Abstract
Asian countries with Confucian heritage culture (CHC) such as China, Vietnam, Singapore, Korea and Japan have been proven to share characteristics of a collectivist society. Researchers agree that this collectivist mentality strongly supports cooperation that CHC's learners/workers best perform in groups. However, little is known about the other side of the coin. Whilst applying a method born in one culture to another, cultural differences have been forgotten. The so-called global application has led to a situation in which a Western model is forced to launch in a completely new and different context. This new context and the existing cultural values are not always incorporated into the implementation of a Western concept of cooperative learning. Consequently, it does not necessarily follow that all forms of cooperative learning will surely succeed within a CHC environment. As a result of ignoring, stereotyping and underestimating cultural and educational characteristics, in CHC countries, the implementation of constructivism and one of its applications—cooperative learning—has ended up in failures, suspicion or resistance. The authors would like to question (1) the fixed assumption that “group-work surely works in CHC countries” and (2) the domination of developmentalism in education nowadays and its mismatch with cultural assets. With this paper, the authors contribute to the recent call for culturally appropriate pedagogy.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Terms borrowed from Ting-Toomey's (1988) facework.
The Vietnamese names (Pham Minh Hac, Nguyen Dang Thin, Le Van Giang, etc.) are written in their culturally appropriate order as follows: family name–middle name–first name.
References
Achilles CM (1996) Students achieve more in smaller classes. Educ Leadersh 53(5):76–77
Agelasto M (1998) Educational disengagement: undermining academic quality at a Chinese university. Retrieved November 5, 2004, from http://www.agelastos.com/disengagement/
Astorga H (2002) Teamwork—a new twist to old Asian collectivism. Asia Pacific Management Forum. Retrieved November 12, 2004, from http://www.apmforum.com/columns/eaststrategy5.htm
Baker FJ, Giacchino-Baker R (2003) Lower secondary school curriculum development in Vietnam. Cal Poly Pomona J Interdiscip Stud 16, 2003
Belenky MF, Blythe MC, Goldberger NR, Tarule J (1997) Women's ways of knowing. Basic Books, New York
Chan S (1999) The Chinese learner—a question of style. Educ Train 41(6/7):294–304
Chan G, Watkins D (1994) Classroom environment and approaches to learning: an investigation of the actual and preferred perceptions of Hong Kong secondary school students. Instr Sci 22:233–246
Chang S (2003) The tutor in multicultural environment. Retrieved September, 24, 2004 from http://www.dis.unimelb.edu.au/sessionals/multiculturalenv.html
Chanock K (2003) Autonomy and responsibility: same of different? Proceeding Independent Learning Conference 2003. Retrieved 23 October, 2004, from http://www.independentlearning.org/ila03/ila03_chanock.pdf.
Cocroft BAK, Ting-Toomey S (1994) Face-work in Japan and in the United States. Int J Intercult Relat 18:469–506
Curro G (2003) Teaching the Chinese learners. Issues in Teaching and Learning at JCU. 1(2) March 19, 2003
Edmond Law H (2003) In search of a quality curriculum in Hong Kong. International handbook of curriculum research. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc. Publisher, Mahwah, NJ, 271–283
Gajdusek L, Gillotte H (1995) Teaching to the developmental needs of nonmainstream learners. New directions for adult and continuing education. 65, Spring 1995
Grashna A (1972) Observations on relating teaching goals to student response styles and classroom methods. Am Psychol 27:144–147
Gydykunst BW, Ting-Toomey S (1988) Culture and interpersonal communication. California: Sage Publication, Inc.
