Abstract
This work reviews the key aspects of coronary and neurovascular flow reserves with an emphasis on physiomic modeling characteristics by the use of a variety of numerical approaches. First, we explain the definition of fractional flow reserve (FFR) in coronary artery and introduce its clinical significance. Then, computational researches for obtaining FFR are reviewed, and their clinical outcomes are compared. In the case of cerebrovascular reserve (CVR), in spite of substantial progress in the simulation of cerebral hemodynamics, only a few computational studies exist. Thus, we discuss the limitations of CVR simulation study and suggest the challenging issue to overcome these. Also, the future direction of physiomic researches for the flow reserves in coronary arteries and cerebral arteries is described. Also, we introduce a machine learning algorithm trained by the existing physiomic simulation data of flow reserve and suggest a prospective research direction related to this.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adiputra Y, Chen SL (2015) Clinical relevance of coronary fractional flow reserve: art-of-state. Chin Med J 128(10):1399–1406. doi:10.4103/0366-6999.156805
Alastruey J, Parker KH, Peiró J, Byrd SM, Sherwin SJ (2007) Modelling the circle of Willis to assess the effects of anatomical variations and occlusions on cerebral flows. J Biomech 40(8):1794–1805. doi:10.1016/j.jbiomech.2006.07.008
Berry C, van’t Veer M, Witt N, Kala P, Bocek O, Pyxaras SA, McClure JD, Fearon WF, Barbato E, Tonino PA, De Bruyne B, Pijls NH, Oldroyd KG (2013) VERIFY (VERification of Instantaneous Wave-Free Ratio and Fractional Flow Reserve for the Assessment of Coronary Artery Stenosis Severity in EverydaY Practice): a multicenter study in consecutive patients. J Am Coll Cardiol 61(13):1421–1427. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2012.09.065
Coenen A, Lubbers MM, Kurata A, Kono A, Dedic A, Chelu RG, Dijkshoorn ML, Gijsen FJ, Ouhlous M, van Geuns RM (2015) Fractional flow reserve computed from noninvasive CT angiography data: diagnostic performance of an on-site clinician-operated computational fluid dynamics algorithm. Radiology 274(3):674–683. doi:10.1148/radiol.14140992
Deng SB, Jing XD, Wang J, Huang C, Xia S, Du JL, Liu YJ, She Q (2015) Diagnostic performance of noninvasive fractional flow reserve derived from coronary computed tomography angiography in coronary artery disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Cardiol 184:703–709. doi:10.1016/j.ijcard.2015.03.025
Douglas PS, Pontone G, Hlatky MA, Patel MR, Norgaard BL, Byrne RA, Curzen N, Purcell I, Gutberlet M, Rioufol G (2015) Clinical outcomes of fractional flow reserve by computed tomographic angiography-guided diagnostic strategies vs. usual care in patients with suspected coronary artery disease: the prospective longitudinal trial of FFRCT: outcome and resource impacts study. Eur Heart J 36(47):3359–3367. doi:10.1093/eurheartj/ehv444
Douglas PS, De Bruyne B, Pontone G, Patel MR, Norgaard BL, Byrne RA, Curzen N, Purcell I, Gutberlet M, Rioufol G, Hink U, Schuchlenz HW, Feuchtner G, Gilard M, Andreini D, Jensen JM, Hadamitzky M, Chiswell K, Cyr D, Wilk A, Wang F, Rogers C, Hlatky MA (2016) 1-Year outcomes of FFRCT-guided care in patients with suspected coronary disease: the PLATFORM study. J Am Coll Cardiol 68(5):435–445. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2016.05.057
