Abstract
Almost 80 million people globally are forcibly displaced. A small number reach wealthy western countries and seek asylum. Over half are children. Wealthy reception countries have increasingly adopted restrictive reception practices including immigration detention. There is an expanding literature on the mental health impacts of immigration detention for adults, but less about children. This scoping review identified 22 studies of children detained by 6 countries (Australia, Canada, Hong Kong, Netherlands, the UK and the US) through searches of Medline, PsychINFO, Emcare, CINAHL and Scopus data bases for the period January 1992–May 2019. The results are presented thematically. There is quantitative data about the mental health of children and parents who are detained and qualitative evidence includes the words and drawings of detained children. The papers are predominantly small cross-sectional studies using mixed methodologies with convenience samples. Despite weaknesses in individual studies the review provides a rich and consistent picture of the experience and impact of immigration detention on children’s wellbeing, parental mental health and parenting. Displaced children are exposed to peri-migration trauma and loss compounded by further adversity while held detained. There are high rates of distress, mental disorder, physical health and developmental problems in children aged from infancy to adolescence which persist after resettlement. Restrictive detention is a particularly adverse reception experience and children and parents should not be detained or separated for immigration purposes. The findings have implications for policy and practice. Clinicians and researchers have a role in advocacy for reception polices that support the wellbeing of accompanied and unaccompanied children who seek asylum.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
UNHCR (2020) Figures at a glance. United Nations high commissioner for refugees. https://www.unhcr.org/en-au/figures-at-a-glance.html. Accessed 19 Jul 2020
UNHCR (2019) Global trends; forced displacement in 2018. UNHCR, Geneva
Hodes M, Melisa Mendoza V, Anagnostopoulos D, Triantafyllou K, Abdelhady D, Weiss K, Koposov R, Cuhadaroglu F, Hebebrand J, Skokauskas N (2018) Refugees in Europe: national overviews from key countries with a special focus on child and adolescent mental health. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 27(4):389–399
Silove D, Ventevogel P, Rees S (2017) The contemporary refugee crisis: an overview of mental health challenges. World Psychiatry 16(2):130–139
Silove D, Austin P, Steel Z (2007) No refuge from terror: the impact of detention on the mental health of trauma-affected refugees seeking asylum in Australia. Transcultural Psychiatry 44(3):359–393
Sampson R, Mitchell G (2013) Global trends in immigration detention and alternatives to detention: practical, political and symbolic rationales. J Migrat Hum Secur 1:97–121
Dudley M, Steel Z, Mares S, Newman L (2012) Children and young people in immigration detention. Curr Opin Psychiatry 25(4):285–292
Newman L, Steel Z (2008) The child asylum seeker: psychological and developmental impact of immigration detention. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am 17(3):665–683
AHRC (2014) The forgotten children: national inquiry into children in immigration detention. Australian Human Rights Commission, Sydney
Bronstein I, Montgomery P (2011) Psychological distress in refugee children: a systematic review. Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev 14(1):44–56
Lustig SL, Kia-Keating M, Knight WG, Geltman P, Ellis H, Kinzie DJ, Keane T, Saxe GN (2004) Review of child and adolescent refugee mental health. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 43(1):24–36
Fazel M, Reed RV, Panter-Brick C, Stein A (2012) Mental health of displaced and refugee children resettled in high-income countries: risk and protective factors. The Lancet 379(9812):266–282
Reed RV, Fazel M, Jones L, Panter-Brick C, Stein A (2012) Mental health of displaced and refugee children resettled in low-income and middle-income countries: risk and protective factors. The Lancet 379(9812):250–265
Kien C, Sommer I, Faustmann A, Gibson L, Schneider M, Krczal E, Jank R, Klerings I, Szelag M, Kerschner B, Brattstrom P, Gartlehner G (2019) Prevalence of mental disorders in young refugees and asylum seekers in European Countries: a systematic review. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 28(10):1295–1310
Vossoughi N, Jackson Y, Gusler S, Stone K (2018) Mental health outcomes for youth living in refugee camps: a review. Trauma Violence Abuse 19(5):528–542
