Abstract
This review paper summarizes the main topics discussed by John Dolan in the LC troubleshooting series published over the last 16 years in LCGC North America. The paper is directed toward non-expert HPLC users to learn from challenges other HPLC users across the world faced. The topics covered here help the reader not only to understand and perform system troubleshooting but also to learn tips and essentials for data analysis, method development, and system testing (for example: proper integration, establishing best calibration curve, enhancing signal-to-noise ratio, improving selectivity, testing pump performance, etc.). The last section of the paper shows helpful tips, shortcuts, and equations that would be very helpful to remember, for example: (1) simplified equations for calculating dead volume and column efficiency, (2) easy-to-remember rules on how to set detector constant and maximum injection volume, (3) helpful tips for method development, such as choosing gradient or isocratic conditions, as well as (4) recommendations on how to take care of the HPLC system and columns. This review paper can also be useful guide for HPLC users to find references of particular interest from the LC troubleshooting series.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Dolan J (2013) Making the most of a gradient scouting run. LCGC, North America, pp 30–35
Dolan J (2013) Gradient elution, Part I: intuition. LCGC, North America, pp 204–209
Dolan J (2000) Starting out right, Part VI—the scouting gradient alternative. LCGC, North America, pp 478–487
Schellinger AP, Carr PW (2006) Isocratic and gradient elution chromatography: A comparison in terms of speed, retention reproducibility and quantitation. J Chromatogr A 1109:253–266
Dolan J (2013) Gradient elution, Part II: equivalent separations. LCGC, North America, pp 300–305
Haidar Ahmad IA, Soliven A, Allen RC, Filgueira M, Carr PW (2015) Comparison of core–shell particles and sub-2 μm fully porous particles for use as ultrafast second dimension columns in two-dimensional liquid chtomatography. J Chromatogr A 1386:31–38
Dolan J (2013) Gradient elution, Part III: surprises. LCGC, North America, pp 382–389
Dolan J (2014) LC method scaling, Part II: gradient separations. LCGC, North America, pp 188–193
Dolan J (2011) Troubleshooting basics, Part II: pressure problems. LCGC, North America, pp 818–824
Dolan J (2011) How fast can a gradient be run?. LCGC, North America, pp 652–657
Dolan J (2008) How Do I…?. LCGC, North America, pp 440–446
Dolan J (2002) The hazards of adjusting gradients. LCGC, North America, pp 940–946
Dolan J (2003) Flow rate and peak spacing. LCGC, North America, pp 350–354
Dolan J (1998) Scaling gradients. LCGC, North America, pp 16–19
Dolan J (2015) Be careful of the flow rate. LCGC, North America, pp 248–253
Dolan J (2000) Reducing column diameter in gradient elution—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 1228–1232
Dolan J (2000) Scaling gradient LC methods to LC-MS. LCGC, North America, pp 1034–1039
Dolan J (2007) The perfect method, Part I: what is your goal?. LCGC, North America, pp 546–552
Dolan J (2007) The perfect method, Part II: where to start?. LCGC, North America, pp 632–638
Dolan J (2002) Stability-indicating assays. LCGC, North America, pp 346–349
Hayes R, Ahmed A, Edge T, Zhang H (2014) Core–shell particles: Preparation, fundamentals and applications in high performance liquid chromatography. J Chromatogr A 1357:36–52
Dolan J (2007) The perfect method, Part III: adjusting retention. LCGC, North America, pp 704–709
Dolan J (2007) The perfect method, Part VII: the gradient shortcut. LCGC, North America, pp 1178–1182