Gould KL, Lipscomb K, Hamilton GW (1974) Physiologic basis for assessing critical coronary stenosis. Instantaneous flow response and regional distribution during coronary hyperemia as measures of coronary flow reserve. Am J Cardiol 33(1):87–94
Grinberg L, Anor T, Cheever E, Madsen JR, Karniadakis GE (2009) Simulation of the human intracranial arterial tree. Philos Trans A Math Phys Eng Sci 367(1896):2371–2386. doi:10.1098/rsta.2008.0307
Hickman M, Jeetley P, Senior R (2004) Usefulness of myocardial contrast echocardiography derived coronary flow reserve to accurately determine severity of left anterior descending coronary artery stenosis. Am J Cardiol 93(9):1159–1162. doi:10.1016/j.amjcard.2004.01.047
Hlatky MA, De Bruyne B, Pontone G, Patel MR, Norgaard BL, Byrne RA, Curzen N, Purcell I, Gutberlet M, Rioufol G (2015) Quality-of-life and economic outcomes of assessing fractional flow reserve with computed tomography angiography: PLATFORM. J Am Coll Cardiol 66(21):2315–2323. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2015.09.051
Itu L, Rapaka S, Passerini T, Georgescu B, Schwemmer C, Schobinger M, Thomas F, Sharma P, Comaniciu D (2016) A machine learning approach for computation of fractional flow reserve from coronary computed tomography. J Appl Physiol 121(1):42–52. doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00752.2015
Kent S, Briggs A, Eckermann S, Berry C (2013) Are value of information methods ready for prime time? An application to alternative treatment strategies for NSTEMI patients. Int J Technol Assess Health Care 29(4):435–442. doi:10.1017/S0266462313000433
Kim KH, Doh JH, Koo BK, Min JK, Erglis A, Yang HM, Park KW, Lee HY, Kang HJ, Kim YJ (2014) A novel noninvasive technology for treatment planning using virtual coronary stenting and computed tomography-derived computed fractional flow reserve. JACC Cardiovasc Interv. 7(1):72–78. doi:10.1016/j.jcin.2013.05.024
Ko NU, Achrol AS, Chopra M, Saha M, Gupta D, Smith WS, Higashida RT, Young WL (2005) Cerebral blood flow changes after endovascular treatment of cerebrovascular stenoses. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 26(3):538–542
Koo BK, Erglis A, Doh JH, Daniels DV, Jegere S, Kim HS, Dunning A, DeFrance T, Lansky A, Leipsic J, Min JK (2011) Diagnosis of ischemia-causing coronary stenoses by noninvasive fractional flow reserve computed from coronary computed tomographic angiograms: results from the prospective multicenter DISCOVER-FLOW (Diagnosis of Ischemia-Causing Stenoses Obtained Via Noninvasive Fractional Flow Reserve) study. J Am Coll Cardiol 58(19):1989–1997. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2011.06.066
Kruk M, Wardziak Ł, Demkow M, Pleban W, Pręgowski J, Dzielińska Z, Witulski M, Witkowski A, Rużyłło W, Kępka C (2016) Workstation-based calculation of CTA-based FFR for intermediate stenosis. JACC Cardiovasc Imaging. 9(6):690–699. doi:10.1016/j.jcmg.2015.09.019
Kwon SS, Chung EC, Park JS, Kim GT, Kim JW, Kim KH, Shin ES, Shim EB (2014) A novel patient-specific model to compute coronary fractional flow reserve. Prog Biophys Mol Biol 116(1):48–55. doi:10.1016/j.pbiomolbio.2014.09.003
Layland J, Oldroyd KG, Curzen N, Sood A, Balachandran K, Das R, Junejo S, Ahmed N, Lee MM, Shaukat A, O’Donnell A, Nam J, Briggs A, Henderson R, McConnachie A, Berry C (2015) Fractional flow reserve vs. angiography in guiding management to optimize outcomes in non-ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction: the British Heart Foundation FAMOUS-NSTEMI randomized trial. Eur Heart J 36(2):100–111. doi:10.1093/eurheartj/ehu338
