Abstract
Background
In the seventeenth century Ottoman Istanbul, especially Greek surgeons specialized in hernia surgery. Both Muslim and non-Muslim patients had signed contracts with surgeons in sharia courts before undergoing a surgery. In this study, we analyze these documents, which serve as informed consent in the Ottoman period, in detail.
Methods
We used Istanbul Sharia Court Registers (Istanbul Sicils) as the primary information source. We scanned a total of twenty nine registers dating back to the seventeenth century. In six of these registers, we determined a total of twenty one informed consents (known as rıza senedi in Turkish literature) regarding hernia surgery and surgeons. Based on these data, we examined the surgeons and hernia surgeries, the fees received by surgeons, and the informed consent documents of the seventeenth-century Istanbul.
Results
In the scanned informed consents, we identified five male surgeons and twenty one patients. While four of the surgeons were Greek, one of them was Muslim. The contracts show that the patients were informed about possible complications before operations, and their permissions were obtained accordingly. The contracts also clearly state that a blood-money from the surgeons would not be requested if a patient dies during or after an operation. The cost of operations ranged between 500 and 2100 aḳče.
Conclusions
The patient-physician relationship in Ottomans was seen as a business relationship. Medical processes were recorded in courts before treatment fees were paid. These court records had been a practice that protected the patients and the physicians in terms of criminal liability.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Blount H (1636) A Voyage into the Levant. Routledge, Londra, p 86
Parker K (ed) (1999) Early modern tales of orient: a critical anthology. Routledge, Londra, pp 175–176
Mossensohn MS (2010) Ottoman medicine: healing and medical institutions, 1500–1700. State University of New York Press, New York, pp 248–249
Yılmaz C (ed) (2011) Eyüb Mahkemesi (Havâss-ı Refîa) 49 Numaralı Sicil (H 1054/M 1644). İSAM Publishing House, İstanbul
Yılmaz C (ed) (2012) Galata Mahkemesi 90 Numaralı Sicil (H. 1073–1074/M. 1663). İSAM Publishing House, İstanbul
Yılmaz C (ed) (2011) Hasköy Mahkemesi 5 Numaralı Sicil (H. 1020–1053/M. 1612–1643). İSAM Publishing House, İstanbul
Yılmaz C (ed) (2019) İstanbul Mahkemesi 10 Numaralı Sicil (H. 1072–1073/M. 1661–1663). İSAM Publishing House, İstanbul
Yılmaz C (ed) (2010) İstanbul Mahkemesi 12 Numaralı Sicil (H. 1073–1074/M. 1663–1664). İSAM Yayınları, İstanbul
Akkoyun S (2019) Galata Mahkemesine Ait 94 no’lu (H. 1074–1075) Şer‘iye Sicilinin Transkripsiyonu ve Değerlendirilmesi. Ondokuz Mayıs University, Institute of Social Sciences, Unpublished Master’s Thesis. Samsun
Akkaya M (2014) Üsküdar’da Bir Cerrah Ailesi: Üstad Cerrah Deniz, Eşi Cerrah Küpeli Kızı Saliha ve Oğlu Cerrah Mehmed Çelebi. History Studies 6(5):1–11
Kahraman SA, Dağlı Y (eds) (2003) Günümüz Türkçesiyle Evliya Çelebi Seyahatnâmesi: İstanbul, 1. Cilt-2. Kitap. YKY Publishing House, İstanbul
Sahillioğlu H (1998) Üsküdar’ın Mamure (Cedide) Mahallesi Fıtık Cerrahları. Yeni Tıp Tarihi Araştırmaları 4:59–66
Pamuk Ş (2000) İstanbul ve Diğer Kentlerde 500 Yıllık Fiyatlar ve Ücretler 1469–1998. Devlet İstatistik Enstitüsü Matbaası, Ankara
Doğan F, Tutak FN (2021) Illustrations of hernia surgery in the early period of the Ottoman empire by Şerefeddin Sabuncuoğlu. World J Surg 45(7):2116–2120
Edwards S (2019) Review of a medical illustration department’s data processing system to confirm general data protection regulation (GDPR) compliance. J Vis Commun Med 42(3):140–143
Slim K, Bazin JE (2019) From informed consent to shared decision-making in surgery. J Visc Surg 156(3):181–184
Williams CM, Nester C, Morrison SC (2019) International approaches to paediatric podiatry curricula: it’s the same, but different. J Foot Ankle Res 12:28. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13047-019-0339-9
Vollmann J, Winau R (1996) Informed consent in human experimentaton before the Nuremberg code. BMJ 313:1445–1449
Ajlouni KM (1995) History of informed medical consent. The Lancet 346(8980):980
Selek S (2010) A written consent five centuries ago. J Med Ethics 36(10):639
Sayligil O, Ozden H (2014) A written consent form dating back to 1524 in Bursa Şer’iye (Sharia Court) records and a proposal of a new start date for consent forms. Ann Saudi Med 34(5):433–436
Aslan N, Korkmaz Ö (2018) Hekim Sorumluluğu Aydınlatılmış Onam -İslam/Osmanlı Hukuku Uygulamaları-. Turk Stud 13(15):9–20
Gedikli F (2007) Osmanlı Hukukunda Hekim Sorumluluğu ve XVII. Yüzyılda Ünlü Bir Fıtık Cerrahı. Türk Hukuk Tarihi Araştırmaları 4:15–27
Anastasopoulos A, Kyriakopoulos C (2019) Treating Hernias in Ottoman Crete (c. 1670–1760): the legal imprint of a medical procedure. Social History of Medicine 33(4):1123–1142
Nükhet V (2015) Plague and empire in the early modern mediterranean world the Ottoman experience, 1347–1600. Cambridge University Press, New York
Faden RR, Beauchamp TL (1986) A history and theory of informed consent. Oxford University Press, New York
Welborn MC (1977) The long tradition: a study in a fourteenth-century medical deontology. In: Burns CR (ed) Legacies in ethics and medicine. Science History Publications, Cambridge, pp 204–217
Katz J (2002) The silent world of doctor and patient. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Acknowledgements
There is no acknowledgment.
Funding
The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
I am the sole author of this article.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The author declares none.
Informed consent
Not required.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Degerli, M.S. Surgeons, Hernia Surgery and Informed Consent in the Seventeenth Century Ottoman Istanbul. World J Surg 46, 1686–1690 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-022-06531-y
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-022-06531-y