El Baba R, Colucci E (2018) Post-traumatic stress disorders, depression, and anxiety in unaccompanied refugee minors exposed to war-related trauma: a systematic review. Int J Culture Mental Health 11(2):194–207
Muller LRF, Buter KP, Rosner R, Unterhitzenberger J (2019) Mental health and associated stress factors in accompanied and unaccompanied refugee minors resettled in Germany: a cross-sectional study. Child Adolescent Psychiatry Mental Health 13:8
Miles EM, Narayan AJ, Watamura SE (2019) Syrian caregivers in perimigration: a systematic review from an ecological systems perspective. Transl Issues Psychol Sci 5(1):78–90
LeBrun A, Hassan G, Boivin M, Fraser S-L, Dufour S, Lavergne C (2015) Review of child maltreatment in immigrant and refugee families. Can J Public Health 106(7):eS45–eS56
Bryant RA, Edwards B, Creamer M, O'Donnell M, Forbes D, Felmingham KL, Silove D, Steel Z, Nickerson A, McFarlane AC (2018) The effect of post-traumatic stress disorder on refugees' parenting and their children's mental health: a cohort study. Lancet Public Health 3(5):e249–e258
Sim A, Fazel M, Bowes L, Gardner F (2018) Pathways linking war and displacement to parenting and child adjustment: a qualitative study with Syrian refugees in Lebanon. Soc Sci Med 200:19–26
Zion D (2013) On secrets and lies: dangerous information, stigma and asylum seeker research. In: Block K, Riggs E, Haslam N (eds) Values and vulnerabilities: the ethics of research with refugees and asylum seekers. Australian Academic Press, Bowen Hills, pp 191–206
Newman L (2013) Researching immigration detention: documenting damage and ethical dilemmas. In: Block K, Riggs E, Haslam N (eds) Values and vulnerabilities: the ethics of research with refugees and asylum seekers. Australian Academic Press, Bowen HIlls, pp 173–190
Kronick R, Cleveland J, Rousseau C (2018) “Do you want to help or go to war?”: Ethical challenges of critical research in immigration detention in Canada. J Soc Polit Psychol 6(2):644–660
Ziersch A, Due C, Arthurson K, Loehr N (2017) Conducting ethical research with people from asylum seeker and refugee backgrounds. In: Liamputtong P (ed) Handbook of research methods in health social sciences. Springer, Singapore, pp 1–19
Block K, Warr D, Gibbs L, Riggs E (2012) Addressing ethical and methodological challenges in research with refugee-background young people: reflections from the field. J Refugee Stud 26(1):69–87
Due D, Riggs DW, Augoustinos M (2014) Research with children of migrant and refugee backgrounds: a review of child-centered research methods. Child Indic Res 7(1):209–227
Hopkins P (2008) Ethical issues in research with unaccompanied asylum-seeking children. Children's Geographies 6(1):37–48
Rousseau C (1993) The place of the unexpressed: ethics and methodology for research with refugee children. Can Ment Health 41(4):12–16
Fazel M, Wheeler J, Danesh J (2005) Prevalence of serious mental disorder in 7000 refugees resettled in western countries: a systematic review. The Lancet 365(9467):1309–1314
Robjant K, Hassan R, Katona C (2009) Mental health implications of detaining asylum seekers: systematic review. Br J Psychiatry 194(4):306–312
von Werthern M, Robjant K, Chui Z, Schon R, Ottisova L, Mason C, Katona C (2018) The impact of immigration detention on mental health: a systematic review. BMC Psychiatry 18(1):382
Baggio S, Gonçalves L, Heeren A, Heller P, Gétaz L, Graf M, Rossegger A, Endrass J, Wolff H (2020) The mental health burden of immigration detention: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Criminology 2:219
Cleveland J, Rousseau C (2013) Psychiatric symptoms associated with brief detention of adult asylum seekers in Canada. Can J Psychiatry 58(7):409–416
Arksey H, O'Malley L (2005) Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res Methodol 8(1):19–32
Tricco AC, Lillie E, Zarin W, O’Brien K, Colquhoun H, Kastner M, Levac D, Ng C, Sharpe JP, Wilson K (2016) A scoping review on the conduct and reporting of scoping reviews. BMC Med Res Methodol 16(1):15
Peters M, Godfrey CM, Khalil H, McInerney P, Parker D, Soares CB (2015) Guidance for conducting systematic scoping reviews. Int J Evid Based Healthcare 13(3):141–146
Tricco AC, Lillie E, Zarin W, O'Brien KK, Colquhoun H, Levac D, Moher D, Peters MJ, Horsley T, Weeks L (2018) PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR): checklist and explanation. Ann Intern Med 169(7):467–473
Wood LC (2018) Impact of punitive immigration policies, parent-child separation and child detention on the mental health and development of children. BMJ Paediatrics Open 2(1):e000338
