massey University, Palmerston North, New ZealandGoogle Scholar
  58. Tompkins DM, Gleeson DM (2006) Relationship between avian malaria distribution and an exotic invasive mosquito in New Zealand. Journal of the Royal Society of New Zealand 36:51–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Travis D, Hungerford L, Engel G, Jones‐Engel L (2006) Disease risk analysis: a tool for primate conservation planning and decision making. American Journal of Primatology 68(9): 855–867.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  60. Twentyman CM (2001) A study of coccidial parasites in the hihi (Notiomystis cincta). Master of Veterinary Science, Massey University, Palmerston NorthGoogle Scholar
  61. van Andel M, Jackson BH, Midwinter AC, Alley MR, Ewen JG, McInnes K (2014). Investigation of mortalities associated with Salmonella spp. infection in wildlife on Tiritiri Matangi Island in the Hauraki Gulf of New Zealand. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 63(4): 235–239.Google Scholar
  62. van Riper C, Forrester DJ (2007) Avian Pox. Infectious Diseases of Wild Birds 131–176Google Scholar
  63. Walker SF, Bosch J, James TY, Litvintseva AP, Valls JAO, Piña S (2008) Invasive pathogens threaten species recovery programs. Current Biology 18(18): R853–R854.Google Scholar
  64. Zippel K, Lacy R, Byers O (2006). CBSG/WAZA amphibian ex situ conservation planning workshop final report. Apple Valley, MN 55124, USA, IUCN/SSC Conservation Breeding Specialist GroupGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© International Association for Ecology and Health 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  • Antonia Eleanor Dalziel
    • 1
    • 2
  • Anthony W. Sainsbury
    • 1
  • Kate McInnes
    • 3
  • Richard Jakob-Hoff
    • 4
  • John G. Ewen
    • 1
  1. 1.Institute of ZoologyZoological Society of LondonLondonUK
  2. 2.Royal Veterinary CollegeLondonUK
  3. 3.Department of Conservation, Conservation House – Whare Kaupapa AtawhaiWellingtonNew Zealand
  4. 4.New Zealand Centre for Conservation MedicineAucklandNew Zealand

Personalised recommendations