Abstract
We present in outline a theory of sensorimotor control based on dynamic primitives, which we define as attractors. To account for the broad class of human interactive behaviors—especially tool use—we propose three distinct primitives: submovements, oscillations, and mechanical impedances, the latter necessary for interaction with objects. Owing to the fundamental features of the neuromuscular system—most notably, its slow response—we argue that encoding in terms of parameterized primitives may be an essential simplification required for learning, performance, and retention of complex skills. Primitives may simultaneously and sequentially be combined to produce observable forces and motions. This may be achieved by defining a virtual trajectory composed of submovements and/or oscillations interacting with impedances. Identifying primitives requires care: in principle, overlapping submovements would be sufficient to compose all observed movements but biological evidence shows that oscillations are a distinct primitive. Conversely, we suggest that kinematic synergies, frequently discussed as primitives of complex actions, may be an emergent consequence of neuromuscular impedance. To illustrate how these dynamic primitives may account for complex actions, we brieflyreviewthree typesof interactivebehaviors: constrained motion, impact tasks, and manipulation of dynamic objects.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Adams RD, Victor M et al (1997) Principles of neurology. McGraw-Hill, New York
Ajemian R, Hogan N (2010) Experimenting with theoretical motor neuroscience. J Mot Behav 42(6): 333–342
Atkeson CG, Hollerbach JM (1985) Kinematic features of unrestrained vertical arm movements. J Neurosci 5(9): 2318–2330
Bässler U (1986) On the definition of central pattern generator and its sensory control. Biol Cybern 54: 65–69
Bernstein N (1967) The coordination and regulation of movement. Pergamon Press, London
Berthier N (1996) Learning to reach: a mathematical model. Dev Psychol 32(5): 811–823
Bhushan N, Shadmehr R (1999) Computational nature of human adaptive control during learning of reaching movements in force fields. Biol Cybern 81: 39–60
Bizzi E, Accornero N et al (1984) Posture control and trajectory formation during arm movement. J Neurosci 4(11): 2738–2744
Boesch C, Boesch H (1990) Tool use and tool making in wild chimpanzees. Folia Primatologica 54: 86–99
Brown TG (1911) The intrinsic factors in the act of progression in the mammal. Proc R Soc Lond Ser B 84(572): 308–319
Brown TG (1914) On the nature of the fundamental activity of the nervous centers; together with an analysis of the conditioning of rhythmic activity in progression, and a theory of evolution of function in the nervous system. J Physiol 48: 18–46
Burdet E, Milner TE (1998) Quantization of human motions and learning of accurate movements. Biol Cybern 78: 307–318
Burdet E, Osu R et al (2001) The central nervous system stabilizes unstable dynamics by learning optimal impedance. Nature 414: 446–449
Cheung VC, d’Avella A et al (2005) Central and sensory contributions to the activation and organization of muscle synergies during natural motor behaviors. J Neurosci 25(27): 6419–6434
Colgate JE, Hogan N (1988) Robust control of dynamically interacting systems. Int J Control 48(1): 65–88
Crevecoeur F, McIntyre J et al (2010) Movement stability under uncertain internal models of dynamics. J Neurophysiol 104(3): 1301–1313
d’Avella A, Portone A et al (2006) Control of fast-reaching movements by muscle synergy combinations. J Neurosci 26(30): 7791–7810
d’Avella A, Saltiel P et al (2003) Combinations of muscles synergies in the construction of a natural motor behavior. Nat Neurosci 6(3):300–308
de Rugy A, Sternad D (2003) Interaction between discrete and rhythmic movements: reaction time and phase of discrete movement initiation during oscillatory movements. Brain Res 994: 160–174
de Rugy A, Wei K et al (2003) Actively tracking “passive” stability. Brain Res 982(1): 64–78
Degallier S, Ijspeert A (2010) Modeling discrete and rhythmic movements through motor primitives: a review. Biol Cybern 103(4): 319–338
Dijkstra TMH, Katsumata H et al (2004) The dialogue between data and model: Passive stability and relaxation behavior in a ball bouncing task. Nonlinear Studies 11(3): 319–344
Dipietro L, Krebs HI et al (2007) Changing motor synergies in chronic stroke. J Neurophysiol 98: 757–768
Dipietro L, Krebs HI et al (2012) Learning, not adaptation, characterizes stroke motor recovery: evidence from kinematic changes induced by robot-assisted therapy in trained and untrained task in the same workspace. IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehab Eng 20(1): 48–57
Dominici N, Ivanenko YP et al (2011) Locomotor primitives in newborn babies and their development. Science 334(6058): 997–999
Elliott D, Helsen WF et al (2001) A century later: Woodworth’s (1899) two-component model of goal-directed aiming. Psychol Bull 127(3): 342–357
