Abstract
Current streambank restoration efforts focus on providing bank stability, enhancing water quality, and improving woody habitat using native vegetation rather than traditional engineering techniques. However, in most cases harsh site conditions limit restoration success. A two-year field study was conducted at Twentymile Creek, in northern Mississippi, investigating edaphic factors governing the survival of black willow (Salix nigra) cuttings used for streambank restoration. Low height growth, above-ground biomass production, and average leaf area were observed in willow cuttings grown in plots subjected to moisture deficits. However, sediment texture emerged as the dominant factor determining willow post growth, health, and survival. Shoot biomass, leaf biomass, and total above-ground biomass were 15-, 10-, and 14-fold greater for large willow cuttings (posts) grown in plots with sandy sediments relative to those grown in plots with similar moisture and soil redox potential but with silt and clay sediments. Average leaf size, average leaf mass and specific leaf area were all lower in fine textured plots. Under moisture conditions present at our sites, coarse-grained sediment (sand) was more conducive to willow growth, biomass production, and survival than were fine-grained sediments (silt/clay). Our results strongly suggest that soil texture and moisture conditions can determine restoration success. Therefore, it is critical that site conditions are factored into the selection of project locations prior to the initiation of willow planting restoration projects.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
N. M. Amlin S. B. Rood (2002) ArticleTitleComparative tolerances of riparian willows and cottonwoods to water-table decline. Wetlands 22 338–346
W. Armstrong S. H. F. W. Justin P. M. Beckett S. Lythe (1991) ArticleTitleRoot adaptation to soil waterlogging. Aquatic Botany 39 57–73 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0304-3770(91)90022-W
A. Cerdà (1999) ArticleTitleParent material and vegetation affect soil erosion in eastern Spain. Soil Science Society of America Journal 63 362–368
T. S. S. Conlin R. van den Driessche (1996) ArticleTitleShort term effects of soil compaction on growth of Pinus contorta seedlings. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 26 727–739
I. G. W. Corns (1988) ArticleTitleCompaction by forestry equipment and effects on coniferous seedling growth on four soils in the Alberta foothills. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 18 75–84
R. B. Daniels J. W. Gilliam (1996) ArticleTitleSediment and chemical load reduction by grass and riparian filters. Soil Science Society of America Journal 60 246–251 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaK28Xns1Srug%3D%3D
C. P. Dionigi I. A. Mendelssohn V. I. Sullivan (1985) ArticleTitleEffects of soil waterlogging on the energy status and distribution of Salix nigra and S. exigua (Salicaceae) in the Atchafalaya River Basin of Louisiana. American Journal of Botany 72 109–119
L. A. Donovan K. W. McLeod K. C. Sherrod Jr. N. J. Stumpff (1988) ArticleTitleResponse of woody swamp seedlings to flooding and increased water temperatures. I. Growth, biomass, and survivorship. American Journal of Botany 75 1181–1190
M. C. Garber (1973) Soil Survey of Lee County, Mississippi U S Department of Agriculture Soil Conservation Service, U S Government Printing Office Washington, DC
E. H. Grissinger A. J. Bowie (1984) ArticleTitleMaterial and site controls of stream bank vegetation. Transactions, American Society of Agricultural Engineers 27 1829–1835
E. A. Hansen H. M. Phipps (1983) ArticleTitleEffect of soil moisture tension and preplant treatments on early growth of hybrid Populus hardwood cuttings. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 13 458–464
B. E. Hassig (1986) Metabolic processes in adventitious rooting of cuttings. M. B. Jackson (Eds) New root formation in plants and cuttings Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht 141–189
D. D. Hook (1984) ArticleTitleWaterlogging tolerance of lowland tree species of the south. Southern Journal of Applied Forestry 8 136–149
J. L. Horton J. L. Clark (2001) ArticleTitleWater table decline alters growth and survival of Salix gooddingii and Tamarix chinensis seedlings. Forest Ecology and Management 140 239–247 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0378-1127(00)00314-5
F. M. R. Hughes N. Barsoum K. S. Richards M. Winfield A. Hayes (2000) ArticleTitleThe response of male and female black poplar (Populus nigra L. subspecies betulifolia (Pursh) W. Wettst,) cuttings to different water table depths and sediment types: implications for flow management and river corridor biodiversity. Hydrological Processes 14 3075–3098 Occurrence Handle10.1002/1099-1085(200011/12)14:16/17<3075::AID-HYP135>3.3.CO;2-C
