Abstract
To assist risk assessors at the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site (SRS), a Geographic Information System (GIS) application was developed to provide relevant information about specific receptor species of resident wildlife that can be used for ecological risk assessment. Information was obtained from an extensive literature review of publications and reports on vertebrate- and contaminant-related research since 1954 and linked to a GIS. Although this GIS is a useful tool for risk assessors because the data quality is high, it does not describe the species’ site-wide spatial distribution or life history, which may be crucial when developing a risk assessment. Specific receptor species on the SRS were modeled to provide an estimate of an overall distribution (probability of being in an area). Each model is a stand-alone tool consisting of algorithms independent of the GIS data layers to which it is applied and therefore is dynamic and will respond to changes such as habitat disturbances and natural succession. This paper describes this modeling process and demonstrates how these resource selection models can then be used to produce spatially explicit exposure estimates. This approach is a template for other large federal facilities to establish a framework for site-specific risk assessments that use wildlife species as endpoints.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
C. D. Apps B. N. McLellen T. A. Kinley J. P. Flaa (2001) ArticleTitleScale-dependent habitat selection by mountain caribou, Columbia mountains, British Columbia Journal of Wildlife Management 65 65–77
M. L. Arbogast (1999) The use of raccoons as bioindicators of radiocesium contamination Thesis, Rutgers University Piscataway, NJ
F. C. Bellrose K. L. Johnson T. U. Meyers (1964) ArticleTitleRelative value of natural cavities and nesting houses for wood ducks Journal of Wildlife Management 28 661–676
L. J. Blus C. J. Henny D. J. Hoffman R. A. Grove (1993) ArticleTitleAccumulation and effects of lead and cadmium on wood ducks near a mining and smelting complex in Idaho Ecotoxicology 2 139–154 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00119436
C. S. Boring (2001) The interactions of home-range, habitat preference and contaminant burdens in relation to ecological risk for raccoon populations living near the borders of the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site MS Thesis, Rutgers University Piscataway, NJ 84 pp.
J. Cairns Jr (1993) ArticleTitleWill there ever be a field of landscape toxicology Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 12 609–610
J. Cairns Jr B. R. Niederlehner (1996) ArticleTitleDeveloping a field of landscape ecotoxicology Ecological Applications 6 790–796
G. N. Cameron S. R. Spencer (1981) ArticleTitle Sigmodon hispidus. Mammalian Species 158 1–9
Y. H. Chou (1997) Exploring spatial analysis in geographic information systems. 5th edition OnWord Press Albany, NY
D. R. Clark SuffixJr P. A. Ogasawara G. J. Smith H. M. Ohlendorf (1989) ArticleTitleSelenium accumulation by raccoons exposed to irrigation drainwater at Kesterson National Wildlife Refuge, California, 1986 Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 18 787–794 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF01160292 Occurrence Handle2619319
Corsi, F. J. DeLeeuw, and A. Skidmore. 2000. Modeling Species Distribution with GIS. Pages 389–434 in L. Boitani and T. K. Fuller (eds.), Research techniques in animal ecology: Controversies and consequences. Columbia University Press, New York, NY.
G. R. Costanzo T. T. Fendley J. R. Sweeney (1983) ArticleTitleWinter movements and habitat use by wood ducks in South Carolina Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Southeastern Association of Fish Wildlife Agencies 37 67–78
C. E. Davis L. L. Janecek (1997) DOE research set-aside areas of the Savannah River Site. Publication SRO-NERP-25 Savannah River Ecology Laboratory Aiken, South Carolina
D. L. DeAngelis L. J. Gross M. A. Huston W. F. Wolff D. M. Flemming E. J. Comiskey S. M. Sylvester (1998) ArticleTitleLandscape modeling for everglades ecosystem restoration Ecosystems 1 64–75 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s100219900006
R. D. Drobney L. H. Fredrickson (1979) ArticleTitleFood selection by wood ducks in relation to breeding status Journal of Wildlife Management 43 109–120
Elkie, P., R. Rempel, and A. Carr. 1999. Patch analyst user’s manual. Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, Northwest Science and Technology, Thunder Bay, Ontario. TM-002. 16 pp + Appendices.
