Abstract
One important aspect of adaptive management is the clear and transparent documentation of hypotheses, together with the use of predictive models (complete with any assumptions) to test those hypotheses. Documentation of such models can improve the ability to learn from management decisions and supports dialog between stakeholders. A key challenge is how best to represent the existing scientific knowledge to support decision-making. Such challenges are currently emerging in the field of environmental water management in Australia, where managers are required to prioritize the delivery of environmental water on an annual basis, using a transparent and evidence-based decision framework. We argue that the development of models of ecological responses to environmental water use needs to support both the planning and implementation cycles of adaptive management. Here we demonstrate an approach based on the use of Conditional Probability Networks to translate existing ecological knowledge into quantitative models that include temporal dynamics to support adaptive environmental flow management. It equally extends to other applications where knowledge is incomplete, but decisions must still be made.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
We use the term environmental water here to encompass all water legally available to the environment through the array of possible allocation mechanisms.
References
Acreman M (2005) Linking science and decision-making: features and experience from environmental river flow setting. Environ Modell Softw 20:99–109
Allan C, Stankey G (eds) (2009) Synthesis of lessons. In: Adaptive envionmental management: A practitioner’s guide. Springer Science, BV Dordrecht, The Netherlands and CSIRO, Collingwood, VIC
Allen CR, Garmestani AS (eds) (2015) Adaptive management. In: Adaptive management of social-ecological systems. Springer Science, BV Dordrecht, The Netherlands and CSIRO, Collingwood, VIC
Anderson KE, Paul AJ, MCcauley E, Jackson LJ, Post JR, Nisbet RM (2006) Instream flow needs in streams and rivers: the importance of understanding ecological dynamics. Front Ecol Environ 4:309–318
Arthington A (2012) Environmental flows-saving rivers in the third millennium. University of California Press, Berkley US
Beven KJ, Alcock RE (2012) Modelling everything everywhere: a new approach to decision-making for water management under uncertainty. Freshw Biol 57:124–132
Blackmore C, Ison R (2012) Designing and developing learning systems for managing systemic change in a climate change world. In: Wals A, Corcoran P (eds) Learning for sustainability in times of accelerating change. Wageningen Academic Publishers, Netherlands
Bryan BA, Higgins A, Overton IC, Holland K, Lester RE, King D, Nolan M, MacDonald DH, Connor JD, Bjornsson T, Kirby M (2013) Ecohydrological and socioeconomic integration for the operational management of environmental flows. Ecol Appl 23:999–1016
Bryan BA, Kandulu J, Deere DA, White M, Frizenschaf J, Crossman ND (2009) Adaptive management for mitigating Cryptosporidium risk in source water: a case study in an agricultural catchment in South Australia. J Environ Manage 90:3122–3134
Bunn S, Arthington A (2002) Basic principles and ecological consequences of altered flow regimes for aquatic biodiversity. Environ Manage 30:492–507
Cain J (2001) Planning improvements in natural resources management-Guidelines for using Bayesian networks to support the planning and management of development programmes in the water sector and beyond. Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Wallingford
Campbell B, Coote E, Foster J, Johnson H (2016) Decision Support Systems - assisting implementation of long-term environmental water planning. Proceeding of the 8th Australian Stream Management Conference. Townsville, Queensland
CEWO (2013) Framework for determining Commonwealth Environmental Water Use. Commonwealth Environmental Water Office, Canberra
Connell D, Grafton RQ (2011) Water reform in the Murray-Darling Basin. Water Resour Res, 47
Crook DA, MacDonald JI, O’Connor JP, Barry B (2006) Use of otolith chemistry to examine patterns of diadromy in the threatened Australian grayling Prototroctes maraena. J Fish Biol 69:1330–1344
De Little SC, Webb JA, Patulny L, Miller KA, Stewardson MJ (2012) Novel methodology for detecting ecological responses to environmental flow regimes: using causal criteria analysis and expert elicitation to examine the effects of different flow regimes on terrestrial vegetation. In: Mader H, Kraml J (eds) 9th International Symposium on Ecohydraulics 2012 Proceedings. International Association for Hydro-Environmental Engineering and Research (IAHR)
