Abstract
Obtaining reliable causal inference is crucial for understanding the climate system. Convergent Cross Mapping (CCM), a recently developed method to infer causal relationships from time series has been shown to be superior to previous methods which are based on linearity assumptions. However, CCM has so far been only tested on low-dimensional or bivariate models, while real-world systems, like the climate system, are high-dimensional and have many more interacting variables. Here, we demonstrate that standard CCM cannot reliably infer causal relations in high-dimensional chaotic systems. However, by using a hierarchy of conceptual models and observational data we show that time-lagged CCM reliably identifies causal relationships in contrast to standard CCM and Pearson correlation. Furthermore, we systematically demonstrate that time-lagged CCM is able to identify long-distance causal interactions. Moreover, we apply time-lagged CCM to detect causal relations in stratosphere-troposphere coupling, and demonstrate the downward causal chain induced by polar vortex activity.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Badin G, Domeisen DIV (2014) A search for chaotic behavior in stratospheric variability: comparison between the Northern and Southern Hemisphere. J Atmos Sci 71:4611–4620
Baldwin MP, Thompson DW (2009) A critical comparison of stratosphere-troposphere coupling indices. Q J R Meteorol Soc 135(644):1661–1672
Baldwin MP, Stephenson DB, Thompson DW, Dunkerton TJ, Charlton AJ, O'Neill A (2003a) Stratospheric memory and skill of extended-range weather forecasts. Science 301(5633):636–640
Baldwin MP, Thompson DW, Shuckburgh EF, Norton WA, Gillett NP (2003b) Weather from the stratosphere? Science 301(5631):317–319
Barnes EA, Simpson IR (2017) Seasonal sensitivity of the Northern Hemisphere jet streams to Arctic temperatures on subseasonal time scales. J Clim 30(24):10117–10137
Coufal D, Jakubík J, Jajcay N, Hlinka J, Krakovská A, Paluš M (2017) Detection of coupling delay: a problem not yet solved. Chaos 27(8):083109
Davini P, Cagnazzo C, Anstey JA (2014) A blocking view of the stratosphere-troposphere coupling. J Geophys Res 119(19):11–100
Donner R, Barbosa S, Kurths J, Marwan N (2009) Understanding the Earth as a complex system: recent advances in data analysis and modeling in Earth sciences. Euro Phys J Spec Topics 174(1):1–9
Franzke CL, Jelic D, Lee S, Feldstein SB (2019) Systematic decomposition of the MJO and its Northern Hemispheric extratropical response into Rossby and inertia-gravity components. Q J R Meteorol Soc 145(720):1147–1164
Gans F, Schumann AY, Kantelhardt JW, Penzel T, Fietze I (2009) Cross-modulated amplitudes and frequencies characterize interacting components in complex systems. Phys Rev Lett 102(9):098701
Granger CW (1969) Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods. Econometrica 37(3):424–438
Hannachi A, Straus DM, Franzke CL, Corti S, Woollings T (2017) Low-frequency nonlinearity and regime behavior in the Northern Hemisphere extratropical atmosphere. Rev Geophys 55(1):199–234
Haynes PH (2005) Stratospheric dynamics. Ann Rev Fluid Mech 37:263–293
Hirota I, Niki T (1986) Inertia-gravity waves in the troposphere and stratosphere observed by the MU radar. J Meteorol Soc Jpn Ser II 64(6):995–999
Hlaváčková-Schindler K, Paluš M, Vejmelka M, Bhattacharya J (2007) Causality detection based on information-theoretic approaches in time series analysis. Phys Rep 441(1):1–46
Hu G, Franzke CL (2017) Data assimilation in a multi-scale model. Math Clim Weather Forecast 3(1):118–139
Huang Y, Fu Z, Franzke CL (2020) Detecting causality from time series in a machine learning framework. Chaos 30(6):063116
Jajcay N, Hlinka J, Kravtsov S, Tsonis AA, Paluš M (2016) Time scales of the European surface air temperature variability: the role of the 7–8 year cycle. Geophys Res Lett 43(2):902–909
