The impact of the PBL scheme and the vertical distribution of model layers on simulations of Alpine foehn Article First Online: 12 November 2007 Received: 20 December 2006 Accepted: 09 August 2007 DOI:
Cite this article as: Zängl, G., Gohm, A. & Obleitner, F. Meteorol Atmos Phys (2008) 99: 105. doi:10.1007/s00703-007-0276-1 Summary
This paper investigates the influence of the planetary boundary-layer (PBL) parameterization and the vertical distribution of model layers on simulations of an Alpine foehn case that was observed during the Mesoscale Alpine Programme (MAP) in autumn 1999. The study is based on the PSU/NCAR MM5 modelling system and combines five different PBL schemes with three model layer settings, which mainly differ in the height above ground of the lowest model level (
z 1). Specifically, z 1 takes values of about 7 m, 22 m and 36 m, and the experiments with z 1 = 7 m are set up such that the second model level is located at z = 36 m. To assess if the different model setups have a systematic impact on the model performance, the simulation results are compared against wind lidar, radiosonde and surface measurements gathered along the Austrian Wipp Valley. Moreover, the dependence of the simulated wind and temperature fields at a given height (36 m above ground) on z 1 is examined for several different regions.
Our validation results show that at least over the Wipp Valley, the dependence of the model skill on
z 1 tends to be larger and more systematic than the impact of the PBL scheme. The agreement of the simulated wind field with observations tends to benefit from moving the lowest model layer closer to the ground, which appears to be related to the dependence of lee-side flow separation on z 1. However, the simulated 2 m-temperatures are closest to observations for the intermediate z 1 of 22 m. This is mainly related to the fact that the simulated low-level temperatures decrease systematically with decreasing z 1 for all PBL schemes, turning a positive bias at z 1 = 36 m into a negative bias at z 1 = 7 m. The systematic z 1-dependence is also observed for the temperatures at a fixed height of 36 m, indicating a deficiency in the self-consistency of the model results that is not related to a specific PBL formulation. Possible reasons for this deficiency are discussed in the paper. On the other hand, a systematic z 1-dependence of the 36-m wind speed is encountered only for one out of the five PBL schemes. This turns out to be related to an unrealistic profile of the vertical mixing coefficient.
Correspondence: Günther Zängl, Meteorologisches Institut der Universitat München, 80333 München, Germany
References Arya, SP 1988Introduction to micrometeorology Academic Press New York Google Scholar
de Arellano JV-G, Vellinga OS, Holtslag AAM, Bosveld FC, Klein-Baltink H (2001) Observational evaluation of PBL parameterizations modeled by MM5. Proc. 11th PSU/NCAR MM5 Users Workshop, Boulder, CO, NCAR, pp 102–105
Ayotte, KW, Sullivan, PP, Andren, A, Doney, SC, Holtslag, AAM, Large, WG, McWilliams, JC, Moeng, H-H, Otte, MJ, Tribbia, JJ, Wyngaard, JC 1996 An evaluation of neutral and convective planetary boundary-layer parameterizations relative to large eddy simulations Bound Layer Meteor 79 131 175 CrossRef Google Scholar Ballard, SP, Golding, BW, Smith, RNB 1991 Mesoscale model experimental forecasts of the Haar of northeast Scotland Mon Wea Rev 119 2107 2123 CrossRef Google Scholar Berg, LK, Zhong, S 2005 Sensitivity of MM5-simulated boundary layer characteristics to turbulence parameterizations J Appl Meteor 44 1467 1483 CrossRef Google Scholar Braun, SA, Tao, WK 2000 Sensitivity of high-resolution simulations of hurricane Bob (1991) to planetary boundary layer parameterizations Mon Wea Rev 128 3941 3961 CrossRef Google Scholar Bright, DR, Mullen, SL 2002 The sensitivity of the numerical simulations of the southwest monsoon boundary layer to the choice of PBL turbulence parameterization in MM5 Wea Forecasting 17 99 114 CrossRef Google Scholar Burk, SD, Thompson, WT 1989 A vertically nested regional numerical weather prediction model with second-order closure physics Mon Wea Rev 117 2305 2324 CrossRef Google Scholar Delage, Y 1997 Parameterising sub-grid scale vertical transport in atmospheric models under statically stable conditions Bound Layer Meteor 82 23 48 CrossRef Google Scholar Dudhia, J 1989 Numerical study of convection observed during the Winter Monsoon Experiment using a mesoscale two-dimensional model J Atmos Sci 46 3077 3107 CrossRef Google Scholar
Dudhia J, Gill D, Manning K, Wang W, Bruyere C (2005) PSU/NCAR Mesoscale Modeling System tutorial class notes and users’ guide (MM5 Modeling System Version 3). Online document, available from
http://www.mmm.ucar.edu/mm5/documents/ Gohm, A, Zängl, G, Mayr, GJ 2004 South Foehn in the Wipp Valley on 24 October 1999 (MAP IOP 10): verification of high-resolution numerical simulations with observations Mon Wea Rev 132 78 102 CrossRef Google Scholar Grell, GA 1993 Prognostic evaluation of assumptions used by cumulus parameterizations Mon Wea Rev 121 764 787 CrossRef Google Scholar