Musalo K, Lee E (2017) Seeking a rational approach to a regional refugee crisis: lessons from the summer 2014 “surge” of Central American women and children at the US-Mexico border. J Migrat Hum Secur 5(1):137–179
Sriraman NK (2019) Detention of immigrant children—a growing crisis. What is the Pediatrician's role? Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care 49(2):50–53
UNHCR (2014) Options for governments on care arrangements and alternatives to detention for children and families. UNHCR, Geneva
Hamilton C, Anderson K, Barnes R, Dorling K (2011) Administrative detention of children: a global report. United Nations Children’s Fund, New York
Lorek A, Ehntholt K, Nesbitt A, Wey E, Githinji C, Rossor E, Wickramasinghe R (2009) The mental and physical health difficulties of children held within a British immigration detention center: a pilot study. Child Abuse Negl 33(9):573–585
MacLean SA, Agyeman PO, Walther J, Singer EK, Baranowski KA, Katz CL (2019) Mental health of children held at a United States immigration detention center. Soc Sci Med 230:303–308
Mares S, Jureidini J (2004) Psychiatric assessment of children and families in immigration detention–clinical, administrative and ethical issues. Aust N Z J Public Health 28(6):520–526
Steel Z, Momartin S, Bateman C, Hafshejani A, Silove DM, Everson N, Roy K, Dudley M, Newman L, Blick B, Mares S (2004) Psychiatric status of asylum seeker families held for a protracted period in a remote detention centre in Australia. Aust N Z J Public Health 28(6):527–536
Mares S (2016) The mental health of children and parents detained on Christmas Island: secondary analysis of an Australian Human Rights Commission data set. Health Hum Rights J 18(2):219–232
Rothe EM, Castillo-Matos H, Busquets R (2002) Posttraumtic stress symptoms in Cuban adolescent refugees during camp confinement. Adolesc Psychiatry 26:97–124
Reijneveld SA, de Boer JB, Bean T, Korfker DG (2005) Unaccompanied adolescents seeking asylum: poorer mental health under a restrictive reception. J Nerv Ment Dis 193(11):759–761
Ehntholt KA, Trickey D, Harris HJ, Chambers H, Scott M, Yule W (2018) Mental health of unaccompanied asylum-seeking adolescents previously held in British detention centres. Clin Child Psychol Psychiatry 23(2):238–257
Rothe EM, Lewis J, Castillo-Matos H, Martinez O, Busquets R, Martinez I (2002) Posttraumatic stress disorder among Cuban children and adolescents after release from a refugee camp. Psychiatr Serv 53(8):970–976
Mares S, Newman L, Dudley M, Gale F (2002) Seeking refuge, losing hope: parents and children in immigration detention. Aust Psychiatry 10(2):91–96
Mares S, Zwi K (2015) Sadness and fear: The experiences of children and families in remote Australian immigration detention. J Paediatr Child Health 51(7):663–669
Zwi K, Mares S (2015) Stories from unaccompanied children in immigration detention: a composite account. J Paediatr Child Health 51(7):658–662
McCallin M (1992) Living in detention: a review of the psychological well-being of Vietnamese children in the Hong Kong detention centres. International Catholic Child Bureau, Geneva
Sultan A, O'Sullivan K (2001) Psychological disturbances in asylum seekers held in long term detention: a participant-observer account. Med J Aust 175(11–12):593–596
Essex R, Govintharajah P (2017) Mental health of children and adolescents in Australian alternate places of immigration detention. J Paediatr Child Health 53(6):525–528
Zwi K, Herzberg B, Dossetor D, Field J (2003) A child in detention: dilemmas faced by health professionals. Med J Aust 179(6):319–322
Kronick R, Rousseau C, Cleveland J (2015) Asylum-seeking children's experiences of detention in Canada: a qualitative study. Am J Orthopsychiatry 85(3):287–294
Kronick R, Rousseau C, Cleveland J (2018) Refugee children’s sandplay narratives in immigration detention in Canada. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 27(4):423–437
Zwi K, Mares S, Nathanson D, Tay AK, Silove D (2017) The impact of detention on the social–emotional wellbeing of children seeking asylum: a comparison with community-based children. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 27(4):411–422
Deans AK, Boerma CJ, Fordyce J, De Souza M, Palmer DJ, Davis JS (2013) Use of Royal Darwin Hospital emergency department by immigration detainees in 2011. Med J Aust 199(11):776–778
Hanes G, Chee J, Mutch R, Cherian S (2019) Paediatric asylum seekers in Western Australia: identification of adversity and complex needs through comprehensive refugee health assessment. J Paediatr Child Health 55(11):1367–1373
Lenette C, Karan P, Chrysostomou D, Athanasopoulos A (2017) What is it like living in detention? Insights from asylum seeker children’s drawings. Aust J Hum Rights 23(1):42–60
