Abstract
In many species, outcomes of male duels determine access to females and, ultimately, male reproductive success. Ritualization of behavior in male contests can reduce the probability of injury, which benefits both contestants. Components of ritualized combat often include postures and displays that showcase a male’s quality in a sequential assessment of fighting ability. Among the most common contest acts in iguanine lizards are bobbing displays. Investigations of bobbing display dynamics often include experimental “playbacks,” in which video or robotic representations of conspecifics are presented to subjects. In most “playback” research, pre-programmed stimuli exhibit behavior that is independent of subjects’ responses, despite the fact that actual animal contests are highly interactive. In the present study, we utilized a robotic Galápagos lava lizard (Microlophus bivittatus) to investigate the importance of interaction in simulated contests under field conditions. Using a matched pairs design where each subject experienced two behavioral variants of the robotic stimulus, we tested the effect of a robot that displayed immediately following a subject’s display versus when the same robot display was postponed 30 s. Results showed that immediate response from the robot stimulated subjects to display significantly more often than when the stimulus was delayed. We speculate that subjects perceived a rapid response from their robotic contestant as being more aggressive than a delayed response. We discuss our results in light of relevant previous work, and we suggest possibilities for future research using interactive lizard robots.
Significance statement
Some of the most impressive examples of ritualized animal behavior can be observed in male contests for access to reproductive females. The use of stereotyped displays in such duels allows males to assess one another’s quality while avoiding dangerous fighting that can lead to injury. For example, males in many lizard species perform bobbing displays where contestants respond to each other in reciprocal fashion. In this study, we used a realistic lizard robot as a stand-in for a contestant in simulated contests. We found that an immediate display response by the robot to a subject’s bobbing display stimulated subjects to display significantly more often than when the robot’s response was delayed by 30 s. To our knowledge, this is the first interactive robot “playback” experiment with lizards. Future research will further explore the “rules” underlying display behavior in lizard contests.
Similar content being viewed by others
Data availability
The datasets generated and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
References
Andersson M (1994) Sexual Selection. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Arnott G, Elwood RW (2009) Assessment of fighting ability in animal contests. Anim Behav 77:991–1004
Batabyal A, Thaker M (2018) Lizards assess complex social signals by laterlizing colour but not motion detection. J Exp Biol 221:jeb173252
Benavides E, Baum R, Snell HM, Snell HL, Sites JW (2009) Island biogeography of the Galápagos lava lizards (Tropiduridae: Microlophus): species diversity and colonization of the archipelago. Evolution 63:1606–1626
Carpenter CC (1966) Comparative behavior of the Galápagos lava lizards (Tropidurus). In: Bowman RI (ed) The Galápagos: Proceedings of the Galápagos international scientific project. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp 269–273
Carpenter CC, Ferguson GW (1977) Variation and evolution of stereotyped behavior in reptiles. In: Ganz C, Tinkle DW (eds) Biology of the Reptilia, vol. 7. Ecology and behaviour. A. Academic Press, New York, pp 335–554
Clark DL, Macedonia JM, Rowe JW, Stuart MA, Kemp DJ, Ord TJ (2015) Evolution and discrimination of species-typical displays in Galápagos lava lizards: comparative analyses of signalers and robot playbacks to receivers. Anim Behav 109:33–34
Clark DL, Macedonia JM, Gillingham JC, Rowe JW, Kane HJ, Valle CA (2016) Why does conspecific display recognition differ among species of Galápagos lava lizards? A test using lizard robots. Herpetologica 72:47–54
Clark DL, Macedonia JM, Rowe JW, Kamp K, Valle CA (2017) Responses of Galápagos lava lizards (Microlophus bivittatus) to manipulation of female nuptial coloration on lizard robots. Herpetologica 73:323–330
