Advertisement

Environmental Management

, Volume 62, Issue 1, pp 70–81 | Cite as

Avoiding Implementation Failure in Catchment Landscapes: A Case Study in Governance of the Great Barrier Reef

  • Allan P. Dale
  • Karen Vella
  • Margaret Gooch
  • Ruth Potts
  • Robert L. Pressey
  • Jon Brodie
  • Rachel Eberhard
Article

Abstract

Water quality outcomes affecting Australia’s Great Barrier Reef (GBR) are governed by multi-level and multi-party decision-making that influences forested and agricultural landscapes. With international concern about the GBR’s declining ecological health, this paper identifies and focuses on implementation failure (primarily at catchment scale) as a systemic risk within the overall GBR governance system. There has been limited integrated analysis of the full suite of governance subdomains that often envelop defined policies, programs and delivery activities that influence water quality in the GBR. We consider how the implementation of separate purpose-specific policies and programs at catchment scale operate against well-known, robust design concepts for integrated catchment governance. We find design concerns within ten important governance subdomains that operate within GBR catchments. At a whole-of-GBR scale, we find a weak policy focus on strengthening these delivery-oriented subdomains and on effort integration across these subdomains within catchments. These governance problems when combined may contribute to failure in the implementation of major national, state and local government policies focused on improving water quality in the GBR, a lesson relevant to landscapes globally.

Keywords

Governance systems Catchment management Water quality Implementation failure 

Notes

Acknowledgements

Funding was provided by the Australian Government’s National Environment Research Program Tropical Water Quality Hub (via the Reef and Rainforest Research Centre), the Australian Government’s Northern Futures Collaborative Research Network (CRN), and the Australian Research Council Linkage Project 130100933. Many thanks also for the contribution of Katrina Keith, Jennifer McHugh, and our participating actors/experts.