C. R. Hupp (1992) ArticleTitleRiparian vegetation recovery patterns following stream channelization: a geomorphic perspective. Ecology 73 1209–1226
C. A. Jones (1983) ArticleTitleEffect of soil texture on critical bulk densities for root growth. Soil Science Society of America Journal 47 1208–1211
R. F. Keim S. H. Schoenholtz (1999) ArticleTitleFunctions and effectiveness of silvicultural streamside management zones in loessial bluff forests. Forest Ecology and Management 118 197–209 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0378-1127(98)00499-X
R. H. Kesel E. G. Yodis (1992) ArticleTitleSome effects of human modifications on sand-bed channels in southwestern Mississippi, USA. Environmental Geology and Water Science 20 93–104
D. Kleinfelder S. Swanson G. Norris W. Clary (1992) ArticleTitleUnconfined compressive strength of some streambank soils with herbaceous roots. Soil Science Society of America Journal 56 1920–1925
B. A. Kleiss (1996) ArticleTitleSediment retention in a bottomland hardwood wetland in eastern Arkansas. Wetlands 16 321–333
T. T. Kozlowski (1999) ArticleTitleSoil compaction and growth of woody plants. Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research 14 596–619 Occurrence Handle10.1080/02827589950154087
J. Kranjcec J. M. Mahoney S. B. Rood (1998) ArticleTitleThe responses of three riparian cottonwood species to water table decline. Forest Ecology and Management 110 77–87 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0378-1127(98)00276-X
W. C. Little C. R. Thorne J. B. Murphey (1982) ArticleTitleMass bank failure analysis of selected Yazoo Basin streams. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers 25 1321–1328
J. M. Mahoney S. B. Rood (1992) ArticleTitleResponse of a hybrid poplar to water table decline in different substrates. Forest Ecology and Management 54 141–156 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0378-1127(92)90009-X
K. W. McLeod L. A. Donovan N. J. Stumpff K. C. Sherrod (1986) ArticleTitleBiomass, photosynthesis and water use efficiency of woody swamp species subjected to flooding and elevated water temperature. Tree Physiology 2 341–346
D. R. Montgomery (1997) ArticleTitleWhat’s best on the banks? Nature 388 328–329 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaK2sXkvVertLg%3D
E. K. S. Nambiar R. Sands (1992) ArticleTitleEffects of compaction and simulated root channels in the subsoil on root development, water-uptake and growth of radiata pine. Tree Physiology 10 297–306
C. R. Neill (1987) Hydraulic design of stable flood control channels, Vol III, case studies of morphologic response Northwest Hydraulic Consultants Inc. Kent, Washington, and Edmonton, Alberta
K. Niiyama (1990) ArticleTitleThe role of seed dispersal and seedling traits in colonization and coexistence of Salix species in a seasonally flooded habitat. Ecological Research 5 317–331
A. J. Odgaard (1987) ArticleTitleStreambank erosion along two rivers in Iowa. Water Resources Research 23 1225–1236
M. Oplatka A. Sutherland (1995) ArticleTitleTests on willow poles used for river bank protection. New Zealand Journal of Hydrology 33 35–58
W. H. Patrick Jr. R. D. DeLaune (1977) ArticleTitleChemical and biological redox systems affecting nutrient availability in the coastal wetlands. Geoscience and Man 18 131–137
S. R. Pezeshki (1991) ArticleTitleRoot responses of flood-tolerant and flood-sensitive tree species to soil redox conditions. Trees 5 180–186
S. R. Pezeshki (2001) ArticleTitleWetland plant responses to soil flooding. Environmental and Experimental Botany 46 299–312 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0098-8472(01)00107-1
S. R. Pezeshki M. I. Santos (1998) ArticleTitleRelationships among rhizosphere oxygen deficiency, root restriction, photosynthesis, and growth in bald cypress (Taxodium distichum L.) seedlings. Photosynthetica 35 381–390 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1006912318352
S. R. Pezeshki P. H. Anderson F. D. Shields Jr. (1998a) ArticleTitleEffects of soil moisture regimes on growth and survival of black willow (Salix nigra) posts (cuttings). Wetlands 18 460–470
S. R. Pezeshki F. D. Shields Jr. P. H. Anderson (1998b) ArticleTitleThe relationships between soil conditions and growth of willow posts on streambanks. Water Resources Engineering 1 447–452
H. M. Phipps E. A. Hansen A. S. Fege (1983) Pre-plant soaking of dormant Populus hardwood cuttings. Res. Pap. NC-241 US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, North Central Forest Experiment Station St. Paul, Minnesota
W. H. Rein R. D. Wright J. R. Seiler (1991) ArticleTitlePropagation medium moisture level influences adventitious rooting of woody stem cuttings. Journal of the American Society of Horticultural Sciences 116 632–636
