Abstract
The snowmobile controversy in Yellowstone National Park not only pits snowmobilers against environmentalists, but it also pits the Bush Administration against the Clinton Administration. Caught in the middle are the National Park Service, scores of natural and social scientists, and Yellowstone’s permanent residents—the flora and fauna. The controversy’s political aspects are the focus of this paper; specifically, the tenuous relationship among research scientists, whose job it is to inform management and policy decisions; politicians, whose job it is to formulate those same decisions in the public arena; and public land management agencies, whose job it is to implement the decisions. The crux of the paper concerns the politicization of natural resource policy and ways in which research scientists tend to get caught up in it. Lessons learned from this Yellowstone episode regarding the role of science in policy-making processes are also considered. Two recent federal court rulings shed additional light on the politics surrounding Yellowstone’s snowmobile controversy, as does the importance of governmental checks and balances in resolving natural resource management disputes.
Similar content being viewed by others
Literature Cited
G. Bishop J. Morris D. Stedman (2001) ArticleTitleSnowmobile contributions to mobile source emissions in Yellowstone National Park Environmental Science Technology 14 2874–2881 Occurrence Handle10.1021/es010513l
Bohlen, C. 1973. Letter to Senator Robert F. Griffin, November 27
Brussard, P. 2001. Letter from 18 prominent scientists to Interior Secretary Gale Norton asking President Bush to phase out snowmobiles from Yellowstone National Park, October 17
Caslick, J. 1997. Impacts of winter recreation on wildlife in Yellowstone National Park: a literature review and recommendations. Yellowstone National Park Branches of Planning and Compliance, Natural Resources, and Resource Management and Visitor Protection
S. Creel J. Fox A. Hardy J. Sands B. Garrott R. Peterson (2002) ArticleTitleSnowmobile activity and glucocorticoid stress response in wolves and elk Conservation Biology 3 809–814 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1523-1739.2002.00554.x
J. Crompton (2002) ArticleTitleThe rest of the story Journal of Leisure Research 1 93–102
Daily, J. 2001. Over-snow vehicle sound level measurements. Technical Report by Jackson Hole Scientific Investigations, Inc.: Jackson, Wyoming. For the state of Wyoming
B. Driver (2002) ArticleTitleReality testing Journal of Leisure Research 1 79–88
D. Dustin (2002) ArticleTitleOne Dog or Another: Tugging at the Strands of Social Science Journal of Leisure Research 1 89–92
ENS. 2002. http://www.mindfully.org/Heritage/Bush-Snowmobile-Yosemite13nov02.htm
B. Flyvbjerg (2001) Making social science matter: Why social inquiry has failed and how it can succeed again Cambridge University Press New York 204 Occurrence Handle10.1017/CBO9780511810503
M. Frome (1992) Crashing through the snow Regreening the National Parks The University of Arizona Press Tucson, Arizona 197–202
L. Fussell (1997) ArticleTitleExposure of snowmobile riders to carbon monoxide. Emissions pose potential risk Park Science 1 8–9
K. Himlot 2003 America’s ten most endangered national parks National Parks March/April: 24 37
International Snowmobile Manufacturers Association. 2002. Facts and statistics about snowmobiling, May
Jewett, T. 2003. Yellowstone named to list of endangered parks. NPCA Press Release, January 14
Kado, N., P. Kuzmicky, and R. Okamoto. 2001. Environmental and occupational exposure to toxic air pollutants from winter snowmobile use in Yellowstone National Park. Dept. of Environmental Toxicology, University of California, Davis. Prepared for the Yellowstone Park Foundation, Pew Charitable Trust, and National Park Service
Linn, R. 1969. Letter to John Craighead, October 13
Littlejohn, M. 1996. Yellowstone National Park Visitor Study. University of Idaho, Cooperative Park Studies Unit. Report 75
L. McAvoy D. Dustin J. Rankin A. Frakt (1985) ArticleTitleWilderness and legal liability: Guidelines for resource managers and program leaders Journal of Park and Recreation Administration 1 41–49
J. Meyer (1996) The spirit of Yellowstone: the cultural evolution of a national park Rowman & Littlefield Publishers Lanham, MD 154
T. More (2002a) ArticleTitle‘ The parks are being loved to death’ and other frauds and deceits in recreation management Journal of Leisure Research 1 52–78
T. More (2002b) ArticleTitleThe marginal user as the justification for public recreation: A rejoinder to Crompton, Driver and Dustin Journal of Leisure Research 1 103–118
C. Mukerji (1989) A Fragile Power: Scientists and the State The Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ 253
D. Peacock (1999) ArticleTitleThe Yellowstone massacre Audubon 3 42
J. Pritchard (1999) Preserving Yellowstone’s Natural Conditions University of Nebraska Press Lincoln, NE 370
Ring, R. 2002. Move over! High Country News, April 1
Royster, W. 2002. 81 percent back ‘bile ban. Jackson Hole News & Guide, June 19
P. Schullery (1997) Searching for Yellowstone: Ecology and wonder in the last wilderness Houghton Mifflin Company Boston, MA 338
Seelye, K. 2003. Report concludes snowmobile ban is best for parks. New York Times, January 30
R. Sellars (1997) Preserving Nature in the National Parks Yale University Press New Haven, CT 380
D. Stynes G. Peterson (1996) Adapting manage ment frameworks to better account for hard-to-define values of public lands B. Driver D. Dustin T. Baltic G. Elsner G. Peterson (Eds) Nature and the Human Spirit: Toward an Expanded Land Management Ethic Venture Publishing Inc., State College Pennsylvania 279–289
U.S. Department of Interior, National Park Service. 2000. Air quality concerns related to snowmobile usage in national parks. U.S. Dept. of Interior and National Park Service, Air Resource Division. Federal Register, vol. 66, no. 194
Winter Visitor Use Management Overview. 1995. Unpublished Paper in “VUM Speech” File, Planning Office Files (POF), Yellowstone National Park, January
M. Yochim 1999 The development of snowmobile policy in Yellowstone National Park Yellowstone Science Spring 2 10
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dustin, D.L., Schneider, I.E. The Science of Politics/The Politics of Science: Examining the Snowmobile Controversy in Yellowstone National Park. Environmental Management 34, 761–767 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-004-0082-1
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-004-0082-1