Feldman AG (1966) Functional tuning of the nervous system with control of movement or maintenance of a steady posture. II. Controllable parameters of the muscle. Biophysics 11: 565–578
Feldman AG (1986) Once more on the equilibirium hypothesis (lambda model) for motor control. J Motor Behav 18: 17–54
Feldman AG, Latash ML (2005) Testing hypotheses and the advancement of science: recent attempts to falsify the equilibrium point hypothesis. Exp Brain Res 161: 91–103
Fitzhugh R (1961) Impulses and physiological states in theoretical models of nerve membrane. Biophys J 1: 445–466
Flash T, Henis E (1991) Arm trajectory modifications during reaching towards visual targets. J Cognitive Neurosci 3(3): 220–230
Flash T, Hochner B (2005) Motor primitives in vertebrates and invertebrates. Curr Opin Neurobiol 15(6): 660–666
Franklin DW, Liaw G et al (2007) Endpoint stiffness of the arm is directionally tuned to instability in the environment. J Neurosci 27: 7705–7716
Gallistel CR (1980) The organization of action: A new synthesis. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ
Goldstein H (1980) Classical mechanics. Addison-Wesley
Gomi H, Kawato M (1996) Equilibrium-point control hypothesis examined by measured arm stiffness during multijoint movement. Science 272: 117–220
Gribble P, Ostry DJ et al (1998) Are complex control signals required for human arm movement?. J Neurophysiol 79: 1409–1424
Grillner S, Wallen P (1985) Central pattern generators for locomotion, with special reference to vertebrates. Annu Rev Neurosci 8(1): 233–261
Hasson CJ, Hogan N et al (2012a) Human control of dynamically complex objects. International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics (BIOROB 2012). IEEE RAS/EMBS, Rome, Italy
Hasson CJ, Shen T et al (2012b) Energy margins in dynamic object manipulation. J Neurophysiol (in revision)
Hodgson AJ, Hogan N (2000) A model-independent definition of attractor behavior applicable to interactive tasks. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern Part C-Appl Rev 30(1): 105–118
Hoffer JA, Andreassen S (1981) Regulation of soleus muscle stiffness in premammillary cats: intrinsic and reflex components. J Neurophysiol 45(2): 267–285
Hogan N (1985) Impedance control: an approach to manipulation. ASME J Dyn Syst Meas Control 107: 1–24
Hogan N (1988) On the stability of manipulators performing contact tasks. IEEE J Robotics Autom 4(6): 677–686
Hogan N (1990) Mechanical impedance of single—and multi-articular systems. Multiple muscle systems: Biomechanics and movement organization. J. Winters and S. Woo. Springer-Verlag, New York, pp 149–164
Hogan N, Buerger SP (2004) Impedance and interaction control. In: Kurfess TR (ed) Robotics and automation handbook. CRC Press, 19–11 to 19–24
Hogan N, Sternad D (2007) On rhythmic and discrete movements: reflections, definitions and implications for motor control. Exp Brain Res 181: 13–30
Hunt GR (1996) Manufacture and use of hook-tools by New Caledonian crows. Nature 379: 249–251
Ivanenko YP, Cappellini G et al (2007) Modular control of limb movements during human locomotion. J Neurosci 27(41): 11149– 11161
Johnson DH (2003) Origins of the equivalent circuit concept: the current-source equivalent. Proc IEEE 91(5): 817–821
Johnson DH (2003) Origins of the equivalent circuit concept: the voltage-source equivalent. Proc IEEE 91(4): 636–640
Johnson-Frey SH (2004) The neural basis of complex tool use in humans. Trends Cognitive Sci 8(2): 71–78
Kandel, ER, Schwartz, JH (eds) et al (2000) Principles of neural science. McGraw-Hill, New York
Kargo WJ, Giszter SF (2008) Individual premotor drive pulses, not time-varying synergies, are the units of adjustment for limb trajectories constructed in spinal cord. J Neurosci 28(10): 2409–2425
Katsumata H, Zatsiorsky V et al (2003) Control of ball-racket interactions in the rhythmic propulsion of elastic and non-elastic balls. Exp Brain Res 149: 17–29
Kenward B, Weir AAS et al (2005) Behavioral ecology: tool manufacture by naïve juvenile crows. Nature 433(121)
Krebs HI, Aisen ML et al (1999) Quantization of continuous arm movements in humans with brain injury. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96(8): 4645–4649
Lackner JR, Dizio P (1994) Rapid adaptation to coriolis force perturbations of arm trajectory. J Neurophysiol 72(1): 299–313
Lacquaniti F, Maioli C (1994) Coordinate transformations in the control of cat posture. J Neurophysiol 72(4): 1496–1515
Latash ML (1992) Virtual trajectories, joint stiffness, and changes in natural frequency during single-joint oscillatory movements. Neuroscience 49: 209–220
Latash ML (2008) Synergy. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Latash ML, Gottlieb GL (1992) Virtual trajectories of single-joint movements performed under two basic strategies. Neuroscience 47(2): 357–365
Loeb GE (1995) Control implications of musculoskeletal mechanics. Annu Int Conf IEE-EMBS 17: 1393–1394
Marr D (1982) Vision: A computational approach. Freeman & Company, San Francisco