Jajcay N, Kravtsov S, Sugihara G, Tsonis AA, Paluš M (2018) Synchronization and causality across time scales in El Niño Southern Oscillation. NPJ Clim Atmos Sci 1:33
Kantz H, Schreiber T (2004) Nonlinear time series analysis, vol 7. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Krakovská A, Jakubík J, Chvosteková M, Coufal D, Jajcay N, Paluš M (2018) Comparison of six methods for the detection of causality in a bivariate time series. Phys Rev E 97(4):042207
Kretschmer M, Runge J, Coumou D (2017) Early prediction of extreme stratospheric polar vortex states based on causal precursors. Geophys Res Lett 44(16):8592–8600
Kuroda Y, Kodera K (1999) Role of planetary waves in the stratosphere-troposphere coupled variability in the Northern Hemisphere winter. Geophys Res Lett 26(15):2375–2378
Lawrence ZD, Manney GL (2018) Characterizing stratospheric polar vortex variability with computer vision techniques. J Geophys Res 123(3):1510–1535
Li J, Ding R (2011) Temporal–spatial distribution of atmospheric predictability limit by local dynamical analogs. Mon Wea Rev 139(10):3265–3283
Limpasuvan V, Hartmann DL, Thompson DW, Jeev K, Yung YL (2005) Stratosphere-troposphere evolution during polar vortex intensification. J Geophys Res 110(D24):1–15
Lorenz EN (1963) Deterministic nonperiodic flow. J Atmos Sci 20(2):130–141
Lorenz EN (1996) Predictability: a problem partly solved. In: Proceedings of ECMWF Seminar on Predictability, vol I, Reading, United Kingdom, ECMWF, pp 40–58
Lucio JH, Valdés R, Rodríguez LR (2012) Improvements to surrogate data methods for nonstationary time series. Phys Rev E 85(5):056202
Malevergne Y, Sornette D (2006) Extreme financial risks: from dependence to risk management. Springer, New York
McCracken JM, Weigel RS (2014) Convergent cross-mapping and pairwise asymmetric inference. Phys Rev E 90(6):062903
McGraw MC, Barnes EA (2018) Memory matters: a case for Granger causality in climate variability studies. J Clim 31(8):3289–3300
Morgenstern O, Akiyoshi H, Bekki S, Braesicke P, Butchart N, Chipperfield M P, Gettelman A (2010) Anthropogenic forcing of the Northern Annular Mode in CCMVal-2 models. J Geo Res 115(D3)
Newman M, Compo GP, Alexander MA (2003) ENSO-forced variability of the Pacific decadal oscillation. J Clim 16(23):3853–3857
Nian D, Fu Z (2019) Contrasting stratospheric-tropospheric multifractal behaviors in NAM variability. Clim Dyn. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00382-019-04981-0
Osprey SM, Ambaum MH (2011) Evidence for the chaotic origin of Northern annular mode variability. Geophys Res Lett 38(15):L15702
Paluš M (2014) Multiscale atmospheric dynamics: Cross-frequency phase-amplitude coupling in the air temperature. Phys Rev Lett 112(7):078702
Paluš M, Krakovská A, Jakubík J, Chvosteková M (2018) Causality, dynamical systems and the arrow of time. Chaos 28(7):075307
Quadrelli R, Wallace JM (2002) Dependence of the structure of the Northern Hemisphere annular mode on the polarity of ENSO. Geophys Res Lett 29(23):47–51
Reichenbach H (1956) The direction of time. University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles
Roe G (2009) Feedbacks, timescales and seeing red. Ann Rev Earth Plan Sci 37:93–115
Ruan Y, Donner RV, Guan S, Zou Y (2019) Ordinal partition transition network based complexity measures for inferring coupling direction and delay from time series. Chaos 29(4):043111
Runge J, Balasis G, Daglis IA, Papadimitriou C, Donner RV (2018) Common solar wind drivers behind magnetic storm–magnetospheric substorm dependency. Sci Rep 8(1):16987
Runge J, Bathiany S, Bollt E, Camps-Valls G, Coumou D, Deyle E, van Nes EH (2019) Inferring causation from time series in earth system sciences. Nat Commun 10(1):2553
Ruzmaikin A, Feynman J (2002) Solar influence on a major mode of atmospheric variability. J Geophys Res 107(D14):ACL-7
Scaife AA, Spangehl T, Fereday DR, Cubasch U, Langematz U, Akiyoshi H, Gettelman A (2012) Climate change projections and stratosphere–troposphere interaction. Clim Dyn 38(9–10):2089–2097
