Abstract
India is a global hotspot for irrigation-induced groundwater withdrawal, leading to widespread lowering of water levels, in turn resulting in disproportionate access to irrigation supplies among farming communities. Efforts to mitigate the situation, however, have fallen short, largely due to technocentric vision (e.g. microirrigation adoption) of the regulatory authorities (RAs), which does little to integrate the vast groundwater-dependent socioecologies with the decision making system. In view of that, we invite the RAs to deliberate upon a cap-and-trade mechanism that proposes to mobilize the farmers at every aspect of planning and execution, while to tackling multiple challenges simultaneously: (a) restrict groundwater pumping to a pre-defined safe level (cap), (b) creating a shared space/quotas for all to pump (allocation); and (c) making provisions for trade of allocations. The latter further augments farmers’ access to groundwater (and irrigation). Using a systematic bibliometric analysis of relevant world literature and contextual appraisal of groundwater-irrigation landscape in India, we develop a conceptual framework of cap-and-trade in three parts. In the first Pre-implementation stage, we emphasize a reality check study to assess ground conditions, if favorable for a cap-and-trade approach (existing social, economic, institutional circumstances). Next, in the Implementation stage, (1) we recommend an integrated hydrogeological-hydrometeorological modeling to determine flexible capping arrangements, with the possibility of delineating certain priority regions (coastal ecosystems); (2) for allocations, a reasonable fraction of the cap over a defined period; we envision a thoroughly participatory arrangement, centering on four action areas: identifying, informing, consulting, and involving the farmers, alongside all stakeholders engaged in the groundwater-irrigation decision making; (3) for trade, we urge the RAs to create win-win situations for both the sellers and buyers; develop the transaction protocols on certain foundational principles (e.g. simplicity, transparency and consistency); strengthening of local institutions, and development of targeted financial support schemes. We consider the third part of the narrative, Post-implementation stage, as a real game changer, comprising of a monitoring, auditing (performance benchmarking) component coupled with multitiered outreach-mentoring drives that demonstrate to the farmers the benefits of becoming part of the cap-and-trade program. Overall, a main motivation to present this research is to shatter the age-old socio-cognitive beliefs/taboos around groundwater pumping (My land, My Water), breaking the hegemony of the water sellers (rich/wealthy large landholder clans), to potentially, create a social norm whereby the farmers realize the value of restricting groundwater pumping and sharing for mutual prosperity.
Similar content being viewed by others
Data availability
All information is available on open sources; no new data were generated.
References
Adithyalakshmanan K, Kaur H, Chaudhuri S (2022) Unpacking land degradation neutrality (LDN), an emerging paradigm to conserve land systems’ sustainability in the 21st century? meta-analysis of challenges and opportunities. Nat Environ Pollut Technol 21(1):91–100
Alcon F, Tapsuwan S, Brouwer R, Yunes M, Mounzer O, de-Miguel MD (2019) Modelling farmer choices for water security measures in the Litani river basin in Lebanon. Sci Total Environ 647:37–46
Ananda J, Aheeyar M (2019) An evaluation of groundwater institutions in India: A property rights perspective. Environ, Dev Sustain 22:5731–5749
Ankita, Patvednaya VU, Chaudhuri S (2021) What do farmers don’t know? a generic index to summarize cognitive awareness of groundwater sourced irrigation and conservation at grassroots. Ecol, Environ Conserv 28(1):179–192
Asoka A, Wada Y, Fishman R, Mishra V (2018) Strong linkage between precipitation intensity and monsoon season groundwater recharge in India. Geophys Res Lett 45(11):5536–5544
Babbitt C, Hall M, Hayden A, Briones ALG, Young R, Brozovic N (2017) Groundwater trading as a tool for implementing california’s sustainable groundwater management act. Environ Defense Fund Mammoth Trading. https://www.edf.org/sites/default/files/documents/water-markets.pdf