Crews D (1975) Inter- and intraindividual variation in display patterns in the lizard Anolis carolinensis. Herpetologica 31:37–47
Dabelsteen T, McGregor PK, Holland J, Tobias JA, Boel Pedersen S (1997) The signal function of overlapping singing in male robins. Anim Behav 53:249–256
Darwin C (1871) The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex. Murray, London
Duke RA, Stammen D (2011) Scribe 4 (for observation and assessment). Learning & Behavior Resources, Austin, TX, https://cml.music.utexas.edu/online-resources/scribe-4/description/
Enquist M, Leimar O (1983) Evolution of fighting behavior: decision rules and assessment of relative strength. J Theor Biol 102:387–410
Evans CS (1991) Of ducklings and Turing machines: interactive playbacks enhance subsequent responsiveness to conspecific calls. Ethology 89:124–134
Frohnwieser A (2016) Using robots to understand animal cognition. J Exp Anal Behav 105:14–22
Fuxjager MJ, Montgomery JL, Becker EA, Marler CA (2010) Deciding to win: interactive effects of residency, resources and ‘boldness’ on contest outcome in white-footed mice. Anim Behav 80:921–927
Gillingham JC, Carmichael C, Miller T (1995) Social behavior of the tuatara, Sphenodon punctatus. Herpetol Monogr 9:5–16
Green PA, Patek SN (2018) Mutual assessment during ritualized fighting in mantis shrimp (Stomatopoda). Proc R Soc B 285:20172542
Greenberg N (1977) A neuroethological study of display behavior in the lizard Anolis carolinensis (Reptilia, Lacertilia, Iguanidae). Am Zool 17:191–201
Gunderson AR, Fleishman LJ, Leal M (2018) Visual playback of colorful signals in the field supports sensory drive for signal detectability. Curr Zool 64:493–498
Huntingford F, Turner A (1987) Animal conflict. Chapman and Hall, London
Husak JF (2004) Signal use by collared lizards, Crotaphytus collaris: the effects of familiarity and threat. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 55:602–607
Husak JF, Lappin AK, Fox SF, Lemos-Espinal JA (2006) Bite-performance predicts dominance in male venerable collared lizards (Crotaphytus antiquus). Copeia 2006:301–306
Husak JF, Lappin AK, Van Den Bussche RA (2009) The fitness advantage of a high-performance weapon. Biol J Linn Soc 96:840–845
Jakobsson S, Brick O, Kullberg C (1995) Escalated fighting behaviour incurs increased predation risk. Anim Behav 49:235–239
Jenssen TA (1970) Female response to filmed displays of Anolis nebulosus (Sauria: Iguanidae). Anim Behav 18:640–647
Jenssen TA (1977) Evolution of anoline lizard display behavior. Am Zool 17:203–215
Jenssen TA (1979) Display modifiers of Anolis opalinus (Lacertilia: Iguanidae). Herpetologica 35:21–30
Jenssen TA, DeCourcy KR, Congdon JD (2005) Assessment in contests in male lizards (Anolis carolinensis): how should smaller males respond when size matters? Anim Behav 69:1325–1336
Johnsson JI, Åckerman A (1998) Watch and learn: preview of the fighting ability of opponents alters contest behaviour in rainbow trout. Anim Behav 56:771–776
Kar F, Whiting MJ, Noble DWA (2016) Influence of prior contest experience and level of escalation on contest outcome. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 70:1679–1687
Kelly CD, Godin J-GJ (2001) Predation risk reduces male–male sexual competition in the Trinidadian guppy (Poecilia reticulata). Behav Ecol Sociobiol 51:95–100
Kelso EC, Martins EP (2008) Effects of two courtship display components on female reproductive behaviour and physiology in the sagebrush lizard. Anim Behav 75:639–646
Kemp DJ, Alcock J (2003) Lifetime resource utilization, flight physiology, and the evolution of contest competition in territorial insects. Am Nat 162:290–301
Kemp DJ, Alcock J, Allen GR (2006) Sequential size assessment and multicomponent decision rules mediate aerial wasp contests. Anim Behav 71:279–287
King SL (2015) You talkin’ to me? Interactive playback is a powerful yet underused tool in animal communication research. Biol Lett 11:20150403
Kizirian D, Trager A, Donnelly MA, Wright JW (2004) Evolution of Galápagos lava lizards (Iguania: Tropiduridae: Microlophus). Mol Phylogenet Evol 32:761–769
Klomp DA, Stuart-Fox D, Cassidy EJ, Ahmad N, Ord TJ (2017) Color pattern facilitates species recognition but not signal detection: a field test using robots. Behav Ecol 28:597–606