Schreiber T (2000) Measuring information transfer. Phys Rev Lett 85(2):461
Schreiber T, Schmitz A (1996) Improved surrogate data for nonlinearity tests. Phys Rev Lett 77(4):635
Schreiber T, Schmitz A (2000) Surrogate time series. Phys D 142(3–4):346–382
Strogatz SH (2018) Nonlinear dynamics and chaos: with applications to physics, biology, chemistry, and engineering. CRC Press, Boca Raton
Stuecker MF, Timmermann A, Jin FF, Chikamoto Y, Zhang W, Wittenberg AT, Zhao S (2017) Revisiting ENSO/Indian Ocean dipole phase relationships. Geophys Res Lett 44(5):2481–2492
Sugihara G (1994) Nonlinear forecasting for the classification of natural time series. Philos Trans R Soc Lond Ser A 348(1688):477–495
Sugihara G, May R, Ye H, Hsieh CH, Deyle E, Fogarty M, Munch S (2012) Detecting causality in complex ecosystems. Science 338(6106):496–500
Takens F (1981) Detecting strange attractors in turbulence. Dynamical Systems and Turbulence Lecture Notes in Mathematics 898: 366–381 (Springer Berlin Heidelberg)
Thompson DW, Wallace JM (2001) Regional climate impacts of the Northern Hemisphere annular mode. Science 293(5527):85–89
Tsonis AA, Deyle ER, Ye H, Sugihara G (2018) Convergent cross mapping: theory and an example. Advances in nonlinear geosciences. Springer, Cham, pp 587–600
Van Nes EH, Scheffer M, Brovkin V, Lenton TM, Ye H, Deyle E, Sugihara G (2015) Causal feedbacks in climate change. Nat Clim Change 5(5):445
Vannitsem S, Ekelmans P (2018) Causal dependences between the coupled ocean–atmosphere dynamics over the tropical Pacific, the North Pacific and the North Atlantic. Earth Syst Dyn 9(3):1063–1083
Vannitsem S, Ghil M (2017) Evidence of coupling in ocean-atmosphere dynamics over the North Atlantic. Geophys Res Let 44(4):2016–2026
Vissio G, Lucarini V (2018) A proof of concept for scale-adaptive parameterizations: the case of the Lorenz 96 model. Q J R Meteorol Soc 144(710):63–75
Wang G, Yang P, Zhou X, Swanson KL, Tsonis AA (2012) Directional influences on global temperature prediction. Geophys Res Lett 39(13):L13704
Wang G, Yang P, Zhou X (2017) Identification of the driving forces of climate change using the longest instrumental temperature record. Sci Rep 7:46091
Wang G, Zhang N, Fan K, Palus M (2019) Central European air temperature: driving force analysis and causal influence of NAO. Theor Appl Clim 137(1–2):1421–1427
Wilks DS (2005) Effects of stochastic parametrizations in the Lorenz'96 system. Q J R Meteorol Soc 131(606):389–407
Woollings T, Hannachi A, Hoskins B (2010) Variability of the North Atlantic eddy-driven jet stream. Q J R Meteorol Soc 136(649):856–868
Ye H, Deyle ER, Gilarranz LJ, Sugihara G (2015) Distinguishing time-delayed causal interactions using convergent cross mapping. Sci Rep 5:14750
Yoden S, Taguchi M, Naito Y (2002) Numerical studies on time variations of the troposphere-stratosphere coupled system. J Met Soc Jpn 80:811–830
Zhang NN, Wang G, Tsonis AA (2019) Dynamical evidence for causality between Northern Hemisphere annular mode and winter surface air temperature over Northeast Asia. Clim Dyn 52:3175–3182
Acknowledgements
We thank the anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments. We thank Da Nian for some helpful discussion about this study. We acknowledge the support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China through Grants No. 41975059 and No. 41675049. CF was supported by the Collaborative Research Centre TRR 181 “Energy Transfer in Atmosphere and Ocean”, funded by the Deutsche Forschungs-gemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation)-Project Number 274762653.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Huang, Y., Franzke, C.L.E., Yuan, N. et al. Systematic identification of causal relations in high-dimensional chaotic systems: application to stratosphere-troposphere coupling. Clim Dyn 55, 2469–2481 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00382-020-05394-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00382-020-05394-0