K. F. Gaines D. Karapatakis G. R. Wein (1999) Wildlife survey for ecological risk assessment activities on the SRS. CD-ROM SREL-59, UC-66-e Savannah River Ecology Laboratory Aiken, SC
K. F. Gaines C. G. Lord C. S. Boring I. L. Brisbin Jr M. Gochfeld J. Burger (2000b) ArticleTitleRaccoons as potential vectors of radionuclide contamination to human food chains from a nuclear industrial site Journal of Wildlife Management 64 199–208
Gaines, K. F., H. Wiggins-Brown, D. J. Karapatakis, G. R. Wein, and I. L. Brisbin Jr. 2000a. Enhancement of the Wildlife Survey GIS Database. Final report to Westinghouse Savannah River Company—Environmental restoration.
Gaines, K. F. 2001. Spatial modeling of the raccoon (Procyon lotor) for ecological risk assessment activities at the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site. CD ROM SREL-62, UC-66e. Savannah River Ecology Laboratory, Aikena South Carolina.
K. F. Gaines (2002) A spatially explicit model of the Wild Hog (Sus scrofa) for ecological risk assessment activities at the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site. CD ROM SREL-68, UC-66e Savannah River Ecology Laboratory Aiken, South Carolina
K. F. Gaines (2003) Spatial modeling of receptor species for ecological risk assessment activities on the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site. Ph.D. Dissertation University of South Carolina Columbia, South Carolina 146 pp
Gaines, K. F., and A. L. Bryan Jr. 2003. A spatially explicit model for wading birds for ecological risk assessment activities at the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site. CD ROM SREL-69, UC-66e. Savannah River Ecology Laboratory, Aiken, South Carolina.
Gardner, R. H. Jr. 1975. Movement and distribution of confined and freely growing populations of cotton rats (Sigmodon hispidus). Ph.D. thesis, North Carolina State, Raleigh, NC, 71 pp.
S. D. Gehrt E. K. Fritzell (1998) ArticleTitleResource distribution, female home range dispersion and male spatial interactions: Group structure in a solitary carnivore Animal Behaviour 55 1211–1227 Occurrence Handle10.1006/anbe.1997.0657 Occurrence Handle9632506
T. F. Glueck W. R. Clark R. D. Andrews (1988) ArticleTitleRaccoon movement and habitat use during the fur harvest season Wildlife Society Bulletin 16 6–11
Golley, F. B., J. B. Gentry, L. D. Caldwell and L. B. Davenport, Jr. 1965. Number and variety of small mammals on the AEC Savannah River Plant. J Mammal 46:1–18.
R. L. Graham C. T. Hunsaker R. V. O’Neill B. L. Jackson (1991) ArticleTitleEcological risk assessment at the regional scale Ecological Applications 1 196–206
P. J. Heglund (2002) Foundations of species-environmental relations. Pages 000–000 J. M. Scott P. J. Heglund M. L. Morrison J. B. Haufler M. G. Raphael W. A. Wall F. B. Samson (Eds) Predicting species occurrences: Issues of accuracy and scale Island Press Washington, D.C, Chapter 1 35–41
G. R. Hepp R. A. Kennamer (1992) ArticleTitleCharacteristics and consequences of nest-site fidelity in wood ducks Auk 109 812–818
C. O. Hoffmann J. L. Gottschang (1977) ArticleTitleNumbers, distribution, and movements of a raccoon population in a suburban residential community Journal of Mammalogy 58 623–636
C. R. Hunsaker R. L. Graham G. W. Suter II R. V. O’Neill L. W. Barnthouse R. H. Gardner (1990) ArticleTitleAssessing ecological risk on a regional scale Environmental Management 14 325–332
T. W. Hughs (1985) Home range, habitat utilization, and pig survival of feral swine on the Savannah River Plant. M.S. Thesis Clemson University Clemson, South Carolina
M. E. Jensen P. S. Bourgerson (2001) A guidebook for integrated ecological assessments Springer-Verlag New York, NY
C. A. Johnston R. J. Naiman (1987) ArticleTitleBoundary dynamics at the terrestrial-aquatic interface: The influence of beaver and geomorphology Landscape Ecology 1 47–57
R. J. Kendall P. N. Smith (2003) ArticleTitleWildlife toxicology revisited Environmental Science and Technology 37 179–18 Occurrence Handle10.1021/es020621n
Kennamer, R. A., and K. F. Gaines. 2002. Habitat specific models of wood duck nest box use for the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site. Final report to Westinghouse Savannah River Company—Environmental Restoration.