Grell GA, Dudhia J, Stauffer DR (1995) A description of the fifth-generation Penn State/NCAR mesoscale model (MM5). NCAR Tech. Note NCAR/TN-398+STR, 122 pp
Holt, T, Raman, S 1988 A review and comparative evaluation of multilevel boundary layer parameterizations for furst-order and turbulence kinetic energy closure schemes Rev Geophys 26 761 780 CrossRef Google Scholar Hong, S-Y, Pan, H-L 1996 Nonlocal boundary-layer vertical diffusion in a medium-range forecast model Mon Wea Rev 124 2322 2339 CrossRef Google Scholar Janjić, ZI 1990 The step-mountain eta coordinate model: Further developments of the convection, viscous sublayer and turbulence closure schemes Mon Wea Rev 122 927 945 CrossRef Google Scholar Janjić, ZI 1994 The step-mountain coordinate: physical package Mon Wea Rev 118 1429 1443 CrossRef Google Scholar Kain, JS 2004 The Kain-Fritsch convective parameterization: an update J Appl Meteor 43 170 181 CrossRef Google Scholar Kain, JS, Fritsch, JM 1990 A one-dimensional entraining/detraining plume model and its application in convective parameterization J Atmos Sci 47 2784 2802 CrossRef Google Scholar Keil, C, Cardinali, C 2004 The ECMWF re-analysis of the MAP special observing period Quart J Roy Met Soc 130 2827 2849 CrossRef Google Scholar Klemp, JB, Durran, DR 1983 An upper boundary condition permitting internal gravity wave radiation in numerical mesoscale models Mon Wea Rev 111 430 444 CrossRef Google Scholar
Lewis HW (2006) The dynamics of the atmospheric boundary layer over steep terrain. Ph.D. thesis, University of Leeds, 305 pp
Louis, JF 1979 A parametric model of vertical eddy fluxes in the atmosphere Bound Layer Meteor 17 187 202 CrossRef Google Scholar Mahfouf, JF, Richard, E, Mascart, P, Nickerson, EC, Rosset, R 1987 A comparative study of various parameterizations of the planetary boundary layer in a numerical mesoscale model J Clim Appl Meteor 26 1671 1695 CrossRef Google Scholar Mellor, GL, Yamada, T 1974 A hierarchy of turbulence closure models for planetary boundary layers J Atmos Sci 31 1791 1806 CrossRef Google Scholar Mlawer, EJ, Taubman, SJ, Brown, PD, Iacono, MJ, Clough, SA 1997 Radiative transfer for inhomogeneous atmosphere: RRTM, a validated correlated-k model for the longwave J Geophys Res 102 16663 16682 CrossRef Google Scholar Pan, Z, Benjamin, SG, Brown, JM, Smirnova, T 1994 Comparative experiments with MAPS on different parameterization schemes for surface moisture flux and boundary-layer processes Mon Wea Rev 122 449 470 CrossRef Google Scholar Post, MJ, Cupp, RE 1990 Optimizing a pulsed Doppler lidar Appl Optics 29 4145 4158 CrossRef Google Scholar Poulos, GS, Burns, SP 2003 An evaluation of bulk Ri-based surface layer flux formulas for stable and very stable conditions with intermittent turbulence J Atmos Sci 60 2523 2537 CrossRef Google Scholar Reisner, J, Rasmussen, RM, Bruintjes, RT 1998 Explicit forecasting of supercooled liquid water in winter storms using the MM5 mesoscale model Quart J Roy Met Soc 124 1071 1107 CrossRef Google Scholar Shafran, PC, Seaman, NL, Gayno, GA 2000 Evaluation of numerical predictions of boundary layer structure during the Lake Michigan Ozone Study (LMOS) J Appl Meteorol 39 412 426 CrossRef Google Scholar Zängl, G 2002a Stratified flow over a mountain with a gap. Linear theory and numerical simulations Quart J Roy Met Soc 128 927 949 CrossRef Google Scholar Zängl, G 2002b An improved method for computing horizontal diffusion in a sigma-coordinate model and its application to simulations over mountainous topography Mon Wea Rev 130 1423 1432 CrossRef Google Scholar Zängl, G 2003a A generalized sigma coordinate system for the MM5 Mon Wea Rev 131 2875 2884 CrossRef Google Scholar Zängl, G 2003b Deep and shallow south foehn in the region of Innsbruck: typical features and semi-idealized numerical simulations Meteorol Atmos Phys 83 237 261 Google Scholar Zängl, G 2004 The sensitivity of simulated orographic precipitation to model components other than cloud microphysics Quart J Roy Met Soc 130 1857 1875 CrossRef Google Scholar Zängl, G, Gohm, A, Geier, G 2004 South foehn in the Wipp Valley – Innsbruck region: numerical simulations of the 24 October 1999 case (MAP-IOP 10) Meteorol Atmos Phys 86 213 243 CrossRef Google Scholar Zängl, G, Gohm, A 2006 Small-scale dynamics of the foehn in the lower Wipp Valley Meteorol Atmos Phys 93 79 95 CrossRef Google Scholar Zhang, D, Anthes, RA 1982 A high-resolution model of the planetary boundary layer – sensitivity tests and comparisons with SESAME-79 data J Appl Meteor 21 1594 1609 CrossRef Google Scholar Zhang, D-L, Zheng, W-Z 2004 Diurnal cycles of surface winds and temperatures as simulated by five boundary layer parameterizations J Appl Meteor 43 157 169 CrossRef Google Scholar