Dolan J (2007) The Perfect Method, Part IV: Controlling Peak Spacing. LCGC, North America, pp 944–950
Dolan J (2007) The perfect method, Part V: changing column selectivity. LCGC, North America, pp 1014–1020
Dolan J (2000) Starting out right, Part III—the role of the solvent in controlling selectivity. LCGC, North America, pp 118–125
Dolan J (2000) Starting out right, Part IV—additional variables to control selectivity. LCGC, North America, pp 286–294
Dolan J (2012) Why does an improvement make things worse?. LCGC, North America, pp 216–222
Dolan J (2011) Selectivity in reversed-phase LC separations, Part II: solvent-strength selectivity. LCGC, North America, pp 28–34
Dolan J (2000) Starting out right, Part II—measuring satisfaction. LCGC, North America, pp 28–32
Dolan J (2007) The perfect method, Part VI: make it faster. LCGC, North America, pp 1094–1102
Dolan J (2005) A Baker’s Dozen. LCGC, North America, pp 1008–1012
Dolan J (2003) How much is enough?. LCGC, North America, pp 968–972
Dolan J (2009) Testing method performance. LCGC, North America, pp 120–128
Dolan J (1997) Method quality, standardization, and peak shape. LCGC, North America, pp 24–27
Dolan J (2006) It’s gonna break. LCGC, North America, pp 374–380
Dolan J (2002) Peak tailing and resolution. LCGC, North America, pp 430–436
Dolan J (2014) Estimating resolution for marginally separated peaks. LCGC, North America, pp 718–725
Dolan J (2012) Troubleshooting basics, Part IV: peak shape problems. LCGC, North America, pp 564–569
Dolan J (2010) Are the method requirements reasonable?. LCGC, North America, pp 866–872
Dolan J (2016) Column plate number and system suitability. LCGC, North America, pp 190–197
Dolan J (2011) The case of the too big little peak. LCGC, North America, pp 486–491
Dolan J (2010) Selectivity in reversed-phase lc separations, Part I: solvent-type selectivity. LCGC, North America, pp 1022–1027
Dolan J (2006) The power of mobile phase strength. LCGC, North America, pp 570–578
Dolan J (2011) Selectivity in reversed-phase LC separations, Part III: column-type selectivity. LCGC, North America, pp 236–244
Snyder LR, Dolan JW, Carr PW (2004) The hydrophobic-subtraction model of reversed-phase column selectivity. J Chromatogr A 1060:77–116
Dolan J (2011) Selectivity in reversed-phase LC separations, Part IV: pressure selectivity. LCGC, North America, pp 318–324
Dolan J (2007) How does temperature affect selectivity?. LCGC, North America, pp 448–452
Dolan J (2003) Extracolumn effects. LCGC, North America, pp 1050–1054
Dolan J (2002) The importance of temperature. LCGC, North America, pp 524–530
Dolan J (2009) Too many changes. LCGC, North America, pp 606–610
Dolan J (2004) Broad peaks. LCGC, North America, pp 26–30
Dolan J (2014) LC method scaling, Part I: isocratic separations. LCGC, North America, pp 98–102
Dolan J (2002) Mobile-phase buffers, Part II—buffer selection and capacity. LCGC, North America, pp 1114–1118
Dolan J (2003) Mobile-phase buffers, Part III—preparation of buffers. LCGC, North America, pp 28–32
Dolan J (2001) Buffers and baselines. LCGC, North America, pp 590–594
Dolan J (2001) From the e-mail bag. LCGC, North America, pp 1192–1196
Dolan J (2002) Mobile-phase buffers, Part I—the interpretation of pH in partially aqueous mobile phases. LCGC, North America, pp 1028–1032
Dolan J (2008) Ion pairing—blessing or curse. LCGC, North America, pp 170–174
Dolan J (2005) Reader questions: mobile phase. LCGC, North America, pp 662–667
Dolan J (2000) Reversed-phase in 100% water. LCGC, North America, pp 936–939
Dolan J (2001) Retaining polar compounds. LCGC, North America, pp 1132–1135
Dolan J (2009) Calibration curves, Part I: to b or not to b?. LCGC, North America, pp 224–230
Dolan J (2014) Readers’ questions: calibration. LCGC, North America, pp 328–333
Dolan J (2009) Calibration curves, Part II: what are the limits?. LCGC, North America, pp 306–312
Dolan J (2007) How little can i see?. LCGC, North America, pp 142–152
Dolan J (2013) What’s the problem with the LLOQ—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 926–931
Dolan J (2009) Calibration curves, Part III: a different view. LCGC, North America, pp 392–400
Dolan J (2009) Calibration curves, Part IV: choosing the appropriate model. LCGC, North America, pp 472–479
Dolan J (2009) Calibration curves, Part V: curve weighting. LCGC, North America, pp 534–540
Dolan J (2009) Integration problems. LCGC, North America, pp 892–899
Dolan J (2008) Odds and ends from the inbox. LCGC, North America, pp 914–920
Dolan J (2006) Obtaining more consistent results. LCGC, North America, pp 30–36
Dolan J (2006) What’s happening to my column?. LCGC, North America, pp 986–992
Dolan J (2008) Method transfer problems. LCGC, North America, pp 254–260
Dolan J (2010) Too little or too much. LCGC, North America, pp 28–32
Dolan J (2010) Getting the most out of calibration standards. LCGC, North America, pp 292–300
Dolan J (2008) Drip, drip, drip…. LCGC, North America, pp 1000–1004
Redkar S, Sadikin S, Inloes R, Zhang DD (2011) Ghost peak investigation in a reversed-phase gradient LC system. LCGC, North America, pp 394–400
Dolan J (1996) Water problems: a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 98–102
Dolan J (2012) Extra chromatographic peaks—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 392–400
Dolan J (2006) Autosampler carryover. LCGC, North America, pp 754–764
Dolan J (2005) Broad peaks. LCGC, North America, pp 738–743
Dolan J (2010) Where did that peak come from?. LCGC, North America, pp 518–523
Dolan J (2001) Unexpected peaks. LCGC, North America, pp 32–36
Dolan J (2016) Detective work, Part III: strong retention and chemical problems with the column. LCGC, North America, pp 20–25
Dolan J (2000) The problem of late elution—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 1136–1140
Dolan J (2001) Autosampler carryover. LCGC, North America, pp 164–168
Dolan J (2001) Attacking carryover problems. LCGC, North America, pp 1050–1054
Dolan J (2013) Gradient elution, Part VI: ghost peaks. LCGC, North America, pp 604–611
Dolan J (2001) Reproducibility and carryover—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 290–296
Bell F, Dolan J (2006) On-column sample degradation. LCGC, North America, pp 1184–1190
Dolan J (2009) LC troubleshooting strategies. LCGC, North America, pp 1040–1044
Dolan J (2009) Method or system?. LCGC, North America, pp 816–821
Dolan J (2008) Peak shape problems. LCGC, North America, pp 610–616
Dolan J (2003) Success with evaporative light-scattering detection. LCGC, North America, pp 120–128
Dolan J (2016) Detective work, Part IV: chemical problems with the column: chemical attack. LCGC, North America, pp 106–113
Dolan J (2010) Too much scrutiny. LCGC, North America, pp 258–363
Dolan J (2005) Peak fronting; column life; and column conditioning. LCGC, North America, pp 566–574
Dolan J (2013) Peak fronting… some of the time. LCGC, North America, pp 992–997
Dolan J (2003) Understanding split peaks. LCGC, North America, pp 1134–1138
Dolan J (2005) Split peaks—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 266–271
Dolan J (2006) Making connections. LCGC, North America, pp 1078–1084
Dolan J (2012) Questions from afar. LCGC, North America, pp 634–638
Dolan J (2006) Dwell volume revisited. LCGC, North America, pp 458–466
Dolan J (2002) Ion suppresion in LC-MS/MS—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 24–32