Global Detention Project (2019) Annual report 2019. Global Detention Project, Geneva
Phillips J (2015) Asylum seekers and refugees: what are the facts? (trans: Library P). Research Paper Series 2014–15. Department of Parliamentary Services, Parliament of Australia Canberra
Dutton P (2018) An Interview with the Honourable Peter Dutton, Australia's Minister of Home Affairs. Int Migr 56(5):5–10
Commonwealth of Australia (2017) Serious allegations of abuse, self-harm and neglect of asylum seekers in relation to the Nauru Regional Processing Centre, and any like allegations in relation to the Manus Regional Processing Centre (trans: Affairs LaC, References Committee). Senate, Canberra
Amnesty International (2016) Australia: appalling abuse, neglect of refugees on Nauru. Amnesty International, London
Mares S (2016) Fifteen years of detaining children who seek asylum in Australia—evidence and consequences. Aust Psychiatry 24(1):11–14
Mares S (2020) Mental health consequences of detaining children who seek asylum in Australia and the implications for health professionals: a mixed methods study (2002–2019). Doctorate by Prior Publication. Flinders University, Adelaide
Kaufman J, Birmaher B, Brent D, Rao U, Flynn C, Moreci P, Williamson D, Ryan N (1997) Schedule for affective disorders and schizophrenia for school-age children-present and lifetime version (K-SADS-PL): initial reliability and validity data. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 36(7):980–988
First M, Spitzer R, Gibbon M, Williams J (1997) Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV Axis I disorders (SCID-IV). American Psychiatric Press, New York
Goodman R (2001) Psychometric properties of the strengths and difficulties questionnaire. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 40(11):1337–1345
Brooks RT, Beard J, Steel Z (2006) Factor structure and interpretation of the K10. Psychol Assess 18(1):62–70
Zwi K, Woodland L, Williams K, Palasanthiran P, Rungan S, Jaffe A, Woolfenden S (2018) Protective factors for social-emotional well-being of refugee children in the first three years of settlement in Australia. Arch Dis Child 103(3):261–268
Anda RF, Felitti VJ, Bremner JD, Walker JD, Whitfield C, Perry BD, Dube SR, Giles WH (2006) The enduring effects of abuse and related adverse experiences in childhood. A convergence of evidence from neurobiology and epidemiology. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 256(3):174–186
Hanes G, Sung L, Mutch R, Cherian S (2017) Adversity and resilience amongst resettling Western Australian paediatric refugees. J Paediatr Child Health 53(9):882–888
Pynoos RS (1992) Scoring and interpretation of the post-traumatic stress disorder reactive index (PTSDRI), Department of Psychiatry. University of California, Los Angeles
Achenbach TM, Ruffle TM (2000) The Child Behavior Checklist and related forms for assessing behavioral/emotional problems and competencies. Pediatr Rev 21(8):265–271
Global Detention Project (2017) United States immigration detention. Global Detention Project https://www.globaldetentionproject.org/countries/americas/united-states. Accessed 16 Jul 2020
Ventevogel P, De Vries G, Scholte WF, Shinwari NR, Faiz H, Nassery R, van den Brink W, Olff M (2007) Properties of the Hopkins Symptom Checklist-25 (HSCL-25) and the Self-Reporting Questionnaire (SRQ-20) as screening instruments used in primary care in Afghanistan. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 42(4):328–335
Bean T, Derluyn I, Eurelings-Bontekoe E, Broekaert E, Spinhoven P (2007) Validation of the multiple language versions of the Hopkins Symptom Checklist-37 for refugee adolescents. Adolescence 42(165):51–71
Bean T, Derluyn I, Eurelings-Bontekoe E, Broekaert E, Spinhoven P (2006) Validation of the multiple language versions of the Reactions of Adolescents to Traumatic Stress questionnaire. J Trauma Stress 19(2):241–255
Spence SH (1998) A measure of anxiety symptoms among children. Behav Res Ther 36(5):545–566
Birleson P, Hudson I, Buchanan DG, Wolff S (1987) Clinical evaluation of a self-rating scale for depressive disorder in childhood (Depression Self-Rating Scale). J Child Psychol Psychiatry 28(1):43–60
Smith P, Perrin S, Dyregrov A, Yule W (2003) Principal components analysis of the impact of event scale with children in war. Pers Individ Dif 34(2):315–322
Barkham M, Mellor-Clark J, Connell J, Cahill J (2006) A core approach to practice-based evidence: a brief history of the origins and applications of the CORE-OM and CORE System. Couns Psychother Res 6(1):3–15