Lee KE, Kwon SS, Ji YC, Shin ES, Choi JH, Kim SJ, Shim EB (2016a) Estimation of the flow resistances exerted in coronary arteries using a vessel length-based method. Pflugers Arch 468(8):1449–1458. doi:10.1007/s00424-016-1831-8
Lee KE, Kim GT, Lee JS, Chung JH, Shin ES, Shim EB (2016b) A patient-specific virtual stenotic model of the coronary artery to analyze the relationship between fractional flow reserve and wall shear stress. Int J Cardiol 222:799–805. doi:10.1016/j.ijcard.2016.07.153
Leipsic J, Yang TH, Thompson A, Koo BK, Mancini GJ, Taylor C, Budoff MJ, Part HB, Berman DS, Min JK (2014) CT angiography (CTA) and diagnostic performance of noninvasive fractional flow reserve: results from the Determination of Fractional Flow Reserve by Anatomic CTA (DeFACTO) study. Am J Roentqenol 202(5):989–994. doi:10.2214/AJR.13.11441
Leng X, Scalzo F, Ip HL, Johnson M, Fong AK, Fan FS, Chen X, Soo YO, Miao Z, Liu L, Feldmann E, Leung TW, Liebeskind DS, Wong KS (2014a) Computational fluid dynamics modeling of symptomatic intracranial atherosclerosis may predict risk of stroke recurrence. PLoS One 9(5):e97531
Leng X, Wong KS, Liebeskind DS (2014b) Evaluating intracranial atherosclerosis rather than intracranial stenosis. Stroke 45(2):645–651
Liebeskind DS, Feldmann E (2013) Fractional flow in cerebrovascular disorders. Interv Neurol 1(2):87–99
Liu J, Yan Z, Pu Y, Shiu WS, Wu J, Chen R, Leng X, Qin H, Liu X, Jia B, Song L, Wang Y, Miao Z, Wang Y, Liu L, Cai XC (2016) Functional assessment of cerebral artery stenosis: a pilot study based on computational fluid dynamics. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 4
Magosso E, Ursino M (2001) A mathematical model of CO2 effect on cardiovascular regulation. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 281(5):H2036–H2052
Min JK, Leipsic J, Pencina MJ, Berman DS, Koo BK, van Mieghem C, Erglis A, Lin FY, Am D, Apruzzese P (2012a) Diagnostic accuracy of fractional flow reserve from anatomic CT angiography. JAMA 308(12):1237–1245. doi:10.1001/2012.jama.11274
Min JK, Koo BK, Erglis A, Doh JH, Daniels DV, Jegere S, Kim HS, Dunning A, Defrance T, Leipsic J (2012b) Effect of image quality on diagnostic accuracy of noninvasive fractional flow reserve: results from the prospective multicenter international DISCOVER-FLOW study. J Cardiovasc Comput Tomogr 6(3):191–199. doi:10.1016/j.jcct.2012.04.010
Min JK, Koo BK, Erglis A, Doh JH, Daniels DV, Jegere S, Kim HS, Dunning AM, DeFrance T, Lansky A (2012c) Usefulness of noninvasive fractional flow reserve computed from coronary computed tomographic angiograms for intermediate stenoses confirmed by quantitative coronary angiography. Am J Cardiol 110(7):971–976. doi:10.1016/j.amjcard.2012.05.033
Min JK, Taylor CA, Achenbach S, Koo BK, Leipsic J, Nørgaard BL, Pijls NJ, De Bruyne B (2015) Noninvasive fractional flow reserve derived from coronary CT angiography: clinical data and scientific principles. JACC Cardiovasc Imaging 8(10):1209–1222. doi:10.1016/j.jcmg.2015.08.006
Miyoshi T, Osawa K, Hiroshi I, Kanazawa S, Kimura T, Shiomi H, Kuribayashi S, Jinzaki M, Kawamura A, Bezerra H (2014) Non-invasive computed fractional flow reserve from computed tomography (CT) for diagnosing coronary artery disease—Japanese results from NXT trial (Analysis of Coronary Blood Flow Using CT Angiography: Next Steps). Circulation J 79(2):406–412. doi:10.1253/circj.CJ-14-1051
Moore S, David T (2006) Auto-regulated blood flow in the cerebral-vasculature. Journal of Biomechanical Science and Engineering 1(1):93–106. doi:10.1299/jbse.1.93
