Effects of intraoperative breaks on mental and somatic operator fatigue: a randomized clinical trial
- 762 Downloads
Intermittent work breaks are common in fields with high workload but not yet for surgeons during operations. We evaluated the effects of intraoperative breaks during complex laparoscopic surgery (5 min every half hour) on the surgeon.
Fifty-one operations were randomized to a scheme with intraoperative breaks and release of the pneumoperitoneum (intermittent pneumoperitoneum (IPP)) or conventional conduct (CPP). Stress hormones and α-amylase were determined in the surgeon’s saliva pre-, intra-, and postoperatively. Mental performance and error scores, musculoskeletal strain, and continuous ECG were secondary endpoints.
Regular intraoperative breaks did not prolong the operation (IPP vs. CPP group: 176 vs. 180 min, p > 0.05). The surgeon’s cortisol levels during the operation were reduced by 22 ± 10.3% in the IPP vs. the CPP group (p < 0.05). There were significantly fewer (p < 0.05) intraoperative events in the IPP vs. the CPP group, which yielded higher α-amylase peaks. The pre- to postoperative increase in the error rates of the bp-concentration test was fourfold reduced in the IPP group (p = 0.052). The relevant locomotive strain-scores were grossly reduced by IPP (p < 0.001).
Our data support the idea that work breaks during complex laparoscopic surgery can reduce psychological stress and preserve performance without prolongation of the operation time compared with the traditional work scheme.
KeywordsIntermittent pneumoperitoneum Work breaks Complex laparoscopic surgery Stress hormones Concentration–error performance
We thank D. Auge and A. Osthaus, MHH for expert help with ECG systems and cardiac output determination, Dr. Judith Orsanu from NASA’s Ames research center in California for discussion, and Prof. R. Dietrich, Humbold University Berlin/Germany for information on simultaneous translation and Mr. Bill Groundwater, Kirkwall/Orkney for help with the manuscript.
This study was financed from the Hannover Medical School general health care budget. Drs. Engelmann, Schneider, Dingemann, Schoof, Ure, and Professors Kirschbaum and Grote have no conflicts of interest or financial ties to disclose.
- 1.Farmer E, Brownson A (2003) Review of workload measurement, analysis and interpretation methods (CARE-Integra-TRS-130-02-WP2). 1130 Brussels, Belgium, Rue de la Fusée 96: EurocontrolGoogle Scholar
- 2.AICC. Guidelines for simultaneous translation. http://www.aiic.de/english/suche_arten2.php. Accessed 2008
- 3.Kilian H (1957) Hinter uns steht nur der Herrgott [“Behind us only god”]. Kindler Publishers, München, pp 1–385Google Scholar
- 5.Janssen WH (2004) Route planning and route guidance: a review of the literature (Report IZF 1979-C13). Instituut voor Zintuigfysiologie, SoesterbergGoogle Scholar
- 6.O’Donnel RD, Eggemeier FT (1986) Workload assessment methodology. In: Boff KR, Kaufmann L, Thomas JP (eds) Handbook of perception and human performance. Volume II, cognitive processes and performance. Wiley, New York, pp 42/1–42/49Google Scholar
- 7.DT (determination) test www.schuhfried.at. Accessed 2008
- 8.Wickens CD (1991) Processing resources and attention. In: Damos DL (ed) Multiple-task performance. Taylor & Francis, London, pp 3–34Google Scholar
- 9.Mulder G, Mulder LJM (1980) Coping with mental workload. In: Levine S, Ursin H (eds) Coping and health. Plenum Press, New York, pp 233–258Google Scholar
- 11.Wickens CD (1992) Engineering psychology and human performance. Harper Collins, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- 14.U.S. Department of Defense (1999) Human engineering program process and procedures (MIL-HDBK-46855A)Google Scholar
- 15.Brickenkamp R, Yillmer E (1998) The d2 test of attention, 1st U.S. edn. Hogrefe & Huber, SeattleGoogle Scholar
- 17.Weston-Lovelock K, Abram A (1996) Establishing the reliability of behaviorally anchored rating scales at the RCB (report no. PLSD/CHS/HS3/CR96055/1.0). DERA, FarnboroughGoogle Scholar
- 19.Damos DL (1996) Multiple-tasks performance. Taylor and Francis Ltd, London, pp 328–360Google Scholar
- 23.Cook NJ (1992) Salivary cortisol and testosterone as markers of stress in normal subjects in abnormal situations. In: Kirschbaum C (ed) Assessment of hormones and drugs in saliva in biobehavioral research. Hogrefe & Huber, SeattleGoogle Scholar
- 25.Gartner WB, Murphy MR (1979) Concepts of workload. In: Hartman BO, McKenyie RE (eds) Survey of methods to assess workload; AGARDograph no. 246. AGARD, Neuilly-sur-SeineGoogle Scholar
- 27.Egan JP (1975) Signal detection theory and ROC analysis. Academic Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- 28.Meister D (1976) Behavioral foundation of system development. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar