Author’s Response

  • Judy L. CraneEmail author


This letter to the editor rebuts flawed analyses made by O'Reilly (2014) and points out duplicative comments that have already been rebutted in the peer-reviewed literature. O'Reilly (2014) provides little new scientific information on the source apportionment of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in sediments, and the author stands by the results of her research.


PAHs Source Apportionment Dust Source Principal Component Analysis Plot Combustion Source 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


  1. Cornelissen G, Gustafsson O, Bucheli TD, Jonker MTO, Koelmans AA, van Noort PCM (2005) Extensive sorption of organic compounds to black carbon, coal, and kerogen in sediments and soils: mechanisms and consequences for distribution, bioaccumulation, and biodegradation. Environ Sci Technol 39:6881–6895CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Crane JL (2014a) Source apportionment and distribution of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, risk considerations, and management implications for urban stormwater pond sediments in Minnesota, USA. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 66:176–200CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Crane JL (2014b) Letter to the editor on “Article title misstates the role of pavement sealers”. Environ Pollut 191:268CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Crane JL (2014c) Response to O’Reilly et al. (2014). Integr Environ Assess Manag 10:323–324CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. DeMott RP, Gauthier TD (2006) Comment on “Parking lot sealcoat: an unrecognized source of urban polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons”. Environ Sci Technol 40:3657–3658CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Johnson GW, Ehrlich R, Full W (2004) Principal components analysis and receptor models in environmental forensics. In: Murphy BL, Morrison RD (eds) Introduction to environmental forensics. Elsevier Academic Press, Burlington, pp 461–515Google Scholar
  7. Li A, Jang J-K, Scheff PA (2003) Application of EPA CMB8.2 model for source apportionment of sediment PAHs in Lake Calumet, Chicago. Environ Sci Technol 37:2958–2965CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Mahler BJ, Van Metre PC, Crane JL, Watts AW, Scoggins M, Williams ES (2012) Coal-tar-based pavement sealcoat and PAHs: implications for the environment, human health, and stormwater management. Environ Sci Technol 46:3039–3045CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (2014) Actions to restrict or discontinue the use of coal tar-based sealants in the United States. tdr-g1-12. MPCA, St. Paul, MN. Available at: Accessed 21 Aug 2014
  10. O’Reilly K (2014) Letter to the Editor. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol. doi: 10.1007/s00244-014-0094-7
  11. O’Reilly K, Pietari J, Boehm P (2012) Forensic assessment of refined tar-based sealers as a source of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in urban sediments. Environ Forensics 13:185–196CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. O’Reilly KT, Pietari J, Boehm PD (2014) Parsing pyrogenic polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: forensic chemistry, receptor models, and source control policy. Integr Environ Assess Manag 10:279–285CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Osborne JW, Costello AB (2004) Sample size and subject to item ratio in principal components analysis. Pract Assess Res Eval 9(11). Available at: Accessed 22 Aug 2014
  14. Polta R, Balogh S, Craft-Reardon A (2006) Characterization of stormwater pond sediments. Final project report. EQA report 06-572. Environmental Quality Assurance Department, Metropolitan Council Environmental Services, St. PaulGoogle Scholar
  15. Van Metre PC, Mahler BJ (2010) Contribution of PAHs from coal-tar pavement sealcoat and other sources to 40 U.S. lakes. Sci Total Environ 409:334–344CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Van Metre PC, Mahler BJ (2014a) In response to O’Reilly et al. (2014). Integr Environ Assess Manag 10:485–488CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Van Metre PC, Mahler BJ (2014b) PAH concentrations in lake sediment decline following ban on coal-tar-based pavement sealants in Austin, Texas. Environ Sci Technol 48:7222–7228CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Witter AE, Sak PB (2014a) Reply to letter on “Coal-tar-based sealcoated pavement: a major PAH source to urban stream sediments”. Environ Pollut 191:262–263CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Witter AE, Sak PB (2014b) Response to O’Reilly’s second letter to the editor on “Coal-tar-based sealcoated pavement: a major PAH source to urban stream sediments”. Environ Pollut 191:266–267CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Witter AE, Nguyen MH, Baidar S, Sak PB (2014) Coal-tar-based sealcoated pavement: a major PAH source to urban stream sediments. Environ Pollut 185:59–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Minnesota Pollution Control AgencySt. PaulUSA

Personalised recommendations