Moore SM, Moorhead KT, Chase JG, David T, Fink J (2005) One-dimensional and three-dimensional models of cerebrovascular flow. J Biomech Eng 127(3):440–449
Morris PD, Ryan D, Morton AC, Lycett R, Lawford PV, Hose DR, Gunn JP (2013) Virtual fractional flow reserve from coronary angiography: modeling the significance of coronary lesions: results from the VIRTU-1 (VIRTUal Fractional Flow Reserve From Coronary Angiography) study. JACC Cardiovasc Interv. 6(2):149–157. doi:10.1016/j.jcin.2012.08.024
Morris PD, van de Vosse FN, Lawford PV, Hose DR, Gunn JP (2015) “Virtual” (computed) fractional flow reserve: current challenges and limitations. JACC Cardiovasc Interv 8(8):1009–1017. doi:10.1016/j.jcin.2015.04.006
Moir S, Haluska BA, Jenkins C, McNab D, Marwick TH (2005) Myocardial blood volume and perfusion reserve responses to combined dipyridamole and exercise stress: a quantitative approach to contrast stress echocardiography. J Am Soc Echocardiogr 18(11):1187–1193. doi:10.1016/j.echo.2005.04.004
Nakazato R, Park HB, Berman DS, Gransar H, Koo BK, Erglis A, Lin FY, Dunning AM, Budoff MJ, Malpeso J (2013) Noninvasive fractional flow reserve derived from computed tomography angiography for coronary lesions of intermediate stenosis severity results from the DeFACTO study. Circulation: Cardiovascular Imaging 6(6):881–889. doi:10.1161/CIRCIMAGING.113.000297
Nam J, Briggs A, Layland J, Oldroyd KG, Curzen N, Sood A, Balachandran K, Das R, Junejo S, Eteiba H, Petrie MC, Lindsay M, Watkins S, Corbett S, O’Rourke B, O’Donnell A, Stewart A, Hannah A, McConnachie A, Henderson R, Berry C (2015) Fractional flow reserve (FFR) versus angiography in guiding management to optimise outcomes in non-ST segment elevation myocardial infarction (FAMOUS-NSTEMI) developmental trial: cost-effectiveness using a mixed trial- and model-based methods. Cost Eff Resour Alloc 13:19. doi:10.1186/s12962-015-0045-9
Nijjer SS, Sen S, Petraco R, Escaned J, Echavarria-Pinto M, Broyd C, Al-Lamee R, Foin N, Foale RA, Malik IS, Mikhail GW, Sethi AS, Al-Bustami M, Kaprielian RR, Khan MA, Baker CS, Bellamy MF, Hughes AD, Mayet J, Francis DP, Di Mario C, Davies JE (2014) Pre-angioplasty instantaneous wave-free ratio pullback provides virtual intervention and predicts hemodynamic outcome for serial lesions and diffuse coronary artery disease. JACC Cardiovasc Interv. 7(12):1386–1396. doi:10.1016/j.jcin.2014.06.015
Nijjer SS, Sen S, Petraco R, Mayet J, Francis DP, Davies JE (2015) The instantaneous wave-free ratio (iFR) pullback: a novel innovation using baseline physiology to optimise coronary angioplasty in tandem lesions. Cardiovasc Revasc Med 16(3):167–171. doi:10.1016/j.carrev.2015.01.006
Nørgaard BL, Leipsic J, Gaur S, Seneviratne S, Ko BS, Ito H, Jensen JM, Mauri L, De Bruyne B, Bezerra H (2014) Diagnostic performance of noninvasive fractional flow reserve derived from coronary computed tomography angiography in suspected coronary artery disease: the NXT trial (Analysis of Coronary Blood Flow Using CT Angiography: Next Steps). J Am Coll Cardiol 63(12):1145–1155. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2013.11.043
Papafaklis MI, Muramatsu T, Ishibashi Y, Lakkas LS, Nakatani S, Bourantas CV, Ligthart J, Onuma Y, Echavarria-Pinto M, Tsirka G, Kotsia A, Nikas DN, Mogabgab O, van Geuns RJ, Naka KK, Fotiadis DI, Brilakis ES, Garcia-Garcia HM, Escaned J, Zijlstra F, Michalis LK, Serruys PW (2014) Fast virtual functional assessment of intermediate coronary lesions using routine angiographic data and blood flow simulation in humans: comparison with pressure wire-fractional flow reserve. EuroIntervention. 10(5):574–583. doi:10.4244/EIJY14M07_01