Dolan J (2002) Quiet, please. LCGC, North America, pp 114–119
Dolan J (2013) Gradient elution, Part V: baseline drift problems. LCGC, North America, pp 538–543
Dolan J (2001) Communicating with the baseline. LCGC, North America, pp 688–693
Dolan J (1996) Noise problems: a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 378–382
Dolan J (2005) The Bermuda Triangle. LCGC, North America, pp 370–375
Dolan J (2010) Enhancing signal-to-noise. LCGC, North America, pp 212–216
Dolan J (2005) The role of signal-to-noise ratio in precision and accuracy. LCGC, North America, pp 1256–1260
Dolan J (2000) Stainless steel surfaces in LC systems, Part II—passivation and practical recommendations. LCGC, North America, pp 688–692
Dolan J (2000) Stainless steel surfaces in LC systems, Part I—corrosion and erosion. LCGC, North America, pp 600–608
Dong Michael W, Louie K (2012) A case of sporadic LC assay results. LCGC, North America, pp 112–118
Dolan J (2010) UHPLC tips and techniques. LCGC, North America, pp 944–950
Wahab MF, Dasgupta PK, Kadjo AF, Armstrong DW (2016) Sampling frequency, response times and embedded signal filtration in fast, high efficiency liquid chromatography: A tutorial. Analytica Chimica Acta 907:31–44
Felinger A, Kilár A, Boros B (2015) The myth of data acquisition rate. Analytica Chimica Acta 854:178–182. doi:10.1016/j.aca.2014.11.014
Dolan J (2014) Column dead time as a diagnostic tool. LCGC, North America, pp 24–29
Dolan J (2013) Variable retention times—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 778–783
Dolan J (2006) Gradient performance problems—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 662–668
Dolan J (2012) Retention time changes. LCGC, North America, pp 312–318
Dolan J (2008) LC pumps. LCGC, North America, pp 1168–1174
Dolan J (2006) Check valve problems. LCGC, North America, pp 132–138
Dolan J (1997) Pump preventive maintenance. LCGC, North America, pp 110–113
Dolan J (2008) Check valves and acetonitrile. LCGC, North America, pp 532–538
Dolan J (2016) How does it work? Part I: pumps. LCGC, North America, pp 324–329
Dolan J (2004) Gradient performance checks. LCGC, North America, pp 982–988
Dolan J (2016) How does it work? Part II: mixing and degassing. LCGC, North America, pp 400–407
Dolan J (2013) Gradient elution, Part IV: dwell-volume problems. LCGC, North America, pp 456–463
Dolan J (2010) Column diameter, linear velocity, and column efficiency. LCGC, North America, pp 114–120
Dolan J (2008) Extracolumn effects. LCGC, North America, pp 1092–1098
Dolan J (2005) Extracolumn effects. LCGC, North America, pp 130–135
Dolan J (2006) Method reproducibility—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 1274–1278
Dolan J (2007) Solvent conservation. LCGC, North America, pp 268–274
Dolan J (2015) How to reduce mobile-phase consumption. LCGC, North America, pp 752–757
Dolan J (2011) Troubleshooting basics, Part I: where to start?. LCGC, North America, pp 570–574
Dolan J (2004) Divide and conquer. LCGC, North America, pp 618–622
Dolan J (2005) LC troubleshooting: the basics. LCGC, North America, pp 1086–1091
Dolan J (2003) Not Another Leak!. LCGC, North America, pp 440–444
Dolan J (2011) Troubleshooting basics, Part III: retention problems. LCGC, North America, pp 1046–1050
Dolan J (2008) Flow-rate adjustment and system suitability. LCGC, North America, pp 30–36
Dolan J (2004) Retention time changes. LCGC, North America, pp 1154–1158
Dolan J (2007) Variability—how to control it. LCGC, North America, pp 360–366
Dolan J (2015) Slow column equilibration. LCGC, North America, pp 102–107
Dolan J (2014) How much retention time variation is normal?. LCGC, North America, pp 546–551
