The effects of agonist and antagonist muscle activation on the knee extension moment–angle relationship in adults and children

Abstract

The present study examined the effect of agonist activation and antagonist co-activation on the shape of the knee extension moment–angle relationship in adults and children. Isometric knee extension maximum voluntary contractions (MVCs) were performed at every 5° of knee flexion between 55° and 90° (full extension = 0°) by ten men, ten women, ten boys and ten girls. For each trial, the knee extensors’ voluntary activation level was quantified using magnetic stimulation and the level of antagonist co-activation was quantified from their electromyographical activity. Peak MVC moment was greater for men (264 ± 63 N m) than women (177 ± 60 N m), and greater for adults than children (boys 78 ± 17 N m, girls 91 ± 28 N m) (p < 0.01). The agonistic activation level was greater for adults (~85%) than children (~70%). Similarly, antagonist co-activation was greater for adults than children, but relative to the agonist moment there were no differences between groups (all groups 7–8%). Correcting the peak moment for agonist and antagonist activation levels resulted in moments produced by fully activated agonist muscles of 334 ± 83, 229 ± 70, 114.2 ± 32 and 147 ± 46 N m, for men, women, boys and girls, respectively. Although correcting for shifts in joint angle during contraction altered the angle of peak moment by ~10° (p < 0.01), the peak moment occurred at ~60° for all groups. Changes in tendon stiffness, muscle size and architecture, and the pattern of the moment arm–angle relationship may in combination occur so that as children develop and mature into adults the shape of the moment–angle relationship is not altered.