Peiro J, Sherwin S, Parker K, Franke V, Formaggia L, Lamponi D, Quarteroni A. (2003) Numerical simulation of arterial pulse propagation using one-dimensional models. Advances in Computational Bioengineering 6
Perdikaris P, Grinberg L, Karniadakis GE (1994) Multiscale modeling and simulation of brain blood flow. Phys Fluids 28(2):021304
Petraco R, Park JJ, Sen S, Nijjer SS, Malik IS, Echavarría-Pinto M, Asrress KN, Nam CW, Macías E, Foale RA, Sethi A, Mikhail GW, Kaprielian R, Baker CS, Lefroy D, Bellamy M, Al-Bustami M, Khan MA, Gonzalo N, Hughes AD, Francis DP, Mayet J, Di Mario C, Redwood S, Escaned J, Koo BK, Davies JE (2013) Hybrid iFR-FFR decision-making strategy: implications for enhancing universal adoption of physiology-guided coronary revascularisation. EuroIntervention 8(10):1157–1165. doi:10.4244/EIJV8I10A179
Pijls NH (2000) De Bruyne B. Coronary pressure Second edition 195:1–448. doi:10.1007/978-94-015-9564-3
Pijls NH, Van Gelder B, Van der Voort P, Peels K, Bracke FA, Bonnier HJ, el Gamal MI (1995) Fractional flow reserve. A useful index to evaluate the influence of an epicardial coronary stenosis on myocardial blood flow. Circulation 92(11):3183–3193
Pijls NH, De Bruyne B, Peels K, Van Der Voort PH, Bonnier HJ, Bartunek J, Koolen JJ, Koolen JJ (1996) Measurement of fractional flow reserve to assess the functional severity of coronary-artery stenoses. N Engl J Med 334(26):1703–1708. doi:10.1056/NEJM199606273342604
Qi X, Zhou F, Wan J, Zhou L, Xu W, Cheng J, Mao Y, Ma W, Ji W, Yang C (2014) Noninvasive assessment of cerebral artery stenoses from anatomic computed tomography angiography. Postepy Kardiol Interwencyjnej 10(1):18–20
Renker M, Schoepf UJ, Wang R, Meinel FG, Rier JD, Bayer RR, Möllmann H, Hamm CW, Steinberg DH, Baumann S (2014) Comparison of diagnostic value of a novel noninvasive coronary computed tomography angiography method versus standard coronary angiography for assessing fractional flow reserve. Am J Cardiol 114(9):1303–1308. doi:10.1016/j.amjcard.2014.07.064
Sankaran S, Leo G, Taylor CA (2015) Impact of geometric uncertainty on hemodynamic simulations using machine learning. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 297:167–190. doi:10.1016/j.cma.2015.08.014
Sen S, Escaned J, Malik IS, Mikhail GW, Foale RA, Mila R, Tarkin J, Petraco R, Broyd C, Jabbour R, Sethi A, Baker CS, Bellamy M, Al-Bustami M, Hackett D, Khan M, Lefroy D, Parker KH, Hughes AD, Francis DP, Di Mario C, Mayet J, Davies JE (2012) Development and validation of a new adenosine-independent index of stenosis severity from coronary wave-intensity analysis: results of the ADVISE (ADenosine Vasodilator Independent Stenosis Evaluation) study. J Am Coll Cardiol 59(15):1392–1402. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2011.11.003
Steiner LA, Andrews PJ (2006) Monitoring the injured brain: ICP and CBF. Br J Anaesth 97(1):26–38. doi:10.1093/bja/ael110
Taylor CA, Fonte TA, Min JK (2013) Computational fluid dynamics applied to cardiac computed tomography for noninvasive quantification of fractional flow reserve: scientific basis. J Am Coll Cardiol 61(22):2233–2241. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2012.11.083
Thompson AG, Raju R, Blanke P, Yang TH, Mancini GBJ, Budoff MJ, Norgaard BL, Min JK, Leipsic JA (2015) Diagnostic accuracy and discrimination of ischemia by fractional flow reserve CT using a clinical use rule: results from the determination of fractional flow reserve by anatomic computed tomographic angiography study. J Cardiovasc Comput Tomogr. 9(2):120–128. doi:10.1016/j.jcct.2015.01.008