Hofstede G (2003) Cultures and organizations—software of the mind. London: Profile Books Ltd
Johnson DW, Johnson RT (1994) Learning together. In: Sharan S (ed), Handbook of cooperative learning methods. Greenwood Press, Westport, CT
Jones A (1999) The Asian learner: an overview of approaches to learning. Teaching and Learning Unit Faculty of Economics and Commerce. University of Melbourne
Kagan S (1994) Cooperative learning. Moore Data Management Services, San Diego
Kee J, Wong K (2004) Are the learning styles of Asian international students culturally or contextually based? Int Educ J 4(4)
Kirby JR, Woodhouse RA, Ma Y (1996) Studying in a second language: the experiences of Chinese students in Canada. In: Watkin D, Biggs J (eds.) The Chinese learners: Cultural, Psychological and Contextual Influences. The Central Printing Press, CERC and ACER, Hong Kong, pp 86–105
Kirkpatrick DW (1998) A classic mistake. Retrieved 20 October, 2004, from http://www.schoolreport.com/schoolreport/articles/AClassicMistake_6_98.htm
Kuh GD, Pace CR, Vesper N (1997) The development of process indicators to estimate student gains associated with good practices in undergraduate education. Research in higher education, 38(4)
Leung K (1997) Negotiation and reward allocation across cultures. In: Earley PC, Erez M (eds) New perspectives on international industrial/organization psychology. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, pp 640–675
Le Van Giang (2003) Lich su gian luoc hon 1000 nam nen giao duc Vet Nam. [A timeline of 1000 years of Vietnam Education]. NXB Chinh Tri Quoc gia. [The National Politics Publisher], Hanoi
Maley A (1983) A miracle of rare device: the teaching of English in China. In: Valdes JM (ed) Culture bound: bridging the cultural gap in language teaching. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 102–111
McCuller JC (1969) G. Stanley Hall's conception of mental development and some indicators of its influences on developmental psychology. Am Psychol 24:1109–1114
Munro-Smith N (2003) A culturally aware course design. In: Crisp G, Thiele D, Scholten I, Barker S, Baron J (eds) Interact, integrate, impact: Proceedings of the 20th Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computer in Learning in Tertiary Education. Adelaide, 7–10 December 2003
Neuman Y, Bekerman Z (2000) Cultural resources and the gap between educational theory and practice. Teach Coll Rec 103(3):471–484
Nguyen Dang Thin (2000) Vietnam education and Training Directory. Education Publishing House, Ministry of Education and Training, Hanoi, Vietnam
Park CC (2002) Cross-cultural Differences in learning—styles of secondary English learners. Biling Res J 26(2) Summer 2002
Pennycook A (1999) Development, culture and language: ethical concerns in a postcolonial world. The Fourth International Conference on Language and Development, October 13–15, 1999
Pham Minh Hac (1998) Vietnam's education: the current position and future prospects. Gioi Publisher, Hanoi
Ralston DA, Van Nguyen T, Napier NK (1999) A comparative study of the work values of north and south Vietnamese managers. J Int Bus Stud 4:655–672
Sadker M, Sadker D, Klein S (1991) The issue of gender in elementary and secondary education. In: Grant G (ed) Review of research in education. American Educational Research Association, Washington, DC, pp 269–334
Salili F (1996) Accepting personal responsibility for learning. In: Watkin D, Biggs J (eds). The Chinese learners: cultural, psychological and contextual influences. The Central Printing Press, CERC and ACER, Hong Kong, pp 86–105
Samuelowicz K (1987) Learning problems of overseas students: two sides of a story. High Educ Res Dev 6:121–133
Scollon R, Scollon S (1995) Intercultural communication. Blackwell, Oxford
Slavin RE (1995) Cooperative learning. Allyn and Bacon, Needham Heights, MA
Smith PL, Ragan TJ (1999) Instructional design. Wiley, New York
Stone JE (1996) Developmentalism: an obscure but pervasive restriction on educational improvement. Educ Policy Anal Arch 4(8)
Strijbos JW (2000) A process-based taxonomy of group-based learning. Paper presented at ORD May 2000, Leiden, The Netherlands. Structural Issue: Optimum Class Size in Early Childhood
Sullivan PN (1996) Sociocultural influences on classroom interactional styles. TESOL J 6(1):32–34
Tang C (1996) Collaborative learning: the latent dimension in Chinese Students' learning. In: Watkin D, Biggs J (eds) The Chinese learners: cultural, psychological and contextual influences. Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong, pp 183–204
Ting-Toomey S (1988) Intercultural conflict styles: a face-negotiation theory. In: Kim Y, Gudykunst W (eds) Theories in intercultural communication. Sage, Newbury Park, CA, pp 213–235
Tjong K-M, Yong S-T (2004) Confucian heritage culture learners' and instructors' expectations and preferences in collaborative learning: convergence or divergence? Retrieved October 24, 2004, from http://herdsa2004.curtin.edu.my/Contributions/NRPapers/A055-jt.pdf
Tjosvold D, Fang SS (2004) Cooperative conflict management as a basis for training students in China. Theory Pract (Wntr)
Triandis HC (1995) Individualism and collectivism. Westview, Boulder, CO
Vogel D et al (2000) Distributed experiential learning: the Hong Kong–Netherlands project. 33rd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences—January 04–07, Maui, HI
Volet S (1999) Learning across cultures: appropriateness of knowledge transfer—Chapter 6. Int J Educ Res 31:625–643
Young-Ihm Kwon (2002) Western influences in Korean preschools. Int Educ J 3(3):153–164
Wessel R (2003) Is there time to slow down? As the world speeds up, how cultures define the elastic nature of time may affect our environmental health. Christ Sci Monit (Jan. 16)
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the family Nalis and Richard Hughes who helped to make this paper possible.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Phuong-Mai, N., Terlouw, C. & Pilot, A. Cooperative learning vs Confucian heritage culture's collectivism: confrontation to reveal some cultural conflicts and mismatch. AEJ 3, 403–419 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10308-005-0008-4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10308-005-0008-4