Compliance with Ethical Standards

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

References

  1. Althaus C, Bridgman P, Davis G (2007) The Australian policy handbook, 4th edn. Allen and Unwin, SydneyGoogle Scholar
  2. Álvarez-Romero JG et al. (2015) Integrated cross-realm planning: a decision-makers’ perspective. Biol Conserv 191:799–808 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2015.07.003CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Álvarez-Romero JG, Pressey RL, Ban NC, Brodie J (2015b) Advancing land-sea conservation planning: integrating modeling of catchments, land-use change, and river plumes to prioritise catchment management and protection. PLoS ONE.  https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0145574
  4. Álvarez-Romero JG, Pressey RL, Ban NC, Vance-Borland K, Willer C, Klein CJ, Gaines SD (2011) Integrated land-sea conservation planning: The missing links. Annu Rev Ecol Evol S 42:381–409 https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-ecolsys-102209-144702CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Aspinall R, Pearson D (2000) Integrated geographical assessment of environmental condition in water catchments: linking landscape ecology, environmental modelling and GIS. J Environ Manage 59(4):299–319 https://doi.org/10.1006/jema.2000.0372CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Baroudi R (2011) Strategy planning and execution from A to Z: 100’s of common weaknesses & tips. Createspace, North CharlestonGoogle Scholar
  7. Barrett P (2003) Better practice public sector governance. ANAO, CanberraGoogle Scholar
  8. Benson D, Jordan A, Huitema D (2012) Involving the public in catchment management: An analysis of the scope for learning lessons from abroad. Environ Policy Govern 22(1):42–54. https://doi.org/10.1002/eet.593CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Biermann F (2007) ‘Earth system governance’ as a crosscutting theme of global change research. Glob Environ Chang 17(3–4):326–337.  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2006.11.010 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bolitho A, Coffey B (2014) Twenty years of integrated catchment management in Victoria: Celebrating the achievements of the Catchment and Land Protection Act (1994) and looking to the future. Victorian Catchment Management Council, Melbourne. Retrieved from http://dro.deakin.edu.au/view/DU:30064975Google Scholar
  11. Brodie J & Pearson R (2016) Ecosystem health of the Great Barrier Reef: time for effective management action based on evidence. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf ScienceGoogle Scholar
  12. Brodie JE, Kroon FJ, Schaffelke B, Wolanski EC, Lewis SE, Devlin MJ, Bohnet IC, Bainbridge ZT, Waterhouse J, Davis AM (2012) Terrestrial pollutant runoff to the great barrier reef: an update of issues, priorities and management responses. Mar Pollut Bull 65(4–9):81–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Brussaard L, Caron P, Campbell B, Lipper L, Mainka S, Rabbinge R, Babin D, Pullerman M (2010) Reconciling biodiversity conservation and food security: Scientific challenges for a new agriculture. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 2(1–2):34–42Google Scholar
  14. Bulkeley H (2005) Reconfiguring environmental governance: towards a politics of scales and networks. Polit Geogr 24:875–902CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Cash D, Adger W et al. (2006) Scale and cross-scale dynamics: governance and information in a multilevel world. Ecol Soc 11(2):8CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Cline KD (2000) Defining the implementation problem: organizational management versus cooperation. J Publ Adm Res Theor 10:551–572CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Curtis A, Lockwood M (2000) Landcare and catchment management in Australia: lessons for state-sponsored community participation. Soc Natur Resour 13:61–73 https://doi.org/10.1080/089419200279243CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Dale AP, Bellamy JA (1998) Regional resource use planning in rangelands: an Australian review. Land & Water Resources Research & Development Corporation, CanberraGoogle Scholar
  19. Dale AP, Vella KJ, Potts R (2013) Governance systems analysis (GSA): a framework for reforming governance systems. J Publ Adm Govern 3:162–187 https://doi.org/10.5296/jpag.v3i3.4385CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Dale AP, Vella KJ, Pressey RL, Brodie JE, Yorkston H, Potts R (2013) A method for risk analysis across governance systems: a great barrier reef case study. Environ Res Lett 8:1–16 https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/8/1/015037CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Dale AP (2014b) Cassowaries and chaplains: How to avoid Canberra’s conservation overreach. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/cassowaries-and-chaplains-how-to-avoid-canberras-conservation-overreach-28034. Accessed 17 Mar 2016.
  22. Dale AP (2014b) Beyond the north-south culture wars: reconciling northern Australia’s past with its future. Springer Briefs in Geography. Springer, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dale AP et al. (2014) Catchment-scale governance in northern Australia: a preliminary evaluation. J Econ Soc Policy 16:2.Google Scholar
  24. Dale AP, Vella K, Pressey RL, Brodie J, Gooch M, Potts R, Eberhard R (2016). Risk analysis of the governance system affecting outcomes in the great barrier reef. Glob Environ Change https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2016.09.013Google Scholar
  25. Davis AM, Moore AR (2015) Conservation potential of artificial water bodies for fish communities on a heavily modified agricultural floodplain. Aquat Conserv https://doi.org/10.1002/aqc.2607. Accessed 8 Dec 2015Google Scholar