Torii R, Oshima M, Kobayashi T, Takagi K, Tezduyar TE (2008) Fluid-structure interaction modeling of a patient-specific cerebral aneurysm: influence of structural modeling. Comput Mech 43(1):151–159
Tu S, Holm NR, Koning G, Huang Z, Reiber JH (2011) Fusion of 3d qca and ivus/oct. Int J Cardiovasc Imaging 27:197–207. doi:10.1007/s10554-011-9808-2
Tu S, Barbato E, Köszegi Z, Yang J, Sun Z, Holm NR, Tar B, Li Y, Rusinaru D, Wijns W (2014) Fractional flow reserve calculation from 3-dimensional quantitative coronary angiography and TIMI frame count: a fast computer model to quantify the functional significance of moderately obstructed coronary arteries. JACC Cardiovasc Interv. 7(7):768–777. doi:10.1016/j.jcin.2014.03.004
Ursino M, Ter Minassian A, Lodi CA, Beydon L (2000) Cerebral hemodynamics during arterial and CO2 pressure changes: in vivo prediction by a mathematical model. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 279(5):H2439–H2455
Vagal AS, Leach JL, Fernandez-Ulloa M, Zuccarello M (2009) The acetazolamide challenge: techniques and applications in the evaluation of chronic cerebral ischemia. Am J Neuroradiol 30(5):876–884
van de Hoef TP, Meuwissen M, Escaned J, Davies JE, Siebes M, Spaan JA, Piek JJ (2013) Fractional flow reserve as a surrogate for inducible myocardial ischaemia. Nat Rev Cardiol 10(8):439–452. doi:10.1038/nrcardio.2013.86
Verbeke F, Segers P, Heireman S, Vanholder R, Verdonck P, Van Bortel LM (2005) Noninvasive assessment of local pulse pressure: importance of brachial-to-radial pressure amplification. Hypertension 46(1):244–248
Willie CK, Tzeng YC, Fisher JA, Ainslie PN (2014) Integrative regulation of human brain blood flow. J Physiol 592(5):841–859. doi:10.1113/jphysiol.2013.268953
Wilson RF, Wyche K, Christensen BV, Zimmer S, Laxson DD (1990) Effects of adenosine on human coronary arterial circulation. Circulation 82:1595–1606
Zhang Z, Takarada S, Molloi S (2011) Quantification of coronary microvascular resistance using angiographic images for volumetric blood flow measurement: in vivo validation. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 300(6):H2096–H2104. doi:10.1152/ajpheart.01123.2010
Acknowledgements
The authors thank all our lab members for their supports. And we thank the anonymous reviewers and editors for their valuable comments.
Authors’ contributions
KE Lee, AJ Ryu, ES Shin, and EB Shim all participated in the study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
The data is deposited in Biosystems Engineering Lab of Kangwon National University. Please contact the correspondence author Eun Bo Shim, ebshim@kangwon.ac.kr, for the usage of data.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The subjects all gave their written informed consent in accordance with local ethics committee of Kangwon National University.
The data used in this research has been approved by the ethics committee of Kangwon National University.
Funding
This work was supported by the National Research foundation of Korea (NRF) grant (NRF-2015R1A2A1A0100774).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lee, K.E., Ryu, AJ., Shin, ES. et al. Physiome approach for the analysis of vascular flow reserve in the heart and brain. Pflugers Arch - Eur J Physiol 469, 613–628 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00424-017-1961-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00424-017-1961-7