Germ cell tumors occasionally disseminate to the ventricular system and spinal subarachnoid spaces [4]. However, metastasis outside the central nervous system is rare. The incidence of metastasis via shunt tube is 10% [2]. Hematogenous metastasis occurs in only 3–5% of cases, and 7 cases of spinal epidural metastasis have been reported [1–3]. Most cases are non-germinomatous germ cell tumors. Histologically, choriocarcinomas are frequent [5].
Sugiyama et al. [6] investigated the relationship between tumor histology and serum AFP and HCG levels. They reported that in patients with serum AFP or HCG < 9.9 the main histological component was germinoma, 10.0 < AFP or HCG < 999 patients had teratomas, and 1000 < AFP or HCG patients had highly malignant yolk sac tumors or choriocacinomas. Serum AFP or HCG in our patient belonged to the AFP or HCG < 9.9 group; however, we could not establish a histologial diagnosis because we only performed a biopsy before irradiation. Therefore, the diagnosis of our case was considered to be a mixed germ cell tumor mainly consisting of germinoma and mature teratoma.
Although our patient underwent VP shunting, metastasis via shunt tube is deniable because the metastatic lesions arose in the retroperitoneal space, and there were no lesions in the abdominal cavity at autopsy. In some patients with primary intracranial germ cell tumors, metachronous lesions in the midline structures have been reported. According to the literature, metachronous lesions developed in the different site of the brain, mediastinum, or testis 8 months to 16 years after complete remission of the primary intracranial lesion [7–9]. As far as we are aware, metachronous multiple occurrence of germ cell tumors has not been reported. Remission of the primary pineal lesion could not be achieved for our case, and the retroperitoneal space and posterior mediastinal lesions were found 11 months after last surgery. The time interval between the initial and second lesions was short compared with previous metachronous cases. Ultimately, the lesion was also confirmed in the lung. Therefore, in our case, extraneural lesions were thought to be hematogenous, rather than metachronous, metastasis. Multiple surgery, including endoscopic biopsy, VP shunting, and craniotomies were regarded as possible factors in the hematogeneous spread.
Hematogenous metastasis from germinoma is rare, only 13 cases have been reported [1, 10–21]. These were ten male patients and three females, aged 9 months to 52 years (median 17.5 years). The duration to metastasis from the initial treatment ranged from 0 to 10.5 years (median 2.4 years). The most common metastatic site was bone, followed by lung, lymph nodes, and soft tissue. Although radiation was used as initial treatment for 11 of the 13 patients, chemotherapy was not performed in all patients. Most patients underwent chemotherapy after metastasis was confirmed. Eight of 13 patients were dead at a time of reporting. The median time to death from metastasis was 4.5 months (range 1 month to 1 year). Hematogenous metastasis from germinoma resulted in a poor outcome. The mechanism of metastasis remains unclear. Previous reports proposed that surgical damage to the blood–brain barrier and immunosuppression by repeated irradiation or chemotherapy may have contributed to the events leading to metastasis [2].
Germinomas are often cured with radiation. In our case, the germinomatous component in the primary region disappeared after radiation. However, metastasis occurred 14 months after presentation. Chemotherapy could not be used as the initial treatment because the patient’s condition was poor. Chemotherapy with cisplatin and etoposide were ineffective because of an adverse allergic reaction and poor general condition, but the lesions transiently diminished in size during the chemotherapy. According to previous reports, chemotherapy was effective for patients with germ cell tumor with metastatic extraneural lesions [1, 14]. However, metastatic lesions are difficult to cure and tend to be associated with poor outcome. Recently, the standard protocol for treatment of germ cell tumors has been chemotherapy followed by radiotherapy [22, 23]. Chemotherapy has not been used for all patients with hematogenous metastasis from germinoma, including our case. Germinomas have often been cured with radiation alone. Chemotherapy and irradiation as initial treatment for primary lesions is important to cure the primary lesion and prevent extraneural metastasis.