Docker BB, Johnson HL (2017) Environmental water regime delivery: maximizing ecological outcomes in a constrained operating environment. In: Horne A, Webb A, Stewardson M, Acreman M, Richter B (eds) Water for the Environment - From Policy and Science to Implementation and Management, Elsevier, Cambridge, MA
Doolan JM, Ashworth B, Swiripik B (2017) Planning for the active management of enivronmental water. In: Horne A, Webb A, Stewardson M, Acreman M, Richter B (eds) Water for the Environment - From Policy and Science to Implementation and Management, Elsevier, Cambridge, MA
Eberhard R, Robinson CJ, Waterhouse J, Parslow J, Hart B, Grayson R, Taylor B (2009) Adaptive management for water quality planning – from theory to practice. Mar Freshwater Res 60:1189–1195
Gippel CJ, Bond NR, James C, Wang X (2009) An asset-based, holistic, environmental flows assessment approach. Int J Water Resour D 25:301–330
Grafton RQ, Chu HL, Stewardson M, Kompas T (2011) Optimal dynamic water allocation: irrigation extractions and environmental tradeoffs in the Murray River, Australia. Water Resour Res 47
Hart B, Pollino C (2009) Bayesian networks for risk-based environmental water allocations. Waterlines Report Series No 14. National Water Commission, Canberra
Henderson P, Pollino C, Hart B (2008) Bayesian Modelling as a Basis for Risk-based Environmental Flow Assessment–A review. National Water Commission, Canberra, Australia
Holling C (ed) (1978) Adaptive environmental assessment and management. Wiley, Chichester
Horne A, O’Donnell E, Tharme RE (2017a) Mechanisms to allocate environmental water. In: Horne A, Webb A, Stewardson M, Acreman M, Richter B (eds) Water for the Environment - From Policy and Science to Implementation and Management, Elsevier, Cambridge, MA.
Horne A, Kaur S, Szemis J, Costa A, Webb J, Nathan R, Stewardson M, Lowe L, Boland N (2017b) Using optimization to develop a “designer” environmental flow regime. Envion Model Softw 88:188–199
Horne A, Stewardson M, Freebairn J, McMahon TA (2010) Using an economic framework to inform management of environmental entitlements. River Res Appl 26:779–795
Horne A, Szemis S, Kaur S, Webb J, Stewardson M, Costa A, Boland N (2016) Optimization tools for environmental water decisions: a review of strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities to improve adoption. Environ Model and Softw 84: 326–338
Ison R, Blackmore C, Iaquinto BL (2013) Towards systemic and adaptive governance: exploring the revealing and concealing aspects of contemporary social-learning metaphors. Ecol Econ 87:34–42
King AJ, Tonkin Z, Mahoney J (2009) Environmental flow enhances native fish spawning and recruitment in the Murray River, Australia. River Res Appl 25:1205–1218
Kingsford RT, Biggs HC, Pollard SR (2011) Strategic Adaptive Management in freshwater protected areas and their rivers. Biol Conserv 144:1194–1203
Koster WM this issue
Koster WM, Dawson DR, Crook D (2013) Downstream spawning migration by the amphidromous Australian grayling (Prototroctes maraena) in a coastal river in south-eastern Australia. Mar Freshwater Res 64:31–41
Ladson T (2009) Adaptive management of environmental flows-10 years on. In: Allan C, Stankey G (eds) Adaptive environmental management: A practitioner’s guide. Springer Science, BV Dordrecht, The Netherlands and CSIRO, Collingwood, VIC
Le Quesne T, Kendy E, Weston D (2010) The implementation challenge-Taking stock of government policies to protect and restore environmental flows. The Nature Conservancy and WWF
Lester RE, Pollino CA, Cummings CR (2011) Improving ecological outcomes by refining decision support tools: a case study using the murray flow assessment tool and the sustainable rivers audit. In: 19th International Congress on Modelling and Simulation, Perth, Australia, 12–16 Decemner
Liebman JC (1976) Some simple-minded observations on the role of optimization in public systems decision-making. Interfaces 6:102–108
Marsh N, Grigg N, Arene S (2007) A framework for capturing and applying models of biological response to natural resource management. In: Oxley L, Kulasiri D (eds) MODSIM 2007 International Congress on Modelling and Simulation. Modelling and Simulation Society of Australia and New Zealand, December 2007
O’Donnell E, Garrick D (2017) Environmental water organizations and institutional settings. In: Horne A, Webb A, Stewardson M, Acreman M, Richter B (eds) Water for the Environment - From Policy and Science to Implementation and Management, Elsevier, Cambridge, MA
