Abstract
Rapid growth in marine sand mining for construction and other uses poses environmental challenges to coastal nations virtually worldwide. Yet the development of management policies, such as a system of fees imposed on operators for damage caused by mining, has been frustrated by a lack of studies to support such measures. Adapting a Beverton-Holt bioeconomic model, this paper attempts to contribute to the estimation of external costs to commercial fisheries due to marine mining. Using the major mining area of Ongjin in Korea as a case study, we estimate economic losses in use value of commercial fisheries through the time to recovery of the injured resource stocks. Present value of lost catch over a 1-year period from mining to resource recovery is estimated at $38,851 for a single “prototype” mining site. Estimated cumulative damages due to recurring mining for 5 and 10 years are $1.5 million and $2.2 million, respectively, at 20 mining sites. Sensitivity analyses are used to examine the effects of alternative assumptions to assess the many sources of uncertainty. Using a form of meta-analysis, dose-response information is used to assess the excess mortality the mining sediment plume has on eggs and larvae and, ultimately, on the value of lost catch ($841). Also addressed is the importance of specifying the appropriate “premining” conditions against which to assess environmental losses at the mining site. Damages estimated with premining fish populations are $23,066 higher than is the case using postmining conditions. Overall, the illustrative results suggest the variety of complex conditions which influence damage to fisheries from mining and which can benefit from further study to improve management guidelines.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Birklund J, Wijsman JWM (2005) Aggregate extraction: a review on the effect on ecological functions. Report Z3297.10. W.L. Delft Hydraulics
Byrnes MR, Richard MH, Tim DT, David BS (2004) Effects of sand mining on physical processes and biological communities offshore New Jersey, U.S.A. Journal of Coastal Research 20(1):25–43
Cho D-O, Chang H-B (2003) A study on the status of supply and demand of marine sand and management system. Research Project Report No. 2003-17. Korea Maritime Institute
Coastline Surveys Ltd. (1999) Marine aggregated mining benthic & surface plume study. MMS-OCS Study 99-0029. U.S. Department of the Interior, Minerals Management Service
Coastline Surveys Ltd. and Marine Ecological Surveys Ltd. (2000) Integrated report on the impact of marine aggregate dredging on physical and biological resources of the seabed. MMS-OCS Study 2000-0054. U.S. Department of the Interior, Minerals Management Service
Diaz RJ, Cutter GR Jr, Hobbs CH III (2004) Potential Impacts of Sand Mining Offshore of Maryland and Delaware: Part 2—biological considerations. Journal of Coastal Research 20(1):61–69
Drucker BS, Waskes W, Byrnes MR (2004) The U.S. Minerals Management Service Outer Continental Shelf Sand and Gravel Program: environmental studies to assess the potential effects of offshore dredging operations in federal waters. Journal of Coastal Research 20(1):1–5
Freeman AM III (2003) Valuing environmental and natural resource services: theory and measurement, 2nd edn. Resources for the Future, Washington, DC
Grigalunas T, Opaluch JJ, Luo M (2001) The economic costs to fisheries from marine sediment disposal: case study of Providence, RI, USA. Ecological Economics 38:47–58
Grigalunas T, Shamshak G, Cho DO (2004) Financial-economic-environmental framework for assessing marine sand and gravel mining in Korea’s EEZ: Phase I report. In: Proceedings, Annual Korea-America Joint Policy Research Center. University of Rhode Island, Kingston
Grigalunas TA, Kim T-g, Chang HB, Cho DO (2005) Estimates of the economic cost to commercial fisheries in Ongjin, Korea, because of marine sand mining. International Cooperative Research 2005-04. Korea Maritime Institute, Seoul, pp 129–195
Gubbay S (2005) A review of marine aggregate extraction in England and Wales, 1970–2005. The Crown Estate, London
Hampton S, Zafonte M (2004) Discounting and uncertainty in natural resource damage assessments. Poster. Fourth SETAC World Congress, November 14–18, Portland, OR
Han KN, Park SH (2002) Eggs and larvae. In: A study on environmental impact of marine sand mining in Gyeonggi Province Bay and assessment of quantity of resources. Korea Aggregates Association, Inchon, Korea, pp 207–312
Hanson CH, Coil J, Keller B, Johnson J, Taplin J, Monroe J (2004) Assessment & evaluation of the effects of sand mining on aquatic habitat and fishery populations of central San Francisco Bay and the Sacramento—San Joaquin Estuary. Hanson Environmental, Inc., Walnut Creek, CA