R. A. Kennamer G. R. Hepp (2000) ArticleTitleIntegration of research with long-term monitoring: Breeding wood ducks on the Savannah River Site Studies in Avian Biology 21 39–49
A. T. Khan S. J. Thompson H. W. Mielke (1995) ArticleTitleLead and mercury levels in raccoons from Macon County, Alabama Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 54 812–816 Occurrence Handle7647494
J. C. Kurz R. L. Marchinton (1972) ArticleTitleRadiotelemetry studies of feral hogs in South Carolina Journal of Wildlife Management 36 1240–1248
J. A. Kushlan (1978) Feeding ecology of wading birds. Pages 249–297 A. Sprint IV J. C. Ogden S. Winckler (Eds) Wading Birds National Audubon Society Research report no. 7 New York, NY
J. A. Kushlan (1993) ArticleTitleColonial waterbirds as bioindicators of environmental change Colonial Waterbirds 16 223–251
Looney, B. B., C. A. Eddy, M. Ramdeen, J. Pickett, V. A. Rogers, P. A. Shirley, and M. T. Scott. 1990. Geochemical and physical properties of soils and shallow sediments at the Savannah River Site. Westinghouse Savannah River Company Publication WSRC-RP-90-0464, Aiken, South Carolina.
J. Lotze S. Anderson (1979) ArticleTitle Procyon lotor. Mammalian Species 119 1–8
B. F. J. Manly (1998) Randomization, bootstrap and Monte Carlo methods in biology—2nd edition Chapman & Hall London
B. F. J. Manly L. L. McDonald D. L. Thomas (1993) Resource selection by animals: Statistical design and analysis for field studies Chapman & Hall New York, New York
K. McGairal B. Marks (1993) FRAGSTATS: Spatial pattern analysis program for quantifying landscape structure. Forest Science Department Oregon State University Corvallis, Oregon
J. W. Mietelski P. Gaca M. Jasinska (2000) ArticleTitlePlutonium and other alpha-emitters in bones of wild, herbivorous animals from north-eastern Poland Applied Radiation and Isotopes 53 251–257 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0969-8043(00)00140-8 Occurrence Handle10879870
D. J. Mladenoff T. A. Sickley R. G. Haight A. D. Wydeven (1995) ArticleTitleA regional landscape analysis and prediction of favorable Gray Wolf habitat in the Northern Great Lakes region Conservation Biology 9 279–294 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1523-1739.1995.9020279.x
J. Neter W. Wasserman M. H. Kutner (1990) Applied linear statistical models: Regression analysis of variance, and experimental design—3rd edition Richard D. Irwin Inc Homewood, Illinois 1181 pp.
M. C. Newman C.L.(eds.). Strojan (1998) Risk assessment: Logic and measurements Ann Arbor Press Chelsea, Michigan 352 pp.
Novak, J. M., Peles J. D, and K. F. Gaines. 2002. A spatially explicit model for the cotton rat (Sigmodon hispidus) habitat preference on the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site. CD ROM SREL-62, UC-66e. Savannah River Ecology Laboratory.
R. V. O’Neill J. R. Krummel R. H. Gardner G. Sugihara B. Jackson D. L. DeAngelis B. T. Milne M. G. Turner B. Zygmunt S. W. Christionsen V. H. Dale R. L. Graham (1988) ArticleTitleIndices of landscape pattern Landscape Ecology 1 153–162 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00162741
Pinder, J. E. III, K. K. Guy, T. E. Rae, and D. J. Karapatakis. 1998. Development of a 1997 habitat map for the Savannah River Site; Final report to Westinghouse Savannah River Company.
T. Punshon K. F. Gaines R. A. Jenkins Jr (2003) ArticleTitleBioavailability and trophic transfer of sediment bound Ni and U in a Southeastern wetland system Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 44 30–35 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s00244-002-1213-4 Occurrence Handle12434216
B. D. Reinhart (2003) The use of small mammals as indicators of heavy metal bioavailability in a contaminated riparian zone. M. S. Thesis University of Georgia Athens, Georgia 50 pp.