  26. Department of the Environment (2013b) NWI policy guidelines for water planning and management. http://www.environment.gov.au/topics/water/australian-government-water-leadership/national-water-initiative/guidelines-water. Accessed 16 Mar 2016
  27. Dorcey A (1986) Bargaining in the governance of pacific coastal resources: research and reform. Westwater Research Centre, UBC, VancouverGoogle Scholar
  28. Dovers S (2000) Beyond everythingcare and everythingwatch: Public participation, public policy and participating publics. Paper presented at the International Landcare 2000: Changing Landscapes, Shaping Futures, MelbourneGoogle Scholar
  29. Drewry J, Higham W, Mitchell C, Mackay Whitsunday Natural Resource Management Group (2008) Water quality improvement plan: Final report for Mackay Whitsunday region. Mackay Whitsunday Natural Resource Management Group, Mackay. http://reefcatchments.com.au/files/2013/02/MWNRM-WQIP-total-report-2008.pdf. Accessed 16 Aug 2016
  30. Duda A, El-Ashry M (2000) Addressing the global water and environmental crises through integrated approaches to the management of land, water and ecological resources. Water Int 25(1):115–126CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Dutra L, Bustamante RH, Sporne I, van Putten I, Dichmont C, Ligtermoet E, Sheaves M, Deng R (2016) Organizational drivers that strengthen adaptive capacity in the coastal zone of Australia. Ocean Coast Manage 109:64–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Dutson G, Bennun L, Maron M, Brodie J, Bos M, Waterhouse J (2015) Determination of suitable financial contributions as offsets within the Reef Trust. The Biodiversity Consultancy Ltd, Cambridge, UK. http://www.environment.gov.au/marine/gbr/publications/determination-suitable-financial-contributions-offsets-within-reef-trust. Accessed 16 Aug 2016
  33. Eldridge JET, Crombie AD (1974) A sociology of organisations. George Allen & Unwin, LondonGoogle Scholar
  34. Emerson K, Nabatchi T, Balogh S (2011) An integrative framework for collaborative governance. J Publ Adm Res Theor 22:1–29 https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/mur011CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Graham J, Amos B, Plumptre T (2003) Principles of good governance in the 21st century. Policy Brief No. 15, Institute of Good Governance, OntarioGoogle Scholar
  36. Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (2010) Reef Rescue Indigenous Land and Sea Country Partnerships Program: TUMRA implementation funding guidelines. GBRMPA, Townsville. http://elibrary.gbrmpa.gov.au/jspui/handle/11017/1017. Accessed 16 Aug 2016
  37. Grech A et al. (2013) Guiding principles for the improved governance of port and shipping impacts in the Great Barrier Reef. Mar Pollut Bull 75:8–20 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2013.07.013CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Heller MG (2009) Capitalism, institutions, and economic development. Routledge, AbingdonGoogle Scholar
  39. Hirsch P (2006) Water governance reform and catchment management in the Mekong region. J Envir Dev 15:184–201 https://doi.org/1070496506288221CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Hockings M, Leverington A, Trinder C, Polglaze J (2014) Independent assessment of management effectiveness for the Great Barrier Reef: Outlook report 2014. Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority, Townsville. http://elibrary.gbrmpa.gov.au/jspui/handle/11017/2857. Accessed 16 Aug 2016
  41. Holzwarth F (2002) The EU water framework directive – a key to catchment-based governance. Water Sci Technol 45:105–112CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Hooghe L, Marks G (2001) Types of multi-level governance. Eur Integr Online Pa 5.  https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.302786
  43. Huppe GA, Creech H, Knoblauch D (2012) The frontiers of networked governance. Manitoba: International Institute for Sustainable Development (ISSD). Retrieved from http://ecologic.eu/4640
  44. Jedd T, Bixler RP (2015) Accountability in networked governance: learning from a case of landscape-scale forest conservation. Envir Policy Gov 25(3):172–187  https://doi.org/10.1002/eet.1670 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Jessop B (2004) Multi-level governance and multi-level metagovernance. In: Bache I, Flinders M (eds) Multi-level governance. Oxford University Press, Oxford, p 49–74.  https://doi.org/10.1093/0199259259.003.0004
  46. Joint Steering Committee for Water Sensitive Cities (2009) Evaluating options for water sensitive urban design–A national guide. http://www.environment.gov.au/system/files/resources/1873905a-f5b7-4e3c-8f45-0259a32a94b1/files/wsud-guidelines.pdf. Accessed 7 Mar 2016
  47. Kroon FJ, Thorburn P, Schaffelke B, Whitten S (2016) Towards protecting the Great Barrier Reef from land-based pollution. Glob Change Biol. 29 February.  https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.13262
  48. Manzungu E, Kujinga K (2002) The theory and practice of governance of water resources in Zimbabwe, Zambezia (2002), XXIX (ii)Google Scholar
  49. Margerum RD (1995) Integrated environmental management: moving from theory to practice. J Environ Planning Manage 38:371–392 https://doi.org/10.1080/09640569512922CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Mitchell B (2002) Resource and Environmental Management, 2nd edn. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  51. Morrison TH (2017) Evolving polycentric governance of the Great Barrier Reef. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (PNAS), 114(15), E3013–E3021. Retrieved from http://www.pnas.org/content/114/15/E3013.full.pdf.  https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1620830114
  52. National Water Commission (2011) National water planning report card 2011. NWC, Canberra. http://www.nwc.gov.au/?a=19805. Accessed 16 Aug 2016