Bayer P, Michael A (2020) The European union emissions trading system reduced CO2 emissions despite low prices. PNAS 117(16):8804–8812
Bhattarai N, Lobell DB, Pollack A, Fishman R (2021) The impact of groundwater depletion on agricultural production in India. Environ Res Lett 16(8). https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ac10de
Bell AR, Ward PS, Shah MAA (2016) Increased water charges improve efficiency and equity in an irrigation system. Ecol Soc. 21(3). https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-08642-210323
Bell AR, Shah MAA, Ward PS (2014) Reimagining cost recovery in Pakistan’s irrigation system through willingness-to-pay estimates for irrigation water from a discrete choice experiment. Water Resour Res 50(8):6679–6695
Birkenholtz T (2009) Groundwater governmentality: hegemony and technologies of resistance in Rajasthan’s (India) groundwater governance. Geographical J 175(3):208–220
Bjornlund H (2006) Recent and Emerging Water Policy Reforms in Australia, CAFRI: Current Agriculture, Food and Resource Issues, Canadian Agricultural Economics Society, 7 p 1–12. https://doi.org/10.22004/ag.econ.46363
Brithal PS, Hazrana J, Negi DS, Mishra A (2022) Assessing benefits of crop insurance vis-a-vis irrigation in Indian agriculture. Food Policy 112:102348. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodpol.2022.102348
Castilla-Rho JC, Rojas R, Anderson MS, Holley C (2017) Social tipping points in global groundwater management. Nat Human Behav 1(9). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-017-0181-7
Chaudhuri S, Roy M, McDonald LM, Emendack Y (2023) Land degradation–desertification in relation to farming practices in india: an overview of current practices and agro-policy perspectives. Sustainability 15(8):6383. https://doi.org/10.3390/su15086383
Chaudhuri S, Kumar A (2022) Urban greenery for air pollution control: a meta-analysis of current practice, progress, and challenges. Environ Monit Assess 194(3):1–30
Chaudhuri S, Parakh D, Roy M, Kaur H (2021a) Groundwater-sourced irrigation and agro-power subsidies: Boon or bane for small/marginal farmers in India? Groundwater Sustain Dev 15(100690). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsd.2021.100690
Chaudhuri S, Roy M, McDonald LM (2021b) Coping behaviours and the concept of time poverty: a review of perceived social and health outcomes of food insecurity on women and children. Food Security 13:1049–1068
Chaudhuri S, Roy M, Jain A (2020a) Appraisal of WaSH (Water-Sanitation-Hygiene) Infrastructure using a Composite Index. Spat Algorithms Sociodemogr Correlates Rural India J Environ Inform 35(1):1–22
Chaudhuri S, Roy M, McDonald LM, Emendack Y (2020b) Reflections on farmers’ social networks: a means for sustainable agricultural development? Environ, Sustainability Dev 23:2793–3008
Chaudhuri S, Roy M (2019) Irrigation water pricing in India as a means to conserve water resources: Challenges and Potential future directions. Environ Conserv 46(1):99–102
Chaudhuri S (2018) https://www.thestatesman.com/opinion/micro-irrigation-challenge-1502599259.html
Chaudhuri S, Roy M (2017) Rural-urban spatial inequality in water and sanitation facilities in India: A cross-sectional study from household to national level. Appl Geogr 85:27–38
Chaudhuri S, Ale S (2014a) Long term (1960–2010) trends in groundwater contamination and salinization in the Ogallala aquifer in Texas. J Hydrol 513:376–390
Chaudhuri S, Ale S (2014b) Temporal evolution of depth-stratified groundwater salinity in municipal wells in the major aquifers in Texas, USA. Sci Tot Environ 472:370–380
Chaudhuri S, Ale S (2014c) An appraisal of groundwater quality in Seymour and Blaine aquifers in a major agro-ecological region in Texas, USA. Environ Earth Sci 71(6):2765–2777
Chaudhuri S, Ale S (2013) Characterization of groundwater resources in the Trinity and Woodbine aquifers in Texas. Sci. Tot. Environment 452:333–348
Chindarkar N, Grafton RQ (2019) India’s depleting groundwater: When science meets policy. Asia and The pacific Policy. Studies 6(1):108–124
Choudhury N, Banerjee P, Roy D (2009) Panchayat irrigation management: A case study of institutional reforms program over Teesta Command in West Bengal. Int J Rural Manag 5(1):1–20
Clement F (2012) Literature review: Gender and water management organizations in Bangladesh. Dhaka, Bangladesh: Challenge Program on Water and Food.