T. E. Ross (1987) ArticleTitleA comprehensive bibliography of the Carolina bays literature Journal of Elisha Mitchell Scientific Society 103 28–42
Sample, B. E., and Suter, G. W. II. 1994. Estimating exposure of terrestrial wildlife to contaminants. Environmental Science Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee. ES/ER/TM-125.
D. Santiago M. Motas-Guzman A. Reja P. Maria-Mojica B. Rodero A. J. Garcia-Fernandez (1998) ArticleTitleLead and cadmium in red deer and wild boar from Sierra. Morena Mountains (Andalusia, Spain) Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 61 730–737 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s001289900822 Occurrence Handle9871001
J. W. Snodgrass (1996) The influence of beaver ponds on the temporal and spatial dynamics of southeastern stream fish assemblages. Ph.D. Dissertation University of Georgia Athens, Georgia 165 pp.
Snodgrass, J. W., Jakes A., Gaines K. F., and J. Burger. 2002. Spatial explicit model of beaver habitat preference in SRS streams. CD ROM SREL-63, UC-66e. Savannah River Ecology Laboratory.
H. L. Stribling I. L. Brisbin Jr J. R. Sweeney (1986) ArticleTitleRadiocesium concentrations in two populations of feral hogs Health Physics 50 852–854 Occurrence Handle3710796
G. W. Suter II (1990) ArticleTitleEnd points for regional ecological risk assessment Environmental Management 14 9–23
F. B. Taub (1989) ArticleTitleStandardized aquatic microcosms Environmental Science and Technology 23 1064–1066 Occurrence Handle10.1021/es00067a601
L. Tichendorf (2001) ArticleTitleCan landscape indices predict ecological processes consistently Landscape Ecology 16 235–254 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1011112719782
J. C. Trexler J. Travis (1993) ArticleTitleNontraditional regression analyses Ecology 74 1629–1637
M. G. Turner R. H.(eds.) Gardner (1990) Quantitative methods in landscape ecology Springer-Verlag New York, New York 536 pp.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 1993. Wildlife exposure factors handbook volumes I and II. EPA/600/R-93/187, Washington, DC.
U. S. Environmental Protection Agency. 1997. Ecological risk assessment guidance for superfund: Process for designing and conducting ecological risk assessments. EPA/630/R-021011, Washington, DC.
USFWS. 1981. Standards for the development of habitat suitability index models. Ecological service manual 103 ESM, release number 1-81. U.S. Department of the Interior, Fish and Wildlife Service, Division of Ecological Services, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.
K. Vermeer J. A. J. Thompson (1992) ArticleTitleArsenic and copper residues in waterbirds and their food down inlet from the Island Copper Mill Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 48 733–738 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00195995 Occurrence Handle1504519
S. Walker M. Sunquist (1997) ArticleTitleMovement and spatial organization of raccoons in north-central Florida Florida Field Naturalist 25 11–21
W. D. Webster J. F. Parnell W. C. Biggs Jr (1985) Mammals of the Carolinas, Virginia and Maryland University of North Carolina Press Chape Hill, North Carolina
White, D. L., and K. F. Gaines. 2000. The Savannah River Site: Site description, land use and management history. Pages 8–17 in J. B. Dunning and J. C. Kilgo (eds.). Avian studies at the Savannah River Site: A model for integrating basic research and long- term management. Studies in avian biology 21. Cooper Ornithological Society, Camarillo, CA, USA
T. D. Williams E. G. Cooch R. L. Jefferies F. Cooke (1993) ArticleTitleEnvironmental degradation, food limitation and reproductive output: Juvenile survival in lesser snow geese Journal of Animal Ecology 62 766–777
Acknowledgments