Dolan J (2008) Column care. LCGC, North America, pp 692–696
Dolan J (2005) Stay Away from the Cliffs!. LCGC, North America, pp 30–35
Dolan J (2010) 300 and counting. LCGC, North America, pp 432–438
Dolan J (2011) Column triage. LCGC, North America, pp 908–912
Dolan J (2003) Now what’s going on?. LCGC, North America, pp 540–544
Dolan J (2005) Extending column life. LCGC, North America, pp 1174–1181
Dolan J (2009) Problems from east and west. LCGC, North America, pp 26–34
Dolan J (1993) Amine adsorption—a case study. LCGC, North America, pp 92–102
Dolan J (2003) LC columns—the top-10 list. LCGC, North America, pp 262–266
Dolan J (2014) Column protection: three easy steps. LCGC, North America, pp 916–920
Dolan J (2015) LC column problems everywhere. LCGC, North America, pp 694–700
Dolan J (2008) Only three things. LCGC, North America, pp 352–358
Dolan J (2014) Mobile-phase degassing: what, why, and how. LCGC, North America, pp 482–487
Dolan J (2014) How much can I inject? Part I: injecting in mobile phase. LCGC, North America, pp 780–785
Dolan J (2012) The role of the injection solvent. LCGC, North America, pp 898–902
Pedersen K, Dolan J (2011) A picture is worth a thousand words. LCGC, North America, pp 136–142
Dolan J (2004) But I can not change the method. LCGC, North America, pp 524–528
Dolan J (2001) When ideal is not practical. LCGC, North America, pp 956–960
Dolan J (1996) Injection problems. LCGC, North America, pp 20–24
Dolan J (2005) Overload or minor peak?. LCGC, North America, pp 470–475
Dolan J (2014) How much can I inject? Part II: injecting in solvents other than mobile phase. LCGC, North America, pp 854–859
Dolan J (2015) Overload in liquid chromatography. LCGC, North America, pp 528–533
Dolan J (2002) Resolving minor peaks. LCGC, North America, pp 594–598
Dolan J (2006) Chromatography forum—use the braintrust. LCGC, North America, pp 268–276
Dolan J (2003) Why do peaks tail?. LCGC, North America, pp 612–616
Dolan J (2004) My favorite shortcuts. LCGC, North America, pp 1074–1080
Dolan J (2003) Honoring readers. LCGC, North America, pp 888–892
Dolan J (2012) LC trouble everywhere. LCGC, North America, pp 36–40
Dolan J (2012) Evaluation of an LC method. LCGC, North America, pp 972–977
Dolan J (2015) Seven things to avoid in the liquid chromatography laboratory. LCGC, North America, pp 18–22
Dolan J (2014) Problems with large-molecule separations. LCGC, North America, pp 256–261
Dolan J (2004) Selecting the best curve fit. LCGC, North America, pp 112–117
Dolan J (2004) Parallel chromatography—double your money. LCGC, North America, pp 338–343
Dolan J (2004) Grandma’s Ham. LCGC, North America, pp 738–743
Dolan J (2013) Past, present, and future—30 years of LC troubleshooting. LCGC, North America, pp 854–859
Acknowledgements
The author would like to acknowledge Dr. Arianne Soliven, Dr. Adrian Clarke, Frank Hrovat, and James Tam for their helpful suggestions.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
No funding for this work was provided.
Conflict of interest
The author declares that he has no conflict of interest.
Ethical approval
This article does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by the authors.
Additional information
Published in the topical collection Young Investigators in Separation Science with editors D. Mangelings, G. Massolini, G. K. E. Scriba, R. M. Smith, and A. M. Striegel.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Haidar Ahmad, I.A. Necessary Analytical Skills and Knowledge for Identifying, Understanding, and Performing HPLC Troubleshooting. Chromatographia 80, 705–730 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10337-016-3225-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10337-016-3225-7