Steel Z, Silove D, Brooks R, Momartin S, Alzuhairi B, Susljik I (2006) Impact of immigration detention and temporary protection on the mental health of refugees. Br J Psychiatry 188(1):58–64
MacLean SA, Agyeman PO, Walther J, Singer EK, Baranowski KA, Katz CL (2020) Characterization of the mental health of immigrant children separated from their mothers at the US–Mexico border. Psychiatry Res 286:112555
American Psychological Association (2018) Statement on the effects of deportation and forced separation on immigrants, their families, and communities: a policy statement by the society for community research action: division 27 of the APA. Am J Community Psychol 62(1–2):3–12
Rowatt WC, Al-Kire RL, Dunn H, Leman J (2020) Attitudes toward separating immigrant families at the United States-Mexico Border. Anal Soc Issues Public Policy. https://doi.org/10.1111/asap.12198
Appleyard K, Egeland B, van Dulmen MH, Sroufe LA (2005) When more is not better: the role of cumulative risk in child behavior outcomes. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 46(3):235–245
Evans GW, Li D, Whipple SS (2013) Cumulative risk and child development. Psychol Bull 139(6):1342–1396
Dudley M (2016) Helping professionals and Border Force secrecy: effective asylum-seeker healthcare requires independence from callous policies. Aust Psychiatry 24(1):15–18
Howe KR (2012) Mixed methods, triangulation, and causal explanation. J Mixed Methods Res 6(2):89–96
Ngo T, Hodes M (2019) Pervasive Refusal Syndrome in asylum-seeking children: review of the current evidence. Clin Child Psychol Psychiatry 25:227–241
Bodegard G (2005) Life-threatening loss of function in refugee children: another expression of pervasive refusal syndrome? Clin Child Psychol Psychiatry 10(3):337–350
Isaacs D (2019) Pervasive refusal syndrome and Nauru. J Paediatr Child Health 55(2):127–128
MSF (2018) Indefinite despair-The tragic mental health consequences of offshore processing on Nauru. https://msf.org.au/article/statements-opinion/indefinite-despair-mental-health-consequences-nauru. Accessed 14 Mar 2019
Achenbach TM, Becker A, Döpfner M, Heiervang E, Roessner V, Steinhausen HC, Rothenberger A (2008) Multicultural assessment of child and adolescent psychopathology with ASEBA and SDQ instruments: research findings, applications, and future directions. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 49(3):251–275
Zeanah CH, Smyke AT, Dumitrescu A (2002) Attachment disturbances in young children. II: Indiscriminate behavior and institutional care. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 41(8):983–989
Silove D (2013) The ADAPT model: a conceptual framework for mental health and psychosocial programming in post conflict settings. Intervention 11(3):237–248
Fazel M, Betancourt TS (2018) Preventive mental health interventions for refugee children and adolescents in high-income settings. Lancet Child Adolescent Health 2(2):121–132
Hodes M, Vostanis P (2018) Practitioner Review: mental health problems of refugee children and adolescents and their management. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 60(7):716–731
Briskman L, Zion D (2014) Dual loyalties and impossible dilemmas: health care in immigration detention. Public Health Ethics 7(3):277–286
Essex R (2016) Healthcare and complicity in Australian immigration detention. Monash Bioeth Rev 34(2):136–147
UN (1990) Convention on the rights of the child. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, Geneva
Newman L, Proctor N, Dudley M (2013) Seeking asylum in Australia: immigration detention, human rights and mental health care. Aust Psychiatry 21(4):315–320
Kronick R, Rousseau C, Beder M, Goel R (2017) International solidarity to end immigration detention. The Lancet 389(10068):501–502
Essex R (2019) Psychology and its response to major human rights abuses. Eur Psychol 24(2):195–203
Silove D, Mares S (2018) The mental health of asylum seekers in Australia and the role of psychiatrists. Br J Psych Int 15(3):65–68
Zion D (2013) Extending the clinical contract: advocacy as a part of ethical health care for asylum seekers. Am J Bioethics 13(7):19–21
Acknowledgements
The research for this paper was undertaken during PhD candidature at Flinders University, Adelaide, South Australia. An earlier version of the work is included in the completed thesis.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mares, S. Mental health consequences of detaining children and families who seek asylum: a scoping review. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 30, 1615–1639 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00787-020-01629-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00787-020-01629-x