Krause J, Winfield AFT, Deneubourg JL (2011) Interactive robots in experimental biology. Trends Ecol Evol 26:369–375
Lappin AK, Husak JF (2005) Weapon performance, not weapon size, determines mating success and potential reproductive output in the collared lizard (Crotaphytus collaris). Am Nat 166:426–436
Lappin AK, Brandt Y, Husak JF, Macedonia JM, Kemp DJ (2006) Gaping displays reveal and amplify a mechanically based index of weapon performance. Am Nat 168:100–113
Leal M (1999) Honest signalling during predator-prey interactions in the lizard Anolis cristatellus. Anim Behav 58:521–526
Leal M, Rodríguez-Robles JA (1997) Signalling displays during predator-prey interactions in a Puerto Rican anole, Anolis cristatellus. Anim Behav 54:1147–1154
Leimar O, Austad S, Enquist M (1991) A test of the sequential assessment game: fighting in the bowl and doily spider Frontinella pyramitela. Evolution 45:862–874
Lobregat G, Kloss TG, Cardoso Peixoto PE, Frankl Sperber C (2019) Fighting in rounds: males of a neotropical cricket switch assessment strategies during contests. Behav Ecol 30:688–696. https://doi.org/10.1093/beheco/arz005
López P, Martín J (2001) Fighting rules and rival recognition reduce costs of aggression in male lizards, Podarcis hispanica. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 49:111–116
Lowry R (2014) VassarStats: Website for statistical comparison, http://www.vassarstats.net
Macedonia JM, Stamps JA (1994) Species recognition in Anolis grahami (Sauria, Iguanidae): evidence from responses to video playbacks of conspecific and heterospecific displays. Ethology 98:246–264
Macedonia JM, Evans CS, Losos JB (1994) Male Anolis lizards discriminate video-recorded conspecific and heterospecific displays. Anim Behav 47:1220–1223
Macedonia JM, Clark DL, Riley RG, Kemp DJ (2013) Species recognition of color and motion signals: evidence from responses to lizard robots. Behav Ecol 24:846–852
Macedonia JM, Clark DL, Brown ZN, Gensterblum S, McNabb L, Myrberg AB, Myrberg BD, Petroche MF, Karson A (2015) Responses of Anolis grahami males to manipulations of species identity and components of displays in lizard robots. Herpetologica 71:110–116
Macedonia JM, Clark DL, Fonley MR, Centurione I, Rowe JW, Valle CA (2019) Analysis of bobbing displays in four species of Galápagos lava lizards using conventional and novel quantitative methods. Herpetologica 75
Marden JH, Waage JK (1990) Escalated damselfly territorial contests are energetic wars of attrition. Anim Behav 39:954–959
Martins EP, Lacy KE (2004) Behavior and ecology of rock iguanas. I. Evidence for an appeasement display. In: Alberts AC, Carter RL, Hayes WK, Martins EP (eds) Iguanas: biology and conservation. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp 101–108
Martins EP, Lamont J (1998) Estimating ancestral states of a communicative display: a comparative study of rock iguanas. Anim Behav 55:1685–1706
Martins EP, Labra A, Halloy M, Thompson JT (2004) Large-scale patterns of signal evolution: an interspecific study of Liolaemus lizard headbob displays. Anim Behav 68:453–463
Martins EP, Ord TJ, Davenport S (2005) Combining motions into complex displays: playbacks with a robotic lizard. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 58:351–360
McLain DK, Pratt AE, Logue J, Barke R (2019) The importance of strength and stamina varies with ownership status in sand fiddler crab contests for breeding burrows. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 73:29
Miller CT, Beck K, Meade B, Wang X (2009) Antiphonal call timing in marmosets is behaviorally significant: interactive playback experiments. J Comp Physiol A 195:783–789
Nava SS, Moreno L, Wang D (2012) Receiver sex differences in visual response to dynamic motion signals in Sceloporus lizards. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 66:1357–1362
Ord TJ, Evans CS (2002) Interactive video playback and opponent assessment in lizards. Behav Process 59:55–65
Ord TJ, Martins EP (2006) Tracing the origins of signal diversity in anole lizards: phylogenetic approaches to inferring the evolution of complex behaviour. Anim Behav 71:1411–1429
Ord TJ, Stamps JA (2008) Alert signals enhance animal communication in “noisy” environments. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 105:18830–18835