Matsuoka K (1985) Sustained oscillations generated by mutually inhibiting neurons with adaptation. Biol Cybern 52: 367–376
McMahon TA (1984) Muscles, reflexes, and locomotion. Princeton University Press, New Jersey
Meyer DE, Abrams RA et al (1988) Optimality in human motor performance: ideal control of rapid aimed movements. Psychol Rev 95(3):340–370
Mussa-Ivaldi FA, Hogan N (1991) Integrable solutions of kinematic redundancy via impedance control. Int J Robotics Res 10(5): 481–491
Nagumo J, Arimoto S et al (1962) An active pulse transmission line simulating nerve axon. Proc IRE 60: 2061–2070
Nichols TR, Houk JC (1976) Improvement in linearity and regulation of stiffness that results from actions of stretch reflex. J Neurophysiol 39:119–142
Prochazka A, Clarac F et al (2000) What do reflex and voluntary mean? Modern views on an ancient debate. Exp Brain Res 130: 417–432
Rabinovich MI, Varona P et al (2006) Dynamical principles in neuroscience. Rev Modern Phys 78: 1213–1265
Raftery A, Cusumano JP et al (2008) Chaotic frequency scaling in a coupled oscillator model for free rhythmic actions. Neural Comput 20(1): 205–226
Rohrer B, Fasoli S et al (2004) Submovements grow larger, fewer, and more blended during stroke recovery. Mot Control 8(4): 472–483
Ronsse R, Sternad D et al (2009) A computational model for rhythmic and discrete movements in uni- and bimanual coordination. Neural Comput 21: 1335–1370
Russell DL (1990) An analysis of constrained motions in manipulation Ph.D., M.I.T.
Sanger TD, Delgado MR et al (2003) Classification and definition of disorders causing hypertonia in childhood. Pediatrics 111(1): e89–e97
Schaal S, Kotosaka S et al (2000) Nonlinear dynamical systems as movement primitives. Proceedings of the 1st IEEE-RAS International Conference on Humanoid Robotics (Humanoids 2000), Cambridge, MA
Schaal S, Sternad D et al (2004) Rhythmic arm movement is not discrete. Nat Neurosci 7(10): 1136–1143
Shadmehr R, Mussa-Ivaldi FA (1994) Adaptive representation of dynamics during learning of a motor task. J Neurosci 14(5): 3208–3224
Sherrington CS (1906) The integrative action of the nervous system. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT
Siegler IA, Bardy B et al (2010) Passive vs. active control of rhythmic ball bouncing: The role of visual information. J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perf 36(3):729–750
Sing GC, Joiner WM et al (2009) Primitives for motor adaptation reflect correlated neural tuning to position and velocity. Neuron 64(4): 575–589
Smith AM (1981) The coactivation of antagonist muscles. Can J Physiol Pharmacol 59(7): 733–747
Soechting JF, Flanders M (2008) Sensorimotor control of contact force. Curr Opin Neurobiol 18: 565–572
Sternad D (2008) Towards a unified framework for rhythmic and discrete movements: behavioral, modeling and imaging results. In: Fuchs A, Jirsa V (eds) Coordination: neural, behavioral and social dynamics. Jirsa. Springer, New York, pp, pp 105–136
Sternad D, Dean WJ et al (2000a) Interaction of rhythmic and discrete pattern generators in single-joint movements. Hum Mov Sci 19: 627–664
Sternad D, Duarte M et al (2000b) Dynamics of a bouncing ball in human performance. Phys Rev E 63: 011902-011901–011902-011908
Sternad D, Duarte M et al (2001) Bouncing a ball: tuning into dynamic stability. J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform 27(5): 1163–1184
Strauss L (1970) Wave generation and shaping. McGraw-Hill, New York
Strogatz SH (1994) Nonlinear dynamics and chaos: with applications to physics, biology, chemistry, and engineering. Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA
Thoroughman KA, Shadmehr R (2000) Learning of action through adaptive combination of motor primitives. Nature 407: 742–747
Toffin D, McIntyre J. et al (2003) Perception and reproduction of force direction in the horizontal plane. J Neurophysiol 90: 3040–3053
Tuller B, Turvey MT et al (1982) The Bernstein perspective: II. The concept of muscle linkage or coordinative structure. In: Kelso JAS (ed) Human motor behavior. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp 253–270
von Hofsten C (1991) Structuring of early reaching movemnets: a longitudinal study. J Mot Behav 23(4):280–292
Wei K, Dijkstra TMH et al (2008) Stability and variability: indicators for passive stability and active control in a rhythmic task. J Neurophysiol 99: 3027–3041
Won J, Hogan N (1995) Stability properties of human reaching movements. Exp Brain Res 107(1): 125–136
Woodworth RS (1899) The accuracy of voluntary movement. Psychol Rev Monogr Suppl 3(3): 1–119
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This article forms part of a special issue of Biological Cybernetics entitled “Multimodal and Sensorimotor Bionics”.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Hogan, N., Sternad, D. Dynamic primitives of motor behavior. Biol Cybern 106, 727–739 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00422-012-0527-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00422-012-0527-1