  53. Offiong JO (2011) The dilemma of implementing effective environmental policies in Nigeria. JORIND 9:420–430Google Scholar
  54. OECD (2004) OECD principles of corporate governance. OECD. http://www.oecd.org/corporate/ca/corporategovernanceprinciples/31557724.pdf. Accessed 14 Mar 2016
  55. Ostrom E (2008) Polycentric systems as one approach for solving collective-action problems. Indiana University, Bloomington.  https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1304697. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1936061. Accessed 16 Aug 2016
  56. Ostrom E (2010) Beyond markets and states: polycentric governance of complex economic systems. Am Econ Rev 100:641–672 https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.100.3.641CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Parker C, Braithwaite J (2003) Regulation. In: Cane P, Tushnet M (eds) The Oxford handbook of legal studies. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 119–145Google Scholar
  58. Paton S, Curtis A, McDonald G, Woods M (2004) Regional natural resource management: Is it sustainable. Australas J Environ 11:259–267 https://doi.org/10.1080/14486563.2004.10648622CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Peters BG, Pierre J (2001) Developments in intergovernmental relations: towards multi-level governance. Policy Polit 29:131–135 https://doi.org/10.1332/030557301250125CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Potts R, Vella K, Dale AP, Sipe N (2015) A study of governance arrangements for land use and natural resource management planning in Cape York Peninsula. Australian Geographer 46(3):389–409CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Pullan W, Bhedeshia H (2000) Structure in science and art. CUP, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  62. Queensland Audit Office (2015) Managing water quality in Great Barrier Reef catchments (Report 20: 2014–15). Queensland Audit Office, Brisbane. https://www.qao.qld.gov.au/reports-parliament/managing-water-quality-great-barrier-reef-catchments. Accessed 16 Aug 2016
  63. Ryan S, Broderick K, Sneddon Y, Andrews K (2010) Australia’s NRM governance system: Foundations and principles for meeting future challenges. Australian Regional NRM Chairs, CanberraGoogle Scholar
  64. Sayer J, Margules C, Boedhihartono AK, Dale AP, Sunderland T, Supriatna J, Saryanthi R (2014) Landscape approaches; what are the pre-conditions for success?. Sust Sci 10:345 https://doi.org/10.1080/07293682.2013.837831CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Schroeder B et al. (2008) SmartCane principles of best management practice. BSES Limited, CANEGROWERS, Bundaberg, QLD. http://www.canegrowers.com.au/icms_docs/70456_BMP_Principles_of_BMP.pdf. Accessed 16 Aug 2016
  66. Sea Forum Working Group (1999) Aboriginal involvement in the management of the southern Great Barrier Reef. Discussion paper prepared for Sea Forum, December 1999. Sea Forum, BrisbaneGoogle Scholar
  67. Smith LED, Porter KS (2009) Management of catchments for the protection of water resources: Drawing on the New York City watershed experience. Regional Environmental Change 10(4): 311–326Google Scholar
  68. Tippett J (2001) Integrated catchment management and planning for sustainability: The case of the Mersey Basin campaign. A dissertation submitted to the University of Manchester for the Degree of MA (Econ.) in Social Research Methods. Faculty of Social Sciences and Law, ManchesterGoogle Scholar
  69. United Nations Development Program (1997) Governance and sustainable human development. UNDP, GenevaGoogle Scholar
  70. Vella K, Dale AP (2014) An approach for adaptive and integrated environmental planning to deal with uncertainty in a Great Barrier Reef catchment. Australian Planner 51:243–259 https://doi.org/10.1080/07293682.2013.837831CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Vella KJ, Bellamy JA, McDonald GT (1999) Looking beyond the fences: Institutional challenges to integrated approaches to catchment management. Paper presented at the International Symposium of Society and Resource Management: Application of Social Science to Resource Management in the Asia Pacific RegionGoogle Scholar
  72. Vella K, Sipe N, Dale AP, Taylor B (2015) Not learning from the past: adaptive governance challenges for Australian natural resource management. Geog Res 53:379–392  https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-5871.12115 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Waltham NJ, Sheaves M (2015) Expanding coastal urban and industrial seascape in the great barrier reef world heritage area: critical need for coordinated planning and policy. Mar Policy 57:78–84 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2015.03.030CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Waterhouse J, Brodie JE, Lewis S, Audas D-M (2016) Land-sea connectivity, ecohydrology and holistic management of the Great Barrier Reef and its catchments: time for a change. Ecohydrol Hydrobiol 16:45–57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecohyd.2015.08.005CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Young OR (2013) On environmental governance: Sustainability, efficiency and equity. Paradigm, Boulder, COGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  • Allan P. Dale
    • 1
  • Karen Vella
    • 2
  • Margaret Gooch
    • 1
  • Ruth Potts
    • 2
  • Robert L. Pressey
    • 3
  • Jon Brodie
    • 4
  • Rachel Eberhard
    • 2
  1. 1.The Cairns InstituteJames Cook University (JCU)CairnsAustralia
  2. 2.School of Civil Engineering and Built EnvironmentScience and Engineering Faculty, QUTBrisbaneAustralia
  3. 3.Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, JCUTownsvilleAustralia
  4. 4.Centre for Tropical Water and Aquatic Ecosystem Research, JCUTownsvilleAustralia

Personalised recommendations