Ord TJ, Stamps JA (2009) Species identity cues in animal communication. Am Nat 174:585–593
Partan SR, Otovic P, Price VL, Brown SE (2011) Assessing display variability in wild brown anoles Anolis sagrei using a mechanical lizard model. Curr Zool 57:140–152
Pratt AE, McClain DK, Lathrop GR (2003) The assessment game in sand fiddler crab contests for breeding burrows. Anim Behav 65:945–955
Rico-Guevara A, Hurme L (2019) Intrasexually selected weapons. Biol Rev 94:60–101
Rowe JW, Martin CE, Clark DL, Valle C, Vintimilla Palacios CP (2019) Habitat use and spatial ecology of three Microlophus lizard species from Santa Cruz and San Cristóbal Islands, Galápagos, and the coastal dry forest of Machalilla, Ecuador. Herpetol Rev 50:43–51
Smith B, Martins EP (2006) Display plasticity in response to a robotic signal: signal matching or song sharing in lizards? Ethology 112:955–962
Stamps JA, Krishnan VV (1997) Functions of fights in territory establishment. Am Nat 150:393–405
Stuart-Fox DM, Johnston GR (2005) Experience overrides colour in lizard contests. Behaviour 142:329–350
Thompson JT, Bissell AN, Martins EP (2008) Inhibitory interactions between multimodal behavioral responses may influence the evolution of complex signals. Anim Behav 76:113–121
Van Dyk DA, Evans CS (2007) Familiar-unfamiliar discrimination based on visual cues the jacky dragon, Amphibolurus muricatus. Anim Behav 74:33–44
Van Dyk DA, Evans CS (2008) Opponent assessment in lizards: examining the effect of aggressive and submissive signals. Behav Ecol 19:895–901
Van Dyk DA, Taylor AJ, Evans CS (2007) Assessment of repeated displays: a test of possible mechanisms. J Exp Biol 210:3027–3035
Woo KL, Rieucau G (2012) Aggressive signal design in the jacky dragon (Amphibolurus muricatus): display duration affects efficiency. Ethology 118:157–168
Zambre AM, Thaker M (2017) Flamboyant sexual signals: multiple messages for multiple receivers. Anim Behav 127:197–203
Acknowledgments
DLC and JMM contributed equally to this study. We thank Juan Pablo Muñoz, Administrador e Investigador, Galápagos Science Center on San Cristóbal, for permission to conduct our research with the Galápagos lava lizards. We would like to thank our reviewers for their thoughtful comments and suggestions. We dedicate this paper to the late Christopher S. Evans, a champion of the playback technique who used sound, video, and robots in experiments with a variety of animal species. Chris was particularly interested in the rules by which animal contests are conducted, and he considered interactive playbacks to be an ideal approach for uncovering those rules.
Funding
This study was funded by internal funding from Alma College.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Ethical approval
All applicable international, national, and/or institutional guidelines for the care and use of animals were followed. This was a strict observational study and no animals were directly handled or harmed during data collection, so ethical approval from an ethics committee was not required.
Additional information
Communicated by T. Madsen
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
(Video 1) Adult male Microlophus bivittatus subject exhibiting dorsal crest erection and gular inflation as it performs a volley of signature displays in response to the conspecific male robot (MP4 5956 kb)
(Video 2) A second example of an adult male Microlophus bivittatus subject exhibiting dorsal crest erection and gular inflation as it performs a volley of signature displays in response to the conspecific male robot (MP4 7501 kb)
(Video 3) Adult male Microlophus bivittatus subject performing two-bob displays as it moves toward the conspecific male robot during a trial (MP4 4099 kb)
Online Resource 4
(Image) Adult male Microlophus bivittatus subject observing the conspecific male robot during a trial (JPG 2117 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Clark, D.L., Macedonia, J.M., Rowe, J.W. et al. Galápagos lava lizards (Microlophus bivittatus) respond dynamically to displays from interactive conspecific robots. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 73, 136 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-019-2732-6
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-019-2732-6