R. Sands E. L. Greacen C. J. Gerard (1979) ArticleTitleCompaction of sandy soils in radiata pine forests. I. A penetrometer study. Australian Journal of Soil Research 17 101–113
InstitutionalAuthorNameSAS (1990) Procedures guide EditionNumberversion 6, 3rd ed. SAS Institute, Inc. Cary, NC
M. L. Scott P. B. Shafroth G. T. Auble (1999) ArticleTitleResponses of riparian cottonwoods to alluvial water table declines. Environmental Management 23 347–358 Occurrence Handle9950697
C. A. Segelquist M. L. Scott G. T. Auble (1993) ArticleTitleEstablishment of Populus deltoides under simulated alluvial groundwater declines. American Midland Naturalist 130 274–285
F. D. Shields SuffixJr. J. J. Hoover (1991) ArticleTitleEffects of channel restabilization on habitat diversity, Twentymile Creek, Mississippi. Regulated Rivers: Research and Management 6 163–181
F. D. Shields SuffixJr. S. S. Knight C. M. Cooper (1995) Streambank protection and habitat restoration. W.H. Espy SuffixJr. P.G. Combs (Eds) Water resources engineering, proceedings of the first international conference on water resources engineering American Society of Civil Engineers New York 721–725
F. D. Shields SuffixJr. S. R. Pezeshki P. H. Anderson (1998) Probable causes for willow post mortality. D.F. Hayes (Eds) Engineering approaches to ecosystem restoration, proceedings of the 1998 wetlands engineering and river restoration conference American Society of Civil Engineers New York 157–162
A. Simon (1989) ArticleTitleA model of channel response in disturbed alluvial channels. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms 14 11–26
W. Stepniewski S. R. Pezeshki R. D. DeLaune J. W. H. Patrick (1991) ArticleTitleRoot studies under variable redox potential in soil or soil suspensions using laboratory rhizotrons. Vegetatio 94 47–55
D. M. Stone J. D. Elioff (1998) ArticleTitleSoil properties and aspen development five years after compaction and forest floor removal. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 78 51–58
J. C. Stromberg D. T. Patten B. D. Richter (1991) ArticleTitleFlood flows and dynamics of sonoran riparian forests. Rivers 2 221–235
R. J. Talbot J. R. Etherington J. A. Bryant (1987) ArticleTitleComparative studies of plant growth and distribution in relation to waterlogging. XII. Growth, photosynthetic capacity and metal ion uptake in Salix caprea and S. cinerea ssp. oleifolia. New Phytologist 105 563–574 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaL2sXktlKrtrk%3D
T. J. Tschaplinski T. J. Blake (1989) ArticleTitleCorrelation between early root production, carbohydrate metabolism, and subsequent biomass production in hybrid poplar. Canadian Journal of Botany 67 2168–2174 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaL1MXmtFais70%3D
C. L. Tuttle M. S. Golden R. S. Meldahl (1988) ArticleTitleSoil compaction effects on Pinus taeda establishment from seed and early growth. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 18 628–632
I. van Splunder H. Coops M. M. Schoor (1994) ArticleTitleTackling the bank erosion problem: reintroduction of willows on riverbanks. Water Science and Technology 29 379–381
I. van Splunder L. A. C. J. Voesenek H. Coops X. J. A. d. Vries C. W. P. M. Blom (1996) ArticleTitleMorphological responses of seedlings of four species of Salicaceae to drought. Canadian Journal of Botany 74 1988–1995
C. C. Watson D. Gessler S. R. Abt (1997) Inspection of selected bank stabilization sites. Internal report. U S Army Corps of Engineers Vicksburg, Mississippi
World Meteorlogical Organization. 1989. Calculation of monthly and annual 30-Year standard normals. WCDP No. 10, WMO-TD/No. 341, World Meteorlogical Organization, Geneva, Switzerland
Y. Zhou D. Watts Y. Li X. Cheng (1998) ArticleTitleA case study of effect of lateral roots of Pinus yunnanensis on shallow soil reinforcement. Forest Ecology and Management 103 107–120 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0378-1127(97)00216-8
Acknowledgements
This work was supported in part by a grant from the U S Department of Agriculture, National Sedimentation Laboratory, Cooperative Agreement #58-6408-6-029. Mention of trade names is for information purposes only and does not constitute endorsement. The authors would like to thank P. B. Rodrigue, R. E. Lizotte, Jr., S. Rood, and two anonymous reviewers for their comments on an earlier draft of this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schaff, S., Pezeshki, S. & Shields, F. Effects of Soil Conditions on Survival and Growth of Black Willow Cuttings . Environmental Management 31, 748–763 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-002-2909-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-002-2909-y