Dalin C, Wada Y, Kastner T, Puma M (2017) Groundwater depletion embedded in international food trade. Nature 543:700–704
Dangar S, Asoka A, Jain V (2021) Causes and implications of groundwater depletion in India: A review. J Hydrol 596:126103. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2021.126103
Deshmukh MS Kumbhar AD (2021) Penetration of micro irrigation in India: A state-wise analysis. J Shivaji Univ (Human Soc Sci). 54(1)
Emile R, Clammer JR, Jayaswal P, Sharma P (2022) Addressing water scarcity in developing country contexts: a socio-cultural approach. Human Soc Sci Commun 9(144). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-022-01140-5
Everard M (2015) Community-based groundwater and ecosystem restoration in semi-arid north Rajasthan (1): Socio-economic progress and lessons for groundwater-dependent areas. Ecosyst Serv 16:125–135
Foster T (2015) Hydro-economic modelling of groundwater-fed irrigation. Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Imperial College, London, 201p.
Gandhi VP, Johnson N, Neog K, Jain D (2020) Institutional structure, participation, and devolution in water institutions of Eastern India. Water 12:476. https://doi.org/10.3390/w12020476
Geerts S, Raes D, Garcia M, Miranda R, Cusicanqui JA, Taboada C, Mendoza J, Huanca R, Mamani A, Condori O et al. (2009) Simulating yield response of quinoa to water availability with AquaCrop. Agron J 101(3):499–508
Gonzales P, Ajami NK (2019) Goal-based water trading expands and diversifies supplies for enhanced resilience. Nat Sustain 2:138–147
Grafton RQ, Wheeler SA (2018) Economics of water recovery in the Murray-Darling basin, Australia. Annu Rev Resour Econ 10:487–510
Grafton RQ, Horne J, Wheeler SA (2016) On the marketisation of water: Evidence from the Murray-Darling basin, Australia. Water Resour Manag 30:913–926
Guilfoos T, Pape AD, Khanna N, Salvage K (2013) Groundwater management: The effect of water flows on welfare gains. Ecol Econ 95:31–40
Harou J, Pulido-Velazquez M, Rosenberg DE, Medellín-Azuara J, Lund JR, Howitt RE (2009) Hydro-economic models: concepts, design, applications, and future prospects. J Hydrol 375:627–643
Harou J, Lund JR (2008) Ending groundwater overdraft in hydrologic-economic systems. Hydrogeol J 16:1039–1055.
Herivaux C, Rinaudo J-D, Montginoul M (2019) Exploring potential groundwater markets in agriculture: Results of a participatory evaluation in five French case studies. Water Econ Policy https://doi.org/10.1142/S2382624X19500097
Holley C, Sinclair D (2014) A new water policy option for Australia? Collaborative water governance, compliance and enforcement and audited self-management. Australas J Nat Resour Law Policy 17:189–216
Jain M, Fishman R, Mondal P, Galford G, Bhattarai N, Naeem S, Lall U, Singh B (2021) Groundwater depletion will reduce cropping intensity in India. Sci Adv 7(9). https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abd2849
Jana SK, Lise W (2013) participation in tank irrigation management in dry zones in India. Eur Water 42:35–50
Kandasamy J, Sounthararajah D, Sivabalan P, Chanan A, Vigneswaran S, Sivapalan M (2014) Socio-hydrologic drivers of the Pendulum Swing between agriculture development and environmental health: a case study from Murrumbidgee River Basin, Australia. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci 18:1027–1041
Khan HF Arshad SA (2022) Beyond water scarcity: Water (in)security and social justice in Karachi. J Hydrol Regional Stud 42(101140).
