Synthetic MgGa₂O₄-Mg₂GeO₄ spinel solid solution and β-Mg₃Ga₂GeO₈: chemistry, crystal structures, cation ordering, and comparison to Mg₂GeO₄ olivine

Abstract

 Structural parameters and cation ordering are determined for four compositions in the synthetic MgGa₂O₄-Mg₂GeO₄ spinel solid solution (0, 8, 15 and 23 mol% Mg₂GeO₄; 1400 °C, 1 bar) and for spinelloid β-Mg₃Ga₂GeO₈ (1350 °C, 1 bar), by Rietveld refinement of room-temperature neutron diffraction data. Sample chemistry is determined by XRF and EPMA. Addition of Mg₂GeO₄ causes the cation distribution of the MgGa₂O₄ component to change from a disordered inverse distribution in end member MgGa₂O₄, ^[4]Ga = x = 0.88(3), through the random distribution, toward a normal cation distribution, x = 0.37(3), at 23 mol% Mg₂GeO₄. An increase in a_o with increasing Mg₂GeO₄ component is correlated with an increase in the amount of Mg on the tetrahedral site, through substitution of 2 Ga³⁺⇄ Mg²⁺+Ge⁴⁺. The spinel exhibits high configurational entropy, reaching 20.2 J mol⁻¹ (four oxygen basis) near the compositional upper limit of the solid solution. This stabilizes the spinel in spite of positive enthalpy of disordering over the solid solution, where ΔH _D  = αx + βx ², α = 22(3), β = −21(3) kJ mol⁻¹. This model for the cation distribution across the join suggests that the empirically determined limit of the spinel solid solution is correlated with the limit of tetrahedral ordering of Mg, after which local charge-balanced substitution is no longer maintained.

Spinelloid β-Mg₃Ga₂GeO₈ has cation distribution ^M1[Mg_0.50(2)Ga_0.50(2)] ^M2[Mg_0.96(2)Ga_0.04(2)] ^M3[Mg_0.77(2) Ga_0.23(2)]₂ (Ge_0.5Ga_0.5)₂O₈ (tetrahedral site occupancies are assumed). Octahedral site size is correlated to Mg distribution, where site volume, site distortion, and Mg content follow the relation M1<M3<M2. The disordered cation distribution provides local electrical neutrality in the structure, and stabilization through increased configurational entropy (27.6 J mol⁻¹; eight oxygen basis). Comparison of the crystal structures of Mg_{1+ N} Ga_{2−2 N} Ge _N O₄ spinel, β-Mg₃Ga₂GeO₈, and Mg₂GeO₄ olivine reveals β-Mg₃Ga₂GeO₈ to be a true structural intermediate. Phase transitions across the pseudobinary are necessary to accommodate an increasing divergence of cation size and valence, with addition of Mg₂GeO₄ component. Octahedral volume increases while tetrahedral volume decreases from spinel to β-Mg₃Ga₂GeO₈ to olivine, with addition of Mg and Ge, respectively. Furthermore, M-M distances increase regularly across the join, suggesting that changes in topology reduce cation-cation repulsion.