Overton IC, Pollino CA, Roberts J, Reid JRW, Bond NR, McGinness HM, Gawne B, Stratford DS, Merrin LE, Barma D, Cuddy SM, Nielsen DL, Smith T, Henderson BL, Baldwin DS, Chiu GS, Doody TM (2014) Development of the Murray-Darling Basin Plan SDL Adjustment Ecological Elements Method. Report prepared by CSIRO for the Murray-Darling Basin Authority. Canberra, Australia
Pearl J (2000) Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference. Cambridgee University Press, Cambridge
Poff NL, Richter BD, Arthington AH, Bunn SE, Naiman RJ, Kendy E, Acreman M, Apse C, Bledsoe BP, Freeman MC, Henriksen J, Jacobson RB, Kennen JG, Merritt DM, O’Keeffe JH, Olden JD, Rogers K, Tharme RE, Warner A (2010) The ecological limits of hydrologic alteration (ELOHA): a new framework for developing regional environmental flow standards. Freshw Biol 55:147–170
Pollard S, du Toit D, Biggs H (2011) River management under transformation: The emergence of strategic adaptive management of river systems in the Kruger National Park. Koedoe 53(2):1011
Reckhow K (2003) Bayesian approaches in ecological analysis and modeling. In: Canham C, Coles J, Lauenroth W (eds) Models in ecosystem science, Princeton University Press, Priceton, New Jersey
Richter B (2014) Chasing Water: A guide for moving from scarcity to sustainability. Island Press, Washington, DC
Rivers-Moore NA, Jewitt GPW (2007) Adaptive management and water temperature variability within a South African river system: What are the management options? J Environ Manage 82:39–50
Shenton W, Bond NR, Yen JDL, Mac Nally R (2012) Putting the “Ecology” into environmental flows: ecological dynamics and demographic modelling. Environ Manage 50:1–10
Shenton W, Hart BT, Chan T (2011) Bayesian network models for environmental flow decision-making: 1. Latrobe River Australia. River Res Appl 27:283–296
Speirs-Bridge A, Fidler F, Mcbride M, Flander L, Cumming G, Burgman M (2010) Reducing overconfidence in the interval judgments of experts. Risk Anal 30:512–523
Stewardson M, Rutherford I (2008) Geomorphic contributions to designing rehabilitated river channels: do we have unreasonable confidence? In: Darby S, Sear D (eds) In: River restoration: managing the uncertainty in resotring physical habitat, John Wiley & Sons
Stewardson M, Webb JA (2010) Modelling ecological responses to flow alteration: making the most of existing data and knowledge. In: Saintilan N, Overton I (eds) Ecosystem Response Modelling in the Murray-Darling Basin. CSIRO Publishing, Melbourne, Australia
Stringer LC, Dougill AJ, Fraser E, Hubacek K, Prell C, Reed MS (2006) Unpacking “participation” in the adaptive management of social-ecological systems: a critical review. Ecol Soc 11:719–740
Tharme RE (2003) A global perspective on environmental flow assessment: Emerging trends in the development and application of enivornmental flow methodologies for rivers. River Res Appl 19:397–441
Walters CJ (1986) Adaptive management of renewable resources. MacMillan Publishing Company, New York
Webb J, Koster W, Stuart I, Reich P, Stewardson M this issue. Make the most of the data you’ve got: Bayesian models and a surrogate species approach to assessing benefits of upstream migration flows for the endangered Australian grayling. Environmental Manage
Webb JA, Watts RJ, Allan C, Warner A (2017) Principles for monitoring, evaluation and adaptive managment of enviornmental water regimes. In: Horne A, Webb A, Stewardson M, Acreman M, Richter B (eds) Water for the Environment - From Policy and Science to Implementation and Management, Elsevier, Cambridge, MA
Williams BK (2011) Adaptive management of natural resources—framework and issues. J Environ Manage 92:1346–1353
Williams BK, Brown ED (2014) Adaptive management: from more talk to real action. Environ Manage 53:465–479
Young WJ, Scott AC, Cuddy SM, Rennie BA (2003) Murray Flow Assessment Tool – a technical description. Client Report, 2003. CSIRO Land and Water, Canberra
Acknowledgements
This study was funded by through ARC Linkage project LP130100174.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no competing interest.
Electronic Supplementary Material
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Horne, A.C., Szemis, J.M., Webb, J.A. et al. Informing Environmental Water Management Decisions: Using Conditional Probability Networks to Address the Information Needs of Planning and Implementation Cycles. Environmental Management 61, 347–357 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-017-0874-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-017-0874-8