Kirby M, Bark R, Connor J, Qureshi ME, Keyworth S (2014) Sustainable irrigation: How did irrigated agriculture in Australia’s Murray-Darling basin adapt in the millennium drought? Agric Water Manag 145:154–162
Kollmuss A, Agyeman J (2002) Mind the gap: why do people act environmentally and what are the barriers to pro-environmental behaviour? Environ Educ Res 8(3):239–260
Kulkarni H, Shah M, Vajat Shankar PS (2015) Shaping the contours of groundwater governance in India. J Hydrol: Regional Stud 4(Part A):172–192
Kumar HMV, Chauhan NB, Patel DD, Patel JB (2019) Predictive factors to avoid farming as a livelihood. J Econ Struct 8:10
Lendevlo S, Munyebvu F, Suich H (2012) Linking Women’s Participation and Benefits within the Namibian Community Based Natural Resource Management Program. J Sustain Dev 5(12):1–13
Loch A, Bjornlund H, Wheeler S, Connor J (2012) Allocation trade in Australia: a qualitative understanding of irrigator motives and behaviour. Agric Resour Econ 56(1):42–60
Luitel K, Tewari R, Mitchell D, Benson A, Johnson P (2013) The Effect of a Cap-and-Trade model for Groundwater use: A case study in the Texas Southern High Plains. No# 149993. Agricultural and Applied Economics Association. August 4-6, Washington, D.C. USA.
Manjunath AV, Speelman S, Mysore C, Huylenbroeck (2011) Impact of groundwater markets in India on water use efficiency: A data envelopment analysis approach. J Environ Manage 92(11):2924–9
Marchiori C, Sayre SS, Simon L (2012) On the Implementation and Performance of Water Rights Buyback Schemes. Water Resources Management. 26(10). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-012-0047-8
Meinzen-Dick RS, Rubin D, Elias M, Mulema AA, Myers E (2019) Women’s Empowerment in Agriculture: Lessons from Qualitative Research. IFPRI Discussion Paper 1797. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute
Meinzen-Dick R, Janssen MA, Kandikuppa S, Chaurvedi R, Rao K, Theis S (2018) Playing games to save water: Collective action games for groundwater management in Andhra Pradesh, India. World Dev 107:40–53
Mishra V, Thirumalai K, Singh D, Aadhar S (2020) Future exacerbation of hot and dry summer monsoon extremes in India. Npj Clim Atmos Sci 3:10
Mukherji A, Shah T (2005) Groundwater socio-ecology and governance: A review of institutions and policies in selected countries. Hydrogeol J 13:328–345
Nehra K (2016) Evaluation Study on Optimization of Agriculture Power Subsidy and Irrigation Water Intensity in Haryana. Report, Department of Economic and Statistical Analysis, Center for Research in Ruraland Industrial Development (CRRID), Government of India
Nylen NG, Kiparsky M, Archer A, Schnier K, Doremus H (2017) Trading Sustainably: Critical Considerations for Local Groundwater Markets under the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. Working Paper, University of California Berkeley School of Law. https://www.law.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/CLEE_Trading-Sustainably_2017-06-21.pdf
Palamuleni LG, du Plessis Y, Bakuwa RC (2022) Response to Water Scarcity: Gender Analysis of the Motivation Factors Toward Water Conservation Behavior in the Workplace. Front Water 4:930681. https://doi.org/10.3389/frwa.2022.930681
Palanisami K (2009) Water markets as a demand management option: Potentials, problems and prospects. Strategic analyses of the national river linking project (NRLP) of India. In Promoting irrigation demand management in India, (Eds) Saleth, RM (pp. 47–70). International Water Management Institute
Palazzo A Brozovic N (2014) The role of groundwater trading in spatial water management. Agric Water Manag 145. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2014.03.004
Parakh D, Chaudhuri S (2021) Groundwater Regulation Bills in Haryana – A Call for Groundwater Conservation and Management for Sustainable Irrigation Supply Services – Opportunities and Challenges. Ecology. Environ Conserv 28(1):147–164
Parakh D, Chaudhuri S (2023) Groundwater Markets in South Asia: A Bibliometric Assessment of Challenges and Opportunities for Sustainable Irrigation Development. J South Asian Dev 18(2):265–294. https://doi.org/10.1177/09731741231151298
Phadke R (2013) Water works in India. J Political Ecol 20:80–97
Saleth RM (1999) Irrigation privatization in india: options, framework, and experience. Econ Polit Wkly 34(26):A86–A92
Saleth RM (1998) Water Markets in India: Economic and Institutional Aspects. In Markets for water: Potential and performance, eds., KW Easter; MW Rosegrant; A Dinar. Connecticut: Kluwer Academic Press