This project was funded through the Financial Assistance Award DE-FC09-96SR18546 from the U.S. Department of Energy to the University of Georgia Research Foundation. We thank T. G. Chandler, H. N. McKellar, and M. E. Hodgson for reviewing earlier versions of the manuscript for this paper. We also thank J. M. Novak, J. Snodgrass, A. L. Bryan, Jr., R. A. Kennamer, and D. J. Karapatakis, for their contributions to the receptor species model development.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Current address: Biology Department, University of South Dakota, Vermillion, SD 57069
Appendix:
Appendix:
Receptor species list compiled for use in ecological risk assessment activities on the Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site (SRS) that use wildlife as endpoints using EPA criteria (USEPA 1997)a
I. Birds (21 species) | |
Common Name | Scientific Name |
American Coot | Fulica americana |
American Crow | Corvus brachyrhynchos |
Anhinga | Anhinga anhinga |
Bachman’s Sparrow | Aimophila aestivalis |
Bald Eagle | Haliaeetus leucocephalus |
Barn Swallow | Hirundo rustica |
Black Vulture | Coragyps atratus |
Eastern Bluebird | Sialia sialis |
Eastern Screech Owl | Otus asio |
Great Blue Heron | Ardea herodias |
Kingfisher | Megaceryle alcyon |
Mallard Duck | Anas platyrynchos |
Mourning Dove | Zenaida macroura |
Northern Mockingbird | Mimus polyglottos |
Pied-billed Grebe | Podilymbus podiceps |
Red-cockaded Woodpecker | Picoides borealis |
Red-tailed Hawk | Buteo jamaicensis |
Ring-necked Duck | Aythya collaris |
Wild Turkey | Meleagris gallopavo |
Wood Duck | Aix sponsa |
Wood Stork | Mycteria americana |
II. Mammals (17 species) | |
Common Name | Scientific Name |
Beaver | Castor canadensis |
Bobcat | Felis rufus |
Cotton Mouse | Peromyscus gossypinus |
Cotton Rat | Sigmodon hispidus |
Eastern Cottontail | Sylvilagus floridanus |
Eastern Coyote | Canis latrans |
Eastern Mole | Scalopus aquaticus |
Feral Hog | Sus scrofa |
Gray Fox | Urocyon cinereoargenteus |
Gray Squirrel | Sciurus carolinensis |
Mink | Mustela vison |
Raccoon | Procyon lotor |
Seminole Bat | Lasiurus seminolis |
Southern Flying Squirrel | Glaucomys volans |
Southern Short-tailed Shrew | Blarina carolinensis |
Virginia Opossum | Didelphis virginiana |
White-tailed Deer | Odocoileus virginianus |
III. Reptiles and amphibians (16 species) | |
Common Name | Scientific Name |
American Alligator | Alligator mississippiensis |
Brown Water Snake | Nerodia taxispilota |
Bullfrog | Rana catesbeiana |
Common Snapping Turtle | Chelydra serpentina |
Eastern Box Turtle | Terrapene carolina |
Eastern Mud Turtle | Kinosternon subrubrum |
Gray Rat Snake | Elaphe obsoleta |
Green Anole | Anolis carolinensis |
Green Treefrog | Hyla cinerea |
Ground Skink | Scincella laterale |
Leopard Frog | Rana utricularia |
Marbled Salamander | Ambystoma opacum |
Mole Salamander | Ambystoma talpoideum |
Mudpuppy | Necturus maculosus |
Southern Toad | Bufo terrestris |
Yellow-bellied Slider | Trachemys scripta |
IV. Fish (16 species) | |
Common Name | Scientific Name |
Bluegill | Lepomis macrochirus |
Bluehead Chub | Nocomis leptocephalus |
Channel Catfish | Ictalurus punctatus |
Dusky Shiner | Notropis cummingsae |
Eastern Mosquitofish | Gambusia holbrooki |
Gizzard Shad | Dorosoma cepedianum |
Lake Chubsucker | Erimyzon sucetta |
Largemouth Bass | Micropterus salmoides |
Redbreast Sunfish | Lepomis auritus |
Sailfin Shiner | Pteronotropis hypselopterus |
Shortnose Sturgeon | Acipenser brevirostrum |
Spotted Sucker | Minytrema melanops |
Tadpole Madtom | Noturus gyrinus |
Tessellated Darter | Etheostoma olmstedi |
Yellow Bullhead | Ameiurus natalis |
Yellowfin Shiner | Notropis lutipinnis |
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gaines, K., Porter, D., Dyer, S. et al. Using Wildlife as Receptor Species: A Landscape Approach to Ecological Risk Assessment. Environmental Management 34, 528–545 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-004-0261-0
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-004-0261-0