Im Y, Hwang S (2002) Age and growth of Sebastes schlegeli in Western Coastal Waters of Korea. Korean Journal of Ichthyology 14(2):143–152
Kenny AJ, Rees HL (1996) The effects of marine gravel extraction on the macrobenthos: results 2 years post-dredging. Marine Pollution Bulletin 32(8/9):615–622
Kenny AJ, Rees HL, Greening J, Campbell S (1998) The effects of gravel extraction on the macrobenthos at an experimental dredge site off north Norfolk, UK. Results 3 years postdredging. ICES CM 14:1–8
Kim CS, Lim H-S (2008) Sediment dispersal and deposition due to sand mining in the coastal waters of Korea. Continental Shelf Research (doi:10.1016/j.csr.2008.01.017)
Kim T-g, Grigalunas TA, Han K-N (2008) The economic costs to fisheries because of marine sand mining in Ongjin, Korea: concepts, methods and illustrative results. Ecological Economics 65(3):498–507
Korea Aggregates Association (2002) A study on environmental impact of marine sand mining in Gyeonggi Province Bay and assessment of quantity of resources. Korea Aggregates Association, Inchon, Korea, 585 pp
Lindeman KC (1997) Comparative management of beach systems of Florida and the Antilles: applications using ecological assessment and decision support procedures In: Cambers G (ed) Managing beach resources in the smaller Caribbean Islands. UNESCO Coastal Region and Small Island Papers 1, pp 134–164
Marine Mineral Services (MMS) (2006) Guidelines for obtaining sand, gravel, and other non-energy mineral resources from the federal outer continental shelf, OCS Report MMS 2006-042, U.S. Department of the Interior
Ministry of Land, Transportation, and Marine Affairs. Available at: http://www.mltm.go.kr
MOMAF (2006) Environmental impact study for undersea sand mining in coastal/shelf waters (II). Technical Report, p 950
Nairn R, Johnson JA, Hardin D, Michel J (2004) A biological and physical monitoring program to evaluate long-term impacts from sand dredging operations in the United States outer continental shelf. Journal of Coastal Research 20(1):126–137
National Fisheries Research and Development Institute (2000) The ecology and fishing grounds of main fisheries resource in Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Busan, Korea, 317 pp
National Fisheries Research and Development Institute (2004) Stock assessment and fishery evaluation report of year 2005 TAC-based fisheries management in the adjacent Korean waters. National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Busan, Korea
Newell RC, Seiderer LJ, Simpson NM, Robinson JE (2004) Impacts of marine aggregate dredging on benthic macrofauna off the south coast of the United Kingdom. Journal of Coastal Research 20(1):115–125
Ongjin Fisheries Cooperative (2000–2005) Statistical data of market price in Ongiin Fisheries Cooperative
Ricker WE (1975) Computation and interpretation of biological statistics of fisheries populations. Bulletin of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada 191:382
Shin D-H, Kum B-C, Lee H-I, Chang S (2008) Monitoring for the geomorphic chang by marine sand mining in the Gyunggi Bay. Proceedings of the fall meeting. Journal of the Korean Society of Oceanography 1(1):316–319
Son KH, Han KN (2007) The fluctuation of biological communities as an effect of marine sand mining in Gyeonggi Bay. Ocean and Polar Research 29(3):205–216
U.S. Department of the Interior, Minerals Management Service. Available at [http://www.mms.gov/sandandgravel]
Wilber DH, Clark DG (2001) Biological effects of suspended sediments: a review of suspended sediment impacts on fish and shellfish with relation to dredging activities in estuaries. North American Journal of Fisheries Management 21:855–875
Yu OH, Lee H-G, Lee J-H, Kim D-S (2006) Impacts of sand mining on the macrobenthic community in Gyeonggi Bay, Korea. Ocean and Polar Research 28(2):129–144
Acknowledgments
This research was supported by a grant from the Korea Maritime Institute, Korea-America Joint Research Program at the University of Rhode Island. We thank Hak-Bong Chang, Dong-Oh Cho, Suk-Jae Kwon, and James Opaluch for valuable comment and fruitful discussions.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
An erratum to this article can be found at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00267-009-9367-8
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kim, Tg., Grigalunas, T. Simulating Direct and Indirect Damages to Commercial Fisheries from Marine Sand Mining: A Case Study in Korea. Environmental Management 44, 566–578 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-009-9339-z
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-009-9339-z