Shah T, Rajan A, Rai GP, Verma S, Durga N (2018) Solar pumps and South Asia’s energy-groundwater nexus: exploring implications and reimagining its future. Environ Res Lett 13:115003. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/aae53f
Shah T (2009a) Taming the Anarchy: Groundwater Governance in South Asia, Resources for the Future International Water Management Institute, Washington, DC/Colombo (2009), p. 310 p
Shah T (2009b) Climate change and groundwater: India’s opportunities for mitigation and adaptation. Environ Res Lett 4:035005
Shinju V, Prasad A (2019) Women, water & well-being: A Case Study of ‘Kuttadampadam’ in Palakkad, Kerala. Shanlax Int J Arts Sci Humanities 7(1):44–49
Siebert S, Burke J, Faures J-M, Frenken K, Hoogeveen J, Döll P, Portmann FT (2010) Groundwater use for irrigation—A global inventory. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci 14:1863–1880
Singh O, Kasana A, Sharma T (2020) Groundwater irrigation market patterns and practices over an agriculturally developed province of north-west India. GeoJournal 85(3):703–729. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10708-019-09992-2
Singh D (2007) Who gains and who loses in the game of groundwater markets in water scarce regions. Agric Econ Res Rev 20(4):345–360
Singha B, Eljamal O (2021) Exploring attitudes and household culture to encourage water conservation behaviour. Proceeding of International Exchange and Innovation Conference on Engineering & Sciences (IEICES) 7, Kyushu University. Japan. Fukuoka. https://doi.org/10.5109/4738581
Sivapalan M, Blöschl G (2015) Time scale interactions and the coevolution of humans and water. Water Resour Res 51:6988–7022
Swain M, Das DK (2008) Participatory irrigation management in India. Implement Gaps J Dev Sustain Agric 3:28–39
Thompson CL, Supall RJ, Martin DL, McMullen BP (2009) Evidence supporting cap and trade as a groundwater policy option for reducing irrigation consumptive use. J Am Water Resour Assoc 45(6):1508–1518
Tong Y, Fan L, Niu H (2016) Water conservation awareness and practices in households receiving improved water supply: A gender-based analysis. J Cleaner Prod 141. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.09.169
van Koppen B, Nagar RK, Vasavada S (2001) Gender and Irrigation in India: The Women’s Irrigation Group of Jambar, South Gujarat. Working paper 10. Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water Management Institute
Wheeler SA (2022) Debunking Murray-Darling Basin water trade myths. Agric Resour Econ 66(4):797–821
Wheeler SA, Garrick DE (2020) A tale of two water markets in Australia: lessons for understanding participation in formal water markets. Oxf Rev Economic Policy 36(1):132–153
Wheeler SA, Loch A, Crase L, Young M, Grafton RQ (2017) Developing a water market readiness assessment framework. J Hydrol 552:807–820
Wheeler SA, Bjornlund H, Zuo A, Shanahan M (2010) The changing profile of water traders in the Goulburn-Murray Irrigation District. Aust Agric Water Manag 97(9):1333–1343
Xiao X, Gutiérrez F, Guerrero J (2020) The impact of groundwater drawdown and vacuum pressure on sinkhole development. Phys Lab Models Eng Geol 279:105894
Zaman A (2019) Participatory irrigation management: Barind model a new sustainable initiative. Univ J Manag 7(6):220–228
Zaveri E, Grogan DS, Fisher-Vanden K, Frolking S, Lammers RB, Wrenn DH, Prusevich A, Nicholas RE (2016) Invisible water, visible impact: groundwater use and Indian agriculture under climate change. Environ Earth Lett 11(8). https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/11/8/084005
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the research staff of the Center for Environment, Sustainability and Human Development (CESH) at the O.P. Jindal Global University.
Authors’ contribution
SC conceived the main idea, wrote the main manuscript, and analyzed the information; MR conducted the literature review, and helped writing the manuscript and analyses; SC and MR prepared the figures and tables; All authors reviewed the manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Chaudhuri, S., Roy, M. & Suresh, M. Can Cap-and-Trade Be a Regulatory Option to Address Groundwater Depletion and Irrigation Crises in India? Reflections, Issues & Options. Environmental Management 73, 177–198 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-023-01908-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-023-01908-8